logoFB-twit-insta.png



Iowa Chapter

Physicians for Social Responsibility



December 10, 2022




 

Wind turbine - Kirkwood College, Cedar Rapids, Iowa 2014.   

Source: John Rachow

 

Hope for the New Year: Truth & Youth Confront CCS


By Peter Montague, Historian and Journalist and Fellow at the Science and Environment Network

Our series of reports have examined concerns, especially regarding health, related to carbon capture. Carbon capture involves a variety of initiatives undertaken purportedly to address looming climate changes. Our previous report addressed the significant opportunity costs of diverting taxpayer dollars to the unlikely benefits of carbon capture. All previous carbon capture and carbon dioxide pipeline Alerts, Fact Sheets, and Reports can be reviewed here.


This edition in our series is a special forward-looking letter from Peter Montegue. 

To my pessimistic or discouraged friends:


Yes, the forces promoting CCS are powerful in the media, in government, in industry, in academia, in organized labor (which has been beaten down for 40 years), and even in the environmental “movement,” such as it is.


Every large CCS project has failed, and every CCS-oil-recovery project is producing more CO2 than it is storing in the ground. The oil and coal industries have been lying to us for 40 years, denying the dangers of global heating. Now they are pretending that, with CCS, nothing needs to change. This is bunkum and anyone with the basic facts knows it. Fossil fuels have got to go. That’s all there is to it.


The economics of CCS only work if Uncle Sam kicks in huge sums of money. In round numbers, the U.S. produces about 5 billion tonnes of CO2 each year. At $85 per tonne, we’d have to spend $425 billion each year to bury all that CO2 – and what if it doesn’t work? Furthermore, all that free money gives Big Oil a powerful incentive to make more CO2 each year – taxpayers will reward them for doing it.


Recent studies – I call them coffin nails -- show that CCS is a highly dubious proposition, and we know (and can show) that cheaper already-proven alternatives already exist, which can save every family $1000 to $2000 per year and can create good jobs in every zip code. See https://www.carboncapturefacts.org.


Meanwhile, a youth movement -- bigger than the anti-Vietnam war movement of 1963-1974 and bigger than the anti-nuclear movement of the 1960s-1970s, perhaps even bigger than the civil rights and Indigenous Peoples’ movements of the 1940s through today – is organized and growing. Young people know their future is being ruined and they’ll become more angry and more organized each passing week. They will not stop until they win. They can’t stop until they win. Their future is being sacrificed by the priesthood of petroleum and the clergy of coal.


Nuclear power was killed by economics – and by boisterous occupations and protests – and the Vietnam war was ended by coalitions of ordinary citizens and Vietnam vets taking to the streets – and of course by huge sacrifices on the part of Vietnamese people determined to expel an invading force, no matter the cost. Giving up was simply not possible for them, just as global heating must be stopped today. There is no alternative.


Huge pipeline projects have been stopped in recent years by Indigenous Peoples and their allies who organized and persisted in the face of brutal repression, regardless of cost to themselves. Now thousands of miles of new, dangerous pipelines are proposed for CO2. 

We know that these CO2 pipelines are the centerpiece – the essential component, the linchpin – of CCS. Without these pipelines, CCS will disappear and a clean, modern economy built on justice can emerge.


New facts about CCS will not, by themselves, stop CCS. But facts do matter. We have the scientific facts – the truth – on our side. The other side is swaddled in self-delusion, pretending they can ignore or deny or somehow finesse the facts. We have seen this happen before – with nuclear power, with foreign wars of aggression, with major petroleum pipelines, with massive land grabs, with American apartheid and the unquestioned reign of white supremacy. 


In these historical examples, the media, government, industry, academia, organized labor, and even some in the environmental “movement,” started out defending the status quo, getting along by going along. But active citizens armed with the facts – buoyed by the truth – never let up, never quit. And in large measure they have prevailed.


History is on our side. The facts are on our side. We can win. It will not be easy – nothing worth winning ever is – but we will prevail.


We can do this, 


Peter Montague

Thanks for reading. Click on the button below to review your giving options.

Support Our Work
Facebook      Twitter