“Our Lived Experiences”


On Thursday, October 7th, the Needham Resilience Network met in Powers Hall at the Needham Town Hall. Following a photoshoot by photographer Cara Soulia, co-creator of “The Front Steps Project,” members continued on their pathway of exploring the “State of Needham.” We focused this month on members’ own lived experiences in Needham. 



REVIEW OF COMMUNICATIONS AGREEMENT

In preparation for the sharing of stories, the group reviewed the NRN Communications Agreement. Our agreement aims to promote the following things:

  • speaking from personal experience
  • listening with resilience and curiosity across different beliefs, experiences and identities
  • building connection and understanding
  • supporting intentional communication using skills of active listening and inquiry. 

Simultaneously, our agreement aims to prevent:

  • debate around policy or theory unrelated to personal experience
  • assumptions that other people or the discussions themselves are polarized or without complexity
  • experiences of feeling attacked, defensive or unable to share perspectives
  • unproductive, vicious cycles around contentious topics
 
Currently, the NRN Agreement is as follows:

  • To “pass” or “pass for now” if we are not ready or do not wish to respond

  • To speak one at a time and not engage in side conversations 

  • To “move up” (if we tend to be shy or quiet) and “move back” (if sharing comes easily to us)

  • To respect time frames for speaking

  • To make ‘I’ statements and speak only for ourselves (or specify if attempting to represent sentiments or experiences held largely in common by a group)

  • To check out our assumptions by asking questions (relying especially on “SAVE - Stories, Actions, Values, Emotions,” and, in particular, deepening our understanding of others’ values and emotions as they relate to a certain experience)

  • To speak in ways that promote connection and learning

  • To maintain confidentiality

  • To name and repair harm when it occurs (because it will occur, possibly in each and every meeting, and our practice of “calling in” and repairing it is what will allow us to create a healthy, caring, and pluralistic community)



PROTOCOL FOR “CALLING IN” AND REPAIRING HARM 


Regarding the final bullet, first, we will practice identifying when the agreement is being violated and how to gently “call each other in” throughout the coming sessions.

Second, because violations of the communications agreement can and do sometimes cause harm among us, we are proposing a protocol for repairing harm within the NRN when it occurs. The questions that we are proposing below derive from “The 5 Questions of Restorative Justice.” 

  • What happened? (For the person being challenged: What were you thinking about at the time? What have you thought about since? For the person/s affected: What were you thinking when you realized what had happened? 

  •  What was the impact of what was done/said? (For the person being challenged: Who has been affected by what you have done, and how? For the person/s affected: What impact has this had on you? What has been the hardest thing?

  • What do you think needs to happen to make this right? (For both the person being challenged and the person/s affected.)

In the coming months, we will practice identifying when harms occur and instigating the question protocol (by speaking up to let folks know we feel harmed, or by asking if someone else interpreted something as a harm, then determining whether the questions need to occur in group context or as a 1-1, etc.).



INTERACTIVE LEARNING: OUR LIVED EXPERIENCES OF OTHERING & BELONGING IN NEEDHAM                                          


Our small group exercise asked groups of 4 to reflect on their own experiences in Needham. In the first exercise, they responded to the following prompts about BELONGING IN NEEDHAM: Speaking from your own perspective, or one you believe to be prominent in your sub-network: Where and/or when have you felt belonging in Needham? What was it about this situation that made you feel belonging? 

These themes were shared back to the large group. 

“I/we’ve felt belonging in Needham when…”

  • An extra effort is made by others to include or bring us into the fold–sometimes it only takes one person
  • A community or group as a whole (school system, neighborhood, etc.) has been welcoming to me or my group
  • As a Black child, in the midst of all you’re exposed to, my family and the larger Black Needham community offered a soft place to land
  • Neighbors are involved in each other’s lives, like extended family
  • Attending a community event, like a vigil, parade, or festival
  • Residents and community officials (town, faith, or other) partner towards common goals such that issues of rank or status become secondary
  • Specific behaviors of inclusion are undertaken (e.g., gift giving, asking questions, approaching, emotionally connecting)
  • I make an effort to reach out, or join a group, and in turn welcome others
  • There is an experience of being a part of a diverse group
  • I interact with objects/people/things of warmth (pets, toys, connecting activities like block parties)

In the second exercise, small groups responded to prompts about OTHERING IN NEEDHAM:

Speaking from your own perspective, or one you believe to be prominent in your sub-network, where/when have you felt like you didn’t belong in Needham? What made you feel “othered” in this case? 

These themes were shared back to the large group:

“I/we’ve felt “othered” in Needham when…”

  • I’ve been seen ONLY as a group member and not as a person, whether the group membership is “Black,” “Quaker,” “elderly,” “disabled,” or “police officer”.
  • I am the target OR observer of social media posts used to disparage, insult or express hate (e.g., racial slurs, language around the recent Presidential election).
  • We realized there are cliques centered around how long one has lived here, e.g., “we old-timers belong here, but new people don’t.” This dynamic is exacerbated by the fact that more recent newcomers to Needham tend to be more diverse.
  • Communications by the majority exclude me or my identity group/s.
  • I’ve worked on uncovering the history of bias, hate, or displacement in Needham (e.g., in terms of slavery, redlining, etc.) and the discomfort this work caused led to public upset, denial and reprimand. 
  • The NRN examined the results of its member survey and realized that non-White participants did not feel an overall sense of belonging in Needham. It made the belonging some felt before–and took for granted as a community-wide experience–feel diminished. 
  • Covid-related disparities surfaced and expanded in Needham.

The group reflected on the realization that each and every NRN member has experienced some form of Othering and therefore knows what it feels like to be labeled as “other.” While this does not imply that all Othering is the same (some groups have been subjected to systems of oppression and violence for hundreds of years), it is universally painful to not be seen, welcomed, included, or empowered (as a co-creator in the community) because of one aspect of one’s multitudinous identity. The group acknowledged that this shared experience can connect us all and provide a starting place for our work together. 


“We are connected by the exclusion, the hurt.
It is a place from which to unify, a shared understanding
from which to build true belonging in our community.”   




THE STATE OF OTHERING & BELONGING IN NEEDHAM: A 6-MONTH JOURNEY THROUGH DATA & STORIES 


In the next six months, local experts will provide data on the following topics (with a focus on disparities by group). All of these topics have been identified as being important to the community in previous NRN discussions. Each presentation will include responses by 1-2 discussants who are members with their own experience on that issue. These panels will serve as a launching pad for NRN participants to share their own and subgroup members’ narratives on these themes, to reflect on the ways current realities reflect identity-based Belonging and Othering, and to identify opportunities for intervention and change. Following this review of the “State of Needham,” the NRN will lay out priorities for 2023-2024 (starting with Rapid Response). 

October: Stories of Belonging & Othering
All NRN Members

November: Food and Economic Insecurity
Sandy Robinson, Community Council

December: Housing & Public Health  
Tim McDonald, Department of Public Health

January: Town Satisfaction & Community Cohesion
Kate Fitzpatrick, Town Manager + Nichole Argo, NRN

February: Law Enforcement 
John Schlittler, Needham Police Department

March: DEI in NPS  
Dan Gutekanst & Joanne Allen- Willoughby, Needham Public Schools



PREPARATION FOR NEXT MONTH'S NRN MEETING                                               

November’s topic is FOOD & ECONOMIC INSECURITY in Needham. Please make your sub-network aware of this upcoming discussion and come prepared to share stories and data related to it on November 3. 



GROUP BIOS


NEEDHAM METCO PARENT COUNCIL

Valine Valbrun, chair of the Needham METCO (Metropolitan Council for Educational Opportunity, Inc launched in 1966) shared about METCO'S history as the largest and second continuously longest running voluntary school desegregation program in the country.  METCO aims to offer Boston residents and Needham students opportunities to develop a deeper understanding of each other, and like NRN aims to build trust and relationship across difference and bring the richness of diversity to the Needham community. The METCO Parent Council supports students' participation in training and leadership programs through the greater Boston METCO Association and invites families to participate in a variety of activities, including arts, dance, educational activism, and get togethers. For example, in the spring of 2020 eight high school students in the METCO program were selected for an internship program called BEAT (Boston Education Activism Tour). The students’ main project involved researching Boston activism initiatives that promote educational equality.  

Thirty-four communities in Massachusetts participate in the METCO program. Needham has one of the largest METCO programs with 180 K-12 students. New students are welcomed into the METCO program through Jump Start which is used to help families acclimate to the program. The parent council meets monthly to discuss what is working well, opportunities for improvement and to celebrate the achievements of each month.

METCO is an organization for all of us, not just the students and families that participate in it, as it enriches communities and promotes equity and inclusion. For more information please email the METCO Parent Council needhammpc@gmail.com or contact Dr. Joanne Willoughby at joanne_allen-willoughby@needham.k12.ma.us. 


                              
UPDATES & NEXT STEPS


In the next few weeks liaisons will: 

  • Introduce their subnetworks to the NRN and begin to collect stories and reflections on lived experiences in Needham. These critical, anonymous narratives will be brought back to NRN for discussion and consideration of action. 

  • Witness and be ambassadors for our ‘coming out’ via social media, the NRN Website and a press release via local news.  

  • Take part in the creative process of developing an information NRN video. 


RESOURCES


What We Are Reading/Watching/Listening to:


  • Watch Joe Bubman, Executive Director of Urban Rural Action, in a short video describing the work of Urban Rural Action, highlighting the experience of folks in Maryland coming together from different ideological perspectives to tackle issues of immigration, economic development, and inclusion with practical local solutions for their state.
 

  • Watch Faith and Polarization. Vice President for Programs at One America Movement, Chandra DeNap Whetstine gave an inspiring talk at Stand Together’s Catalyst Summit describing their approach to combating toxic polarization, working with faith communities across the U.S.

  • Watch Targeted Universalism, john a. powell. Targeted Universalism--introduced by Berkeley professor john a. powell of the Othering and Belonging Institute--sets universal goals for the general population that are accomplished through targeted approaches based on the needs of different groups.

  • Read Surviving Polarization, by Adrian Rutt. This is an overview of several different takes on polarization. One powerful insight: “…we are all bundles of contradictions, whatever else we like to think about our expressed beliefs and their consistency and cogency…It is not the case that we possess rigorously formulated ‘belief systems’, which stamp out our thoughts and reactions in a fully determinable way. People alter their reactions and expressions to cope with the particularities of the situation they find themselves in.”

  • Listen to Power Building with Alicia Garza, Finding Our Way Podcast. In this episode, author, political strategist, and organizer Alicia Garza, breaks down what power is, how we build it and why we need it in order to build a more equitable society.

  • Listen to The Power of Crisis, Future Hindsight Podcast. This interview discusses The Power of Crisis: How Three Threats – and Our Response – Will Change The World, a new book by Ian Bremmer which posits that the climate crisis, disruptive technologies, and pandemics are existential threats to humanity, but also offer an opportunity for real cooperation across the world.

  • Listen to Journeying on the Road to Reconciliation, ThinkPeace Podcast. “Going down the road of reconciliation is a daunting path that not many people can take. This road may test you in ways you couldn't imagine but when the end result leads to tangible and sustainable change, you realize that the journey is worth it.” Director of the Mary Hoch Center for Reconciliation, Antti Pentikainen discusses his journey into reconciliation, his experiences working in different contexts, and what have been the most effective methods in working towards reconciliation.

  • Read The Sum of Us, by Heather McGee. McGHee’s book is an invitation to consider letting go of this country’s ‘zero sum game’ lens where one group has to be depleted and disempowered for another to be strengthened; instead we can be richer, and stronger together. Wealth and impoverishment, Education and Healthcare. Climate and Housing are viewed through the lens of race, with the suggestion that the pooling versus division of resources can enrich us all.  


  • Suzie Wise has a fabulous book on belonging, replete with ideas and exercises for local application. Check out Design for Belonging.


Onward!
Beth & Nichole (NRN Co-Directors)