|
Jordan Valley EMS director fired
Hope Wynkoop-Morris, a longtime Jordan Valley EMS billing specialist, reads a statement to the Jordan Valley EMS Authority Board during its Oct. 12 meeting. She criticized board members for failing to act on financial concerns she said she had raised repeatedly over the past eight months regarding former EMS Director Joel Yonkman, who was fired at the meeting.
> Full story below.
| | |
Inside this issue:
- Jordan Valley EMS director fired amid financial investigation
- Sheriff Vondra offered county administrator position
- Boyne City moves to establish own brownfield authority
- Rincon withdraws from Village of Boyne Falls election
- BC School Board tours career tech rooms under construction
- 410 students to volunteer all over the community on Friday
- Boyne City approves firefighter training facility at airport
- Bay Township Board, voters talk EMS millage ballot proposal
- Melrose sets meetings for vacant trustee, supervisor posts
- Evangeline Township meeting report for Oct. 14
- Emergency services funding dominates November ballot
- Housing nonprofit InvestMitt plans meeting at Boyne Library
- 20 fun local events for Halloween from Oct. 16-31
- Kiwanis honors founding member Doc Mansfield
- History mystery photo of the week: “Nobody smile”
- Roots of Resilience wellness event set for weekend
- Library recognizes National Friends of Libraries Week
- Yacht Club Gilligan’s Island scarecrows take top prize
- NLEA Regional Economic Outlook set for Oct. 30
- Turkey drive aims to feed families this Thanksgiving
- Boyne City regular and diesel gas prices rise again
- Patrick McCleary history: Solving a history mystery
- News briefs, Obituaries & Municipal News
- Thanks to the donors who keep the news coming!
- Music and entertainment listings
| |
> Like this newsletter? Forward to a friend and help us grow!
If they like it, they can subscribe here. We just hit 2,619 subscribers this week. You can reach those local subscribers with a display ad for $100; email jim@boynecitizen.com for details.
> The Boyne Citizen is committed to being a free resource for in-depth local news you can trust. If you support that goal, you can join 530+ donors who believe the Boyne area needs a high-quality news source. Donate here or send a check to Boyne Citizen, P.O. Box 83, Boyne City MI 49712.
| | |
Jordan Valley EMS Authority board member Alex Busman, second from right, responds to criticism over the board's handling of financial concerns involving former Director Joel Yonkman during the Oct. 12 meeting. Busman, an accountant, acknowledged that Yonkman had misled the board, telling the audience, "I'm an accountant, I'm not a forensic accountant." Pictured from left are board members Joshua Chamberlain, President Mark Penzien, Busman and Jim Rathbun.
Jordan Valley EMS director fired amid financial investigation and calls for board resignations
By Annie Doyle Grove, annie@boynecitizen.com
The Jordan Valley EMS Authority Board unanimously fired its director Monday, Oct. 12, amid a criminal investigation into allegations of misuse of taxpayer funds, following months of warnings from an employee who says her concerns were repeatedly ignored by the authority's leadership.
Joel Yonkman, who had served as director for a little more than a year, was terminated for cause following a closed session during a contentious board meeting that drew a crowd of more than 40 people.
The firing came days after newly appointed board member Joshua Chamberlain brought concerns about financial irregularities to Charlevoix County Sheriff Chuck Vondra, prompting an investigation and Yonkman's removal from the EMS facility.
Chamberlain, who joined the board just two months earlier, received repeated praise for taking action after eight months of warnings had failed to produce results.
During public comment, several in the audience called for the resignation of the five longer-serving board members: President Mark Penzien, representing the city of East Jordan; Alex Busman of Banks Township; Brian Olszewski of Wilson Township; Tim Timmer of Echo Township; and Jim Rathbun of Jordan Township.
The speakers accused board leadership of failing to protect public funds and ignoring concerns dating back to February. Chamberlain, who represents South Arm Township, was consistently singled out as the exception.
As of publication, Yonkman has not been charged with a crime, and authorities have not determined or publicly disclosed how much taxpayer money may have been misused.
Sheriff Vondra confirmed that Chamberlain brought the concerns directly to his office.
"Josh Chamberlain brought some concerns to us about what was going on financially at Jordan Valley," Vondra told the Boyne Citizen. "He provided us with information that was certainly worth looking into and we immediately started the process to figure out what was going on, and the investigation is ongoing."
Vondra said the information warranted immediate action "for the good of the organization and the community."
Employee says warnings went unheeded
Hope Wynkoop-Morris, a Jordan Valley EMS billing specialist for 10 years, said she first approached board President Mark Penzien in February after noticing unusual purchasing accounts and expenses.
Among the transactions she questioned were gas station purchases, a new Home Depot account, and a massage appointment she said Yonkman charged to an authority credit card but never reimbursed.
Wynkoop-Morris said she quietly collected receipts and financial records, keeping them in a folder labeled "Medicaid" in her desk drawer to avoid attracting attention.
In August, she said, Yonkman asked her to prepare a false invoice for work that had not been performed to conceal a larger expense associated with a Chevrolet Tahoe purchased by the authority.
She refused.
“That's fraud," Wynkoop-Morris said in an interview with the Boyne Citizen. She said she subsequently provided financial documentation to board members Busman and Olszewski, hoping they would investigate.
When her concerns still were not adequately addressed, she turned to Chamberlain, who had recently joined the board.
Wynkoop-Morris said Chamberlain listened, reviewed the documentation with her and brought the information directly to the Charlevoix County Sheriff's Office.
Within 24 hours, Yonkman had been barred from the EMS facility and placed on paid suspension, according to Wynkoop-Morris.
At Monday's meeting, she confronted the longer-serving board members about their failure to act."Had any of you listened to me or just paid attention to the data, we wouldn't be here right now," she said. "After eight months of expressing our concerns and hoping that one of you, just one of you, were going to take them seriously, my hope diminished each day that went by, and nothing was investigated."
She described the experience as one of "complete and utter hopelessness."
"What I did for eight months was nothing short of begging for somebody to take me serious," she said.
But she said that changed when Chamberlain joined the board.
"Somehow, by the grace of God, we managed to get a new board member who actually listened to our cries," she told the audience. "One and only one of you started to ask the right questions."
Addressing Chamberlain directly, she added: "What you did to help us is nothing short of heroic, and we deeply value you and your contribution."
Chamberlain, who also serves on the Charlevoix County Board of Commissioners, said he takes his responsibility to protect taxpayer dollars seriously.
"Within my first two months on the board, I identified financial irregularities that I believed warranted further investigation and brought the information to the Charlevoix County Sheriff's Office," Chamberlain said in a statement.
"Because this matter remains under criminal investigation, I cannot comment on specific evidence or allegations."
Board members face calls to resign
During the Oct. 12 meeting, several audience members called for the five longer-serving board members to resign, accusing them of ignoring warnings about Yonkman's financial conduct.
"You are all — outside of Mr. Chamberlain — responsible for his hiring and his lack of supervision," East Jordan resident Tony Azzopardi told the board.
"As a taxpayer, I ask for the resignation of the board members for allowing this to happen, and I applaud Mr. Chamberlain for putting an end to this madness."
Wynkoop-Morris also called for the board members to step down, criticizing Penzien for his response when she first raised concerns.
"When I came to you in February expressing my concerns, you gave me a lecture on praying and how God was going to take care of it," she said.
In a subsequent interview, Wynkoop-Morris alleged that Penzien confronted her before Monday's meeting and warned that speaking publicly could jeopardize her employment.
Her father, Roy Wynkoop, challenged Penzien about the allegation during public comment and also called for his resignation.
Penzien refused, defending the board's efforts and saying he had previously looked into concerns about Yonkman but lacked sufficient evidence to act.
"We knew something was not right, but we didn't know how to address it," Penzien said. He acknowledged shortcomings in the board's oversight and credited Chamberlain for bringing the matter to law enforcement.
"I'm not going to step down because I believe God put me where I'm supposed to be," Penzien said.
Board member Alex Busman also rejected calls to resign, acknowledging that Yonkman had misled the board.
"Did he snow us? Yes,” Busman said.
"I'm an accountant, I'm not a forensic accountant," he added.
Busman said he had devoted countless hours to the authority and wanted to help it move forward.
Authority moves forward without director
Following the closed session, the six-member board voted unanimously to terminate Yonkman's employment for cause, effective immediately.
It was acknowledged that Assistant Director Ryanne Lucero would oversee day-to-day operations while the board considers longer-term leadership arrangements, including a job description for an interim director.
Lucero assured residents that ambulance service would continue despite the turmoil.
"You call 911, you will get an ambulance," Lucero said.
In addition, the board voted to discontinue its in-house mechanic program, allowing previously accepted work to be completed but prohibiting new projects.
Mike Bertram, ambulance director for Torch Lake Township EMS, expressed support for Jordan Valley EMS during public comment, emphasizing cooperation among neighboring emergency service agencies and offering assistance.
Jesse Silva, director of the Lake Charlevoix EMS Authority, also offered assistance with billing, staffing, inventory and other operational needs, emphasizing that neighboring agencies need to support one another.
"No one agency has enough resources to take on the entire county," Silva told board members.
He said his authority was not looking to take over Jordan Valley EMS but wanted to help it regain financial stability.
"We have to remember that no matter what has happened, it has to be people before politics," Silva said.
The leadership crisis comes as Jordan Valley EMS recently expanded its service territory to include Boyne Valley Township, which transferred its ambulance service from Boyne City in September.
The Jordan Valley EMS Authority Board will meet again at 5:30 p.m. Thursday, Oct. 15, at the EMS station located at 555 Maple St. in East Jordan.
| Roy Wynkoop, father of Jordan Valley EMS billing specialist Hope Wynkoop-Morris, confronts Jordan Valley EMS Authority Board President Mark Penzien during the Oct. 12 meeting in East Jordan. Wynkoop challenged Penzien over allegations that he had threatened his daughter's employment if she spoke publicly about financial concerns involving former EMS Director Joel Yonkman. Wynkoop also called for Penzien's resignation. | |
Sheriff Vondra offered county administrator position
By Carole Shane, cjshane@charter.net
Sheriff Chuck Vondra may soon become the administrator of Charlevoix County. Commissioners voted unanimously Wednesday to extend a conditional offer of employment to Vondra, who was one of three candidates interviewed by the board at a special meeting on Monday, Oct. 12.
Vondra has been performing the county administrator duties since he was named interim administrator in July, following the resignation of Kevin Shepard. Vondra will have to resign his position as sheriff if and when he is officially under contract as administrator.
If Vondra accepts the conditional offer, contract negotiations will get underway with the county’s Civil Counsel Peter Wendling assisting.
The two other candidates interviewing for the position were James Dyer and Kent Ellis.
Commissioners unanimously voted to approve Xavier Cavagnaro of East Jordan to the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) Committee. The other applicant for the position was current DHHS committee chairperson Mary Jason, whose term expires this year.
The appointment, which will replace Jason with a newcomer, was made without discussion.
Jason, a former teacher with an advanced degree in educational leadership, is a life-long resident of Charlevoix County with a decades-long resume of service on numerous boards and committees. Her application indicated extensive experience in almost all areas listed as relevant to the position. Jason indicated that “Yes” she has read the board bylaws that are available on the county website.
Cavagnaro listed no relevant experience for the position, stated “No” in answer to the question regarding having read the board bylaws, indicating that he “couldn’t find them.” He stated that he wants to be “more engaged in the county politically” and “bring young, fresh ideas” as his reasons for seeking the appointment to the board.
Cavagnaro’s LinkedIn profile indicates that he is the campus coordinator with Turning Point USA, Michigan Virtual Academy in East Jordan. His work experience is listed as busser and host with two years of experience at the Terrace Inn and 1911 Restaurant in Petoskey.
Christopher Kraemer of East Jordan was appointed to the Commission on Aging Advisory Committee. There were no other applicants for that position.
In other business, the board agreed to move their Nov. 11 meeting to Nov. 12 at 9:30 a.m. in observance of Veterans Day.
Commissioner comments during the meeting included:
- Ann-Marie Conway’s announcement that Bergmann Center is looking for a volunteer bookkeeper.
- Josh Chamberlain’s report that financial information regarding the Six Mile Lake Special Assessment District is disappointingly incomplete.
- Bob Jess’s report that routing the Boyne City to Charlevoix “bike trail” from the north side of Boyne City Road to the south side (crossing over in the area of Quarterline Road) would likely result in significant cost savings.
Resolutions passed unanimously included:
- Amendment to the Grandvue MERS Defined Benefit Contribution Plan and the Grandvue 457 Retirement Plan
- Retiree Healthcare Benefit for employees hired prior to 1993
- Whiting Hall roof replacement
- Probate and Family Court restoration program restitution grant
- MDOT master agreement
| |
Boyne City moves to establish own brownfield authority after county rejects housing plan
By Annie Doyle Grove, annie@boynecitizen.com
Boyne City is taking steps to establish its own brownfield redevelopment authority after Charlevoix County commissioners rejected a financing plan considered critical to moving forward with a proposed 96-unit workforce housing development.
The City Commission voted unanimously Tuesday, Oct. 13, to approve a resolution of intent to create a city brownfield authority and schedule a public hearing for Oct. 27.
The move follows the Charlevoix County Board of Commissioners' 4-2 rejection Sept. 23 of a brownfield tax increment financing plan for Flats on Court, a proposed $14 million housing development at 508 Court St.
The financing was a key component of the project's financial plan, and its rejection has delayed construction while city officials and the developer seek another way to make the development financially feasible.
City Manager Sam Demel said previous city commissions had considered establishing their own authority but were assured the county could meet the city's needs.
"We've found that not to be the case," Demel told commissioners.
The proposed development, planned by Moxie, would include four three-story buildings with 96 apartments, including 72 units designated for households earning no more than 120% of the area's median income.
The city had unanimously supported the county brownfield plan, which would have captured an estimated $7.9 million in future property tax revenue over 20 years to reimburse eligible development costs.
Brownfield tax increment financing, or TIF, uses a portion of the additional property taxes generated by redevelopment to reimburse approved expenses. Although traditionally associated with contaminated properties, Michigan's program can also support qualifying housing developments.
Commissioner Bridget Foltz noted the strong turnout of Boyne City residents, business owners and housing advocates who attended the county meeting to support the project.
"They essentially shot it down, they halted this project," Foltz said of the county's decision. Despite the setback, she said she was encouraged that, to her knowledge, the developer remains committed to moving forward.
Mayor Bob Farrell described establishing a city authority as an alternative way to secure the financing needed to move forward.
"The project is not dead. It's just we have to figure out a different method, and this is our way — this is Plan B," Farrell said.
He said construction had been expected to begin in November but would be delayed until the financing issue is resolved. He hopes work can begin next year.
Farrell noted that East Jordan already has its own brownfield authority.
"Our needs are different than what the county feels their needs are at the current time," he said.
Commissioner Beano Hampton called the proposal an important step toward giving the city greater control over redevelopment decisions.
Demel emphasized that a city brownfield authority could also support eligible projects involving contaminated properties, infrastructure and business development.
The Oct. 13 vote does not formally establish the authority. A public hearing is scheduled for noon Tuesday, Oct. 27, at City Hall, 319 N. Lake St., before commissioners decide whether to proceed.
Under the proposal, the Boyne City Economic Development Corporation's board would also serve as the brownfield authority board.
Establishing a city authority would not automatically secure financing for Flats on Court. Any future brownfield plan would still require separate review, a public hearing and approval.
| | |
Rincon withdraws from Village of Boyne Falls election amid upcoming marijuana vote
By Annie Doyle Grove, annie@boynecitizen.com
Voters in the Village of Boyne Falls will see two candidates for village president on their Nov. 3 ballots, but only one is still seeking the position.
Brandi Rincon has withdrawn from the race for president of the Village of Boyne Falls, leaving incumbent Marilyn Cousineau as the only candidate actively seeking the position in the election.
Rincon notified the Boyne Citizen of her decision Tuesday, Oct. 13. However, her name will remain on the ballot because she withdrew after the official deadline, according to Charlevoix County Clerk Julia Drost.
Drost said that if Rincon receives more votes than Cousineau and wins the election, she can resign from the position.
Rincon declined to explain her decision, citing "unforeseen circumstances."
"Other than that, I would like to retain my privacy if possible," she told the Boyne Citizen.
Her withdrawal comes amid controversy over marijuana establishments in the village, an issue on which the candidates held opposing views.
Rincon opposed allowing marijuana businesses and organized a petition drive that placed a proposal on the Nov. 3 ballot asking voters whether to prohibit the establishments within village limits.
Cousineau, who voted in favor of allowing the businesses, supports them as a potential source of revenue for the village.
The referendum remains on the ballot despite Rincon's withdrawal.
One of two marijuana establishments approved for the village opened Friday, Oct. 9.
| |
Cousineau seeking another term
Cousineau, pictured here, has served as village president for six years. She previously served 16 years as Charlevoix County treasurer and 16 years as village clerk and has lived in Boyne Falls for 48 years.
In responses to questions submitted by the Boyne Citizen before Rincon's withdrawal, Cousineau said she is seeking another term to complete ongoing projects, particularly work involving the village pond and dam.
"I am running for president again because we have projects in the works regarding our pond and dam," Cousineau said. "I would like to see this project through as well as other issues."
She identified cleaning up the pond, removing the dam and repairing roads as priorities.
"I feel that I have been here for the people of the village and work with them to the best of my ability," she said.
Marijuana referendum remains a central issue
Although Rincon is no longer seeking the presidency, the referendum she helped bring before voters could have significant implications for the village.
The proposal asks whether Boyne Falls should adopt an ordinance prohibiting marijuana establishments, potentially reversing the village's decision to allow them.
Cousineau supports the businesses, citing the potential revenue they could generate for village improvements.
"I believe that marijuana stores should be allowed in the village because we get revenue from the State of Michigan for allowing them," she said.
She acknowledged that some residents oppose the businesses but pointed to Michigan voters' 2018 decision to legalize recreational marijuana and the state's regulations governing licensed establishments.
"I realize that some people don't approve of them, but the people of the State of Michigan passed a law to make marijuana legal," Cousineau said.
She also cited identification requirements for customers and restrictions against consuming marijuana on the premises.
"The income from these stores will help with updating equipment as well as fixing roads," she said.
With one approved marijuana establishment already operating and another approved, the referendum raises questions about the future of those businesses if voters adopt the prohibition.
Voters will decide both the village presidency and the marijuana referendum Nov. 3.
> The Boyne Citizen has also learned that Boyne Falls Village Council member Larry Organek is also withdrawing his candidacy for reelection, citing a medical issue and advice from his doctor. Organek’s name will still appear on the Nov. 3 ballot, although he has said he will not serve if elected.
| School board members and others attending the board meeting toured the Boyne City High School Building Trades addition construction, which is also picture below. From left are Principal Adam Stefanski, Trustee Jill Towne-Patton, Trustee Riley Cope, Superintendent Pat Little, Secretary Sara Ward, President Zareena Koch, Treasurer Mary Towne, Trustee Joel Schraw. | |
Boyne City School Board tours career tech rooms under construction
By Jamie Baumann, jamie@boynecitizen.com
"See your tax dollars at work," said Boyne City School Board President Zareena Koch, as all who attended Monday's meeting donned hard hats to view the progress on the new Career and Technical Education (CTE) classrooms at the high school. The project includes renovation of the former home economics room, as well as new construction.
With foundation work in place, tour participants viewed the enormity of the new construction, which is on schedule for completion in December 2027.
The Culinary Arts Program now housed in the Boyne City Education Building will move to state-of-the-art facilities in the high school. The new facility will include a food and materials storage area, a second room for food preparation stations, a prep cook area, and a classroom with two adjoining restrooms. The classroom will be used for instruction and as a dining room for smaller catered events. Fifteen instructional minutes each class period will be gained by eliminating transit time to the other site, according to Chef Cole Thornton.
Once the Culinary Arts Program moves, the area it vacates will become an on-site kitchen to prepare food for the 150 preschoolers in the Early Learners Program. Currently, food is prepared in the high school cafeteria and transported over to the site, which is logistically complex involving verifying all the food handling and temperature regulations are followed at each location.
A classroom for professional development or meetings during the school day will be a part of repurposed vacated space."Right now, we really don't have a place when school is in session to meet for professional development," Superintendent Pat Little said.
The high school CTE addition includes a 5,000-square foot area that will house the Building Trades and Lineworker programs. A garage roll-up door will allow trucks to bring materials right to the workshop. Outdoor work space will be covered with a large canopy. A small instructional classroom adjoins the workshop.
Currently, Building Trades students only practice skills on the job while building a house, which doesn't allow every student hands-on practice on every skill. For example, a toilet is installed in the house only once, and that process can't involve the whole class. The space in the new workshop will give students multiple opportunities to practice plumbing, electrical, carpentry, and other construction skills.
The 36-ft. ceilings will allow Lineworker Program students to practice on both indoor and outdoor-sized poles. The Energy Fundamentals class with a Lineworker emphasis is a pre-apprenticeship program offered in conjunction with Char-Em ISD, DTE, Consumers Energy, and Great Lakes Energy.
In other action, the board:
- Approved a resolution stating that senior citizens over 60 years old and all students would have free entry to all home sporting events sponsored by the district, starting with the current school year. (Tournaments will not be included.) Senior citizens must live within the Boyne City school district to get free admission.
- Decided to not engage in negotiations regarding a proposal by the Griffin family for an easement that would go through trails at the Boyne School Forest. Board President Zareena Koch said there are multiple other options for access to the property that the Griffins could pursue that wouldn't disrupt the trail system.
- Approved a snowplow bid to North Bay Hydroseed.
- Approved the Char-Em ISD Alternative Education Course Catalog.
- Approved a salary schedule for non-represented staff.
- Adopted an emergency operating plan.
| | Eric Chechack (yellow vest) from builder Barton Malow explains the transformation of the old Home Economics room to become the food storage area in the new Culinary Arts facility to those who attended the board meeting. | | |
410 high school students to serve all over the community on Friday
By Jamie Baumann, jamie@boynecitizen.com
On Friday morning, more than 400 Boyne City High School students and staff will be volunteering at area businesses and organizations.
The service activities fall under the umbrella of Portrait of a Rambler, a community-wide process in which the district and community members defined attributes that ideal Rambler graduates should possess. They determined that graduates should be "responsible, adaptable, and compassionate." In addition, they should be able to communicate, collaborate and think critically.
"As a staff, we decided to focus on compassion this year," Principal Adam Stefanski said.
To foster compassion in the students, two days of service are planned, the half day on Friday, as well as a full day in the spring. Preliminary discussions with Main Street Executive Director Ingrid Day and Chamber of Commerce Executive Director Jennifer Clasman are tentatively looking at reviving Buff Up Boyne in some format for the spring day of service.
"The hope is that students who may have never volunteered anywhere might find that spark to continue to volunteer to give back to the community," Stefanski said. Students may also find an interesting vocation to pursue.
The day of service will include 410 students and 33 staff volunteering at one of 38 different locations ranging from Lavender Hills Farm, Last Dance Rescue Ranch, Boyne City Hall, Charlevoix Area Humane Society, Boyne District Library, Evangeline Township Cemetery and Grandvue Medical Care Facility, to name a few. The students will work with service clubs, help in parks, work on bike trails, and help in businesses. Five students have been designated as a video crew to film the day's activities.
| | |
The trusses are up
High school students Sawyer Cadarette (left) and Camden Johnecheck (right) work on the new building trades house under the supervision of instructor Todd Shumaker. Each year, the Building Trades class builds a house from start to finish. This week the trusses went up on the 2026-2027 house. Last month, the school board accepted an offer of $414,900 for the house built in 2025-2026. Proceeds from the sale support materials and personnel costs of the Building Trades program.
| | |
Conceptual site plan of the proposed fire department training facility at the Boyne City Municipal Airport.
Boyne City approves firefighter training facility at municipal airport
By Annie Doyle Grove, annie@boynecitizen.com
Boyne City firefighters will have a new place to practice live-fire training after the City Commission unanimously approved the use of a portion of the municipal airport property for a training facility in their meeting on Tuesday, Oct. 13.
Fire Chief Dennis Amesbury said the facility would be the first of its kind in Boyne City, giving local firefighters an opportunity to practice responding to fires and other emergencies without traveling to training centers outside the area.
The proposed facility will consist primarily of a modified 40-foot steel shipping container placed on a gravel pad at the Boyne City Municipal Airport. Firefighters will be able to conduct controlled live-fire exercises and practice search and rescue, ventilation, hose advancement and other emergency response skills.
The project will be funded by the Boyne City Firefighters Association, with no tax dollars requested for construction or development.
Amesbury said access to realistic training facilities can be limited for smaller departments, particularly when training requires travel, additional staffing and scheduling arrangements. Having a local facility would allow firefighters to train more frequently.
The facility could also be used for occasional joint training with neighboring fire departments, providing opportunities for regional cooperation and emergency preparedness.
| |
|
Bay Township Board, voters talk EMS millage ballot proposal
By Noah Hausmann, noahhausmannwriter@gmail.com
The Bay Township Board of Trustees heard questions and concerns from a small gathering of voters Thursday, Oct. 8, regarding the Nov. 3 ballot proposal for levying a new tax millage for emergency medical services.
The board hosted an informational meeting at 5 p.m. at the Bay Township Hall, an hour before the trustees’ regular monthly meeting to help explain to voters their reasoning for the EMS millage proposal that will appear on Bay Township’s Nov. 3 general election ballot. Letters had been mailed to township residents to tell them of the ballot proposal and to announce the informational meeting. About five residents not serving in an official capacity attended.
The proposal would permit the Lake Charlevoix Emergency Medical Service Authority to levy a tax of up to 1.75 mills for three years, 2026-2028, from the six member municipalities involved in the authority, including its newly added member, Bay Township.
The millage would annually levy $1.75 for every $1,000 of taxable property value. For example, for a property worth $100,000 in taxable value, this millage would levy $175 per year from the property owner taxpayer.
In June, the Bay Township board voted unanimously to join as an incorporated member with Lake Charlevoix EMS Authority, with ambulance services starting Jan. 1, 2027. This replaces the township’s current contract with Boyne City EMS, which will end Dec. 31, 2026.
The board explained the cost of emergency medical services has increased through the years and Bay Township’s general fund alone would no longer be sufficient to pay for these services, whether through Lake Charlevoix EMS or if the township had decided to continue contracting with Boyne City EMS. This 1.75 millage would earmark new tax dollars specifically for funding emergency medical services through Lake Charlevoix EMS Authority, with the taxes being levied from residents to the authority directly, rather than being paid from Bay Township’s budget.
But Bay Township residents will not be the only voters weighing in on this proposal. The voters in Lake Charlevoix EMS’s five other member municipalities will also consider the same proposal at their polls. For the other member municipalities (the townships of Hayes, Charlevoix, Marion and Norwood and the City of Charlevoix) the proposal, if approved, would result in a tax reduction for them, since they already approved an EMS millage of up to 1.9239 mills in the August primary. This new proposal would amend their existing EMS millage, decreasing it from 1.9239 mills to 1.75 mills, a 0.1739-mill drop for those taxpayers.
This tax decrease for the other member municipalities would be feasible because the addition of Bay Township to Lake Charlevoix EMS’ jurisdiction will spread the expense of operating the ambulances across a larger community of taxpayers, so that all would pay up to 1.75 mills.
If the majority of votes in the member municipalities within Lake Charlevoix EMS Authority’s jurisdiction approve the proposal, the new millage rate will go into effect for all the communities involved, according to Lake Charlevoix EMS Authority Board President Roy Griffitts, who also attended the meeting.
A few Bay Township residents said the legal jargon of the proposal is difficult to understand. They said the wording of the proposal is possibly confusing and potentially could be misleading for Bay Township voters. This stems from the proposal wording having to be the same on the ballots of all the voting precincts affected. For a Bay Township voter who is unaware this 1.75 millage would be new to the township, the language sounds like a decrease from 1.9239 to 1.75 mills (which it is for the other municipalities, but not for Bay Township). The voter might think he or she is voting for a tax decrease, when it is actually a tax increase for Bay Township.
“That’s kind of deceptive when it looks like a drop in the millage,” said resident Craig Reynolds during the closing public comment of the board meeting. “As a voter, it’s confusing without having that background knowledge.”
Reynolds asked who authored the proposal’s language.
Township Supervisor Xavier “X” Gaudard said Lake Charlevoix EMS Authority wrote the proposal language since the millage would be levied under the authority’s jurisdiction. The Bay Township board did review the wording prior to the proposal being put on the ballot, but the township did not have a say over its language. At this point, how the proposal is worded now cannot be changed.
“It’s already on the ballot,” Gaudard said.
Bay Township Trustee Debra Beynon acknowledged why a resident could question the proposal language and be concerned. “I understand it feels deceptive,” she said.
Gaudard expressed his gratitude for how well the informational meeting went and the conversation with the residents, that the discussion did not result in criticism becoming “personal attacks.”
“It’s just nice, it not being personal,” Gaudard said. “In this day and age especially, I appreciate it.”
In its presentation, the board explained that services, representation and financial transparency were all draws for Bay Township to switch its EMS agreement to partner with Lake Charlevoix EMS.
The authority is continually staffed with EMS first responders on duty 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Ambulance crews can be on the road responding to an emergency within 90 seconds of a 911 call, according to the authority’s data. Bay Township will also have a seat on Lake Charlevoix EMS Authority’s Board of Directors, providing the township’s trustees with a direct say into its services and expenditures.
Road fund, audit, boat launch renovation
The Bay Township board also approved the payment of $267,258.50 to the Charlevoix County Road Commission from the road fund for roadway maintenance, which was about $10,000 more than the originally approved bid, Gaudard said.
The board also OK’d the payment of $10,800 to Morgan & Associates PC CPAs for the township’s financial audit as well as $5,678.90 to Maner Costerisan for audit preparation and accounting support. Township Treasurer Deb Bonneville said the audit found no problems, went smoothly and she was grateful for the assistance.
The construction company Groundworks Michigan will perform its repair work to the Walloon Lake boat launch at Sumner Road to lift and fill the voids with foam under the concrete ramp on Oct. 30, Gaudard said, adding that the work is expected to be completed during that single day.
| |
Fire Chief Ben Mathers with the department's new mini-pumper brush truck.
Melrose Township has a new fire chief; Meetings set for vacant trustee and supervisor positions
By Karen Colburn, KarenColburn@LoveUpNorth.com
Fire Chief Ben Mathers passed his final review by then-Supervisor Robin Berry following his probationary period. Coincidentally, a mini-pumper brush truck was delivered after months of waiting. The new truck still needs to be outfitted with equipment and radios, with training for the truck to be done on October 15.
In a Facebook post, Mathers said “This new addition to our fleet is an important investment in the safety of our community and the firefighters who proudly serve it.” He said the new truck “will help strengthen our department's ability to respond to brush fires, grass fires, wildland fires, and other emergencies where a smaller, more maneuverable apparatus can make a difference.”
Chief Mathers has been diligently working with the Melrose fire committee in revising operating procedures, bylaws and creating a longevity program. The committee requested a $5,000 increase in pay beginning October 17, stating that while the position was “part-time, the responsibility was full-time.” The pay increase aligns with other township fire chiefs, and the committee does not want to lose him. After a full discussion, the board approved the pay increase.
Robin Berry resigned from her position as supervisor on October 5, leaving an opening for her position. Mary Pat Goldich resigned from her position in September, leaving a trustee position open. Legally, both positions must be filled within 45 days of their resignation. Five people have sent letters of Interest for the trustee position and have been asked to be present for the November 10 township board meeting for interviews.
The board has not sent out formal notice to the community regarding the supervisor position; however, those who are interested in that position need to send a letter of interest to the board by October 30. A special meeting will be held on November 5 at 6 p.m. to appoint the new supervisor. The position will be for the remainder of Berry’s term, or about two years.
Calling all snow plowers - Melrose Township is looking for a company or person to plow this winter. The township has its own plow and would be interested in hiring someone who would use it, although they are also open to hiring a company, if necessary. The township owns 23 properties, but not all properties need plowing. Interested parties are asked to contact the clerk at the township hall at 231-535-2310 and leave a message.
The township allows 55 short-term rental licenses and that quota has been met. The township is working with Jonathan Scheel, owner of Up North Planning, Zoning and Community Development, who processes license applications and has helped the township create regulations for the rentals.
Scheel hopes to have registration and payment capability online by November 1. That date begins the new registration period from December 1, 2026, to December 31, 2027. A new license costs $1,000 with $300 going to the township and $700 to Up North Zoning. A renewed license is $800 with $100 going to the township and $700 to Up North Zoning.
Once all licenses have been distributed, property owners may contact Scheel at 231-342-9025 or jszoning@gmail.com to be placed on a waiting list. A $50 non-refundable fee needs to accompany the application, which must be dropped off at the Melrose Township Hall, 04289 M-75 North.
Two rentals per week are allowed, an initial inspection of the septic system by the health department must be performed (new license only) and pump-out of the system must be done every two years.
On the agenda for the next board meeting is a discussion on the density of short-term rentals. Code enforcement officials are not authorized to, and will not enforce private homeowners’ association rules, covenants and deed restrictions.
> Township board meetings are held on the second Tuesday of each month at 6 p.m. The township website is www.melrosetwp.org/.
| | |
Evangeline Township meeting report for October 14
The Evangeline Township Board held its regular meeting on Wednesday, October 14. Here is a summary provided by the township:
- The township assessor is doing site inspections over the next couple of weeks.
- Call Street road construction is complete.
- Swim buoys have been removed from Kim Park.
- Kim Park sidewalk repairs have been made and look good.
- Received reports from planning & zoning and from zoning enforcement officer.
- There are currently 18 short-term rentals in the township, and renewal letters have been sent.
- 240 absentee voter ballots have been sent out, with 60 returned so far.
- 94.3% of property taxes have been paid, with 5.7% outstanding.
- The Public Accuracy Test for the November General Election was held October 12.
- Friday, October 16 is cemetery clean-up day.
- October 24 to November 1 mandatory early voting will be held at Charlevoix County.
- November 1, 8am-4pm will be the clerk’s special weekend hours.
- November 3, 7am-8pm is the General Election at the Town Hall.
- The next regular board meeting will be held November 11, 5:30pm at the Town Hall.
| | |
Emergency services funding dominates Charlevoix County's November millage proposals
By Annie Doyle Grove, annie@boynecitizen.com
Charlevoix County voters will decide a series of property tax proposals Nov. 3, with funding for ambulance and fire services among the most prominent issues on local ballots.
The proposals include a reduction in the Lake Charlevoix Emergency Medical Service Authority's recently approved millage, a new ambulance and rescue tax in Boyne Valley Township and fire and ambulance funding proposals in several other communities.
Voters also will consider millages for roads, school operations, medical services and historical preservation.
A mill is equal to $1 in property taxes for every $1,000 of taxable value. A 1-mill tax, for example, costs $100 annually for property with a taxable value of $100,000.
Emergency services proposals
Lake Charlevoix EMS Authority seeks lower millage rate
Voters in the Lake Charlevoix Emergency Medical Service Authority will be asked to reduce an ambulance operating millage authorized just three months earlier.
In August, voters approved a maximum levy of 1.9239 mills to fund ambulance operations, equipment and maintenance through 2028.
The November proposal would reduce that maximum to 1.75 mills and extend the levy to Bay Township, which joined the authority after the August election. The authority includes the City of Charlevoix and Hayes, Charlevoix, Marion, Norwood and Bay townships.
If approved, the 1.75-mill levy would generate an estimated $2.43 million in its first year. It would cost $175 annually for property with a taxable value of $100,000, compared with $192.39 under the previously approved maximum rate.
If voters reject the proposal, the August millage authorization will remain in effect. The proposed lower rate would apply for three years, 2026 through 2028.
Boyne Valley seeks ambulance and rescue millage
Boyne Valley Township voters will consider a new 1-mill property tax for ambulance and rescue services.
The millage would be levied for two years, 2026 and 2027, and generate an estimated $244,000 in its first year. A 1-mill levy would cost $100 annually for property with a taxable value of $100,000.
The proposal follows Boyne Valley Township's decision in August to leave the Boyne City EMS system and join the Jordan Valley EMS Authority. The change in ambulance service took effect in September.
Evangeline seeks fire and ambulance funding
Evangeline Township voters will decide whether to authorize an increase of up to 1 mill for fire and ambulance services.
The millage would be levied for four years, 2026 through 2029, and generate an estimated $122,253 in its first year.
At the full 1-mill rate, the tax would cost $100 annually for property with a taxable value of $100,000.
Hayes proposes fire protection millage
Hayes Township voters will consider an additional 0.4 mill for fire protection services for three years, 2026 through 2028.
The millage is expected to generate approximately $129,601 in its first year and would cost $40 annually for property with a taxable value of $100,000.
The proposal is separate from the Lake Charlevoix EMS Authority millage, which also applies to Hayes Township residents.
Norwood seeks fire protection renewal
Norwood Township voters will consider renewing the township's fire protection millage at 1 mill for four years, 2026 through 2029.
The previously approved rate had been reduced to 0.9850 mill through required Headlee rollbacks. The proposal would restore the original 1-mill authorization and generate an estimated $72,000 in its first year.
Beaver Island voters face fire and medical millages
St. James Township voters on Beaver Island will consider three proposals involving fire protection and medical services.
A fire protection proposal would renew the township's 1-mill authorization for four years, 2026 through 2029. The previous rate had been reduced to 0.9634 mill. The renewal would generate an estimated $67,993 in its first year.
Voters will also consider two proposals for Beaver Island's medical center.
One would renew a 2-mill operating tax for four years, restoring a rate reduced to 1.9268 mills. It would generate an estimated $135,986 in its first year.
A separate proposal seeks an additional 0.5 mill for medical center operations, generating an estimated $33,996 in its first year.
Other millage proposals
Marion Township roads
Marion Township voters will consider an additional 1.5 mills for road construction, repairs and maintenance for three years, 2026 through 2028. The proposal would generate an estimated $203,789.89 in its first year.
St. James Township roads and historical society
St. James Township voters on Beaver Island will also consider renewing up to 1.25 mills for street and road construction and maintenance for four years. The proposal would generate an estimated $84,991 in its first year.
A separate St. James proposal seeks an additional 0.2543 mill for the Beaver Island Historical Society for two years. The township currently levies 0.2457 mill for the organization, and approval would bring the total to 0.5 mill. The additional tax would generate an estimated $17,290 in its first year.
School operating millages
Boyne Falls Public Schools
Boyne Falls Public Schools is seeking authorization for up to 22 mills for 12 years, 2026 through 2037, on nonhomestead property and other property not exempt from the tax. The district would continue to levy no more than the statutory 18 mills, with the remaining authorization available to restore reductions required under Michigan's Headlee Amendment. The proposal is expected to generate approximately $3.55 million in 2026 if 18 mills are levied.
Charlevoix Public Schools
Charlevoix Public Schools is seeking authorization for an additional 3 mills for two years, 2027 and 2028, on nonhomestead and other nonexempt property. The district would levy only the amount necessary to restore reductions to its existing 18-mill operating tax.
The proposal would generate an estimated $145,463 in 2027 if 0.1981 mill is levied.
Cheboygan-Otsego-Presque Isle Educational Service District
The Cheboygan-Otsego-Presque Isle Educational Service District is seeking renewal of a 0.6231-mill special education tax for six years, 2027 through 2032. It would generate an estimated $2.99 million in its first year across the district.
Non-millage ballot proposals
In addition to millages, voters will encounter several other ballot questions.
Two statewide proposals address whether Michigan should convene a constitutional convention in 2027 (Proposal 1) and campaign finance restrictions and disclosure requirements (Proposal 2).
City of Charlevoix voters will decide whether to amend the city charter to increase City Council terms from two years to four years.
Village of Boyne Falls voters will consider an ordinance prohibiting marijuana establishments within village boundaries.
Those questions do not involve property tax millages.
| | |
Housing nonprofit InvestMitt plans Oct. 21 meeting at Boyne Library
InvestMitt, a nonprofit organization that hopes to help working people live where they work, is hoping to spread its message to people in the Boyne area by holding an informational meeting at the Boyne District Library from 6-7 p.m. Wednesday, Oct. 21.
Attendees can learn how the cooperative and its Community Investment Fund work, hear more about their Petoskey apartment project, discuss future projects being considered, and explore ways to participate through investing or donating. No investment experience is necessary. For more information, visit InvestMitt.org.
“Our motto is ‘Neighbors Investing in Our Neighborhoods,’” said Derek Shiels, founding member of InvestMitt Cooperative. “When a community loses housing that working people can afford, it loses more than apartments. It risks losing the neighbors, workers and families who make it the place we call home.”
InvestMitt has extended its investment deadline to Dec. 1 for a project to preserve 24 apartments on Balsam Avenue in Petoskey, giving community members additional time to participate in an effort to keep locally-owned housing affordable for area residents.
InvestMitt has raised $1.25 million toward its goal of preserving the apartments since launching the Community Investment Fund in January. With a Dec. 1 deadline to secure the funding needed to move the project forward, the cooperative is inviting more community members to learn how they can help keep these homes affordable for local residents.
The Petoskey-Harbor Springs Area Community Foundation has committed to match each dollar invested in InvestMitt’s Community Investment Fund, up to $1 million, through the end of the year.
Visit the InvestMitt website for more information.
| | |
Lots of Halloween fun from Oct. 16-31
Here is our annual list of Halloween events, which start Oct. 16 and run through Oct. 31 in Boyne City, Boyne Falls, Horton Bay, and Walloon Lake. To add your event to this list, email jim@boynecitizen.com.
> BEFORE HALLOWEEN:
SPOOKY MIDDLE SCHOOL - Boyne City Middle School will host spooky Halloween parties from 5:30-7 p.m. Friday, Oct. 16, for fifth and sixth graders, and from 7:30-9 p.m. for seventh and eighth graders. Dress in your Halloween costume and dance the night away with your friends. Start by walking the always popular haunted hallway that leads into the spooky cafeteria. Eat pizza, drink cider and enjoy a variety of homemade treats plus carnival games to go with the glow light DJ dance party. There will be prizes for the best costumes. Suggested donation is $5. Parents are asked to check their emails for Sign-up Genius. Have questions? Email bcmsramblers@gmail.com.
BOYNE FALLS MONSTER BASH - Boyne Falls School says all are welcome to join them at their Monster Bash from 5:30 to 8 p.m. Friday, Oct. 16. Admission is $8 per person or $25 per family (two adults plus kids). The event includes Trunk or Treat, a family dance with DJ T-Bone Thompson, dinner and a costume contest. All students must have an accompanying adult. If you are interested in decorating a car for Trunk or Treat, contact Alaina Giem via text at 231-268-9392 to register. Win a prize for the best decorated car. Event flyer.
SPOoOoKY HIKE - The Walloon Lake Association and Conservancy will host a family-friendly Spooky Hike at the Postle Farm Preserve from 5-7 p.m. on Friday, Oct. 23. There will be trick-or-treating along the trail, a warm fire, apple cider and pumpkin painting at the preserve’s historic red barn. Guests are encouraged to wear their costumes. All ages are welcome, but parents must be present with their children. There is no fee to attend, but RSVPs are encouraged.
HALLOWEEN HOOPLA comes to Boyne Mountain the weekend of Oct. 23-25 with character meet-and-greets, a magic show, face painting, wagon rides, and trick-or-treating across the resort. Details. Avalanche Bay Waterpark transforms into a haunted aquatic adventure where every swimmer becomes a glowing ghoul. Details.
HALLOWEEN MOVIE - Lavender Hill Farm will be showing “Hotel Transylvania” for a free Halloween Movie Night at 5 p.m. Saturday, Oct. 24 inside the Farmhouse. Before the movie, little ghosts and ghouls can enjoy Halloween coloring activities while the whole family explores the Farmhouse Boutique and gets settled for the show. The Copper Room will be open with wine and spirit flights, deconstructed cocktails, mocktails, bites, popcorn, and a special Boo-Berry Fizz created just for the evening. Admission is free, but every guest, including children, must reserve a ticket in advance.
TRUNK N’ READ - Boyne City Elementary School is hosting its annual Trunk n' Read Event on Thursday, Oct. 29 from 5-6:30 p.m. at the front parking lot. It's going to be a spooktacular time with trick-or-treating, free books, fun literacy items, donuts and cider, Scholastic Book Fair, the Boyne District Library Bookmobile and more. Parents must stay with their children during this family event.
> HALLOWEEN EVENTS ON SATURDAY, OCT. 31:
OFFICIAL HOURS - The City of Boyne City official trick or treating hours are 5 to 8 p.m. on Halloween night.
HORTON BAY GENERAL STORE is hosting tours of the haunted store and lunch that will benefit the Boyne City Public Schools’ Room 156. Tour the haunted general store and have lunch out back. The “G” rated front porch will have fun games for little ones. The store will be decorated by volunteers with spooky Halloween decor. Chef-prepared chili and cornbread lunch will be in the beer tent out back. Tickets are $20 for adults and $10 for kids ages 6-17. Timeslot options are 10-11am , 11-noon, 12 noon-1pm , 1-2pm, 2-3pm. Details, tickets and volunteer signup.
BOYNE AREA SENIOR CENTER is hosting a Halloween Celebration and luncheon at 11:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. Friday, Oct. 30, at 411 E. Division St., Boyne City. There will be live music with Michigan Sands and a costume contest with prizes. On the menu: Ghoul-lash with ground beef & diced tomatoes, vampire garlic bread, graveyard vegetables, and a spooktacular dessert.
BOYNE CITY EAGLES are hosting a Children’s Halloween Party Oct. 31 from 1 to 3 p.m. and a party for the adults from 7-10 p.m. The Eagles are asking for donations of wrapped Halloween candy for the little ghosts and goblins.
MELROSE FIRE & RESCUE is hosting "Sirens, Sweets & Spooks," with Halloween candy, warm apple cider and donuts from 5-8 p.m. in Walloon Lake Village on Saturday, Oct. 31. Come and say hello to your local Fire & Rescue crew.
BOYNE CITY HALLOWEEN PARADE - Boyne City’s Halloween Parade steps off Saturday, Oct. 31 at 4:45 p.m., with participants lining up at 4:30 p.m. in the theater parking lot. The parade will travel north along Lake Street, turning east on Water Street, south on Park Street and ending at the Boyne District Library and First Presbyterian Church on Pine Street for Trunk or Treat from 5-6 p.m.
LIBRARY BOOKMOBILE will be open for trick-or-treating from 5 p.m. until they run out of treats.
COMMUNITY TRUNK OR TREAT - Just one block south of the library, the First Presbyterian Church will feature their famous Community Trunk or Treat on Halloween Night. Organizer Paula Larson encourages people to make Trunk or Treat their first stop, because they usually run out of candy by 6 or 6:30 p.m. “Everyone is welcome to join our trunk line to make Halloween a safe environment for the ghosts, princesses, and Spider-Men in our community” she said. “If folks that would like to participate, please have your vehicles parked along Pine Street opposite the Presbyterian Church with their trunks open by 5 p.m. Plan on over 800 pieces of individually wrapped candy to pass out to the kids.”
FIRE AND EMS DEPARTMENTS at Boyne City Hall will be handing out treats from 5 to 8 p.m.
BOYNE CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT will be giving out treats at Trunk or Treat at the Presbyterian Church.
BOYNE CITY HARDWARE is hosting a haunted house, complete with treats for the kids, from 5-7 p.m. Saturday.
THE BROOK OF BOYNE CITY invites all ages to join them for trick or treating from 5:30 to 6:30 p.m. at 701 Vogel Street.
RESTAURANTS AND BARS - Many local bars and restaurants are planning Halloween parties and costume contests, including Cafe Sante, Muskrat Distilling, Walloon Watershed, Red Mesa Grill. Most are on Halloween except Red Mesa on Oct. 24. Details in our Music and Entertainment listings at the end of this newsletter.
> ADD YOUR EVENT to this list - email jim@boynecitizen.com.
| | |
Kiwanis Club members surround founding member Richard “Doc” Mansfield after he was awarded the Frank O. Staiger Award.
Boyne City Kiwanis celebrates new leadership and honors founding member Doc Mansfield
The Kiwanis Club of Boyne City celebrated a new year of service, welcomed a new member and honored one of its own during its October 8 meeting. Immediate Past Governor Cindy Greening visited the club to install its incoming officers and induct new member Beth Korczynski.
The installation ceremony marked the beginning of another year dedicated to Kiwanis’ mission of serving children and strengthening the community. The new leadership team includes Immediate Past President Scott MacKenzie, President Syrina Dawson, President-Elect Rebecca Young, Secretary Lisa Lalande, Assistant Secretary Tammy Raveau, and Treasurer Mike Lalande.
The club also welcomed Korczynski into the Kiwanis family, adding another member to its ongoing efforts to support local youth, families and community organizations.
A highlight of the morning was the presentation of the Frank O. Staiger Award to Richard “Doc” Mansfield, a founding member of the Boyne City Kiwanis Club when it was established in 1999.
Mansfield’s recognition was particularly meaningful following a fundraiser for the Boyne Area Free Clinic held the previous evening, with several Kiwanis members participating. The fundraiser reflected the same spirit of community service that has been central to Kiwanis throughout its history.
Mansfield has long been involved in the Boyne City community, with connections to local education and school board service, Kiwanis, and founder of the Boyne Area Free Clinic. His years of involvement reflect a commitment to making Boyne City a better place to live, work and raise a family.
Those interested in learning more about the Kiwanis Club of Boyne City or becoming involved in its community projects can visit the club’s Facebook page.
| | |
Nobody Smile. This is going to take a while
At first glance, this photograph looks like somebody gathered the entire cast of a very serious 19th-century family drama, lined them up in front of a weathered building, and told them: “Nobody smile. This is going to take a while.” Some listened very well, like the woman in the center. Others couldn’t help but let a full-on smile come through. We’re looking at you, young lady on the left, and grandma – we see the start of a smile!
But now, more than a century later, we have a problem - we don’t know who they are. It would be great to identify everyone – or even just some! - for the Boyne Heritage Center photo collection.
This appears to be a late-19th-century photograph. The clothing, photographic format, and overall appearance suggest roughly the 1880s–1890s. Since no other information is available regarding the photograph, that’s an estimate rather than a firm date.
So we have:
- One old photograph
- One unidentified wooden building
- Two magnificent beards
- Several women in period clothing
- Three men in uniform
- One very good dog
- And zero names
Somewhere, there may be another copy of this photograph. Somebody may have the original album.
Somebody may have a photograph with the names written underneath. And somebody - perhaps a descendant of one of these people - is going to look at this picture and suddenly recognize Grandpa, Grandma, Aunt Mary, and Uncle Whoever standing outside the old family building.
If you’re that somebody, let Len DiLaura know what you know! Contact him at ljd49712@gmail.com.
“The mission of the Boyne Heritage Center is to be the expressive living voice and collective memory of those who came before and those who will come after us, stewards of artifacts and an engaged, collaborative historical hub for our region.”
| |
Roots of Resilience wellness event set for Friday and Saturday
Roots of Resilience, a family-centered wellness event, will present a number of classes, conversations and workshops on Friday night and all day Saturday at Boyne City High School.
Kick-Off Night is from 5:30-7 p.m. Friday, when families can enjoy dinner, on-site childcare, conversations with local organizations and community experts, giveaways, and time to connect with one another. Participants will be introduced to the Roots of Resilience Passport, which encourages reflection and practical family wellness activities beyond the event.
Saturday offers opportunities to learn from local presenters and participate in practical workshops focused on mental wellness, parenting, relationships, and navigating everyday family life. The attached flyer includes the full schedule and presenter information.
Organizers said, “The goal is to help families connect with resources, local experts, and with one another, in a welcoming setting where asking questions and learning together feel comfortable.”
Kick-Off Night registration is recommended but not required. Here is additional event information.
> Friday Kickoff Night flyer and Saturday schedule.
| |
Friends of the Boyne District Library Board members are, from left, Jean Musilek, Emily Ellibe, Julie Hasse, Larry Taylor, Robin Wright, and Joanne Costello. Not shown is Ward Collins.
Boyne District Library celebrates National Friends of Libraries Week
Library communities in northern Michigan and across the country will celebrate National Friends of Libraries Week from Oct. 18-24 - a time each year to publicly recognize the volunteers who help their libraries thrive.
Library friends groups are non-profit charitable groups that play a vital role in supporting library programs, materials, and special projects through service and fundraising - efforts that help libraries continue to enrich the lives of their residents and visitors alike.
Library Director Monica Peck said the Boyne District Library “benefits greatly from the generosity of the Friends of the Boyne District Library. In the past 12 months, this enthusiastic group has raised more than $13,800 through membership dues, used book sales, and special fundraising events like The Art of the Pour event this past March, a wine-tasting event that included a live auction of artwork by local artists.”
Peck said this Friends group “isn’t shy about putting that money to good use, donating substantially to the cost of Boyne District Library’s children’s area refresh in 2025 and giving $10,000 towards the new book-lending machine installed this September at Boyne City High School.”
Call the library at 231-582-7861 to find out more about the Friends of the Boyne District Library.
| |
Gilligan’s Island scarecrows
Boyne City Main Street's Scarecrows on Vacation Contest was full of creativity and imagination. Here are the winning entries:
- 1st place: Boyne City Yacht Club with their Gilligan's Island scarecrows.
- 2nd place: Boyne Valley Garden Club with their scarecrow family taking a trip around the world.
- 3rd place: Challenge Mountain with their Minion scarecrows enjoying a beach vacation.
Prizes include a beautiful flower arrangement from Hidden Blossoms and a gift certificate to Beani's Coffee Lounge.
| |
NLEA Economic Outlook set for Oct. 30
Join the Northern Lakes Economic Alliance for Catalyst Conversations: Regional Economic Outlook from 10-11:30 a.m. Friday, October 30, at Odawa Casino in Petoskey for a closer look at the economic trends, challenges, and opportunities shaping our region.
The event will feature the latest regional economic data from the Fall 2026 Economic Pulse Report, a presentation from nationally recognized economist Dr. Iryna Lendel, and a panel discussion with regional business leaders.
NLEA President Payton Heins said, “Together, we’ll explore what the data is telling us about Northern Michigan’s economy — and what it could mean for businesses, communities, and the region moving forward. Come prepared to look beyond where we are today and consider what’s next for Northern Michigan.”
Here are the speakers:
-
Dr. Iryna Lendel - Senior Director of Regional Economic and Community Development, W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research
-
Greg Shooks - Owner, Cellar 1914 and Shooks Farms
-
George Ranville – President, Biere de Mac Brew Works
-
Ken Provost – Owner & President, Birchwood Construction
- Yulin Pair – Director of Finance and HR, Midwest International Standard Products
> Register online for $25.
| |
Turkey drive aims to feed families this Thanksgiving
Good Neighbors Food Pantry is kicking off its annual “Let’s Talk Turkey” campaign to help put Thanksgiving meals on the tables of families in need. For every $20 donation, the pantry will provide a household with a complete Thanksgiving dinner, including a turkey and all the fixings. Donations can be made in several ways:
- Drop off cash or checks at Pat O’Brien and Associates Real Estate in Boyne City throughout November.
- Mail a tax-deductible check to Good Neighbors Food Pantry, P.O. Box 35, Boyne City, MI 49712.
-
Donate online at www.goodneighborsboyne.org.
This year’s campaign coincides with the pantry’s 11th anniversary. Over the past decade, Good Neighbors has provided fresh, wholesome food to local residents facing food insecurity.
| | |
Boyne City regular and diesel gas prices rise again
Prices for regular unleaded gas and diesel rose quite a bit this week at the Marathon station at 470 N. Lake Street. Unleaded gas jumped 30 cents per gallon to $4.79, while diesel rose 40 cents to $6.69. Here are recent prices spot checked by the Boyne Citizen since the Iran war started on Feb. 28:
|
- March 3 - $3.099
- March 6 - $3.409
- March 12 - $3.669
- March 21 - $3.999
- March 26 - $4.199
- March 27 - $3.999
- April 6 - $3.899
- April 7 - $4.199
- April 13 - $4.159
- April 15 - $4.099
- April 22 - $3.799
- April 24 -$3.999
- April 29 - $4.299
- May 6 - $4.799
- May 13 - $4.999
- May 20 - $4.919
- May 27 - $4.759
- June 3 - $4.459
- June 10 - $4.459
- June 17 - $4.059
- June 18 - $3.999
- June 25 - $4.299
- July 1 - $4.099
- July 8 - $3.999
- July 15 - $3.999
- July 22 - $4.299
- July 29 - $4.279
- August 5 - $4.299
- August 12 - $4.299/$5.299
- August 19 - $4.299/$5.499
- August 26 - $4.399/$5.499
- Sept. 2 - $4.199/$5.999
- Sept. 9 - $4.399/$5.999
- Sept. 16 - $4.599/$6.499
- Sept. 23 - $4.999/$6.799
- Sept. 30 - $4.799/$6.699
- Oct. 7 - $4.49/$6.29
- Oct. 14 - $4.79/$6.69
> Michigan gas price average (AAA) is $4.59. The national average is $4.33.
| | |
BUSINESS AFTER HOURS - Celebrate the season with a cozy “Falling for Fiction” Business After Hours at Dust & Blush Bookshop on Thursday, Oct. 15, from 5:30-8:30 p.m. at 116 S. Lake St. in Boyne City. Enjoy fall mocktail flights, seasonal refreshments and activities, books, business and great company. Guests are also encouraged to wear their favorite fall look - flannel, sweaters, autumn colors and more - for a chance to win prizes from 106 KHQ. The Boyne Area Chamber Business After Hours event is open to the public, and organizers suggest that you “bring a friend and come enjoy a fall evening at one of Boyne City’s newest businesses.”
PICK A PROJECT - The Charlevoix County Community Foundation (C3F) has launched Pick a Project, a new online giving opportunity that lets donors browse local projects and choose where they’d like their support to go. The catalog features 22 vetted local nonprofits and community projects, and gifts of any size are welcome. Pick a Project is open through Nov. 15. Browse Pick a Project and donate.
DEMOCRACY MARCH - The Charlevoix County Women for Democracy will hold their regular third Saturday “Join in Boyne” rally at 11 a.m, Saturday, Oct. 17, in front of Boyne City Hall. They will begin gathering and organizing at 10:45, with the rally for freedom beginning at 11 and ending at noon. Organizers invite anyone to join them and they said, “Bring a sign or a bell or a flag! If you are unable to stand or walk for an hour, bring a chair.”
MOUNTAIN BIKE UPDATE - The Top Of Michigan Mountain Bike Association will hold its next town hall meeting at 6 p.m. Tuesday, Oct. 20 in the Commission Chambers at Boyne City Hall. They will share quick updates on current projects, then open the floor for questions and feedback on topics like the Harbor Springs Sewer Authority trails, volunteer opportunities, the Trail Steward Program, and fat bike grooming. This meeting is exclusively for TOMMBA members.
HEALTH CARE FORUM - “Universal Health Care – What is It? What does it mean for me?” is the topic of the next public forum planned by the League of Women Voters of Northern Lower Michigan (LWVNLM). It will be held Wednesday, Oct. 21 from 5:30-7 p.m. at the Charlevoix Public Library conference room. Speakers are: Laura Ford, PhD, RN, CNP, Professional Senior Instructor at Western Michigan University; and William Wadland, MD, MS, Professor Emeritus Past Chair Department of Family Medicine Michigan State University Associate Dean. Following the presentation, there will be an opportunity for participants to ask questions. Light refreshments will be served. Register for the forum at https://www.lwvnlm.org/october-2026-forum. Attendees can participate in person or by Zoom. The forum will be recorded for future viewing.
INTERNATIONAL WEEK - North Central Michigan College will celebrate cultures and perspectives from around the world during International Week, Oct. 26-30. The weeklong celebration features food, film, dance, travel presentations and other activities for students and community members. Proceeds from select events will support NCMC students participating in the May 2027 Mexico Field Studies program. Events include a travel photography exhibition, Bollywood dance lesson, international trivia competition, food tasting, Japanese-style karaoke and presentations exploring international travel, history and education. Press release with details and schedule.
NEED A CAMPAIGN SIGN? The Charlevoix County Republican and Democratic parties have opened offices next door to each other in the shopping center at 5 W. Main Street in Boyne City. The Republicans’ office is open Tuesday and Thursdays from 3-7 p.m. and Saturdays and Sundays from 10 a.m.-2 p.m. The office entrance is on the lake side of the building. Here is their Facebook page. The Democrats’ office on the back side of the building is open Monday, Wednesday and Friday from 2-6 p.m. and Saturday from 10 a.m.-12 noon. Here is the Domocrats’ Facebook page. Both parties say that their office hours depend on volunteer availability.
EARLY VOTING - Charlevoix County residents can vote in person at the Charlevoix County Building, 301 State St. in Charlevoix from Saturday, Oct. 24, until Sunday, Nov. 1 from 8:30 a.m.‐4:30 p.m. Voters are reminded to bring a picture ID.
BLOOD DRIVES - Several local organizations are sponsoring blood drives in the coming weeks. Versiti Blood Center says, “The need for blood is urgent and constant. One in seven patients entering a hospital requires the availability of blood for various medical reasons.” Here are the upcoming blood drives in Boyne City and Boyne Falls:
- Friday, Nov. 20 - Boyne City High School, 9 a.m.-2:30 p.m.
- Thursday, Dec. 3 - Boyne Falls Public School, 8 a.m.-2 p.m.
- Friday, Dec. 18 - Boyne District Library, 11 a.m.-4 p.m.
> To register, click here and enter your zip code for nearby locations.
BOYNE AREA SENIOR CENTER is open from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. weekdays and serves daily lunches from 11:30 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. at 411 E Division St, Boyne City. For seniors ages 60+, the lunch donation is $5, for ages 59 and under, $10; and for children 12 and under, $8.
> Here is the October lunch menu and October activity calendar.
| |
Local news is made possible by you!
The Boyne Citizen is committed to being a free resource for in-depth local news and information you can trust. Will you join more than 500 donating members who believe the Boyne area needs high-quality news and information?
| |
Regional News
From Bridge Michigan, Interlochen Public Radio, & Traverse Ticker
| | |
Trees damaged by last year’s ice storm are seen along a highway in Boyne Falls in January. (Ellie Katz/IPR News)
Northern Michigan foresters frustrated as ice storm recovery funds run dry - Story
Northern Michigan's Short-Term Rentals Are Tracking Toward Their Busiest Autumn Season Ever - Story
Michigan foster kids struggle under system that gives ‘nothing’ after aging out - Story
Bridge Michigan’s extensive coverage of state politics and the Nov. 3 election - Stories
| | City of Boyne City Municipal News | | |
FIRE DEPARTMENT OPEN HOUSE - Come meet the firefighters who serve and protect our community. The Boyne City Fire Department invites you and your family to an evening of fun, learning, and community connection on Tuesday, October 20, from 5-8 PM. Here's what you can look forward to:
- Fire Safety Education: Explore an educational smoke trailer provided by Resort Bear Creek Fire Department! Learn and practice how to safely escape a building in the event of a fire.
- Fall Treats: Enjoy cider, donuts, coffee, and hot chocolate while visiting with our firefighters.
- Check Out Our New Mural: Stop by to see the department's new mural.
- Meet Your Firefighters: Get to know the men and women who serve our community, learn more about the department, and see the important work they do to keep Boyne City safe.
Bring the whole family. It's a great opportunity for kids and adults alike to learn valuable fire safety skills, enjoy some fall treats, and connect with those who answer the call when our community needs them most.
PROVIDE YOUR INPUT for Boyne City's future! Take the strategic plan survey here: bit.ly/BoyneCityStrategy. Your voice matters! For additional information on the Boyne City strategic planning process, please visit nwm.org/boynecity.
CITY BOAT LAUNCH on North Lake Street, located across from Family Fare, will be closed for renovations beginning Monday, Oct. 26. Manthei Construction will be reconstructing a portion of the boat ramp, including replacing concrete and reducing the slope of the ramp to improve launch operations. Work is expected to be completed by November 13. Please plan accordingly while the launch is closed. We appreciate your patience as these improvements are completed.
SIGN UP FOR CITY ALERTS - The City of Boyne City has an Alerts feature on our website to help you stay up-to-date on projects, notices, and other important things happening around town. It’s designed to be a quick, easy way to get real-time updates, as they become available, directly to your email or phone. Sign up at: https://www.boynecity.gov/enotify/index.php.
CITY MEETINGS – Click here for board information, agendas, and minutes.
> City Commission's next regular meeting is at 12 p.m. Tuesday, Oct. 27. Agenda page.
| |
|
From a lone and unidentified military portrait to a recognized and fully documented piece of local history, this image of former Boyne City resident Clifford L. Frantz provides an outstanding example of how community involvement, preservation, identification, and documentation all go hand in hand.
THROUGH THE HISTORIAN'S LENS
A history mysteries solved – the Clifford L. Frantz story
By Patrick McCleary, Throughthehistorianslens@gmail.com
I can honestly say that there are very few things that leave me utterly speechless. When something goes beyond the scope of what I believed to be possible and goes into that realm of a mouth drop and uttering, “Are you serious?” Such is the case with the above photograph.
I own and maintain a vast collection of local and county history material, the majority of which consists of photographs. Among this collection, which I guess should come as no surprise, there are many nameless faces. I’m happy to say that over the years I have been able to name dozens of them - documenting not only the names but also the biographical information to accompany them. It is seldom an easy task, but one that I feel comes with the territory of being a responsible docent of any historic collection.
Recently, Boyne Citizen readers have been able to view some of the images contained within the Boyne Heritage Center’s collection. It is nice to see this being done, as I strongly feel that we are reaching that “last generation” who may be able to assist in the naming of unknown material. I commend them for their efforts.
Seeing these images prompted me to again use Facebook as tool in possibly getting some of my own “unknown” photographs identified. I’ve done this in the past and had a great deal of success. So, I began with a military image, thinking that at the very least, I could learn more about the uniform and at least add that information to my records. The interesting thing about this image is that not only is an original in my own collection, but there is also an identical image in the Boyne Heritage Center’s collection. When I first came across it while on the BHC Board of Directors, I remember thinking, “two remarkable portraits, in two collections, and no one knows who he is.” So, what left me so speechless? Well, within the hour, comments began to be received and, well, the rest is “history.”
My online friend MaryJo Stresky of Sheridan, Wyoming, an author and photographic expert in her own right, provided me with the first solid information when she wrote:
“Definitely Navy. Red horizontal stripes (chevrons) worn on the sleeve indicate junior enlisted ranks - one stripe for E-1 (Seaman Recruit), two for E-2 (Seaman Apprentice), and three for E-3 (Seaman).”
Local genealogist Missy Hammell used an AI feature on Ancestry.com that even I had no idea existed. She shared:
“I used Ancestry’s facial recognition (as much as I hate and loathe AI) and it found only one possible match. Clifford Frantz. He and his wife lived in Boyne City. He died in 1998.”
Next, brothers John and Dan McGeorge chimed in, saying, “I knew Clifford from church” and “Yes, I can clearly see the likeness now that we have a name.”
So, who was this Clifford Frantz and how did two collections wind up with his military portrait? To answer the latter questions, I have the late Jerry Kelts to thank. While conducting local estate sales, this and other images fell into Jerry’s hands - several of which were military photographs. Jerry made sure that they were not destroyed and later gifted them into my care for future preservation. What an excellent example of the preservation of local history. I can only assume that he gave a duplicate copy to the Boyne Heritage Center… or perhaps even its predecessor, the Boyne City Historical Museum.
As for Clifford Frantz? Let me introduce you to him. He is now much, much more than just a nameless photograph.
Petoskey News-Review - Monday, May 23, 1977 – Page 12
AREA MAN CIRCLES GLOBE ON JETS AND CAMELS
BOYNE CITY – “I’d ride anything that moved” is how Clifford Frantz described his modes of transportation, which varied from supersonic jets to rather subsonic camels in his recent six-month trip around the world.
New world travel is old hat to many 20th Century Americans, but the 72-year-old Frantz didn’t always do it by the seat of his pants in a gleaming jet or chartered bus tour. He avoided gift shops and towering high rises to sleep in mud huts and hostels in an effort to see the “real” world.
“After a time, big cities started to look alike,” Frantz says in a firm voice. “It was the same routine -heavy traffic, lots of people and high buildings. It’s better to get off the beaten path. You can see more.
And see more Frantz did, eating up nearly 35,000 miles and travelling to 24 countries while circling the globe with only himself as company. He saw the Taj Mahal, rode the Orient Express, stayed with seldom-seen relatives of his wife Margaret’s in Scotland and New Zealand and generally went where he wanted to go and saw what he wanted to see when he wanted to.
Frantz poured over maps and travel books before embarking on his lengthy journey, but much of his travel was left to whim.
“Well, I studied world maps and decided I wanted to go here, and I wanted to go there, and I wanted to go around the world,” he said, using his hands to add emphasis to the conversation. “And once I got there if I wanted to stay a few days, I did, and if I decided to move on to someplace else, I did.”
Frantz said this is the beauty of traveling by yourself. You can go wherever you want to whenever you want to. One drawback of traveling alone, however, in a foreign country is that many times there is no one to talk English to but yourself.
“In many places that I visited I didn’t hear too much English,” he said. “Sometimes I could get in a few words of English, but many times I had to use a form of sign language or just point at things.”
Of course, one of the reasons why Frantz had to abandon his native language at various internals was his penchant for getting off the beaten path.
Frantz managed to find a way to flee big city civilization as often as possible. He stayed in huts, ate native food and survived insects and mud the same as those who lived with them day after day.
He speaks fondly of his journeys in inner Pakistan and the Philippines - though he did not enjoy the quality of life found in small villages in these lands; he thoroughly enjoyed the opportunity to see “How the other half lives.”
| | |
The photograph and caption that appeared in the Petoskey News Review’s 1977 article documenting Mr. Frantz trip around the globe. Courtesy of the Greenwood Cemetery website: www.gwood.us
Frantz said he had no bad experiences during the lengthy one-man journey through he did keep a close watch on his possessions and was careful of what he ate and drank. One of the biggest problems was clearing airport metal scanners which search passengers for guns and other hidden weapons. He carried a padlock with him so could safely secure his possessions in a locker if he wanted to, but the thing would trigger the sensitive scanners.
The well-traveled Boyne Cityite didn’t think much of overgrown cities such as Tokyo and Hong Kong, but he was partial to New Zealand and Australia.
Two interesting things happened to him in Australia: he saw and got a chance to photograph Queen Elizabeth and Prince Philip of England, and he rode in a bus for 2,000 miles across the country in 110-degree heat.
In fact, Frantz took nearly 300 pictures while traveling through Europe, Asia, Australia and Alaska. He got a chance to take twice as many pictures on April 11 as he gained a day crossing the international dateline. He spent one April 11 in Japan and liked the day so much he spent another April 11 in Alaska.
Both of the Frantzes enjoy traveling, but Mrs. Frantz said she thought this trip would be a bit too much for her with her husband continually getting off the beaten path. They have a camper truck and have made many trips in the past. They went to Scotland to visit her relatives in 1960 and got a peek at Europe at that time too.
Frantz has done a little traveling in his time. He was in the Merchant Marine in 1926-1927 and was in the Seabees during World War II, so he’s been around.
When asked if he had any more thoughts of lengthy journeys in the back of his well-traveled head, he replied, “I can’t really tell. Once you get the disease you just have to get up and go.”
Frantz said he learned something universal about people - they are unhappy over high taxes and unemployment. He said America looks like “a piece of heaven” to many people.
= = =
At this point, I had enough information to compile a biography card to be included along with the now-named military portrait. I hope you now see how many hands go into the documentation of a collection… and every little comment counts! While some may yet remember Clifford Frantz on a personal basis, his portrait and biographical information can now be preserved as a tangible reminder of a former Boyne City resident and a life well-traveled and well-lived.
CLIFFORD LYNN FRANTZ
Clifford Lynn Frantz was born on July 30, 1904, at Ubly, Huron County, Michigan. He and his twin brother Wesley were the sons of Ambrose and Hannah (Johnson) Frantz. He was in the Merchant Marine from 1926 to 1927 and then took up employment with the Railway Express Agency, working in their depot in Detroit. He was a Seabee during World War II and then returned to his work with the Railway Express Agency.
On June 7, 1930, he married Margaret MaryAnn Morrison, in Detroit. She was the daughter of William Wood Morrison and wife, Margaret Ann (Beattie) Morrison. Margaret had been born in Medina, Oxford County, Ontario, Canada on February 6, 1904, and had come to settle in Detroit with her parents. It wasn’t until May 26, 1937, that she became a naturalized citizen in Petoskey.
At some point, the couple moved to Boyne City where they became quite involved with the activities of the Christian Temperance Union (CTU) and Mr. Frantz was quite outspoken on the subject of underage drinking, yet a proponent against the raising of the legal drinking age to 21 years, back when this was being debated in both the local and national courts. According to local newspaper accounts, he was a world traveler and avid photographer. After his round-the-world trip in 1977, he spoke publicly on several occasions and to a variety of groups - sharing stories and photographs detailing his adventures.
Mrs. Frantz passed away on February 22, 1993, at Grandvue Medical Care Facility in East Jordan and is buried in Maple Lawn Cemetery in Boyne City. Shortly after that, auctioneer Frank Leist handled the complete liquidation of the Frantz home on Division Street, along with its contents. Once the sale was complete, Mr. Frantz moved south, relocating to his childhood hometown of Ubly in Southern Michigan. He passed away there on April 23, 1998, and is buried alongside his parents and siblings in Valley Cemetery at Ubly.
| > Patrick McCleary is a certified genealogist who has devoted years to the ongoing research and study of Boyne City and Charlevoix County history. In addition to conducting classes on genealogy and family history, he also speaks on a variety of topics. For further information, contact Patrick by email: Throughthehistorianslens@gmail.com. | | |
Thank you to the generous donors who are supporting local journalism and the Boyne Citizen!
> We are a 501c3 nonprofit organization. You can donate online here, or mail a check to Boyne Citizen, PO Box 83, Boyne City MI 49712.
2026 Donors
This week's new donors are listed in bold.
Founding Donors
$5,000 and up
Press Forward Northern Michigan, hosted by
the Grand Traverse Regional Community Foundation
| | |
The Hill Donors
$1000 - $4999
Pat and Jane O'Brien
Kirk and Lynne Jabara
The Caplener Family
Charlevoix County Community Foundation Mini Grant and Community Priorities Grant
Stowe Family Fund
Howard and Marcia Newkirk
Anonymous
Julia Schmittdiel
Avalanche Donors
$500 - $999
Glen and Gwen Catt
Chip and Laura Hansen
Bud and Nancy Shear Julie and Dan Schmittdiel
Lynne Ross
Matthew Blandford
Jane Stieber Amato and Tony Amato
Floyd and Nancy Wright
Jim and Kelly McKee
Patti Jasper
Anonymous
Sean Vinson
Lake Charlevoix Donors
$100 to $499
Andy Schmittdiel
Edward Jones
Kyle Roberts
Carole Shane
Debi O'Leery
Barbara Mendoza
Robert Kirk
Don and Laurie Owen
Bekah Rutz and David Osterhouse
Kathleen Warner
Mary Jane Cargill
Dave and Linda Burnham
Thomas Veryser
Steve and Susan Watson
Gow Litzenburger
Shelli Duff Karen Colburn
Christine A. Judd
Pam Cislo and Tom Schraw
Jim and Kathe Carter
Bill and Cindy Binder
Kevin and Marci Lavin
Tad Richards
Jeff and Kari Streelman
Miriam Hollar
Lucy Hartlove
Jake Snyder
Judith White
Nancy Hannan
Ronald and Joanne Danczak
Terry and Betty Desmond
Cheri Leach
Holly and Tony Sasso
Judith Goodchild
John Hoffman
Barbara Mathes
Michele Nickel-Frasz
Mark Martin
Carl VanDomelen
Sharon Kuethe
Steve and Carole Drake
Ronald VanHorn
Liesel Litzenburger Meijer Richard and Gayle Bouters
Gary and Sylvia Cofer
Jane Burger
Bill Aten
Barbara Bryant
Nancy Cunningham
Broc and Lynne Johnson
Paga Family Dentistry
Nancy and Jim McKinstry
Stephanie Moody
John Betts
Stephen Wickens
Gary and Nikki Blakeslee
Andrew and Jo Sahara
Judith Gardner
Dawn Ebersole
Don Ryde
Mark and Cathy Pumford
Jay and Peggy Smith
Omer and Carole Racine
Christopher Jones Pumford
Margo Kuhns
Robert Kendell
Walter Kidd
Robin Hissong Berry
Tom and Barbara Miller
Kathy Fruge
Linda G. Knibbs
Mary-Anne Stieber
Richard and Maureen Shipley
Beverly Neville
Marvin Verwys
Caren Peltier
Diane Burke
Michael Sheean
Ward Collins
Georganna Monk and Chuck Gremel
Zachary Shaltz
Randy Hackney Emil and Pat Nelson
Michael and Jacque Harrington
Babette Stenuis Stolz and Jack Stolz
Roger and Patricia Jacobsen
Ray and Karen Guzniczak
Deborah and John Rohe
Vasco and Joan Zucchiatti
Jeff and Beth Freeman
Mary and Dave Anderson
John and Monica Ross
Gregory Damman
James Graves
Nancy DeMeuse
Ronald LewisCarol Ross
Gayle Harbaugh
Wirt-Rivette Group & Moxie Development
Yvonne Schmidt
Catherine Bowers
Jim Nielsen
Randy and Cathy Parker
Candy and Bob Greene
Jeff and Carolee MacFarlane
Jock and Marilyn Rader
Rachel and Louis Swiss
Peter Linetzky & Susan Willoughby Linetzky
Theresa Vondra
Mike and Diane Bajko
Barbara and George Ellwanger
The Frykberg Family
Peter Moss
Jeanine Larsen
John and Jan Bennish
Cynthia Tonkavich
(Continued next column)
| | | |
Lake Charlevoix Donors
$100 to $499 continued
Mike and Lisa Sullivan
Mike and Cheryl Delahanty
Patricia Bierlein
Matthew Janer
Cindy Allen
Joel & Karen Cohn
Lisa & Ian Whitelaw
Ken Schrader
John and Carol Stimpson
Ralph Gillett
Vicki Otten
Susan Coyle
Brian and Charlotte Battjes
Perry Irish Hodgson
Molly Tripp
Kathleen Hoffman
Cheryl and Joe Wald
Jerry Swift
JoEllen Rudolph
Carol Hanes-Nason
Keith and Lisa Fitzpatrick
Randy Parker
Anne Nemes
Michele and Tom Carter
Craig and Terri Reynolds
Linda Burgert
Becky Nohel
Rolf Bates
Brigit and Kurt Anthony
John and Monica Ross
Kathy and Vern Goodwin
Jody Jacobson
Sara and Brent Ward
John and Jane Rozycki
Linda Kosc
Julie and Craig Love
Robert Earl
Robert Niemi
Diane Hale
Betsy Schnell
Carlin Smith
Jeffrey Rowe
Shirlee Suter
Mark LeFevre
Pam Cislo
Bill Nichols
Vicki Otten
Diane Krenn
Wes Dilworth
Jim Nielsen
Sharon MacJennett
Rick Shipley
Jack and Babette Stenuis
Dorne Davis
Jock Rader
Michael and Katherine Cain
Kirk and Cynthia Kujawski
Thomas and Deborah Neidhamer
Glenn and Karen Mertz
Richard Wright
Kim Altobello
Lauren MacIntyre
Doyle & Pat Cloud Candy and Bob Greene
Boyne City Rotary
Pamela L. Gnodtke
Jean Holzschu Fiel Faith
Sunset Beach Donors
$60- $99
Jack Laurent
Monica Peck
William Cousineau
Jay E. Vanderwall
Mitchell and Carly Klooster
Joel and Nancy Epstein
Don Stolt
Elizabeth Swift
Steve and Karen Jarema
Bob and Bedonna Perish
Eleanor West
Patricia and Nord Schroeder
Chad Henry
Brian Tappan
Whitney Schmit
The Tosch Family
Mark Christensen
LuAnne Kozma
Paul and Colleen Kuehl
Cristina Staats
Kathy Breedlove
Carolyn Sullivan
Penny Churchill
JoAnn Smith
Bill and Dee Kelly
Laurel Henkel
Douglas Melvin
Lucy Hartlove
Jessie Belford
Peninsula Beach Donors
Under $60
Leisa Ratu
Christy Weaver
Marc Ressler
Didi Brown
Caroline Sottrel
Larry Bernhardt
Margaret Fitzpatrick
Edward and Colette Geck
Barbara Wulff
Tom Shifrin
John George Martin
Sheldon and Karla Buckmaster
Henry and Donna Erber
Jayne Howard
Brooke Sandtveit
Margaret Beegen
Jane Prebble Bill Nichols Terry and Jeffrey Gaither
Joe and Lorraine Manary
Captain Bob Goodenough
Sheri Rhoads
Janice Lavanway
Bob and Lenore Beckman
Dory Ferguson
Bunny Marquardt
Theresa Whitley-Farley
Don Kaegi
William Himmelspach
James Costello
John McCahan
Christine Brown
Cheryl Alger
Marcia Vermaire
Marcia Vermaire
Cynthia Young
Rita Taylor
Kelley Dobbelaer
Laura Danschroder
Susan Taylor
Lewis Schlanbusch
April Lardie
Connie Dunlop
John McCahan
| | Donors from 2024 and 2025 are listed on our website. | | |
MUSIC, ARTS, AND ENTERTAINMENT
Please email your special events and music information to jim@boynecitizen.com.
AMERICAN LEGION Post 228 - 302 S Lake St., Boyne City, (231) 459-4188.
Bingo every Tuesday, open to the public, refreshments provided. Doors open at 3 p.m., play starts at 5, ending around 9. The Legion also has a breakfast on the second Saturday of every month from 8-11 a.m.
BC LANES/THE VENUE BAR & GRILL - 1199 M-75 S, Boyne City, (231) 582-6353.
> Saturday, Oct. 17 - Baker Doubles Tournament at 11 a.m. This is a team game where two partners alternate frames to complete a single 10-frame game. $70 entry fee per team includes six games.
BOYNE ARTS CENTER - 211 Water Street, Boyne City, (231) 622-2073.
> Upcoming events, classes and exhibits:
-
Book a Private Art Party for the holidays
-
Floral Painting Using Pastels- Oct 15, 22, 29, and Nov 5, 9 am-12 noon
-
Demo Night- Mark Mehaffey - Thursday, Oct. 22, 6-8 pm
-
Mehaffey, Two Day Plein Air Class - Oct 23 & 24, 10 am - 4 pm
-
Kids' Morning Makers Class - Saturday, Nov. 21, 10 am - Noon
-
BAC Holiday Market - Nov. 2 - Dec. 23
-
Demo Night- 100 DAYS PROJECT- Thursday, Nov. 19, 6-8 pm
-
Christmas Card Making Event - Saturday, Nov. 14, 1-4 pm
BOYNE CITY FARMERS MARKET - Outdoors at Veterans Park, 207 N. Lake Street, Boyne City, from 8 a.m.-12 noon on Saturdays. (231) 582-9009. We will continue with Saturdays outdoors through Oct. 17, then we switch to inside the pavilion on Oct. 24.
> Live music 10 a.m. to 12 noon:
- Saturday, Nov. 12 - John Richard Paul
BOYNE CITY TAP ROOM - 220 S. Lake St., Boyne City, (231) 459-4487.
- Mondays - Trivia, 7 p.m.
- Thursdays - Adam and The Cabana Boys, 7-10 p.m.
- Fridays - Patrick Ryan & guests, 7-10 p.m.
- Saturdays - Patrick Ryan, 7-10 p.m. (No Saturday music if MSU or UM have a late game)
BOYNE DISTRICT LIBRARY - 201 East Main St., Boyne City, 231-582-7861. Newsletter with Octber events and details.
BOYNE MOUNTAIN RESORT - 1 Boyne Mountain Rd., Boyne Falls, (855) 688-7024.
> Weekly schedule of events and entertainment at all Boyne Mountain venues.
> HALLOWEEN HOOPLA comes to Boyne Mountain the weekend of Oct. 23-25 with character meet-and-greets, a magic show, face painting, wagon rides, and trick-or-treating across the resort. Details. Avalanche Bay Waterpark transforms into a haunted aquatic adventure where every swimmer becomes a glowing ghoul. Details.
BOYNE VALLEY VINEYARDS - 05325 US 131 S, Petoskey, (231) 373-2090.
> LIVE MUSIC:
- Friday, Oct. 16 - Chris Calleja (4-7:30)
- Saturday, Oct. 17 - Chris Calleja (2-6)
- Sunday, Oct. 18 - Chris Calleja (1:30-5)
- Friday, Oct. 23 - Nelson Olstrom (4-7:30)
- Saturday, Oct. 24 - Two Track Mind (2-6)
- Saturday, Oct. 31 - Michelle Chenard (2-6)
CAFE SANTE - 1 Water St., Boyne City, (231) 582-8800.
> Fall specials: $10 Thursday Pasta special begins Oct. 1, and $6 Monday pizza special begins Oct. 6. (We knew $5 pizzas couldn't last forever!)
> Live music:
- Friday, Oct. 16 - Sean Bielby, 7-10 p.m.
- Saturday, Oct. 17 - The Fridays, 7-10 p.m.
- Monday, Oct. 19 - The Shifties, 6-9 pm.
- Friday, Oct. 23 - Michelle Chenard, 7-10 p.m.
- Saturday, Oct. 24 - The Fridays, 7-10 p.m.
- Monday, Oct. 26 - The Shifties, 6-9 pm.
- Friday, Oct. 30 - Pete Kehoe, 7-10 p.m.
- Saturday, Oct. 31- John Monkman, 7-10 p.m. Halloween Tomfoolery with a ghoulish cocktails and a costume contest with three winners of $75, $50, and $25 gift cards. Register between 6 and 7:30, judging at 8 p.m.
- Monday, Nov. 2 - The Shifties, 6-9 pm.
CROOKED TREE ARTS CENTER - 461 E. Mitchell Street. Petoskey, (231) 347-4337.
> See website for updated art shows, entertainment, and children's activities.
- Saturday, Oct. 17 - Downtown Sound: The Proud Naturals, 7:30 p.m. Tickets are $10-$55. Details.
FRESHWATER GALLERY & CONCERT VENUE - 217 S Lake St., Boyne City, (231) 582-2588. Music series:
- Saturday, Nov. 28 - Henhouse Prowlers, 8 p.m.
- Saturday, Dec. 29 - Larry McCray, 8 p.m.
- Saturday, Feb. 13 - Uprooted, 8 p.m. - Featuring Rusted Root principal songwriter, lead singer, and guitarist Michael Glabicki and other former Rusted Root members, including longtime guitarist Dirk Miller.
GREAT LAKES CENTER FOR THE ARTS - 800 Bay Harbor Drive, Petoskey, (231) 439 -2600. Details.
- Saturday, October 24 - Moxie Entertainment Presents: The Magic of Motown. The Hits. The Harmonies. The Motown Sound.
MUSKRAT DISTILLING - 121 Water St., Boyne City, (231) 268-0178.
> Karaoke Night - every Wednesday, 8-11 p.m.
> Music and events:
- Friday, Oct. 16 - Live music with Dave Cisco, 8-11 p.m.
- Friday, Oct. 23 - Live music with Lou Thumser, 8-11 p.m.
- Monday, Oct. 26 - Release party for A Court of Thorns and Roses (ACOTAR) Book #6. 6 p.m. check in at Dust & Blush. 7 p.m. Trivia starts at Muskrat.
- Saturday, Oct. 31 - Halloween Party. Karaoke costume contest with music by DJ T-Bone, 9-11:59 p.m.
PIED PIPER ROLLER RINK - 04454 M-75 N, Walloon Lake. Admission $10, skate rental $3. Candy, chips, soda/pop, and pizza available for purchase.
- Friday, Oct. 16 - Open skating, 5-10 p.m.
- Saturday, Oct. 17 - Open skating, 3-10 p.m.
RED MESA GRILL -117 Water St, Boyne City, (231) 582-0049.
> Wednesday, Oct. 21 - Painting on the porch with Dan Duncan from Duncan Studios, 6-8 p.m. You will be painting a spooky pumpkin patch, enjoying a delicious bowl of pumpkin soup, and sipping on a Red Mesa margarita. Seats are limited - call to reserve your spot, $48 per person.
> Saturday, Oct. 24 - Halloween Fiesta from 7-10 p.m. with ghoulish drinks, music with DJ T-Bone and a costume contest wtih gift cards as prizes at 9:30.
STIGGS BREWERY & KITCHEN - 112 S. Park St., Boyne City, (231) 497-6100
> Oct. 15 and the third Thursday of the month - Open Mic & Stand-up hosted by Peter Allen Jensen, 6-9 p.m.
WALLOON WATERSHED - 4128 M-75 , Walloon Lake, (231) 535-6048.
Live music:
-
Tuesdays - Laura Crowe, 6-9 p.m.
- Wednesdays - Pete Kehoe, 6-9 p.m.
- Saturday, Oct. 31 - (Sold out) Halloween party from 6:30-10 p.m. featuring DJ Parker Marshall and a costume contest. Tickets on our website.
THE WHI-SKI INN - 2670 US 131 South, Boyne Falls, (231) 549-3346.
> Celebrating the 10-year anniversary of the Whi-Ski Inn from Oct. 20-24.
- Friday, Oct. 23 - Rod & Jeromy Loper, 6:30-9:30 p.m.
- Saturday, Oct. 24 - Spencer Opperman, 6:30-9:30 p.m.
- Saturday, Nov. 14 - Bill Oeming, 6:30-9:30 p.m.
- Friday, Nov. 27 - Spencer Opperman, 6:30-9:30 p.m.
| | © Copyright 2026 Boyne Citizen, all rights reserved | | | | |