New research is out on Tennessee’s targeted pre-K program, among the most well-known programs under study and the first of its size and nature to be examined through a randomized control trial. (I wrote about it seven years ago, here.) The latest study is out, and follows data on pre-K participants through grade 6. Study results confirm what earlier studies showed – which is the somewhat counterintuitive finding that pre-K participants had lower academic and behavioral outcomes than non-participants. (And this isn’t the only such study to provide empirical evidence of this.) New America offers a solid recap of the research, and this piece by Vox is thought-provoking and important as well, with one takeaway that “child development is especially tricky to research, and focusing on just one study... can lead you astray.”
It’s critical that early learning advocates be equipped with an understanding about the importance of this study, as well as its limits. First, it’s imperative that folks know that the non-participating group of children (the control group) being compared to Tennessee pre-K participants weren’t receiving no treatment. They were likely enrolled in Head Start, or at home with family or nannies, in contrast to the children who were in the state pre-K program. Thus, studies like this may affirm that certain environments seemed to lead to better outcomes than the state pre-K program. That is a very different conclusion than stating Tennessee’s pre-K program “didn’t work.” Second, targeted state pre-K programs like the one studied in Tennessee allow working parents, mothers especially, to return to work. The outcomes that may be associated with that – like workforce participation, increased income, or less stress for the family – weren't the ones being studied. As Vox noted, “Less stressed, working parents could mean better-off kids in the very long run, even if that doesn’t show up in test scores.”