|
Job search for those with mental health challenges or cognitive differences
Editorial by Christian Saint Cyr
National Director / Canadian Job Development Network
.
Employment barriers for those with mental health challenges and cognitive differences are challenging as these are two of the primary areas where the disabilities can be invisible to employers.
And yet, we see the employment outcomes for these individuals are considerably lower than for individuals who do not have these challenges.
Employment outcomes for Canadians with mental health issues are significantly lower than the national average. Only 46% of adults with mental health-related disabilities are employed, compared to 80% of those without any sort of disability.
Up to 90% of individuals with severe mental illnesses remain unemployed, and they face high rates of long-term joblessness, according to data gathered by Statistics Canada.
A higher proportion of people with mental health issues actively look for work but fail to find it (12.2%), compared to the general population (8.6%), according to the Future Skills Centre.
While general Canadian employment rates hover around 84 per cent for those without conditions, the employment rate for those with cognitive differences is notably lower (approximately 76-77%).
Research from the Labour Market Information Council reveals that over 90% of Canadian job postings require social-emotional skills that can unintentionally screen out neurodivergent candidates. Over 40% also contain complex application processes or confusing jargon.
To help us better understand these challenges, the Future Skills Centre recently published: ‘Labour Market Experiences of Canadians with Mental Health Conditions and Cognitive Differences’
For a better understanding of these challenges it’s helpful to get technical definitions.
According to the Canadian Psychological Association, "a mental health condition refers to psychological and emotional well-being, specifically affecting mood, feelings, and behavior."
Meanwhile, "a cognitive difference refers specifically to the brain's baseline ability to process information, including learning, reasoning, and memory."
In developing the report, Future Skills Centre hoped to better understand three questions:
- How do employment outcomes, job satisfaction, and financial outlooks differ between individuals with cognitive differences, individuals with mental health conditions, and those with no condition?
- What role do workplace training and supports play in shaping job satisfaction and work experiences across these groups?
- How do broader economic pressures and workplace conditions, such as job security and automation concerns, influence labour market experiences?
In compiling the research, the authors came to three primary insights. Among participants between the ages of 25 and 54 with a mental health condition, a higher proportion report looking for work, but not finding employment (12.2%), compared to those with cognitive differences (5.7%), or no conditions (8.6%).
Employment outcomes are significantly lower for these populations. Among respondents aged 25 to 54 years with no condition, 83.7 per cent report being employed, compared to 61.7 per cent of those reporting a mental health condition and 76.4 per cent of those reporting a cognitive difference.
Long-term unemployment is also a significant factor in this population, particularly among women.
Among those with mental health conditions, 84% of women report unemployment lasting six months or longer, compared to 62 per cent of men; a similar pattern appears among those with cognitive differences (80% of women vs. 60% of men).
Both the Canadian Mental Health Association and the Mental Health Commission of Canada have suggested key workplace accommodations that could significantly improve the employment outcomes for those with mental health challenges as well as those with cognitive differences. These include:
-
Flexible Schedules: Modifying start/end times or allowing part-time hours to attend therapy or manage medication side effects.
-
Modified Workspaces: Relocating a workspace to a quieter area, allowing noise-canceling headphones, or reducing sensory overstimulation
-
Task Adjustments: Breaking large projects into smaller milestones, adjusting deadlines, or altering non-essential duties.
-
Leave & Time Off: Utilizing short-term medical leave, sick days, or leave under the Employment Insurance (EI) sickness benefits program.
Employers can also play a significant role in supporting workers with mental health challenges and cognitive differences.
Stakeholders argue that legitimate support goes beyond basic legal requirements and spans proactive programs embedded in Canadian workplaces:
-
Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs): Most medium to large employers offer confidential, short-term counselling and crisis support for employees and their families.
-
Mental Health First Aid (MHFA): Many organizations train peers and managers through the Mental Health Commission of Canada to identify and respond to emotional distress.
-
Psychological Health and Safety: Organizations are increasingly adopting the National Standard of Canada for Psychological Health and Safety in the Workplace to actively reduce stigma and prevent burnout.
Supporting workers with cognitive differences in Canada requires a combination of targeted pre-employment training, specialized workplace accommodations, and access to national or provincial funding programs. Employers and job seekers alike benefit from specialized initiatives that prioritize skills matching, job coaching, and career retention.
Whether it’s an invisible disability such as a mental health challenge, cognitive difference, chronic pain or apparent challenges such as mobility, visual impairment or auditory impairment, it’s often a lack of understanding that prevents employers from hiring individuals.
Without a full understanding of the challenge and certainly not the strengths, employers will often hire the candidate that doesn’t have the disability.
We all know that there are a multitude of factors that result in success or failure in the workplace and it’s unfortunate that so many employers can limit it to just one factor.
More than half of workplace modifications in Canada cost $0, and 80% cost less than $500.
For the roughly 37% of cases that do require a direct one-time purchase, the average cost for a specific modification is approximately $500, according to data provided by the Government of Canada.
In my experience, nothing convinces an employer of the value of an employee with a disability than having hired a worker with a disability.
While that may sound like a ‘catch-22’, it really speaks to our need to put a personal face and experience on job development. If we can help create personal interactions through job fairs, information interviews, mentorship and workplace tours, we can give our clients with disabilities an opportunity to present themselves as more than just their disability.
We’ll be discussing insights from the latest job vacancy report at our #MotivatingMondays meeting of the Canadian Job Development Network, Monday July 20th at 8:30am Pacific; 9:30am Mountain; 10:30am Central; 11:30am Eastern; 12:30pm Atlantic and at 1pm in Newfoundland.
.
On the morning of Monday July 20th 'Click this Link' to join the session.
.* * *
Staying on top of labour market information...
Canadian Labour Market Reports
The Canadian Labour Market Reports provide a weekly round-up of the major labour market information that most impacts those in
career transition. Click on the relevant
labour market report below.
.
BC Labour Market Report
www.labourmarketonline.com
.
Alberta Labour Market Report
www.jobdevelopment.org/albertalmr
.
Prairie Labour Market Report
www.jobdevelopment.org/prairielmr
.
Ontario Labour Market Online
www.ontariolabourmarketonline.org
.
Atlantic Labour Market Report
www.jobdevelopment.org/atlanticlmr
..
To learn more, send me an email at:
csaintcyr@labourmarketsolutions.ca
|