Client Alert

National Implications of Supreme Court Decision for Foreign Businesses Registered in Pennsylvania

 
 

Client Alert: National Implications of Supreme Court Decision for Foreign Businesses Registered in Pennsylvania


A recent groundbreaking decision by the U.S. Supreme Court could have far-reaching implications for businesses registered to do business in Pennsylvania. The ruling permits Pennsylvania courts to exercise general jurisdiction over such foreign entities for acts committed anywhere, regardless of any connection to Pennsylvania.


Under a law which effectively forces foreign companies seeking to do business in Pennsylvania to “consent” to general jurisdiction of the Pennsylvania courts (i.e., the power to hear any matter against an entity regardless of whether the facts of the case are related to the forum) when they register to do business in the Commonwealth, companies now risk being sued in Pennsylvania for alleged acts that occurred anywhere, by people who had never stepped foot in Pennsylvania, and even if the case has nothing to do with Pennsylvania.


In Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway Company, the U.S. Supreme Court, on June 27, 2023, reversed the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's opinion that this mandatory consent infringes upon due process rights, boosting Pennsylvania’s already strong reputation as a hotspot for forum shoppers.


In a narrow ruling, a five-Justice, both liberal and conservative, majority, comprised of Justices Gorsuch, Thomas, Alito, Sotomayor, and Jackson, leaned on a century-old decision to uphold Pennsylvania’s scheme as compatible with the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause. In a conclusory manner, the majority disagreed with the Pennsylvania Supreme Court and the four dissenting Justices who found that that compelled consent circumvents constitutional protections as established by the nearly 80 years of evolving Supreme Court precedent limiting the exercise of personal jurisdiction since International Shoe in 1945.

 

Their decision left open the future possibility of challenging Pennsylvania's law under the dormant Commerce Clause as theorized in Justice Alito’s concurring opinion.


We are closely tracking the unfolding legal landscape.


For more information, please contact us.



New York | Philadelphia | Los Angeles | Dallas

 
 

leaderberkon.com