March 2026

Your School's Plan (and Iron Mike)

By Charles T. Evans, Senior Partner


Oh, THE STRATEGIC PLAN! Every independent and parochial school board wants one (dashboards, KPIs, benchmarks!). 


Every head of school needs one (looking at you, accrediting associations!). 


Every leadership team dreads one (still looking at you, accrediting associations!). 


Teachers don’t mind if you have one (especially if they get paid a little extra to sit in meetings!). 


Parents couldn’t care less if you have one—count the clicks on the Strat Plan page of your website (except for that parent who writes plans at Dell or Oracle for a living!). 


Students love one (another missed class with pizza provided!).


We can blame the ubiquity of strategic planning as a feature of private schooling on a host of management gurus and obsessions from the past 70 years. Americans in military or corporate or government or non-profit or education leadership love planning. It’s a tangible product—verification of their necessity.


Lest you jump to the conclusion that we at BetterSchools think strategic plans are useless obligations imposed by the managerial class, there are a few benefits to be derived from a strategic plan (btw, AI suggested these alternate turns of phrase: “roadmap”, “blueprint”, “master-game-action plan”—that’s my favorite):


  1. It gives your school’s board members something to do besides reading (or not) repetitive monthly reports and investigating the fifth-grade bullying problem.
  2. It checks the box for your accreditation renewal.
  3. It gives the advancement people something to publish.
  4. It populates the agenda for staff meetings.


But can a strategic plan do more than that? Can it be a greater force for good? Can it reliably propel your mission and strengthen your school’s value proposition?


Maybe. But here’s why many schools’ multi-year roadmaps/blueprints/master-game-action plans don’t: They miss the point.


The point of a well-crafted strategic plan is not to prove that we, as leadership or a community, are merely thinking about the future and printing that future in glossy documents. The point is that we are resourcing that future. And that’s where these labor-intensive, blue-skying, what-iffing, current-reality-checking exercises fall apart.


They don’t pay for anything. They don’t recognize underfunded failed initiatives from the last plan. They don’t admit that adding more stuff to the current staff’s to-do-list might decrease their productivity (not to mention morale). They are wish lists that can’t be realized (except here and there on the margins—Woo hoo! New math curriculum!) because they don’t require original, risky thinking.


Well conceived, a strategic plan is essentially a framework for prioritizing investment. 


A great example of this mindset comes from one of our client schools. After a couple of years priming the community with careful communication about an expanded application of its mission, the school incorporated paradigm-shifting goals into the planning. They set a goal to be racially and ethnically representative of their city—not just their represented churches. They targeted teacher compensation at the same level as local public schools. To accomplish these things, they had to radically revisit the comfortable business model they had been operating with for two decades.


Typical plans are often imaginative, but they still lack imagination. That is, they don’t alter the basic assumptions that guide a school’s approach to teaching, learning, and community. They take what presently exists and try to improve it. In the end, a list of boxes has been checked, but the school is essentially the same. No transformation. No emancipation.


It’s not all about money, but money is a big part of it. Money is terrifying. Money is scarce. And money is emancipating. Money is transformative.  


When a school brings BetterSchools in to help with its next strategic plan, we won’t do it without an accompanying framework for the resources the plan deserves. Multi-year, assumption challenging, scary thinking. 


To paraphrase Iron Mike: Everyone has a plan until the budget punches them in the face..

 


We have a new website!

Check out our updated consulting service descriptions, our Team, and comments from nearly 20 years of well-served clients.

BetterSchools' Proprietary Financial Planning Tool: The IHAT

Long-term financial planning is hard, and the quality of the tools at your financial team's disposal makes all the difference. Common accounting platforms like Quickbooks or Blackbaud keep your numbers straight and periodic reports accurate, but they don't help you look down the road.


BetterSchools' Institutional Health Assessment Tool (IHAT) brings crucial data together into one integrated platform to make financial projections simple, accurate, and comprehensive. The IHAT includes a one-page dashboard summary of five-year outcomes linked to a multi-year profit and loss summary, grade by grade enrollment projections (including lost revenue calculations from attrition and gross revenue numbers from tuition and fees), a planning sheet that allows your planners to instantly adjust each level of tuition by percentages, and much more.


We haven't seen anything else like it that combines complete customization, total integration of key data, and infinite expandability for future use.


Contact us to see what we can do to help your school move forward in a fiscally intentional, mission-resourced manner.

You can access articles on a range of topics at our BetterSchools Blog.

It's all free, downloadable, and printable--and it's mostly good stuff!


Access a Trove of Articles