June 12, 2025

Top stories

■ House votes to claw back $9 billion for foreign aid and public broadcasting (New York Times) / ‘...Now the Senate has five weeks to pass the package. If the Senate ignores it, PBS and NPR keep their funding for the next two years.’ (Brian Stelter) / Conservative activists have waited decades to defund PBS and NPR. They are finally getting their chance (CNN) / Planned PBS, NPR cuts would overwhelmingly hit outlets in states Trump won, report finds (CBS News) / PBS statement on House vote (PBS News)


■ ‘In video obtained by Jacob Soboroff [NBC News], agents cuff Sen. Alex Padilla on the floor outside DHS Secretary Kristi Noem news conference.’ (Jesse Rodriguez) / ‘What an AP photo by Etienne Laurent of Sen. Alex Padilla being physically dragged away by the DHS secretary's security’ (Farnoush Amiri)


■ Inside ABC News’s decision to oust longtime correspondent Terry Moran (Wall Street Journal) / Terry Moran launches Substack channel to continue ‘important work’ after ABC News dismissal (Deadline)


■ L.A. law enforcement’s treatment of journalists during protests is once again under scrutiny (Los Angeles Times) / Why the death of reporter Ruben Salazar 55 years ago resonates with journalists covering L.A. protests today (CalMatters) / Number of Australian journalists hit by U.S. law enforcement during L.A. protests climbs (The Guardian)


■ Associated Press seeks full appeals court hearing on access to Trump administration events (Associated Press) 


■ FTC may impose political bias rule on Omnicom and Interpublic merger (New York Times) 


■ Why Warner Boss Zaslav is having to split up the media empire he built (Wall Street Journal)


■ CNN plans a podcast expansion push (Hollywood Reporter) 


■ Big Tech stumbles into a big brawl over C-SPAN’s streaming future (Washington Post) / Bill to require big tech to pay Oregon newsrooms advances with fewer legal concerns  (Oregon Live)


■ BBC News journalists lodge ageism complaint as they face being fired under Newsdesk merger (Deadline)


■ Carrie Budoff Brown returns to POLITICO as executive editor and executive vice president (POLITICO) / Boutwell named managing editor for Troy Publications Inc. (Boone Newsmedia) / Jeff D’Onofrio appointed chief financial officer (Washington Post) / Gray Media names Shalayna Valencia as general manager of KOSA in Odessa, Texas (Gray Media) / Forbes hires Di Licosa as reporter on wealth team (Talking Biz News) / Cronkite School welcomes new professor of practice in AI and investigative journalism (Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication) 


■ As threats grow, fact-checkers double down on standards, IFCN report finds (Poynter)

CRAFT

How these reporters found bad citations in the 'Make America Healthy Again' report


NOTUS reporters Emily Kennard and Margaret Manto recently made headlines after breaking a bombshell story on how Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s “Make America Healthy Again” report cited several studies that didn’t exist.


Then, on June 11, they returned with another big takeaway: RFK Jr. used the report to advance vaccine misinformation.


The Institute spoke with Kennard and Manto to find out the story behind their scoop.


Can you walk us through how you first discovered the falsities in the MAHA report released in May?

Manto: I got a tip over Memorial Day weekend that there might be some issues in the MAHA report. I started checking the citations Saturday morning. For some reason I decided to check bottom-up, which was lucky since the last two citations both turned out to be fabricated. That definitely motivated me to check every citation. 


My NOTUS colleague Emily Kennard and I checked them all over the next few days. To be absolutely certain that we weren’t missing real research, Emily had the good idea to reach out to the “authors” of the fake papers.

Once we heard back from them saying they’d never heard of the papers they’d supposedly authored, we felt ready to publish.



When the original article was published, Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt defended the MAHA report, citing the errors as “formatting issues” rather than factual errors. What advice do you have for reporters when government officials try to spin the story incorrectly?

Kennard: We gave administration officials the opportunity to comment on our findings before we published them. They didn’t comment.


Our reporting proved that the issues went beyond formatting, and I hope the investigation speaks for itself. As reporters, that’s all we can do. We aren’t responsible for how officials handle any resulting PR cleanup — that’s above our pay grade.


How did you go deeper into the story to find out the issues surrounding vaccine effectiveness that you published yesterday? 

Kennard: Secretary Kennedy often gets called out for his past anti-vaccine efforts, so we figured we should take a closer look at that section in the report, which we thought was surprisingly short. Homing in on just one section, rather than all 78 pages and 522 citations, allowed us to focus much more on the specific claims and the research the report uses to back them up.


When you are reporting on lengthy documents like the MAHA report, how do you stay organized and on deadline? 


Manto: I made a color-coded spreadsheet to keep track of all the citations and the issues we found as we went through them. We split that sheet into topic sections once it became clear we’d have to go through the citations for scientific merit. 


As far as staying on deadline, it felt like such a hiding-in-plain-sight kind of story that we were pretty motivated to get it done as quickly as possible. Constantly communicating (Emily and I sit next to each other in the office) and Congress being out of session also helped! 


What is your advice for finding a scoop on a heavily reported topic like health policy?


Manto: Do things that seem boring or like more trouble than they’re worth. Those are the things no one else will do, so you might break some ground. 


But more importantly, to all the hiring managers reading this: Emily and I are both fellows at NOTUS. When our fellowship term ends next year, hire us and we will find more scoops for you.

CAREER
 

A journalist’s guide to protest safety


As protests continue in Los Angeles against ICE raids, journalists must know how to stay safe. In recent days, members of the press covering these demonstrations have faced violence from law enforcement, including being struck by rubber bullets and exposed to tear gas.


According to Reporters Without Borders, at least 27 journalists have been attacked by law enforcement while covering the protests between June 6 and June 8.


“We really need to think about creating a culture of safety collectively, of keeping each other safe as journalists … but also keeping the people we cover safe because that really impacts down the line whether we’re safe doing our work,” said Corinne Chin, director of news talent for recruitment at The Associated Press, during an Institute program on journalist safety.


Here are tips journalists can use to stay safe during protest coverage, as written by Institute summer intern Maggie Amacher (Ohio University '26):


Before heading into the field


  • Do your research. Scout your locations ahead of time. Identify exit routes, choke points, and safe parking. Understand the cultural context of the space and those involved in the protest. Familiarize yourself with local power structures, including law enforcement, political groups, and social dynamics.


  • Conduct a risk assessment. Identify potential hazards: Who might be at risk, and how likely each risk is. Plan how to mitigate each threat.


  • Communicate with police. Establish a line of communication with local law enforcement to clarify expectations on both sides. “Trying to figure all of this out in the heat of a riot, the heat of a protest, is never going to be productive,” said Mickey Osterreicher, general counsel to the National Press Photographers Association (NPPA), during an Institute program on journalist safety. “You should have and build a relationship.”


What to bring


  • Print emergency contacts and ID. Always carry your press credentials and know how to display them safely.


  • Wear practical clothing. Avoid open-toed shoes or anything impractical for quick movement or unpredictable conditions.


  • Bring protective gear. Consider wearing goggles and a respirator in case of tear gas, and carry a basic first-aid kit. Use this checklist for preparing your safety kit.


  • Use the buddy system. Work in teams when possible. Freelancers should consider partnering with others on the ground.


In the field


  • Maintain situational awareness. Know where your exits are, who is nearby, and where your team is located. Regularly check in with your physical and mental state. “Do not get tunnel vision,” Osterreicher said. "Look around you. Be aware of what’s happening.”


  • Stay in touch with your team. Agree on rally points and what to do if separated. For example, meet at a set location every 30 minutes. Have a backup meeting spot away from the protest zone. Plan communication strategies in case phones are down. Set clear signals for when to leave.


  • Keep your focus. Be intentional in your reporting. “What is it that you want to let people know?” said Chin. “There are things that we can do collectively to be a little bit more thoughtful about it.”


Interacting with law enforcement


  • Prepare for confrontations. Police may seize equipment or detain journalists. Carry a lawyer's number on paper, use a secondary phone if needed, and establish backup communication methods. (Keep the number for the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press free Legal Hotline handy.)


  • Document everything. Record all law enforcement interactions for accountability. “Don’t assume that just because there are laws in place to protect you that the authorities are necessarily going to follow them,” said Seth Stern, director of advocacy at Freedom of the Press Foundation, during another Institute program on safety tips for journalists in the field.


  • Protect your sources and materials. Use encrypted tools like Signal for secure and confidential communication. Be aware of local laws about filming police.



  • Tell your story. Write about your interactions with law enforcement. “Make a scene, make some noise,” Stern said. “This is a real threat, not just to journalists, but to the public.”


Know your rights


Understanding your legal protections is essential.


“Everything that’s legal, it’s always more complicated than a simple yes or no,” Osterreicher said. 


Key protections to remember: 


  • The First Amendment guarantees five protections, including the right to speech and the press, but is subject to time, place and manner restrictions. Photography and videography are considered a form of free speech.


  • The Fourth Amendment protects journalists against unreasonable search and seizure. 


  • The 14th Amendment ensures due process and equal protection under the law.



These tips were pulled from the following previous Institute programs: "Protest Protocol: How journalists can stay safe in times of unrest" and "Arrested on the Job: Press freedom trends & advice for journalists working in the field."

 
 
 
COMMUNITY

Resources

This newsletter is written & edited by the National Press Club Journalism Institute staff: Beth Francesco, Holly Butcher Grant, Elliot C. Williams, and Mitch Harle. Send us your questions and suggestions for topics to cover.


Get this from a friend? Subscribe, and view the archives.

Facebook  X  Linkedin  Youtube  

DONATE TO THE INSTITUTE


The National Press Club Journalism Institute promotes an engaged global citizenry through an independent and free press, and equips journalists with skills and standards to inform the public in ways that inspire a more representative democracy. As the non-profit affiliate of the National Press Club, the Institute powers journalism in the public interest. The Institute's tax ID number is 52-1750908.