Public Health Authority
Case Updates

December 1, 2023

Case updates this week:


Monday November 20th: The federal District Court for the Southern District of New York granted a motion to dismiss against a teacher claiming wrongful termination after he refused to receive the COVID-19 vaccine. In Evans v. New York City Department of Education, the plaintiff alleged that by terminating him for refusing the vaccine, the Department of Education turned vaccination status into a disability, and then discriminated against him on the basis of this disability. However, the District Court held that the case should be dismissed as moot because the vaccine mandate has since been rescinded, but did take the time to make clear that it found the plaintiff’s allegations did not state a claim for relief because vaccination status is not a disability under the Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”). Neither was plaintiff perceived by the Department of Education as having a disability. Finally, resisting a vaccine mandate is not a protected activity under the ADA.

 

Monday November 20th: The federal District Court for the Northern District of Illinois dismissed with prejudice two claims arising from a cancelled wedding in Schneider v. City of Chicago. The plaintiffs intended to marry in February 2022, at a time when the City of Chicago had a public health order in place prohibiting gatherings in large areas without either COVID-19 vaccination or proof of a prior religious or medical exemption to the vaccine. The plaintiffs had not received the vaccine due to their religious beliefs, and had no proof of religious exemption. They cancelled the wedding and lost their deposit. They then sued the City of Chicago under two state statutes, the Illinois Healthcare Right of Conscience Act and the Illinois Religious Freedom Restoration Act, claiming that the City’s vaccine mandate burdened their free exercise of religion by forcing them to choose between violating their religious beliefs or losing their deposit money. However, the court found that their free exercise rights were not burdened because the mandate included religious exemptions, and the plaintiffs made merely perfunctory efforts to obtain them.

 
 
This newsletter is distributed by Public Health Law Watch as part of Act for Public Health, a working group of the Public Health Law Partnership that is convening to provide law and policy research, analysis, and expertise in support of public health authority.
The Public Health Law Partnership includes organizations with decades of experience in public health law, authority, and governance, including ChangeLab Solutions, the Network for Public Health Law, the Center for Public Health Law Research at Temple University, the Public Health Law Center at Mitchell Hamline School of Law, and Public Health Law Watch, a George Consortium initiative housed at the Center for Health Policy and Law at Northeastern University.
 
 
 
Twitter