Scale Trains SDL-39 Notice
Scale Trains has recently released a model of the SDL-39 in versions for Milwaukee Road, Soo Line and Wisconsin Central. The model has many innovative features. It comes equipped with an ESU LokSound v5 21MTC decoder and supports ten lighting functions. ESU designed all the electronics, including the motherboard, specifically for this loco. Previously, the LokSound v5 decoder was found to be compliant with NMRA Standards and received Conformance Warrant 2020-0007
The NMRA Standards and Conformance team was requested to test and review the SDL-39, after some end users complained that the locomotive would not work with other decoder brands besides the ESU LokSound V5 21MTC decoder supplied with the locomotive.
The locomotive was inspected and tested with the ESU LokSound decoder and also tested with a SoundTraxx Tsunami2 21MTC decoder. The locomotive worked as advertised with the ESU decoder. However, all lighting features did not work with the SoundTraxx decoder. In order to have any lighting functions work on other decoders, a jumper must be soldered between pins 5 and 16 of the motherboard. Users are advised to contact Scale Trains for more information on how to do this. Not all available decoders were tested, and there exists a possibility that a jumper between pins 5 and 16 could damage some decoders. Even with the jumper, all lighting features will not be functional with a decoder other than the LokSound v5 decoder.
Modelers everywhere are wanting more features, lighting functions, and sounds. The SDL-39 is a fine example of a locomotive produced to satisfy these customer demands. The NMRA DCC Working Group released S-9.1.1.3 21MTC Decoder Interface last year along with other Standards for other decoder interfaces.
Scale Trains and ESU are not outside of any NMRA Standards with this product. However, the intent of Standards is to assure interoperability between equipment of different brands. That is the whole purpose of the DCC Standards. In this case, interoperability is lacking.
The NMRA DCC Working Group is focused on expanding these Standards to meet modelers’ demands, maintaining compatibility to permit the exchange of decoders while not limiting future innovation.
Sincerely,
Mark Juett
Standards & Conformance - DCC