|
A number of lawsuits in the recent spate of anti-childhood vaccine litigation have had the financial backing of monied interest groups. These groups also appear to be coordinating their litigation strategy for the cases they are backing. While so far these challenges have produced only a few wins, the presence of wealthy backers means the suits are likely to continue, whether or not they are likely to succeed. Further, we can undoubtedly expect to see additional cases in the future. Those advocating for public health can take a page from their playbooks by collaborating across organizations to become more proactive in protecting public health authority.
ICAN
The most recent successful challenge to a state’s lack of religious exemptions for childhood vaccines is a Mississippi case funded by ICAN, the Informed Consent Action Network. The group’s website bills the organization as “empower[ing individuals] to make truly informed decisions about their own health and the health of their families.” A common tactic across these groups is couching their stance on vaccines in terms of informed consent and “man-made disease,” a term referring to vaccine related injuries, along with long-disproven claims that vaccines cause autism. They are advancing an “anti-government mandate” agenda primarily through lawsuits against public health authorities and through their media arm.
ICAN notched their first major win in Bosarge v. Edney, a case that found that Mississippi’s lack of religious exemptions to their childhood vaccine mandate violated the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment. Challengers in suits in other states unsurprisingly cite Bosarge in support of their claims that their states’ childhood vaccine mandates are unconstitutional. But they also appear to go one step further by repurposing the language of the Bosarge complaint for their own suits.
Advocates for Faith and Freedom
The religious liberty group Advocates for Faith and Freedom was founded in 2005, as a “legal ministry.” Their stated goal is to “safeguard[] the constitutional liberties that define the United States as a beacon of freedom and prosperity,” especially those arising out of the First Amendment, “such as freedom of speech and the free exercise of religion.” They are currently involved in multiple religious cases, primarily in California, that touch on a wide range of issues including vaccines, employment, trans rights, medical censorship, and more.
The group is currently involved in a challenge to the lack of religious exemptions to California’s childhood vaccine mandate. Royce v. Bonta was filed in the Federal District Court for the Southern District of California in October. Interestingly, large sections of the Royce complaint closely track the Bosarge v. Edney complaint. For example, both complaints describe the plaintiffs’ religious beliefs in the following terms:
“[The plaintiff and their spouse] prayed extensively and consulted the Bible when deciding whether or not to vaccinate [their child/children], and they arrived at the firm religious conviction that they must not. Because many of the required childhood vaccines were derived from aborted fetal cells, [plaintiff] believes vaccinating [his/her] children would cause [him/her] and [his/her] family to be complicit in abortion.”
The plaintiffs in each case describe arriving at their religious conviction through private prayer. Yet the language they use to describe these private events are nearly identical, suggesting that they coordinated their litigation efforts.
We The Patriots USA
We The Patriots USA, an anti-vaccine advocacy group, is based out of Idaho. Their stated goal is “to create a powerful network of Patriots to preserve and reclaim our God-given inalienable rights–including but not limited to the rights recorded in the United States Constitution–through education, advocacy, and litigation.”
We covered Milford Christian Church v. Russell-Tucker in last week’s newsletter. Milford was an unsuccessful challenge in the Federal District Court for the District of Connecticut to Connecticut’s decision to repeal its religious exemption to its childhood vaccine mandate. We The Patriots USA financially backed the plaintiffs in that suit. We The Patriots USA had previously challenged Connecticut’s vaccine mandate in We The Patriots, Inc. v. Connecticut Office of Early Childhood Development. The Second Circuit dismissed that case as well. The group has indicated they plan to apply to the Supreme Court for certiorari, with a stated goal of requiring religious exemptions nation-wide. We The Patriots USA has a page on their website detailing their ongoing efforts to overturn the Connecticut vaccine mandate. They specifically mention that they looked to the recent Mississippi case, Bosarge v. Edney, that overturned the lack of religious exemptions.
The We The Patriots USA v. Connecticut complaint and the Milford Christian Church v. Russell-Tucker complaint are very similar. They not only allege similar claims in nearly identical language, but they also use verbatim descriptions of vaccines and their risks. These similarities indicate that We The Patriots USA is not only backing the Milford case financially, but is perhaps coordinating on litigation strategy.
Children’s Health Defense
Another group looming large in the anti-vaccine space is the Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.-backed Children’s Health Defense (CHD). While not currently challenging a state childhood vaccine mandate, the group is involved in several suits challenging other vaccine policies. CHD’s focus areas are mostly pulled from common conspiracy theories, such as 5g cell towers being dangerous, the CDC suppressing COVID-19 information, and vaccines being ineffective.
Like many other groups, CHD uses obfuscating language to downplay their focus on eliminating vaccine mandates. Instead of stating they fight to eliminate vaccine mandates, the group states they “fight corruption, mass surveillance and censorship […] as well as advocat[ing] for worldwide rights to health freedom and bodily autonomy.” These goals sound admirable in the abstract, but upon a closer look devolve into a general anti-government stance. The fear and uncertainty surrounding the COVID-19 vaccine provided an opportunity for these groups to appeal to a wider audience of potential supporters.
We wish you a Happy Holiday season. The PHLW Newsletter will be taking a break, and the next Litigation Update will be in your inbox in January.
|