|
When should I spot drill vs. center drill?
Spot drilling and center drilling might look like the same job, but they serve different purposes. Pick the wrong one and you’ll end up with broken drills, off-center holes, or chamfers that don’t belong there. The right choice depends on what you’re trying to accomplish and the tools you’re using next.
Use spot drills for CNC work.
Spot drills are short, rigid, and have a simple point angle, usually 90 or 120 degrees. They’re made to locate the true position of a hole before drilling, not to guide a live center. The stiff design keeps the drill from walking, especially on angled or curved surfaces.
Match the point angle to your drill.
The spotting angle should be equal to or larger than the drill’s point angle. If the spot is sharper, the drill will cut only at the tip and wear out fast. For standard jobber drills at 118 degrees, use a 120 degree spot drill. For split-point or carbide drills at 135 degrees, pick a 140 degree spot.
Use center drills only when needed for turning or secondary ops.
Center drills were designed for lathe centers, not for guiding twist drills in CNC milling. They have a weak pilot tip and a secondary chamfer angle that creates an unnecessary countersink. That shape makes them prone to chatter and breakage in mills.
Spot drill small holes for accuracy.
When drilling small holes, a quick spot helps the bit start exactly on location. It’s especially important for harder materials, angled faces, or any time you’re using a carbide drill.
Skip spotting when using stub or solid carbide drills with self-centering points.
These drills are rigid and have web-thinning geometry that eliminates the need for a pilot spot. In fact, spotting can cause chipping if it creates an uneven landing surface for the carbide tip.
Keep your spot depth shallow.
You only need a clean chamfer for the drill to start in. Going too deep adds cycle time and risks creating a visible countersink when it’s not needed. Just enough to break the surface is plenty.
Bottom line:
Spot drills locate holes; center drills make centers. Use spots for precision and rigidity, and save center drills for the lathe tailstock.
Have a programming question?
Send it in for the next edition of Ask a CAM Pro!
|