David Beats Goliath: Citizens Triumph Over BNSF in Wittmann
On November 5th, the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors voted unanimously against BNSF’s proposed Comprehensive Plan Amendment—a stunning victory for the citizens of the West Valley. It was truly a David and Goliath battle, and yes, David won.
The Power of the People
BNSF came into this fight confident—some might say cocky. They described their amendment as merely “correcting a mapping error,” believing it would be an easy win. But the people of Wittmann, Surprise, and surrounding rural communities saw through the spin.
Despite BNSF’s underhanded tactics—including paying to get signatures of support, using misleading clickbait links on social media, bullying local residents, and spending hundreds of thousands on a PR campaign—citizens refused to be intimidated or deceived.
The Last-Minute Trick
When it became clear their plan was in trouble, BNSF tried one last desperate maneuver. Less than 36 hours before the vote, the company blasted a mass email and flooded social media claiming they were “requesting a continuance.” It was a transparent attempt to suppress turnout from the opposition.
But the citizens didn’t fall for it. Word spread quickly, and on the morning of the meeting, the Board of Supervisors’ chambers were packed. There wasn’t an empty seat in the house. The walls were lined with residents wearing “No BNSF” stickers, standing shoulder to shoulder in peaceful opposition.
The Vote and the Victory
BNSF’s attorney, Susan Demmitt, again asked for a continuance during her opening remarks—but her request went nowhere. After three previous continuances, the Board wasn’t playing that game anymore.
Four union representatives spoke in favor of BNSF, citing potential construction jobs during the building phase. But those jobs would be temporary, while the impact on families, schools, property values, and the environment would be permanent.
More than 30 citizens took to the microphone to speak passionately against the proposal. Each Supervisor explained their vote before the roll call—and one by one, they all voted with the people.
A Moment to Celebrate
When the final vote was announced, the room remained calm. Even in victory, the opposition remained respectful. Chairman Galvin called for a brief recess, and as the crowd filed outside, there were tears of joy, hugs, and high-fives all around. It was a beautiful moment for the people of the West Valley—a reminder of what can be accomplished when we stand united.
The Fight Isn’t Over
While this was a tremendous victory, it was just one battle in a larger war. BNSF has deep pockets and powerful interests behind them. They may have lost this round, but they won’t go away quietly.
We will continue gathering signatures, rallying public officials to speak out, and turning out in force at future hearings. We are strong when we stand together—and rural Arizona is worth fighting for.
Thank you to every citizen who made this victory possible, and to the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors for listening to the people they represent.
For now, let’s take a moment to breathe, smile, and celebrate this win for rural America.
Gratitude and Many Thanks
I would like to take a moment to thank Supervisor Debbie Lesko for her leadership and dedication in ensuring that all voices were heard regarding BNSF’s agenda item. She went above and beyond, taking the time to listen to every speaker, ask thoughtful questions, and truly understand the complexities of this issue and the profound impact it will have on the West Valley community. Her commitment to transparency, fairness, and genuine public input is deeply appreciated by the citizens she serves.
|