December 12, 2024 | Issue #15 | Past issues

New groomer for Avalanche

The City of Boyne City purchased a new grooming machine for the trails at Avalanche Preserve, and volunteer Mike Cortright drove to the Upper Peninsula to pick it up, then put it into use after the first snowstorm of the season. When the second storm blew into the area with lots of fresh powder this Wednesday, Cortright said he’d be out grooming again. There are multiple trails at Avalanche for multiple users - cross-country skiers, fat tire bikers, snowshoers and hikers. 

Inside this issue

• Rave reviews for improved online audio for city meetings
• School board approves “zero tax increase” bond issue 
• City Commission keeps meeting times at 12 and 7 p.m. 
• Upsy-Daisy closing storefront but not going away
• School bands perform free holiday concerts
• Avalanche Warming House opens as snow returns
• Chamber's Holiday Business After Hours tonight
• School Candy Gram sales end Friday
• Patrick McCleary history: The Boyne Theatre
• Obituaries: RIP, Craig Stadtmiller
• Thanks to the donors who keep the news coming!
• Music and entertainment listings

CITIZEN HOLIDAY SCHEDULE - The Boyne Citizen will publish one more issue on Thursday, Dec. 19, and then we will take two weeks off for the holidays. We will resume publication on Thursday, Jan. 9. Send your news to jim@boynecitizen.com. 

> Like this email? Forward it to a friend and help us grow.

Our Agents

Sponsored post

Local news is made possible by you

The Boyne Citizen is committed to being a resource for in-depth local news and information you can trust. Will you join more than 200 donating supporters who believe the Boyne area needs high-quality news and information? We are a 501c3 nonprofit organization.

> Please consider the Boyne Citizen in your year-end giving plans. You may donate online or mail a check to 1119 West Street, Boyne City MI 49712.

City staff member Jacob Duncan with the mixing board he used to improve the poor sound quality for online City Commission meetings.

Rave reviews for improved audio for online City Commission meetings

By Jim Baumann, jim@boynecitizen.com

The Boyne City Commission meeting on Nov. 26 featured much improved audio for those who watch and listen to the proceedings online via Facebook or Zoom. After several years of complaints, there were actually rave reviews in the comments section of the meeting video.

Cindy Banner posted “Much better audio!” And Asuka Barden chimed in with “Sounds great!” Both are regular online commission watchers who have complained in the past about poor sound quality. 

Asked by the Boyne Citizen for her thoughts on the issue, Barden said, “I applaud the city commissioners for listening to their constituents and working hard to create transparent meetings that are easily accessible on multiple platforms: Facebook, Zoom and YouTube.” 

“Since 2021, when then candidate (Tim) Nemecek would stream the meetings from his personal phone, to being in office and bringing in the Owl system, then finally fine-tuning things to get direct audio feeds - folks like me can tune in while we are going about our busy lives and hear what’s happening in our local government. We can even speak during public commentary via Zoom. I’m proud of what these commissioners have done for the city,” Barden said.

The Owl system she referred to is a recording system the city purchased in 2022 that uses two automated devices that look like owls, placed in the front of the commission chambers, that record sound and video of the meetings. But the audio provided by that system didn’t work very well. 

Then Jacob Duncan, the city’s deputy clerk-treasurer, came to the rescue in November with the help of what he calls “YouTube University.” 

“There are a lot of great videos on YouTube,” he said. Those led him to purchase the mixing board he is holding in the picture with this story. “We already had good wireless microphones, now we just had to feed the mics through the mixing board to Zoom, which is also the source for the Facebook audio,” Duncan said. 

For the first meeting using the new mixing board, Duncan sat in the back of the commission chambers, adjusting the sound. “Everyone speaks at different volumes,” he noted, and the mixing board allowed him to make adjustments so online viewers can clearly hear what is being said by each person participating in the meeting.

Duncan notes that watching via Zoom, where there is a “raise your hand” feature, is how people can participate remotely and give live input to the commission during the meeting. When issues are being discussed, Mayor Nemecek typically asks for public comment from people in the meeting room and then says, “Anything online, Mike?” directed to City Manager Mike Cain, who monitors possible requests for comments from people watching via Zoom.

Links to watch each meeting via Zoom and Facebook are provided near the top of every City Commission agenda, which can be accessed here on the city website. 

Now that the audio is improved, Duncan said, “We want to thank everyone for their patience, and comments that have helped us improve the experience for everyone watching remotely. We’re committed to improving accessibility for public meetings, fostering greater transparency in the process.”

School board approves “zero tax rate increase” bond issue for May election

By Jamie Baumann, jamie@boynecitizen.com

The Boyne City Public Schools Board voted unanimously Monday to approve ballot wording requesting $24 million for a zero tax rate increase bond election. If voters approve the bond on May 6, 2025, the tax rate would stay the same as it is now, rather than decrease as previous bond obligations are fulfilled.

"Zero tax rate increase has been the board's approach since the 2016 bond was passed,” said Superintendent Patrick Little. “This board has been steady in that they have no interest in increasing the tax rates; rather, they just keep them the same to make these improvements." 

The ballot wording, based on advice from Thurn Law Firm's election specialists, stipulates that the money cannot be used for operating costs or salaries. If the voters pass the bond, the money must be used for capital improvements and equipment.

Over the past few months, the board has narrowed a list of needs and wants from $38M down to $24M, the number needed to keep the bond proposal at a zero tax rate increase. The proposed list now includes renovations at the elementary school, including a four-classroom addition, as well as renovations in the middle school, the middle school playground/athletic field, and the athletic complex buildings.

At the high school, Career and Technical Education additions would be built, and improvements would be made in the high school auditorium. The Education Center’s Morgan Shaw School restrooms would be improved. Technology for students and staff, buses, and bus bay heaters are included in the proposal. A visual emergency alert system and wayfinding maps to enhance safety are also in the proposal.

In public comments before the board voted, Chris Christensen, a local realtor who has a sophomore son at the high school, said, "I'm not opposed to a bond and meeting district needs. I'm afraid that we backed ourselves into a corner where we are always going for zero tax increase millages, because we think that if we lower the millage, when there is a need to increase it, it could fail."

Christensen said that since 2016, the district has gone to the voters for $36.5 million. The 2025 bond proposal of $24M will bring the total to over $60M of capital improvement and equipment bond requests over nine years.

Charlevoix County Sheriff and Boyne City High School graduate Chuck Vondra, whose son and daughter also graduated from BCHS, advocated with Christensen to scale back the bond request to $18M from $24M.They both acknowledged the need for the elementary school addition and renovation as a priority over the additional classrooms for Career and Technical Education. They both emphasized that they support the district and want the schools to have the resources to meet the needs, but not necessarily the "wants."

Vondra said he and his brother own some rental homes that they try to keep affordable, but taxes are a part of the equation that he needs to factor into rents. "Affordable housing does come down to taxes sometimes," he said.

Erin Mastin, a third grade teacher at Boyne Elementary School and BCHS alumna, thanked the board for their decision to support the elementary and all of the schools. "I have been looking at the elementary plans. What is being proposed is not so much an expansion as a reorganization. Currently, the corner rooms in the elementary aren’t as safe as other rooms. This issue is addressed with the elementary school addition."

The $24M figure will keep the millage at the current 3.14 mills for debt retirement, which costs $588 and $502 per year for owners of median-priced, principal, and non-principal residences, respectively. However, median-priced, non-principal residences are assessed an additional $2880 per year for operational millage, from which principal residences are exempt. These figures are based on a median-priced principal residence of $375,000 with an assessed value of $187,500 and a median-priced, non-principal residence of $320,000 with an assessed value of $160,000.

If the board had decided to lower the bond proposal from $24M to $18M, that would have resulted in a difference of about $28 per year for median-priced principal residences and $22 per year for median-priced, non-principal residences.

The board's consensus was that every improvement included in the $24M bond proposal was either a need or an investment in the community's future. The elementary school, which has had cosmetic upgrades from past bonds, is overdue for renovation and reconfiguration. The Career and Technical Education additions give needed classroom and lab space to the culinary arts, linesman, and building trades programs. These programs provide skills that lead to local good jobs upon high school graduation.

Board member Joel Schraw said, "We aren't getting all of our wants with the proposed improvements. If we had all the money in the world, we would get artificial turf for the stadium, for example. What we have here is a good balance of needs and wants that serve all of the constituents."

In public comments at the end of the evening, though disappointed with the board's decision to stick with the $24M proposal, Christensen said, "I hope the bond passes for the sake of the elementary school."

The district's next step will be to launch a communications campaign to explain the proposed improvements to the public. Community meetings will be held to answer people's questions about the bond proposal. The district team will also present to civic organizations and other gatherings around the school district. Information will be mailed to registered voters, and the Boyne City Public Schools website will have a bond information page.

If the bond passes in May, the district will proceed to the next level of design detail. "With the budget in mind, architects will work with staff on concepts like sizing, materials, accessibility, technology integration, and overall image to create some great spaces for our students," Little said.

Superintendent Patrick Little’s contract is extended

After a closed session on Monday night, the Boyne City Public Schools board voted to extend Superintendent Patrick Little's contract an additional year, to expire in June, 2028.

"After discussing and reviewing evidence, the board unanimously rated him as 'effective.' We are pleased with Mr. Little's commitment to the district and our students. We look forward to subsequent years of outstanding leadership," Board President Zareena Koch said. 

Michigan law requires that all public school boards in Michigan adopt and implement a “rigorous, transparent and fair” performance evaluation system for all teachers and school administrators that includes multiple legal requirements.

The district used an evaluation tool developed by the Michigan Association of School Boards. The process involves a self-evaluation and sharing evidence to the board for several leadership categories. The board then uses a rubric to rate the superintendent, and they collaborate with the superintendent on goals. In the revised superintendent rating system from the State of Michigan, "effective" is the highest category ranking. 

City Commission keeps meeting times at 12 and 7 p.m., hears childcare expansion proposal

By Jim Baumann, jim@boynecitizen.com

After taking an online survey, the Boyne City Commission decided to keep its meeting days and times the same as they have been in the past - 7 p.m. meetings on the second Tuesday of the month and 12 noon meetings on the fourth Tuesday. 

A Facebook survey showed that 11 of 17 people said they were “not happy” with the current meeting times, but the current meeting times came out on top when asked what times people preferred.

For the second Tuesday 7 p.m. meetings, the survey result was:

• Keep 7 p.m. - 8 votes
• Start at 6 p.m. - 5 votes
• Start at 5:30 p.m. - 4 votes

For the fourth Tuesday 12 noon meetings, the survey result was:

• Keep 12 p.m. - 8 votes
• Start at 7 p.m. - 5 votes
• Start at 6 p.m. - 3 votes
• Start at 5:30 p.m. - 1 vote

Included in the resolution approving the general meeting dates and times was a provision to have the City Commission discuss budget priorities at their noon meeting on Jan. 28, followed by detailed budget review sessions on March 13, 17 and 19.

The commission learned of a proposal to use the Community of Christ Church building at 777 Vogel Street as a child-care center for children ages 3 and under. During the “Citizen Comments on Non-agenda Items” part of the meeting, local resident Lee Rainey told the commission that his wife Keagan Rainey would like to expand her Little Ducklings Childcare business in the church building, but it does not meet zoning requirements. Commissioners and Planning Director Scott McPherson all agreed that this site seemed ideal for such a use, and that more childcare services were badly needed in the community, especially for children under age 3. The matter was referred to the Planning Commission for rezoning consideration, which would require an ordinance change that may take 60 days or more to be approved. 

The commission is working to schedule several upcoming meetings with other entities, including the Boyne City Main Street board, a joint meeting of all city boards and commissions, and a meeting with Community Heart & Soul, a nonprofit that may be retained to help the city with a community goal-setting project. 

It was announced at the meeting that City Hall would be closed for upcoming Christmas and New Year’s holidays on Dec. 24, 25, 31 and Jan. 1.

The next regular City Commission meeting will be held at 7 p.m. Tuesday, Jan. 14, 2025.

> City Manager’s Report for the Dec. 10, 2024 meeting.

Upsy-Daisy closing storefront but will continue floral business

Sydney Wormell has announced that she is closing her Upsy-Daisy Floral storefront on Christmas Eve at 5 West Main Street - but she’s not getting out of the business. 

In a recent Facebook post, she said: “17 years ago, we started Upsy-Daisy Floral in a space just big enough for a workstation and a floral cooler. We didn't know where this journey would take us, and we are proud of where we are today. It is now time for a change - we will be closing our retail store and moving our business into a studio format. As we transition into this next chapter of our business, we thank you all for your support and love.”

What does this mean? “We will still be here for all your life events: weddings, parties, funerals,” she said. “We will also continue to brighten your days with daily deliveries of fresh flowers and plants.”

Wormell said the change will also open the door to “new and exciting opportunities. Look for more flower classes to be added to our calendar. We will also be scheduling pop-up shops for holidays and events” such as Valentine's Day and Prom. She is also looking forward to having more time with family and to being more involved in the community.

The phone number, (231) 582-0972, and www.upsydaisyflorist.com website will remain the same. 

Chamber's Holiday Business After Hours set for tonight

The Boyne Area Chamber invites everyone to join them for their Holiday Business Hours from 5:30 to 7 p.m. Thursday, Dec. 12. The event will be held at One Water Street, upstairs above Alpine Chocolat Haus, hosted by the Boyne Arts Center, Boyne City Massage & Wellness, and Edward Jones.

Enjoy an ugly sweater competition, hors d’oeuvres by Cafe Sante and Lake Street Pub; with wine, beer, and cocktails provided by the Arts Center and Boyne City Massage and Wellness, and desserts provided by Edward Jones. Everyone is welcome to come network and make new friends. Admission is free.

School bands perform free holiday concerts Tuesday 

The Boyne City school bands will be presenting a holiday concert in the high school Performing Arts Center on Tuesday, Dec. 17. The sixth grade band will perform at 6 p.m.,  the middle school concert band will perform at 7 p.m., and the high school concert and jazz bands will perform at 8 p.m. All the concerts are free and open to the public to enjoy the holiday music.

Boyne City High School students, from left, Benjamin Ivie, Ruby Richards, Olivia Dobbins, Will Minnaar, and Whitney Root represented Boyne City in the  District 2 Honors Band. 

Boyne City students participate in Honors Band

Five student musicians from Boyne City were selected to perform in the Michigan School Band and Orchestra District 2 Honors Band concert, which took place at Harbor Springs High School in October. In early November, students from across District 2, which is all of northern lower Michigan, auditioned and were selected for the ensemble by a panel of musicians. Over this past weekend, the entire Honors Band stayed in Petoskey as they practiced and performed with guest conductor Dr. Pam Klena, professor from Oakland University.

Boyne City High School Band Director Brandon Ivie said, "The performance was one of the best Honors Bands ever." He added that the students "represented Boyne City with pride." 

Winners of the Candy Gram art contest are, from left, seventh grader Ali Leathers, and sixth graders Selina Duma, Maria Gerster, and Braylee Bearss.  

Middle School PTO raises funds with Candy Grams

It's time to order Candy Grams from the Boyne City Middle School PTO as the deadline for orders is Friday, Dec. 13. Students at the middle and high schools can purchase them at lunch for $1 Candy Gram, $2 Flower Gram, $3 for a Flower and Candy Gram. Candy Grams will be delivered to the students on Monday, Dec. 16. Parents and community members who would like to send Candy Grams to their middle or high school students can order here: 

> Middle school order form. 

> High school order form.

"This fundraiser started four years ago out of sheer desperation," PTO Treasurer Jenny Clasman said. "We didn’t make enough from our Halloween dance, and we couldn’t fund any of the activities the PTO was designed to perform. We were pleasantly surprised that both the students and the community really enjoyed this fundraiser and found joy sending their children little notes and candy during the holiday season."

Candy Grams have become their biggest fundraiser, raising $1,500 last year. The proceeds are used to host the Snowflake Dance, fund Teacher Appreciation, and to provide a start-up fund for exiting eighth graders to take to the high school for the freshman class. In addition, the money raised is used for scholarships to send sixth graders to Camp Daggett. The camp’s prices have increased from $60 per child to $100, so this fundraiser has become even more important to ensure that finances don't stand in the way of any sixth grader going to Camp Daggett, according to Clasman. 

This year, the PTO sponsored a Candy Gram art design contest that attracted almost 100 entries. Entries were posted around the cafeteria and the middle school students then voted on their favorite designs. The four with the most votes became this year's Candy Gram designs. "The kids had a blast with it," PTO President Teryn LeVoy said, "so we will definitely be doing it again."

Warren Miller film benefits school ski teams on Friday

The Lake Charlevoix Varsity Ski Team and the Boyne City Middle School Ski Team invite the community to join them Friday, Dec. 13, for “an unforgettable evening at the Boyne City High School Performing Arts Center as we present Warren Miller’s 75.” This iconic ski film celebrates 75 years of heart-pounding action, breathtaking powder stashes, and inspiring stories from around the globe.

The evening begins at 6:45 p.m. with displays from ski resorts and outfitters, followed by the Warren Miller 75 film at 7:30. Tickets are $15, available at the door or in advance with online purchase.

Field of Dreams e-bike raffle

The Waterfront Field Of Dreams is holding a fundraising raffle for a Retrospeck-Valen electric bike, pictured here on display at the Holiday Craft Show, to raise money for the new ballfield in Veterans Park. Tickets can be purchased online, at Boyne City Hardware, or Lynda's Real Estate for $10. The drawing will be held at 6 p.m. Thursday, Dec. 19, at Lynda's office. You don’t need to be present to win. 

Send us your Christmas memories!

The Boyne Citizen is bringing back an old-time tradition from the Charlevoix County Press of the 1970s. We’re asking readers to send us their Christmas memories from years past. Tell us what made your holiday special - back when you were a kid, or when your now adult kids were young. Maybe it was a walk in the woods to cut down a Christmas tree. Perhaps it was skiing at Boyne Mountain, a school pageant, or making cookies or a Christmas Eve tradition. Try to keep your Christmas memory under 200 words, include your name and maybe even a photo and email it to jamie@boynecitizen.com by Dec. 15th.

Avalanche Warming House opens

Mother Nature dumped nearly a foot of snow on the Boyne area Wednesday night and this morning, and the Avalanche Preserve Warming House is now open for the season. Feeling brave? Come borrow one of their sleds and take a slide down what has been called the best sledding hill in Michigan. Warming House attendant Lacey Kotalik has been running the Warming House since 2015. “We have Lots of sleds and skates to choose from this year, thanks to our amazing community,” she said, noting that it’s all free. Enjoy some hot chocolate by the warm fire afterwards. Regular hours of operation for the warming house and the attendant are 4-9 p.m. Monday - Friday and 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Saturday and Sunday. Holidays throughout the winter when school is not in session will follow the weekend hours of 11a.m. to 9 p.m. The ice rink is not open yet, as it needs a sustained period of temperatures that remain below freezing.

Wreaths Across America ceremony honors Bay Township veterans on Saturday

Everyone is invited to attend the Bay Township Wreaths Across America Ceremony at Dyer Cemetery at 11:45 a.m. Saturday, Dec. 14. Wreaths Across America in Bay Township is celebrating its 11th year.

You do not have to be a wreath sponsor to participate in the ceremony. At noon a moment of silence will be held across the entire nation. At this time the eight ceremonial wreaths will be placed on the graves of the veterans throughout the township's three cemeteries and the Scattering Garden at the Horton Bay United Methodist Church. 

The Boyne City American Legion Ernest Peterson Post 228 will be assisting at this ceremony for Color Guard and Taps at each location. It will be a very special time to honor all our veterans and their families. "Live With Purpose" is the National Wreaths Across America Day Theme for 2024.

Here is an information and sponsorship form. Note that the organization has made online sponsoring much easier now. Call Georganna Monk at 231-883-9867 if you have any questions. 

Mike Kondrat Jr. and his girlfriend Jamie Fortune have donated these13 bikes that will be given away at the Boyne Valley Fire and Rescue Christmas Breakfast. The bikes range from 12-inch to 20-inch, two scooters, and two tykes walk bikes. They made the donation in honor of Mike's son Xavier, whom the family lost earlier this year. 

Boyne Valley Fire & Rescue sponsors annual Christmas Breakfast with Santa on Saturday

Boyne Valley Fire and Rescue invites the community to join them for their annual Christmas Breakfast with special guest Santa Claus this Saturday, Dec. 14. Breakfast will be served from 8 a.m. to 12 noon, and Santa will be there starting at 9:30. Stop in, fill your bellies, talk to some neighbors, and most importantly, create some holiday memories. Breakfast with Santa will be held at the Boyne Valley Fire and Rescue Hall, 2286 Railroad St., Boyne Falls.

Tractor Supply hosts photos with Santa on Saturday

The Boyne City Tractor Supply store will spread holiday cheer this year with their Photos with Santa event. Held Saturday, Dec.14 from 10 a.m. until 2 p.m., Tractor Supply customers are invited to bring their children and pets to the store for photos with Santa and other holiday activities. 

A local photographer will be on site during the event taking holiday-themed photos of Santa's Little Helpers and their owners. The first 25 customers to take their photo with Santa will also receive a free magnetic picture frame.

"At Tractor Supply, we welcome families with open arms," said Jackie Morse, manager of the Boyne City Tractor Supply store. "This is one of many children and pet-friendly events held throughout the year to show our appreciation for our loyal customers and their loved ones."

In addition to photos with Santa, customers will have the opportunity to enjoy pet photos, a bake sale and pet adoption opportunities. This event is open to the public and will take place at 1200 S. M-75. For more information, contact the store at 231-582-2882.

Presbyterian Church continues free community Christmas dinner 

The First Presbyterian Church of Boyne City will continue its tradition of offering a free Christmas Day Community Meal from 12 - 1 p.m. on Wednesday, Dec. 25th. Any donations will go to the Good Neighbors Food Pantry. The church is located at 401 S. Park St., and attendees are asked to use the Pine Street entrance near the Fellowship Hall. Flyer for this event.

Interim church staff member Daryl Michael said, "We are grateful for BC Pizza, Boyne River Grill/True North Catering, and Boyne City Hospitality for their generosity in providing this meal." Anyone who would like to support the effort may call 231-582-7983. 

On Christmas Eve at 7 p.m., everyone is welcome to come to First Presbyterian Church's Christmas Eve Worship, which will include many Christmas songs, Bible readings, and a finale by candlelight.

Catholic Community lists Christmas, Holy Day Mass schedule

• Tuesday, December 24 - Christmas Eve. Mass at 6:00 pm at St. Matthew - Boyne City Mass at 9:00 pm at St. Matthew - Boyne City.
• Wednesday, December 25 - Christmas Day. Mass at 9:00 am at St. Augustine - Boyne Falls.
• Tuesday, December 31 - Solemnity of Mary the Mother of God. Mass at 5:00 pm at St. Augustine - Boyne Falls.
• Wednesday, January 1 - Solemnity of Mary the Mother of God. Mass at 9:00 am St. Matthew - Boyne City.

> We welcome announcements about other holiday church schedules for churches from the Boyne area. Please email jim@boynecitisen.com by December 10. Our last issue before Christmas comes out on December 19.

Help us spread the word about local journalism ...

• Ask your friends to subscribe for free.
• Consider making a donation. We are a 501c3 nonprofit.
• If you’re a business, run an ad - details here.
• Follow us on Facebook and make a comment.
• Email jim@boynecitizen.com with story ideas and your thoughts about the new Boyne Citizen.
• We’d also like to hear from writers and editors who would like to become involved.

An early theatrical production performed on the Bellamy Opera House Stage. The central figure in this dance of Scottish lasses is a very young Mary (McNamee) Churchill. Unfortunately, the other young ladies are unknown. Photo credited to early Boyne City photographer Russell C. Leavenworth and courtesy of the collection of Bob Morgridge- a gift to him from Mrs. Mary Churchill.

THROUGH THE HISTORIAN'S LENS

The revival of our theatre: Will the show go on?

By Patrick McCleary

The Charlevoix County History Preservation Society

Each week we’ll visit some aspect of the lesser-known history of Boyne City and the surrounding area - not only major events, but the people and families who assisted in making them happen. In doing so, we help to preserve our rich, colorful and fascinating local history. Please don’t hesitate to suggest areas of interest or to share additional information and stories by emailing throughthehistorianslens@gmail.com. Come learn with us!

I have read with much interest the recent reminiscences and memories, along with the speculations and banter being passed around on various social media platforms, regarding the former Bellamy Opera House and Boyne Theatre. The timing seems about right to me, however, as March 2024 marked the 120th anniversary of this Boyne City landmark. For several years now, I have hoped to see some group or public interests take notice of this former icon’s current state of being. Sadly, not all of the past 120 years have been kind to our old friend. Since I have been asked by several of our Boyne Citizen readers to share some details of the theatre’s past, I happily accept the challenge - along with some additional points to ponder. 

One of the first comments to come to my attention was a statement that “if only we could restore the building to its original state.” I would caution you on the term “original,” as the “original” state of the theatre is not what you perceive it to be today. When Charles I. Bellamy opened his establishment, the Bellamy Opera House, he did so on Saturday evening, March 19, 1904. At that time, the entire operation did not extend to the Water Street sidewalk. Yes, you read that correctly. The front of the building as we now know it to be, the marquee, the ticket office, concession stand area and the long, brick walled hallway leading up to the main theatre area, did not exist. Essentially, you walked down a well-lit alleyway to get to the main entrance door. You purchased your tickets from a seller situated in a small cubby, which later became a janitor’s closet. I point this out for those who might one day seek state and federal grant monies to restore the building to its “original” state. You may meet with the sad realization that the front of the building would need to be removed in order to do so - something I think that we would all agree on to the contrary. 

While the original Opera House may have lacked its more impressive Water Street façade, it did not fall short of being a town marvel by any means. Mr. Bellamy came to Boyne City in late 1901 from Luther, Michigan, where he had been engaged in the opera house business for nearly 30 years prior. Recognizing the steady growth of Boyne City’s population, and the influx of business coming from outside of town and across the country, he determined that a first-class entertainment establishment would warrant success - for both him and the town in general. He spared no expense in creating the most modern facility that the times could warrant. 

In those days, most props and scenery were built on rollers. When the lights dimmed between one scene and another, the audience was subjected to the squeak of wheels as backdrops were being rolled from one end of the stage to the other. Bellamy’s scenery was raised and lowered on pulleys that were not only well-oiled for near silence, but also made for quicker scene changes. It is hard for us today to imagine the scenery that was created to enhance any number of performance venues. Each was hand-painted on canvas by some of the best scenery painters in Chicago, who Bellamy employed in Chicago with their finished product being brought to Boyne City by train. These men were very well-versed in English stage sets; interiors of any number of home and occupational sets; as well as the classic garden and column settings (the latter which can be seen in the image above.) Even the installation of these set pieces was completed by theatrical professionals. The heavy draperies, which covered the stage, that many may still remember today, required a small team of seamstresses to put together and to adorn with tassels, and they were made of the most modern fireproof material - asbestos! 

The hardwood floors in the central theatre were built on a slant. This allowed for each and every seat to have a premier view of the stage. At the time of its grand opening, it was said that 500 people could sit comfortably on the main floor and that another 250 people could be seated in the balcony. I do not claim to be an expert in this regard, but having cleaned the theatre for several years in my youth, I do not recall there ever being 750 seats. Perhaps I am mistaken, however. Sadly, all of the seats have been removed and destroyed, so now we may never know. Behind the stage and curtains were seven “good sized and conveniently arranged dressing rooms,” with an outside entrance from which they could also be reached (another of Charles Bellamy’s fire safety precautions). For those questioning stage lighting and footlights to illuminate the 25’ x 40’ stage, the building has never had “gaslight” and was always fully equipped with electricity. At the time of its opening, it was touted as being “one of the best and most modern theatrical establishments of its size in the State."

Original newspaper headline as it appeared in the 1904 edition of The Boyne Citizen.

PERHAPS YOU DIDN’T KNOW?

Over the years, the early Bellamy Opera House and later the Boyne Theatre were the location of professional plays, lectures and musicals. The Boyne City schools hosted school plays, graduations and award presentations there. The local churches and our many civic organizations held nearly all of their “honorary events,” guest speakers and community services within those same walls. In the May 27, 1904, edition of The Boyne Citizen, there was an article about the first Commencement Exercises to be held in the Bellamy Opera House. An excerpt from that article reads: 

“Never before have we been able to accommodate all who desired to attend, and it gives us great pleasure to be able to offer to the public so comfortable and pleasant a place as the Bellamy.” 

While the magician Harry Houdini never graced the stage of the Bellamy Opera House as some might allude, there were a few famous names to appear on its stage, as Mr. Bellamy was a very successful promoter.

Playbills like the one above, announced to the local populace the coming attractions and the dates that they would be performed. Courtesy of the Bob Morgridge Collection.

On June 2, 1906, our East Jordan neighbors gave this account in their newspaper, The Charlevoix County Herald:

“A crowded house greeted the appearance of Dorrit Ashton, in East Lynne, at Bellamy’s theatre on Wednesday evening. The rendition of this old favorite was excellent, a good share of the time there being but a few dry eyes in the audience. All parts were in capable hands and the impression left by the company upon our theatre goers is a most favorable one.” 

For those unfamiliar with the name Dorrit Ashton, she was a well-known stage actress of more than 50 years. She began her career with her father J.B. Ashton and played on Broadway for David Belasco and other famous names. In Vaudeville, she formed the Newton Stock Company in 1907 and toured the South and Southwest. The company was disbanded in 1915, and she then went to work for American Films. Her husband Charles Newton was also a stage and screen actor, and their daughter Dodo Newton, was a screen actress.

It wasn’t until 1907 when the first moving pictures were introduced to the Bellamy establishment. That year, a photographer by the name of C. Frank Hoffman came onto the Boyne City scene and opened a small gallery on Lake Street. Envisioning the future success of “silent movies,” Hoffman approached Bellamy and the “stage was set” as they say in show business, for moving pictures to come to the Boyne City populace- making Boyne City the “first of its size in the State to have this feature of entertainment for its citizens.” 

MARY E. (BELLAMY) KIDD AND HYLON HEATON, SR. COME ONTO THE SCENE 

Charles Bellamy died on June 4, 1925, and is buried in Maple Lawn Cemetery. He was never married and had no children, so his estate, including the entire Opera House holdings, went to his sister, Mary E. (Bellamy) Kidd. Now, Mary had lived quite an interesting life all her own, having married a prominent politician and political advocate for the development of the territory now known as South Dakota. However, we will leave that story for another date. Mary was already a widow by this time and immediately moved to Boyne City and took up the running of the operation. Unfortunately for Mary, she did not bring good health along with her. By the following year she returned to Luther and shortly after to Ionia, Michigan, where she passed away in 1926. Her estate and the Theatre operation were sold and Boyne City’s Judge, John M. Harris, handled the administration of her affairs. 

In 1926, there were two theaters being operated in Boyne City - both on Lake Street. When the Bellamy Opera House came onto the market, Hylon Heaton, Sr. purchased the building in 1927, along with the second theatre operation, known as the Princess Theatre - situated just a few storefronts north, on the same side of Lake Street. Mr. Heaton promptly closed the Princess Theatre, and in doing so, removed his only competition! Well played. 

Hylon J. Heaton III has been so kind as to help keep the story of Boyne Theatre a prominent one. Before myself, he graciously assisted my friend, teacher and co-author, Robert Morgridge. Mr. Heaton’s recollections contain many important detail,s which will find their way into a more permanent, future publication. It was Hyland’s grandfather, Hyland J, Heaton Sr. who purchased the Bellamy Theater in 1927. The September 9, 1927, issue of The Boyne Citizen outlined the many updates and modifications that had taken place, concluding with this statement from the editor: “The place will open on Tuesday night under the name of ‘The Boyne Theatre,’ and also, we might add that we like the new name!” 

An excerpt from an early Bellamy Opera House Playbill. Courtesy of the Patrick McCleary Collection.

While some may yet recall Erven Worthing, who operated the last of Boyne City’s cigar and newsstand shops at 213 S. Lake Street, it was his elder brother, Albert Worthing. who was hired as the new projectionist by Mr. Heaton. The entire building was cleaned, repaired and redecorated by Heaton and Worthing. According to newspaper accounts, the new color scheme was much more pleasing to the eye and the former ticket office became the first ladies “Cloak and Rest Room.” 

Several of the other changes that were outlined are more in keeping with the way today’s generations may recall seeing the theatre during the generations of guests that followed. 

Early Boyne City resident Naida (Burdick) Ypma shared the following recollections of the early days of moving pictures in Boyne City. 

“We used to go to the movies at the ‘Opera House,’ which is still there. When we were very young, my father took my brother and I to see Fatty Arbuckle, Charlie Chaplin and other comedians. When we were old enough to go alone, we went to Saturday matinees. There was always a serial, which ended in a cliffhanger, so we had to go back the next Saturday. It cost ten cents. The serial that I remember best starred Pearl White in ‘The Perils of Pauline.’ When I was older, my friend Virginia Bissell and I would go to the Princess Theater, which was located (on Lake Street)]  Mrs. Bissell played the piano during the movie. There was no other music. She sat almost under the screen and played music fast or slow, according to the action.”

Moving pictures also provided more paying jobs, as projectionists like Albert Worthing and various piano players found employment. Two of the most well-remembered theatre pianists were Mrs. Cecil (Rowen) Bissell and Jessie (Heaton) Haig. 

Much like the ideas behind the restoration of our historic Boyne Theatre, the details and stories shared herein are only the beginning of a much larger and more extensive exploration into the history of our landmark theatre. Be on the lookout for future articles on this subject. In the meantime, do your part toward the goal of preservation. Take a moment to share your memories and stories - no matter how large or small they may be. Simply pass them along for inclusion to my email: throughthehistorianslens@gmail.com.

> Patrick McCleary is a Certified Genealogist affiliated with the Charlevoix County History Preservation Society (CCHPS), 12555 Taylor Road, Charlevoix, MI 49720. The CCHPS promotes the understanding and appreciation of the heritage of the people of Charlevoix County and its townships by seeking out, collecting, preserving, and interpreting artifacts of historical and cultural significance. For further information, contact Patrick by email: Throughthehistorianslens@gmail.com.

Boyne Area News Briefs

HISTORIC ORNAMENTS - For the second year in a row, the Boyne Heritage Center is selling historic Christmas ornaments. The 2024 ornament features Boyne City's Clock Tower. It is an exact replica of the clock tower, made of brass and enamel by Beacon Design ChemArt Company. The E. Howard clock and 1400 lb. Meneely and Co. bronze bell were originally installed in the downtown tower in 1905. Through the diligent care of early clock winders and the foresight and preservation of various owners, both the clock tower and bell were restored and now top City Hall to be enjoyed by generations to come. The ornaments cost $35, which helps support the center. They are available every day from 7:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. at City Hall and will also be sold at the Farmers Market Sip n' Shop event on Friday, Dec. 6. There are 250 ornaments available. A limited number of the 2023 ornaments, replicas of the LaFrance firetruck, are available for $30.

MAJOR GIFT TO COLLEGE - North Central Michigan College is excited to announce a transformative lead gift for its Career and Technical Education Enhancement (CATEE) project, a $22 million initiative that will redefine workforce education in Northern Michigan. In recognition of a generous contribution from the Martin and Patricia Jahn Foundation (MAPJF), North Central’s new 11,500 square-foot technology building will be named the Martin Jahn Technology Center, celebrating the family foundation’s remarkable commitment to the future of the college and the Northern Michigan region.

> Full story.

City of Boyne City Municipal News

OVERNIGHT PARKING REMINDER - Boyne City Ordinance Sec. 66-92 prohibits the parking of vehicles on any public roadway from the hours of 2 a.m.-6 a.m. Vehicles found in violation may be towed at the owner’s expense if needed for snow removal. Even when no new snowfall is expected, DPW crews sometimes remove snow overnight. Removing vehicles from roadways makes their jobs easier and more efficient. 

CEMETERY GROUNDS BIDS - Sealed bids are now being accepted for the 2025-2027 Boyne City Maple Lawn and Wilson Cemetery Grounds Maintenance Services. Bids will be received in a clearly marked envelope labeled “Cemetery Grounds Maintenance Services” until 2 p.m. January 8, 2025 at the Boyne City Hall, 319 North Lake Street, Boyne City, MI 49712, at which time they shall be opened and read. The City of Boyne City reserves the right to reject any or all bids and waive any irregularities in their best interest. Complete specifications are available at City Hall or online here.

CITY BOARD OPENINGS - Are you interested in getting involved and having a voice on what is happening in the City? Volunteer to serve on a board! For more information and to download an application, visit the City’s website. 

• Airport Board – 2 seats open
• Economic Development Corporation (EDC) / Local Development Finance Authority (LDFA) - 1 seat open.
• Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) – 3 seats open
• Housing Commission – 1 resident position open
• Parks and Recreation Commission – 2 positions open

CITY MEETINGS – Click here for board information, agendas, and minutes.

> City Commission's next meeting is at 7 p.m. Tuesday, Jan. 14.

Obituaries

Bernard "Craig" Stadtmiller

September 20, 1949 - December 7, 2024 (age 75)

Jacquelyn Rae Capelin

December 4, 2024 — November 29, 2024 (age 77)

Thank you to the generous 2024 donors who are supporting local journalism and the Boyne Citizen!

> We are a 501c3 nonprofit organization

MUSIC, ARTS, AND ENTERTAINMENT

Please email your special events and music information to jamie@boynecitizen.com.

BARREL BACK. 4069 M-75, Walloon Lake, (231) 535-6000.

> Brunch with Santa - 10 a.m., Saturday, Dec. 14 (order off menu)

> Live music 6-9 p.m. Mondays, Tuesdays and Wednesdays with music and trivia on Thursdays.

Mondays - Sean Bielby

Tuesdays - Lara Fullford

Wednesdays - Pete Kehoe

Thursdays - Trivia & music by Holly Keller

BC LANES/THE VENUE BAR & GRILL. 1199 M-75 S, Boyne City,(231) 582-6353.

> Open bowling 5-9 p.m. Tuesdays, 3-10 p.m. Fridays, 7 a.m.-10 p.m. Saturdays, 8 a.m.-8 p.m. Sundays.

> LIVE MUSIC

Saturday, Dec. 14 - Shuvlhed, 8-11 p.m.

Saturday, Dec. 21 - Yankee Station, 8-11 p.m.

Saturday, December 28 - Two Beats, 7-10 p.m.

BOYNE CITY FARMERS MARKET. Indoors in the pavilion at Veterans Park, 207 N. Lake Street, Boyne City. (231) 582-9009.

> Open Saturdays 8 a.m.-12 p.m.

BOYNE CITY TAP ROOM. 220 S. Lake St., Boyne City, (231) 459-4487.

> MY CLUE TRIVIA - Mondays

> SINGO BINGO - Tuesdays

> LIVE MUSIC at 7 p.m.

Thursdays - Adam and the Cabana Boys

Fridays - Patrick Ryan and Josh Raber

Saturdays (starting Dec. 7) - Patrick Ryan

> WINTER BREAK ADDITIONAL DATES

Sunday, Dec. 29 - Patrick Ryan

Tuesday, Dec. 31 - New Year's Eve with the Sleeping Gypsies

BOYNE MOUNTAIN. 1 Boyne Mountain Rd., Boyne Falls, (855) 688-7024.

> Weekly schedule of events and entertainment at all Boyne Mountain venues.

BOYNE VALLEY VINEYARD. 05325 US 131 S, Petoskey (231) 373-2090.

> LIVE MUSIC - Saturdays 2-6 p.m.

Saturday, Dec. 14 - Chris Calleja

Saturday, Dec. 21 - Michelle Chenard

Saturday, Dec. 28 - Chris Calleja

Sunday, Dec. 29 - Chase & Allie

Monday, Dec. 30 - Michelle Chenard

Tuesday, Dec. 31 - Chris Calleja

CAFE SANTE. 1 Water St., Boyne City, (231) 582-8800.

> LIVE MUSIC- Mondays 6-9

Monday, Dec. 16 - The Shifties. 6-9 p.m.

Friday, Dec. 20 - Pete Kehoe, 7-10 p.m.

Saturday, Dec. 21 - Pete Kehoe, 7-10 p.m.

Friday, Dec. 27 - Lavender Lions, 7-10 p.m.

Saturday, Dec. 28 - Sean Bielby 7-10 p.m.

Tuesday, Dec. 31- New Year's Eve Party with The Shifties, 8 p.m. - 12 a.m.

CROOKED TREE ARTS CENTER. 461 E. Mitchell Street. Petoskey, (231) 347-4337.

> LIVE MUSIC

> See website for Holiday Bazaar, Swirl, art shows, and children's activities.

FRESHWATER Art Gallery and Concert Venue , 217 S Lake St., Boyne City, (231) 582-2588.

> LIVE MUSIC - 8 p.m. Call to reserve tickets.

Saturday, Dec. 28 - Thornetta Davis

Sunday, Dec. 29 - Larry McCray

GREAT LAKES CENTER FOR THE ARTS. 800 Bay Harbor Dr., Petoskey, (231) 439 -2600.

> LIVE PERFORMANCES

Thursday, Dec. 12 and Friday, Dec. 13 - The Messiah by Candlelight, by the Great Lakes Chamber Orchestra and Chorus, 7 p.m.

Sunday, Dec. 15 - Doctor KaBoom! The Science of Santa, featuring the magic of physics - 2 p.m.

Saturday, Dec. 21 - The Nutcracker, two performances, 3 and 7 p.m.

Sunday, Dec. 22 - The Nutcracker, 3 p.m.

> HOLIDAY DOUBLE FEATURE

Saturday, Dec. 14 -The Muppets Christmas Movie, 2 p.m. and Meet me in St. Louis, 7 p.m.; $8 for both features; $5 for one.

LAKE STREET PUB. 202 S. Lake St., Boyne City, (231) 497-6031.

> TRIVIA NIGHT - Wednesdays at 7 p.m.

MUSKRAT DISTILLING.121 Water St., Boyne City, (231) 268-0178.

> KARAOKE - 8 to 11 p.m. every Wednesday

> LIVE MUSIC 8 to 11 p.m.

Friday, Dec. 13 - Two Track Mind

Friday, Dec. 20 - Eric Jacqua

Friday, Dec. 27 - Jelly Roll

Tuesday, Dec. 31 - Saxu4ia

PROVISIONS LOUNGE. 123 Water St., Boyne City, (231) 582-2151.

LIVE MUSIC, 6-8 p.m. Tuesdays and Saturdays

Tuesday, Dec. 17 - Sean Bielby

Tuesday, Dec. 24 - CLOSED

Tuesday, Dec. 31 - No music; prix fixe dinner for New Year's Eve.

RED MESA GRILL.117 Water St, Boyne City, (231) 582-0049.

LIVE MUSIC 6-9 p.m.

Tuesday, Dec. 17 - Lou Thumser

Tuesday, Dec. 24 - CLOSED

Tuesday, Dec. 31 - No music

STIGGS BREWERY & KITCHEN. 112 S. Park St., Boyne City, (231) 497-6100

> Thursdays - Industry Nights - $3 Stiggs Mainstays, late night food, beats by @leefer_madness and @coffeeh0t.

> First Wednesday of the month - Open Mic Nights hosted by Nelson Olstrom, 6-9 p.m.

WALLOON LAKE VILLAGE. M75 just south of US 131.

> Christmas in Walloon Movie Night, 7:15-9 p.m., Friday, December 13 in the Talcott Event Center - indoors. Enjoy "The Santa Clause" movie. Free entry for hotel guests and community members. Concessions available for purchase.

> Wreath Making Class featuring Sweetwater Floral; 3-4 p.m., Saturday, Dec. 14 in the Talcott Event Center, $80 per person

The Boyne Citizen

Email: jim@boynecitizen.com

Phone: 231-459-4166

© Copyright 2024 Boyne Citizen, all rights reserved