|
Epistemic Injustice
Philip Candilis, MD, DFAPA
| | |
One of the great movements in modern ethics is identifying epistemic injustice, the discrediting of certain providers of knowledge or testimony. First articulated by philosopher Miranda Fricker in 2007, the concept describes the undermining of minoritized or marginalized “knowers” by a prejudicial lack of credibility. Leigh Gilmore, one of our distinguished speakers for Tampa 2026, describes this as “the tainted witness” in her book by the same title. Women, in Gilmore’s analysis, are not credited when they make accusations of sexual assault because they lack this epistemic standing. Fricker herself uses the film The Talented Mr. Ripley to show how a female character’s accurate suspicions about the murderous Mr. Ripley are discounted as emotional or intuitive.
This problem of trust is already evident in medical and forensic literature; I’ve described it previously in the Journal. It is exposed in the language physicians use to document statements by certain patients (“The patient claims” or “insists”), in forensic assessments of people of color (especially their size and strength), and in biased witness recall for associations between race and the use of weapons. We think of people differently depending on who they are, so it should be no surprise that we treat them differently as witnesses and even as authorities on their own experience. Students of epistemic injustice use sexual harassment as the cardinal example of a mistrusted phenomenon when it was first described: there was no framework for challenging an aggressive male workplace culture.
| | MEDICAL DIRECTOR'S COLUMN | | |
AAPL Practice Resource Document Development: A Primer
Debra A. Pinals, MD
|
| | | Happy spring! It is always hard to believe how fast time starts flying at this time of year. In my role at work, I watch fellows start to look beyond fellowship and enter the job market. It is a big step for them, and I recall my own days of ending fellowship and trying to find a job with the right mix of forensic evaluations and clinical practice, with some administrative opportunities. I would not have expected then to have the career I have had, and I am sure we each can think about times when our career pivoted in unexpected ways- mostly good overall, but sometimes challenging. As such, with spring comes new beginnings and 2026 has many new beginnings, even when there is a world of challenges we all might be facing. To that end, AAPL is a great organization for gatherings and connecting and collegial support, and I hope anyone reading this thinks of opportunities to stay connected with fellow AAPL members- especially at the upcoming annual AAPL Meeting that will undoubtedly be excellent.
Turning to other AAPL matters, for this column, I wanted to take an opportunity to review with readers information about our AAPL practice resource documents. These documents are distinct from peer review articles or our ethics guidelines in that they are written by a group of experts who develop a document that outlines typical ways practice is conducted. Although written in a consensus format, they have by agreement previously been published by the Journal of AAPL, though this option requires ongoing discussion as these documents are not subject to traditional peer review as the “authors” are members of AAPL and reviewers include the entire membership. More recent resource documents are posted on the AAPL website with only a summary page published in the AAPL Journal.
| | |
Privacy, Privilege and Artificial Intelligence
Chinmoy Gulrajani, MD, DLFAPA
| | |
Today more than 800 million people worldwide use OpenAI every week. (1) Over 50% of households in the US have adopted some form of AI platform. (Ref 1, p59) In my own home, we have used generative AI applications for a myriad of tasks ranging from planning trips to birthday parties, editing images and seeking clarification of income tax laws. While most of the world is dabbling with Artificial Intelligence (AI) based applications, the implications of AI for the law are only beginning to be explored. One recent case out of the Southern District of New York illustrated the privacy and confidentiality related concerns associated with excessive reliance on AI based applications.
In US v Heppner (S.D.N.Y., Feb. 2026) the federal district court addressed a question of first impression - whether, when a user communicates with a publicly available AI platform in connection with a pending criminal investigation, are the AI user’s communications protected by attorney client privilege or the work product doctrine? (2)
| | |
Association of Directors of Forensic Psychiatry Fellowships
Stephen Noffsinger, MD, President, ADFPF
| |
Forensic psychiatry fellowship program directors of the Association of Directors of Forensic Psychiatry Fellowships (ADFPF) have again agreed to use the Electronic Residency Application Service (ERAS) and the National Residency Match Program (NRMP aka “The Match”) for the 2026 forensic psychiatry fellow selection process for the 2027-2028 Academic Year.
The key dates for the 2027-2028 Academic Year application process are:
- July 1, 2026 – Applicants may apply to forensic psychiatry fellowships via ERAS.
- July 15, 2026 – Forensic psychiatry fellowship programs begin to review applications on the ERAS platform.
- July 15, 2026 and after – Forensic psychiatry fellowship programs interview applicants.
- August 5, 2026 – Match Registration opens.
- September 2, 2026 – Ranking opens.
- September 23, 2026 – Quota Change and Withdrawal deadline.
- October 7, 2026 – Rank Order List Certification deadline.
- October 21, 2026 – Match Day. Unfilled/Unmatched Lists available.
| | |
VAAPL: A New Era of Forensic Psychiatry Education
Charles L. Scott, MD
| | |
The American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law (AAPL) continues to expand its commitment to lifelong learning through its dynamic virtual education platform, Virtual AAPL (VAAPL). Designed to meet the evolving needs of forensic psychiatrists, VAAPL offers members an accessible, flexible, and comprehensive way to stay current with developments across the field, while earning Continuing Medical Education (CME) credits.
A Robust and Expanding Educational Resource
VAAPL was established in 2021 to provide high-quality online learning opportunities, initially in response to the COVID-19 pandemic but now recognized as a lasting and valuable member benefit. Today, it serves as a central hub for virtual education, offering a wide array of courses, panels, and lectures that span the full spectrum of forensic psychiatry.
Educational offerings cover diverse practice areas, including criminal and civil forensic psychiatry, corrections and correctional health care, legal regulation, research, and special topics. Content is also tailored to patient populations across the lifespan, from children and adolescents to geriatric populations. This breadth ensures that members can find relevant material regardless of their subspecialty or clinical focus.
| | |
On Hold for Attorney Clearance
Neil S. Kaye, MD, DLFAPA; Graham Glancy, MB, ChB, FRC Psych, FRCP; Ryan Hall, MD
| | |
Neil S. Kaye, MD, DFAPA, Graham Glancy, MB, ChB, FRC Psych, FRCP (C), and Ryan Hall, MD, will answer questions from members related to practical issues in the real world of Forensic Psychiatry. Please send questions to nskaye@aol.com.
This information is advisory only, for educational purposes. The authors claim no legal expertise and should not be held responsible for any action taken in response to this educational advice. Readers should always consult their attorneys for legal advice.
Q. Is it okay for the retaining lawyer to write the first draft of a report or affidavit, or to insist it be formatted in a specific way?
| | FORENSIC CHILD PSYCHIATRY | | |
Gray Area: An Extension of Parental Responsibility for Juvenile Crime
Marta Herger, MD, JD
| | |
In March of 2026, Colin Gray was convicted of murder.(1) Mr. Gray was not the primary actor in the crime; in fact, he was not even present at the crime scene. His criminal liability was
attached instead to the acts of another person: his 14-year-old son. Prosecutors asserted that Mr. Gray was aware of his son’s history of online threats, self-harm, property destruction,
extreme school absenteeism, escalating aggression, and interest in school shooters, including creating a shrine of the perpetrator of a 2018 Florida school shooting in his bedroom.(2) Despite this knowledge, Mr. Gray did not engage his son in mental health treatment, bought him an AR-style rifle for Christmas, and allowed him to keep the gun in his room to avoid conflict. The following September, Mr. Gray’s son used the rifle in a school shooting that took the lives of two students and two teachers. While the shooter awaited his own trial, Mr. Gray defended himself, arguing that his actions were misguided in hindsight but not criminal, and that “never in a million years” could he have foreseen the tragedy that unfolded.(3) The Georgia jury deliberated for less than two hours before finding Mr. Gray guilty on all 26 counts, including second-degree murder.(1)
| | |
Distinguishing Methamphetamine-Induced Psychosis from Primary Psychosis: Techniques, Relevance, and Challenges
Jason Barrett, MD
AAPL Addiction Psychiatry Committee
| | |
At the AAPL 2025 Annual Meeting, Ashley VanDercar, MD, JD, Christopher Marett, MD, MPH, Edward Thomas Lewis III, MD, Gregory Iannuzzi, MD, and Jason Barrett, MD presented Distinguishing Methamphetamine-Induced Psychosis from Primary Psychosis: Techniques, Relevance, and Challenges. This topic was a workshop sponsored by the AAPL Addiction Psychiatry Committee. The learning objectives were to: review the epidemiology and clinical impact of methamphetamine use disorder and methamphetamine-related psychosis; explore how neurobiology and cognitive theory inform symptoms in methamphetamine-related psychosis; and outline the impact of methamphetamine use on individual case evaluations as well as broader system wide impacts.
Annual data from the 2024 National Survey on Drug Use and Health, conducted by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, estimated that 2.4 million people in the United States used methamphetamine. Since 2021, the largest age group engaged in use has remained those 26 years of age or older. Attendees in the session were reminded of methamphetamine’s half-life of 9-24 hours, but also to be aware that a single use can remain in the body for up to 7 days.
| |
|
Beyond Placement: Foster Care Impact on Criminality
Kiana Andrew Tregre, MD MPH; Jordan McCoy, MD; Olivia Hindera, MD
CAP and the Law Committee
| | Today, forensic psychiatrists are tasked with treating some of the most vulnerable populations, ranging from incarcerated pregnant women to individuals with serious mental illnesses who have been deemed unrestorable. Included among these groups are children and adolescents placed within the foster care system. Just as these youth are faced with an unfortunate, new reality, child and adolescent/forensic psychiatrists are charged with providing compassionate and competent care, all the while helping to address trauma, unstable family relationships, and other significant stressors that have led to their current circumstances. In 2024, a staggering 328, 947 youth fit this description. (1) Fortunately, this number has declined over the years, with significant decreases seen across most demographics. (1) However, overrepresentation persists, particularly for youth of color. For example, Black and Indigenous children are more likely than White children to interface with child protective services and enter out-of-home care. (2) In addition, national data shows that Black children are 2.5 times more likely to be placed in foster care. (3) While African-American youth constitute just 14% of the youth population in the U.S., they make up 22% of the youth in care. (4) Such disparities are also reflected in those youth in the foster care system who subsequently become adopted: Children who are White are more likely to be adopted out of foster care, with 48% of completed adoptions being of White youth. (5) | | |
The Perils of Visual Diversity
Bushra M Khan, MD, MPH, FRCPC and Luca Pauselli, MD
Diversity Committee
| | |
Courts often claim to prioritize neutrality and objectivity, yet the moment an expert, especially a forensic psychiatrist, enters the room, perceptions can influence how their expertise is received even before they speak. Across cases, experts whose appearances deviate from the traditional mental image of “the psychiatrist”—whether through gender expression, race, age, disability, or other visible signs—face subtle and overt signals that their credibility depends on conforming to expectations they did not set.
We are aware that aspects of diversity that are visible are not the sole types of diversity that exist within forensic psychiatry or the courtroom. However, this article focuses on aspects of diversity that are visual. Notably, visual diversity encompasses a multitude of aspects of diversity and can be intersectional. Intersectional theory, coined in 1989 by Dr. Kimberlé Crenshaw, is the study of overlapping or intersecting social identities and related systems of oppression, domination, or discrimination.(1) The intersectional framework is rooted in the premise that human experience is jointly shaped by multiple social positions (e.g., race, gender) and cannot be adequately understood by considering a singular position. The impact and experience of intersectional individuals, and especially intersectional experts, have yet to be examined thoroughly in contemporary forensic psychiatry. Visual intersectionality and differences can have more impact (and not necessarily positive) now than in the past due to extreme political divisiveness.
| | |
Game Over? Litigation, Liability, and the Future of Online Youth Safety
Mark Andrew Tobias, DO
| |
On Feb 12th, 2025, a lawsuit was filed against technology companies Roblox Inc. and Discord Inc. claiming a 13-year-old boy was harassed, groomed, and eventually sexually exploited on these platforms due, in part, to the lack of safety measures in place to keep him safe [1]. This story is one of many that have occurred over the past decade, with the rise of social media, online video gaming, and other digital communication platforms, and their increased use by people of all ages [2]. The victimization of minors online is not new, but popular applications such as Roblox and Discord, among others, present unique avenues for potential contact, grooming, and exploitation. This article will explore Roblox and Discord in particular, their potential to victimize minors, what the future might hold amid legal battles in this technological space, and potential solutions to safeguard vulnerable online populations.
| | |
Assessing Future Violence Risk in TAY
Kristy Matasavage DO, Rosa E. Negron-Muñoz MD, DFAPA, DFAACAP
| | Transitional aged youth (TAY) is a term originally coined by the foster care system to describe individuals aged 16–25, a developmental period spanning late adolescence through emerging adulthood. The American Psychiatric Association published a position on TAY in 2024 stating that this developmental period is a critical time in one’s life where many mental illnesses initially present or worsen.(1) This stage is characterized by rapid neurological maturation, shifting social roles, identity formation, and increasing independence. In forensic and clinical psychiatry, TAY frequently present with first-episode psychiatric illness, evolving personality structure, and unstable psychosocial supports; all of which complicate violence risk assessment. Yet despite their developmental distinctiveness, TAY remain poorly represented in structured violence risk research. They are often evaluated using tools designed either for juveniles or fully mature adults, leaving clinicians without a developmentally precise evaluation tool. | | |
Contemporary Issues in Forensic Psychiatric Ethics:
An Educational Initiative for AAPL Members and Reflections from AAPL’s 2025 Annual Meeting Panel
Christina Nyquist, MD, Lisa Gondo, MD, Ariana Nesbit Huselid, MD, MBE
| |
A workgroup of the AAPL Ethics Committee, funded by a grant from the AAPL Institute for Education and Research (AIER), recently completed a video curriculum titled “Contemporary Issues in Forensic Psychiatric Ethics.” This initiative arose from longstanding requests by forensic psychiatry fellowship directors for additional resources to support ethics training, but expanded beyond its initial vision. It now serves not only as an educational resource on forensic psychiatric ethics for forensic trainees but also as a broader offering for AAPL members. In addition, the project records for posterity firsthand accounts of the thought leaders who have shaped the field of forensic psychiatric ethics, including discussions of their theoretical approaches in their own words. These materials are now publicly available to AAPL members free of charge on the AAPL website under the “Ethical Guidelines” section and the VAAPL platform.
This video archive formed the foundation of a panel presented at AAPL’s 2025 Annual Meeting in Boston, Massachusetts, titled “Ethics in Forensic Psychiatry: Recording the Past, Shaping the Future.” Rather than serving solely as a showcase of the video project, the panel situated the project within the larger historical evolution of forensic psychiatric ethics and connected that history to current efforts to revise AAPL’s Ethics Guidelines.
| | |
Unresolved Issues in Right-to-Treatment: A Generative Workshop at the 2025 AAPL Conference
Olivia Silva, MD, Raina Aggarwal, MD, Danielle Kushner, MD, Ren Belcher, MD
| | |
Twenty - Twenty-Five marked the 65th anniversary of the publication of Morton Birnbaum’s seminal paper arguing that individuals civilly committed for severe mental illness possess a constitutional right to psychiatric treatment (1). Published in the American Bar Association Journal in 1960, Birnbaum's article, "The Right to Treatment," faced significant initial resistance and was rejected by fifty other academic and legal journals before finally finding a platform. (2) Morton Birnbaum’s work contributed to a grassroots effort to bring relevant fact patterns to the court’s attention, culminating in the landmark litigation of Wyatt v. Stickney in the early 1970s. (3, 4) The Wyatt court articulated three fundamental conditions required for adequate and effective treatment programs in public mental institutions: a humane psychological and physical environment, qualified staff in sufficient numbers, and individualized treatment plans. (4)
While the Wyatt standards remain relevant to state hospital care today, a rapidly changing medical and legal landscape frequently finds forensic psychiatrists in uncharted medicolegal situations that raise important questions of law. In such situations, with established precedents offering only limited guidance, clinicians may find themselves acting as real-time players in what may eventually become future landmark litigation. Such conflicts may arise in any setting but are particularly salient in forensic hospitals and in jails and prisons.
| | |
Dr. Micah Duggins-Warf
Catherine Mier, MD
| | |
Dr. Duggins-Warf is a graduate of Eastern Virginia Medical School and did both his general psychiatry residency and forensic fellowship at Brown University.
Can you tell us about how you became a forensic psychiatrist?
I majored in philosophy and classical guitar performance. I loved both, but once I finished college, I realized that I didn't have a clear career path in either of those directions. Sort of by chance I got a job with a community mental health center in Massachusetts, working with largely homeless clients that had serious mental illnesses. I was their representative payee, I was taking them to their appointments, I was helping them find housing and I really loved it. I became very interested in the pathology, very interested in the team approach, very interested in the public sector nature of it. I really liked that it required a team and in the fact that this was a very underserved population that didn't really get a lot of attention from society.
| |
A Tribute to Dr. Eugene Lee
Danielle B. Kushner, MD
| | |
A tremendous thank you to Dr. Eugene Lee, the friendly and welcoming forensic psychiatrist behind the camera who has been documenting our AAPL meetings for the past 10+ years. He focuses not just on the presidential addresses and leadership events, but also captures new and old members, highlighting presentations, posters, educational events, and social gatherings that connect the individuals of our organization. In bringing people together for a photo, his friendly demeanor introduces members to each other and radiates the welcoming spirit that AAPL strives for.
| | |
Highlights of the AMA Interim Meeting
Jennifer Piel, MD, JD, Delegate; Patricia Westmoreland, MD, Alternate Delegate; Jason Barrett, Young Physician Delegate
| | The American Medical Association (AMA) House of Delegates HOD met in November 2025 at The Gaylord National Harbor in Maryland. The AAPL delegation remained active at the meeting. Dr. Piel remains the Vice Chair for the Psychiatry Section Council, which is comprised of the American Psychiatric Association, American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, American Association for Geriatric Psychiatry, American Academy of Addiction Psychiatry, Academy of Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry, and AAPL. She also served on the reference committee on Ethics and Bylaws and served on the elections committee. More information can be found at: https://www.ama-assn.org/house-delegates/interim-meeting. During this meeting, several resolutions of import to psychiatry were considered and adopted. | | |
The AAPL Newsletter is published by AAPL, One Regency Drive, PO Box 30, Bloomfield, CT 06002. Opinions expressed in bylined articles and columns in the Newsletter are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official position of AAPL or Newsletter editors. Manuscripts are invited for publication in the Newsletter. They should be submitted
to the editor via email to NewsletterEditor@aapl.org. The Newsletter is published in Winter (deadline for submission is November 15), Spring (deadline March 1), and Fall (deadline July 1).
| | | | |