Creditor News
A Newsletter for individuals and businesses concerned with Creditor’s Rights

November 2026 | 416th Edition

 

Inside This Issue:


  • Child Support Exemption for Garnishment
  • IRA Funds are not Disposable Income in Chapter 13
  • Statute of Limitations Enforced on Challenge to Bylaws Amendment
  • Notice of Sale

Also Featuring:

  • Ted's Tips
  • Law Review: Estate Planning
  • Firm Attorney Biographies

Spotlight:

Tracy Koegler

Creditor's Rights - It's Our Focus!

Creditors hear too much about debtors' rights - creditors need to fight back! Bankruptcy laws are primarily drawn to protect debtors. The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act also protects debtors, and limits creditors' activity. Both laws prescribe punishments for violations.

We believe that creditors deserve due process and consideration. We work hard to protect our clients' rights through collection activities, civil litigation, and bankruptcy practice. To be competitive, we offer retainer plans and several fee options. To be accessible, we promise prompt and consistent communication.

We would greatly appreciate the opportunity to meet with any prospective client to review your needs and services. Please schedule your appointment by calling Eddie at 804-545-6251, Jennifer at 804-545-6242, or Daniel at 804-545-6220.

 
 

Collections: Child Support Exemption for Garnishment

In the case of General Electric Capital Auto Lease, Inc. v. Turner, the City of Richmond Circuit Court denied a debtor's exemption to garnishment claim.

 

In Turner the debtor claimed an exemption based on the amount of monthly child support the debtor owed. The Court noted that the specific exemption claimed by the debtor on the garnishment form was the exemption created by Virginia Code §55-165. The judgment creditor argued that this code section only applied to assignments of wages executed and approved by a judge under the procedure specifically set out in Virginia Code §55-161 through 167. That procedure included notice to and consent of the debtor's creditors, the appointment of a trustee, and so on. The Court found as fact that none of those things were done in this case. Therefore, the Court ruled that an exemption under Virginia Code §55-165 did not apply. The Court also considered all the other exemptions from garnishment listed in Virginia Code §8.01-512.4, and none of those exemptions applied either. Accordingly, the debtor's claim of exemption was denied.

Ted's Tips

When giving us your delinquent accounts, always include a social security number, birth date, and other identifying information that could be helpful for Skiptracing.

 

Bankruptcy: IRA Funds are not Disposable Income in Chapter 13

The case of Solomon v. Cosby, decided by the United States District Court in Baltimore, Maryland, served as a good review (although bad outcome) of how Individual Retirement Account funds are treated in a Chapter 13 bankruptcy.


The Appeals Court reversed the Bankruptcy Court's decision that IRA funds are disposable income, and that the debtor's Chapter 13 plan should be rejected as not paying "all of the debtor's projected disposable income".  


In Solomon, the debtor, a retired physician, had proposed a Chapter 13 plan excluding approximately $1.4 million invested in an IRA. The debtor was facing tort claims of sexual misconduct from several former medical patients who sought damages of $160 million at the time he filed his Chapter 13. The plan provided for only $45,000.00 over five years.


The Appeals Court held that under the clear terms of Bankruptcy Code §1325(b)(2), the debtor's IRA funds are not "income". Both the statutory definition of "disposable income" as income that is received by the debtor, as well as the requirement that projected income must be calculated over the life of the plan, contemplate income that a debtor is actually receiving at the time of the confirmation hearing, the debtor was not actually receiving any disbursements from his IRAs. The debtor also insisted that he had no intentions of withdrawing funds from the IRAs during the life of the plan.

Law Review of the Month: Estate Planning

The firm has extensive experience in estate planning. We welcome the opportunity to discuss wills, trusts, living wills (Declarations for Natural Death) and other planning matters.

 

Real Estate: Statute of Limitations Enforced on Challenge to Bylaws Amendment

The Virginia Condominium Act, specifically Virginia Code Section 55-79.71(C), provides for a statute of limitations in regard to challenging amendments to governing documents. The section provides, in part:


“An action to challenge the validity of an amendment adopted by the unit owners’ association pursuant to this section may not be brought more than one year after the amendment is recorded.”


In the case of Godwin v. Bay Point Association Board of Directors, a Norfolk Circuit Court was faced with a homeowner challenge to bylaw amendments. The homeowner, Godwin, had sued the association alleging that it breached its governing documents by taking actions four years earlier and three years earlier that increased her assessment for insurance premiums. The association filed a motion to dismiss Godwin’s complaint on the ground that it was time-barred pursuant to Virginia Code Section 55-79.71(C).


Four years earlier the association’s board of directors signed a resolution regarding physical damage and flood insurance. Three years earlier it drafted and signed a bylaw amendment relating to insurance premiums. The association argued that challenging either of these actions was time-barred under the statute of limitations. 


The court ruled that the resolution was not an amendment to the condominium governing documents within the meaning of the act. The court found that, at most, the resolution represented a statement of the board’s opinion that the bylaws should be amended to revise the way insurance premiums were assessed against the unit owners. In the resolution, the board acknowledged the need to amend the bylaws and stated that the amendment process was lengthy and inconsistent with the budget preparation schedule for the upcoming fiscal year. Because the resolution was not an amendment adopted by the unit owners pursuant to the act, the court found that the act’s statute of limitations did not apply. However, the court ruled that the bylaws amendment was an amendment to the governing documents within the definition contemplated by the act. Accordingly, the one-year statute of limitations applied.


Godwin argued that because the association violated mandatory procedures for amending the bylaws, the amendment was null and void, and thus, the statute of limitations did not apply. The court, however, in examining the statute, noted that nothing in the statute suggested that only valid bylaw amendments are subject to the one-year statute of limitations. The court noted that any amendment, not just valid ones, may be challenged within one year. Accordingly, Godwin’s claim was barred by the statute of limitations.


Godwin then tried to argue that there was a breach of fiduciary duty (the legal duty of the board to act in the best interests of the residents). Godwin and the association agreed that an action for such breach must be filed within two years from the date of breach. Godwin argued that, although the association initially breached its fiduciary duty four and three years earlier “when in bad faith it knowingly and willfully” adopted the resolution and the bylaws amendment, there were renewed breaches when the annual budgets were adopted in the last two years, which reflected the change made to assessments for insurance premiums. The court disagreed, finding that any breach of fiduciary duty relating to the change in the insurance premium assessment took place when the association acted four and three years ago to adopt the resolution and bylaw amendment. The latest of these actions occurred over two years prior to Godwin’s filing suit. Therefore, the claim was time-barred.

 

Foreclosure: Notice of Sale

The Code of Virginia provides specific guidance as to giving notice of a foreclosure sale.


In 2019, §55-59.1 was repealed and replaced with language in §55.1-321 and 322. 


§55.1-321 and 322 require that the written notice of sale contain the time, date and place of the proposed sale, as well as either (i) the instrument number, or, deed book and page number, of the instrument of appointment filed (appointment of substitute trustee), or, (ii) a copy of the executed and notarized appointment of substitute trustee. Personal delivery or mailing a copy of the advertisement by certified or registered mail is sufficient.


Virginia Code requires the trustee to send written notice of the time, date and place of the sale to (i) the present owner of the property … (ii) any subordinate lienholder … (iii) any assignee of such note … (iv) any condominium unit owner’s association that has filed a lien … (v) any property owner’s association that has filed a lien … (vi) any proprietary lessees’ association that has filed a lien.


It is important to know that in addition to the notice required by statute, the note or the deed of trust may contain additional notice requirements. Accordingly, the trustee should examine both of these documents.

Looking for more Creditor News articles? Check our our Creditor News Blog!

Lafayette Whitlock Fischer Hughes PLC is a full-service creditor’s rights firm. While many attorneys do “collections”, few attorneys have the trained expertise and staff to represent creditors in all four areas of Creditor’s Rights—Collections, Bankruptcy, Real Estate and Foreclosure. We do, and, we represent credit unions, banks, loan companies, homeowner associations, doctor’s offices, landlords, small businesses and individuals. In Creditor News we will explore all four areas of Creditor’s Rights.

Meet the Attorneys of LAW, PLC

Edward S. Whitlock, III, Esq.

Editor

Eddie is a Richmond native with a concentrated law practice in creditor representation. His practice focuses on creditor’s rights (Collection, Bankruptcy, Real Estate, and Foreclosure), but also includes the general practice of law (Business and Will & Estate Planning). Eddie holds a B.A. (1984) in Political Science, and a Juris Doctor (1987) from the University of Richmond. He is the former Chief of Admin/Military Law for the 329th Support Group (Area) in the Virginia Army National Guard. Eddie is the former President of both the Henrico County Bar Association and the Virginia Creditors’ Bar Association. He is the chair of the Virginia State Bar’s Fee Dispute Resolution Program, and a former member of the Virginia State Bar’s Disciplinary Committee. He is the chairman of the Henrico Economic Development Authority. He is the President of Home Loans for KOVAR Corporation. He is also a former director of Henrico CASA, and a former adjunct professor of criminal law at J. Sargeant Reynolds Community College.

Jennifer W. Fischer, Esq.

Editor

Jennifer concentrates her practice in creditor representation (Collection, Bankruptcy, Real Estate, and Foreclosure), but also Business and Will & Estate Planning. Jennifer holds a BS (2011) in business administration from Christopher Newport University, and a Juris Doctorate (2014) from University of Richmond, T.C. Williams School of Law. She was admitted to the Virginia State Bar in October 2014. She is a Past President of the Virginia Creditors' Bar association and the Henrico County Bar Association.

C. Daniel Waters, Esq.

Editor

Daniel Waters primarily represents consumer and commercial finance companies, credit unions, medical practices, landlords, and construction material companies in creditor’s rights and civil litigation matters in Virginia. He has represented clients in Virginia Circuit and General District Courts as well as the Federal District Court in Richmond. After graduating from Old Dominion University with a double major in Political Science and Philosophy, Daniel studied law at Regent University School of Law in Virginia Beach. He serves as the President of the Virginia Creditors' Bar Association and as Trustee at a local private school. He resides in the Richmond area with his wife and children.

Megan C. Jones, Esq.

CREDITOR NEWS © 2026. This newsletter is prepared and published by Edward S. Whitlock, III, Esquire, Jennifer W. Fischer, Esquire, and C. Daniel Waters, Esquire and is provided free of charge. The information contained in this newsletter is general in nature. It is intended to be helpful but does not, and is not meant to, replace consultation with an attorney in connection with a legal problem. Readers needing legal advice should retain competent legal counsel.

 

Lafayette Whitlock Fischer Hughes PLC

www.lawplc.com

 
Facebook  Twitter  Linkedin