|
Online privacy has long been a fertile topic for regulation and legal disputes, but over the past two years litigation in the area has exploded. These claims, sometimes called “web tracker,” “tracking pixel” or “cookie” cases, focus on technologies that collect user information, such as the advertising trackers offered by Meta and X, or the website analytics captured by Google. They allege that the collection and use of that information by third parties is a violation of state privacy or wiretapping laws, most notably the California Invasion of Privacy Act (“CIPA”).
Hayward is, in many ways, a typical website privacy case. Plaintiffs filed their complaint in federal court in the Northern District of California but defendants, headquartered in New York, successfully moved to transfer venue to the Southern District of New York. Defendants’ decision to move to transfer turned out to be dispositive, as the court, guided by Second Circuit precedent, dismissed the claims for lack of Article III standing. It specifically noted that “[c]ourts in the Second Circuit have held that the disclosure of addresses, telephone numbers, email addresses, device identifiers, and the like are insufficient to support finding a cognizable injury.”
The lesson of Hayward and similar recent decisions is that, as these cases become more involved, the facts matter. Courts look closely at what data was collected, how it was shared and used, and what disclosures and consents were in place. A series of best practices around privacy (including data minimization, functioning consent systems, appropriate policies, and timely auditing) can substantially limit risk if and when a demand letter comes.
|