Dear Members & Friends of All Souls,


Your Ministerial Search Committee (MSC) has completed our three listening sessions, and we are grateful to the roughly 140 of you who showed up, shared openly, and cared enough to help shape our future. Below is a summary of what we asked and what we heard.


Why this matters now?

What you told us goes directly into our Congregational Record, the packet prospective ministers will use to decide whether to pursue All Souls. Think of it as our dating profile: our chance to make the case for who we are and who we hope to become. The Record is due in early November, so we moved quickly, and your input made that possible.


Session 1: Sunday, October 4, at 10 am (in person, roughly 40 attendees)


We asked about our five-year vision, what we’re proud of (aside from our beautiful, beloved music!), and what we expect of a minister on social justice, interfaith work, and the UUA. You told us:


  • Vision: A more united congregation that overcomes silos, practices right relations, and manages conflict well. You want a thriving intergenerational community, empowered volunteer leadership, a clearer shared mission with sustainable resources, and renewed religious education (RE), outreach, and social action.
  • Pride: Our tradition of intellectual and spiritual inquiry, our “deeds, not creeds” ethic, our legacy of social action, our talented volunteers and programs, and our remarkable building, which we should build on but not be defined by. 
  • Expectations: Visible, sustained leadership in social justice. Deeper in-person ties with other faith communities and the wider city. A clearer relationship with the UUA, where views differ between those who want more engagement and those who value congregational autonomy. A minister with theological breadth who welcomes diverse beliefs and protects freedom of inquiry.


Session 2: Sunday, October 18, at 1 pm (in person, about 80 attendees)


Because “Code Red” had emerged as a theme, we focused on our children, the RE program, youth, young adults, and new leadership, and on our hopes and dreams. You told us:


  • Children, families, and RE: The next minister must genuinely love children and welcome them in worship. We should rebuild RE after losing 100+ families.
  • Reaching younger generations: Ideas included a revived 20s/30s/40s fellowship, peer mentoring among youth, and using All Souls School as a gentle on-ramp for young families.
  • A community hub: Make better use of our building and connect with our neighbors.
  • A focused, sustainable ministry: Many suggested separating administrative and spiritual leadership, for example with an executive director, so the minister can minister and our overburdened staff can be supported. This is a governance decision for the congregation, not for the minister.
  • Hopes and dreams: Shared ownership of our community’s energy, spiritual leadership that says “yes” to member initiative, social justice visible throughout the week, stronger diversity and belonging, and listening to people beyond our current membership. You also reminded us that no minister can create renewal alone.


Session 3: Tuesday, October 20th at 7 pm (Zoom, 16 attendees, 5 of them first-timers)


We asked directly: What are we willing to change about ourselves and our culture? You told us:

  • Honor our heritage without being mired in it and prepare ourselves to handle disagreement when change touches things we cherish.
  • Pastoral care matters as much as preaching. People want a minister who shows up, even at coffee hour.
  • Inspiring, warm preaching and connection with newcomers drive growth.
  • We can feel intimidating to newcomers, and we should keep working on unconscious bias and welcome.
  • Views differ on a minister’s age: some want a younger voice, while others value our multigenerational community.


The big themes across all sessions

  1. Renewing children, youth, and young families was the most consistent theme.
  2. The congregation must change too. Members expect to volunteer more, increase annual giving, adjust the RE budget, and try new things.
  3. A new leadership model that frees the minister to focus specifically on ministry.
  4. Care, presence, and inspiring preaching with intellectual depth.
  5. Social justice and community, with visible action beyond Sundays and deeper neighborhood and interfaith ties.
  6. Diversity, inclusion, and welcome.
  7. UU identity and the UUA, where we hold differing views.
  8. Unity and trust, through right relations and a clear shared mission.

The Sessions by the numbers:

Session

Date & Format

Attendance

1

Oct. 4, 10 am, in person

About 40

2

Oct. 18, 1 pm, in person

About 80

3

Oct. 20, 7 pm, Zoom

16 (5 first timers)

That is about 140 attendances, not counting MSC members or staff.


What’s next: Join us for the Break Barriers / Build Beliefs (B4) Workshops


Please save the dates for our B4 workshops on Tuesday, Nov 17, and Wednesday, Nov 18 at 7 pm: two Zoom sessions of about 90 minutes each. Zoom links will follow. We hope you’ll join us for these sessions designed to prepare congregations and search committees for an equitable ministerial search by recognizing and reducing unconscious bias, preventing discrimination, and strengthening inclusive thinking.


Your voices are the foundation of this search. We are listening, and we want to be transparent with you at every step.


With deep gratitude and great hope,

• Julie Brannan, Committee Co-Chair

• David Rockefeller, Committee Co-Chair

• Shu-Wie Chen

• Nancy Northup

• Bryce Stack

• Karen Steele

• Jennifer Vermont-Davis

• Victor Fidel


P.S. Our MSC Covenant, affirmed at our first meeting on June 3, 2026: “As a Search Committee representing our congregation, we covenant to serve to the best of our ability, recognizing that, individually and collectively, we represent the face of our congregation and community in the ministerial search process. We will act with honesty, care, compassion, and respect. We also commit to assuming good faith, maintaining confidentiality, and working together in a collegial spirit.”


P.S..2: We want to hear from you—feel free to reach out to us at msc@allsoulsnyc.org