A Newsletter for individuals and businesses concerned with Creditor’s Rights | September 2026 | 414th Edition | | |
Collections: Pre Default Waiver of Notice of Sale is Void | | | |
In the case Woodward v. Resource Bank, from the Circuit Court, City of Virginia Beach, the Virginia Supreme Court reviewed provisions in a promissory note that provided for the debtors' waiver of notice of the default sale of the collateral securing the loan. In Woodward, a married couple operated a gas station and convenience store in Portsmouth and desired to expand. The couple obtained the financing necessary to purchase a store in Virginia Beach (the Pavilion Store) from a bank. In doing so the couple executed a note for $80,000.00 which was secured by a second deed of trust on their home, as well as with security interests in the inventory and equipment at the Pavilion Store. Later the couple decided to purchase a third store in Virginia Beach. They obtained financing from the same bank by executing a note in the amount of $90,900.00, and by signing a security agreement which granted the bank a security interest in the equipment and inventory of all three stores. The bank required the principal shareholders of the corporation to sign a guaranty for $45,000.00 of the $90,900.00 note. The guarantee agreement stated that the liability of the guarantors would not be affected by "any failure to ... give any required notices" by the bank.
The couple defaulted on the note and the bank demanded that the guarantors honor their respective guaranties. Thereafter, the bank sold the collateral securing the notes without formal notice. The collateral was sold at prices far below the stated value. The shareholders argued that they were entitled to notice of the sale, notwithstanding that they had signed pre-default waivers of notice, because they were "debtors" within the meaning of Virginia Code §8.9-105(1)(d) and §8.9-504(3). The Virginia Beach Circuit Court agreed with the bank that the waivers precluded the necessity of giving notice, but the Virginia Supreme Court ruled that since the shareholders were "debtors" within the meaning of the statutes, they were entitled to notice of the disposition of the collateral. Applying the plain language of Virginia Code §8.9-504(3), the Virginia Supreme Court held that the notice provision contained therein may not be waived before the occurrence of a default.
The Virginia Supreme Court further ruled that a rebuttable presumption arose that the value of the collateral that the bank sold equaled the amount of the debt because the bank failed to give notice to the guarantors, and because the sale was thus "commercially-unreasonable". Virginia Code §8.9-504(3) requires that every aspect of the disposition of collateral, including "the method, manner, time, place and terms must be commercially reasonable". Because the bank failed to rebut this presumption by putting on evidence to the contrary, the Court ruled that the indebtedness was extinguished, and the creditor was precluded from further collection.
The lesson of Woodward is simple: always obtain a legal opinion regarding sales of reclaimed security, and always follow the requirements of the applicable statutes.
| | | | | Each county and city publishes real estate assessment data that includes records of current and previous owner information. This is especially helpful when verifying addresses or checking whether a debtor still owns a property. | | | |
Bankruptcy: Voluntary Conveyance - Debtor's Inheritance | | | In the case of Shaia v. Meyer, the United States Bankruptcy Court, Eastern District of Virginia, Richmond Division, Judge Tice ruled that a bankruptcy trustee may recover funds a debtor inherited from his father and used to pay off two mortgages on property the debtor owned with his wife in a tenancy by the entirety. Essentially, the Court ruled that the debtor's payments constituted a voluntary or fraudulent conveyance that could be recovered by the bankruptcy estate. | | | | | Law Review of the Month: Business Law | |
The firm has extensive experience in the representation of small business, whether corporations, limited liability companies, partnerships or sole proprietorships.
The firm has participated in the buying, selling, and financing of numerous businesses, working closely with clients, attorneys and accountants to obtain the desired result. This experience, coupled with a broad background, gives our firm the ability to provide the multi-faceted representation which is so vital to today’s smart business person.
| | | |
Real Estate: Using Real Estate to Secure Your Debt | | | |
Many fail to recognize the benefit of using real estate to improve their position as creditors. Properly securing debts through real estate could make the difference between collecting the funds and incurring a loss.
Securing debt with real estate can occur in several ways: deeds of trust, judgment liens, homeowner association liens, mechanic’s liens and lis pendens in litigation cases, just to name a few. In the upcoming issues of Creditor News we will explore these, as well as the ways that I can assist you.
We have experienced attorneys and staff who can examine title, do real estate closings, seek judgment and docket and enforce the same, and prepare and enforce statutory liens, such as those for litigation, homeowner’s associations and mechanic lien situations.
| | | |
Foreclosure: Trustees in Foreclosure | | | Trustee under a deed of trust are agents for both the lender and the borrowers. Accordingly, a trustee must act fairly and impartially. The lender must not let either the lender or the borrower influence the manner in which a trustee carries out the terms of the deed of trust, especially if this would be detrimental to either party. If any question arises as to the existence of the default or the amount in default, a trustee should seek the aid and direction of the court. The powers and duties of a trustee are governed by the deed of trust and Virginia Code Section 55.1-320 et seq. The code provides when the deed of trust does not. A trustee has no right to exercise the power of sale or to obtain possession until such time as the borrower defaults under the note or deed of trust, and, then, only for the purpose of selling the property at foreclosure or preserving the property until sale. When a default occurs, there is no change in title – the property merely becomes eligible to be sold under the powers originally conferred to the trustee by the owner. Thus, the noteholder has the right to have the property sold and the proceeds of the sale applied to the debt. | | | Looking for more Creditor News articles? Check our our Creditor News Blog! | | Lafayette Whitlock Fischer Hughes PLC is a full-service creditor’s rights firm. While many attorneys do “collections”, few attorneys have the trained expertise and staff to represent creditors in all four areas of Creditor’s Rights—Collections, Bankruptcy, Real Estate and Foreclosure. We do, and, we represent credit unions, banks, loan companies, homeowner associations, doctor’s offices, landlords, small businesses and individuals. In Creditor News we will explore all four areas of Creditor’s Rights. | | Meet the Attorneys of LAW, PLC | | |
Edward S. Whitlock, III, Esq.
Editor
Eddie is a Richmond native with a concentrated law practice in creditor representation. His practice focuses on creditor’s rights (Collection, Bankruptcy, Real Estate, and Foreclosure), but also includes the general practice of law (Business and Will & Estate Planning). Eddie holds a B.A. (1984) in Political Science, and a Juris Doctor (1987) from the University of Richmond. He is the former Chief of Admin/Military Law for the 329th Support Group (Area) in the Virginia Army National Guard. Eddie is the former President of both the Henrico County Bar Association and the Virginia Creditors’ Bar Association. He is the chair of the Virginia State Bar’s Fee Dispute Resolution Program, and a former member of the Virginia State Bar’s Disciplinary Committee. He is the chairman of the Henrico Economic Development Authority. He is the President of Home Loans for KOVAR Corporation. He is also a former director of Henrico CASA, and a former adjunct professor of criminal law at J. Sargeant Reynolds Community College.
| | |
Jennifer W. Fischer, Esq.
Editor
Jennifer concentrates her practice in creditor representation (Collection, Bankruptcy, Real Estate, and Foreclosure), but also Business and Will & Estate Planning. Jennifer holds a BS (2011) in business administration from Christopher Newport University, and a Juris Doctorate (2014) from University of Richmond, T.C. Williams School of Law. She was admitted to the Virginia State Bar in October 2014. She is a Past President of the Virginia Creditors' Bar association and the Henrico County Bar Association.
| | |
C. Daniel Waters, Esq.
Editor
Daniel Waters primarily represents consumer and commercial finance companies, credit unions, medical practices, landlords, and construction material companies in creditor’s rights and civil litigation matters in Virginia. He has represented clients in Virginia Circuit and General District Courts as well as the Federal District Court in Richmond. After graduating from Old Dominion University with a double major in Political Science and Philosophy, Daniel studied law at Regent University School of Law in Virginia Beach. He serves as the President of the Virginia Creditors' Bar Association and as Trustee at a local private school. He resides in the Richmond area with his wife and children.
| | CREDITOR NEWS © 2026. This newsletter is prepared and published by Edward S. Whitlock, III, Esquire, Jennifer W. Fischer, Esquire, and C. Daniel Waters, Esquire and is provided free of charge. The information contained in this newsletter is general in nature. It is intended to be helpful but does not, and is not meant to, replace consultation with an attorney in connection with a legal problem. Readers needing legal advice should retain competent legal counsel. | | |
|
Lafayette Whitlock Fischer Hughes PLC
www.lawplc.com
| |
| | | |