|
JUNE 2025
PROXY SEASON IN FOCUS: ACTIVIST TRENDS AND REGULATORY SHIFTS TO WATCH
| | |
|
This past spring, Bulldog succeeded in winning one seat on the Tejon Ranch Co. (TRC) board of directors. How they did it, though, is worth reviewing.
TRC develops real estate. Its principal asset is an enormous parcel of 270,000 acres of land, in various stages of development and operation, north of Los Angeles. While it earns a profit, its share price has barely moved in the past year, and is down 10% in the past two years.
Bulldog is a long-time activist fund with over $500 million in assets under management. It typically invests only in closed-end funds, so its investment in TRC represents one of its rare investments in an operating business. It owns about 2% of the shares of TRC.
TRC has a 10-member board of directors. After some unsuccessful efforts to nudge the company to more efficient operations and responsive leadership, Bulldog nominated three candidates: Bulldog principals Phil Goldstein and Andrew Dakos, and an attorney, Aaron Morris. TRS scheduled its AGM for May 13, 2025. InvestorCom advised Bulldog with its proxy solicitation.
TRC put Bulldog at a disadvantage when it disclosed it planned to spend $3.4 million on the proxy contest. Bulldog disclosed a budget of only $80,000.
The campaign needed to keep in mind one critical factor: TRC remains one of the very few US public companies with cumulative voting. Thus, shareholders could concentrate their votes for candidates for the ten BoD seats among just a few nominees. Communicating to shareholders how this works and working with them to cast votes that reflect their preferences required diligent contact and careful communication.
At the AGM, Andrew Dakos won election to the board. Neither the company or shareholders knew the result immediately, though, because cumulative voting allows shareholders to cumulate votes based on proxies submitted. Bulldog (and TRC) could exercise discretion about how to cumulate votes to support the most candidates for each. Thus, TRC released the voting results, after each of TRC and Bulldog would cumulate their votes for their specific nominees, about a week after the AGM.
| |
Sometimes an annual meeting vote and solicitation means finding shareholders for what amounts to an important but obscure agenda. In the case of SHF, uncommon voting standards, an unusual agenda, and significant retail holding created a challenging AGM and solicitation.
SHF is a long-time closed end fund where Bulldog leadership invested and served on the board. It historically invested only in Swiss-based public equities, which limited its investment opportunities and returns. After a few years’ discussion, SHF decided to appoint Bulldog its portfolio manager and expand its investment mandate beyond Swiss markets. If approved, SHF would restructure its portfolio and deliver a substantial cash distribution to shareholders.
Winning approval was tricky, though. Under the Investment Company Act of 1940, the principal law regulating these funds, any change of manager or strategy requires approval of a majority of the outstanding shares. Alternatively, two-thirds of the shares present at the shareholder meeting could also approve it, if that two-thirds represents a quorum (50% of outstanding). Even more difficult, SHF has significant retail investor ownership. Both contacting those shareholders and explaining the vote became a significant challenge.
The annual meeting agenda was not controversial, of course. The SHF board approved the measures, no shareholder opposed them, and the benefits were clear. The effort required diligent communication through multiple channels, including mail, phone, and email. Even tracking attendance, participation, and votes demanded extensive coordination among SHF, Bulldog, and numerous custodians and advisors.
That effort paid off. Shareholders approved the proposals overwhelmingly. Even better, SHF ended up within a modest budget for the annual meeting.
| Increase in “Vote No” Campaigns (Targeting Directors) Instead of Full Proxy Fights | | Not every activist is looking to run a full-blown proxy contest these days. An increasing number are opting for “vote no” or “withhold” campaigns as a lower-cost, high-impact way to apply pressure and draw attention to their concerns. By targeting one or more incumbent directors — often those serving on nominating, compensation, or governance committees — activists can spotlight deficiencies in oversight, capital allocation, or ESG performance. This approach has gained momentum in recent years because it allows activists to mobilize institutional investors and proxy advisors effectively, often yielding significant influence over corporate decision-making, even when a formal proxy fight doesn’t occur. | | | For example, in 2025 we saw the H Partners Management “Vote No campaign for the election of three of Harley-Davidson’s long-tenured incumbent directors. Similarly, this year Ancora Holdings Group ran a campaign to withhold the vote for Forward Air board chairman two other directors at the company's annual meeting. | | |
Implication: Boards can no longer assume reelection is automatic. Proactive engagement and diligent surveillance have become critical for identifying and addressing these under-the-radar threats before they gain momentum. | | |
SEC Rulemaking on Shareholder Proposals:
What’s Next?
|
| With the 2025 proxy season largely wrapped, attention is turning to the SEC and how it may recalibrate its approach to shareholder proposals in 2026 and beyond. Competing pressures from activists and corporate interests have left the agency in a delicate balancing act. Will new guidance further clarify how ESG or politically charged proposals are treated? In February of this year, the SEC issued Staff Legal Bulletin No. 14M (“SLB 14M”), which rescinds Staff Legal Bulletin No. 14L (“SLB 14L”) and reinstates earlier guidance on the exclusion of shareholder proposals under Rule 14a-8 of the Securities Exchange Act, creating a more challenging environment for certain inclusions of shareholder proposals under Rule 14a-8. We are monitoring no action requests at this time. | | | All signs point to an active rulemaking period ahead, and issuers are already assessing how these potential changes could affect the landscape for annual meetings. | | |
Implication: Companies and activists alike should watch closely as this develops, as any shift will have a direct impact on the shareholder proposal process — and the dynamics of proxy season — in 2026. | | |
STAY AHEAD IN A CHANGING PROXY LANDSCAPE | As the proxy landscape grows more nuanced, issuers are encouraged to stay ahead of evolving trends in shareholder engagement. Investorcom provides tailored proxy solicitation, proactive stock surveillance, and strategic governance advisory services designed to keep you informed, engage effectively with shareholders, and anticipate key voting trends. We help clients navigate this changing proxy environment. Contact us to learn how we can support your next vote! | |
Let’s Stay Connected!
Join the conversation and keep up with us on socials! Be the first to know about exclusive industry updates and insight, exciting announcements and company news you don’t want to miss. Why stop here? Follow us on social media and tag us—we’d love to connect. Engage with us today!
📲
See You Online!
|
ICOM PRESIdent and ceo moderates a panel at skytop | Skytop Strategies brings together leaders, innovators, and advocates for smarter shareholder engagement and we’re just getting started. From corporate raiders to ESG-focused campaigns, shareholder activism has come a long way since the 1980s. At Skytop, we unpacked the evolution of greenmail, and what the rise of activism means for today’s issuers. See you at the next Skytop conference! | | |
Tejon Ranch Company Board Sees Shift as Shareholders Elect Activist, Remove longtime director: | We're proud to congratulate our client, Bulldog Investors, on the success of their shareholder campaign at Tejon Ranch Company. This effort culminated in the appointment of Bulldog’s nominee, Andrew Dakos, to the company’s board of directors. | | |
InvestorCom President & CEO John Glenn Grau Joins IPO Edge Editor-in-Chief John Jannarone to Discuss The Shifting Dynamics of Proxy Season And Shareholder Activism. | |
At InvestorCom, we equip issuers with data-driven strategies and expert guidance through services like proxy solicitation and stock surveillance.
Even companies that don’t consider themselves activist targets must stay informed—understanding their shareholder base, voting behaviors, affiliations, and even identifying non-13F filers is crucial. Being proactive is key. Know who your shareholders are with InvestorCom!
| | |
|
Contact Us
203-972-9300
Info@Investor-Com.com
|
| We can't wait to serve you soon! | | InvestorCom | 19 Old Kings Highway South | Darien, CT 06820 US | | | | |