Monday Evening, May 19, 2025

 
Military Religious Freedom Foundation 20th Anniversary Logo with gold strip behind displaying 2005 to 2025
 

CHRISTIAN NATIONALIST DOT SEC’Y DUFFY

VINDICTIVELY MOVING GIANT JESUS PAINTING

BACK TO USMMA CONFERENCE ROOM —

MRFF FILES GIANT JESUS FOIA REQUEST



In 2023, MRFF, acting on a complaint from an group of

17 alumni, midshipmen, faculty, and staff at the U.S. Merchant Marine Academy, a number that nearly doubled, succeeded in getting an enormous painting of Jesus moved from the

Elliot M. See conference room in the Academy’s

administrative building to the chapel.


Then, last month, former reality TV star and Christian supremacist transportation secretary Sean Duffy visited the Academy, whipping Christian midshipmen into a frenzy of Christian nationalistic approval when he asked: “Can we bring Jesus up from the basement?” 


Duffy has been milking the viral video of his USMMA Jesus painting performance ever since, along with spreading his

blatant lie that the painting was moved because of a “complaint from ONE ‘concerned citizen,’” a lie that is now being repeated in the plethora of articles from the Christian, Christian nationalist, and MAGA-friendly media since Duffy’s DOT press release last Thursday announcing that he was moving the painting back to its original Constitution-flouting location in the Elliot M. See Room.


Unfortunately, due to Secretary Duffy’s seemingly insatiable

lust for attention and vindictive compulsion to stick it to

MRFF, a constitutional solution that could have been reached when the Christian midshipmen who wanted the painting moved suggested moving it to the Academy’s Ackerman Auditorium will now not happen. There, it would have been among several other similarly gigantic artworks of secular subjects, and, with a simple disclaimer on its signage, would have passed constitutional muster.

 
 

Also in this dispatch:


Veteran journalist Jonathan Larsen interviews

Mikey Weinstein about MRFF in these dark days

of the current Christian nationalist MAGA administration

 
 
Split image of Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and the giant Jesus painting

U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy/

The enormous Jesus painting dominating conference room in the

administrative building at Merchant Marine Academy before

being moved to chapel in 2023 due to MRFF

Photos: Transportation Sec. Sean Duffy transportation.gov website/

Jesus Painting, Coast Guard

MRFF files FOIA request on Sean Duffy

and the giant Jesus painting


Submitted to the U.S. Department of Transportation on:


Thursday, May 15, 2025

 


To Whom It May Concern:


This is a request under the Freedom of Information Act, 5 U.S.C.§ 552.


On behalf of the Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF), I request that copies of the following documents be produced to MRFF within twenty (20) business days:


1. All communications between U.S. Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy and any faculty, staff, leadership, or other personnel, including midshipmen, at the U.S. Merchant Marine Academy regarding the Academy’s painting “Jesus on the Water” between January 28, 2025 and the present.


2. All documents and communications related to Secretary Duffy procuring and installing a replica of the Merchant Marine Academy’s “Jesus on the Water” painting in his Department of Transportation office.


Please note that MRFF is a non-profit organization requesting this information in order to benefit the public interest by increasing understanding of the government’s operations and activities pursuant to 5 U.S.C. § 552(a)(4)(A)(iii). Accordingly, MRFF is entitled to a waiver of all costs associated with responding to this request.


If you have any questions regarding this request, I may be contacted at 732-XXX-XXXX or at research@militaryreligiousfreedom.org.


Respectfully,


Chris Rodda

Senior Research Director

Military Religious Freedom Foundation

 
 

THE DAILY BEAST

COVERS DUFFY’S GIANT JESUS CRUSADE


Sean Duffy Moves Jesus Painting

Amid Another Safety Crisis


By: Erkki Forster 


Thursday, May 15, 2025


Echoing comments on Duffy’s giant Jesus social media posts and videos — such as “Are we now hoping that Jesus will keep planes from falling out of the sky?” — the Daily Beast writes:


“Duffy made a splashy announcement about the picture just as the Federal Aviation Administration launched an investigation into an incident in which Colorado air traffic controllers directing flights across a large section of the Western United States lost contact with pilots for up to six minutes when transmitters went dark.”

Scroll down for much more giant Jesus coverage

JONATHAN LARSEN

COVERS MRFF


Veteran journalist Jonathan Larsen co-created Up w/ Chris Hayes and wrote for Countdown with Keith Olbermann at MSNBC, helped launch CNN’s Anderson Cooper 360° and Air America Radio, and has also worked at The Daily Show with Jon Stewart and The Young Turks.



The Quiet War to Save the U.S. Military


By: Jonathan Larsen


Saturday, May 17, 2025


Article excerpts:


But while Trump’s abuses and Hegseth’s crusade get the headlines, everyone should understand that they aren’t the only ones fighting to forge the future of the U.S. military. The Constitution still has defenders in uniform and those defenders still have allies outside the military.


One of those allies is the Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF), which fights for constitutional secularism in the military as if divinely inspired. I’ve written before about founder and President Mikey Weinstein, a Jewish military veteran who worked in the administration of President Ronald Reagan and now endures the slings and arrows of outrageous Christian radicals every time he successfully defends members of the military — mostly Christian — from theocratic commanders.


The MRFF has been winning battles that rarely make the news, but serve to hold the line against Hegseth’s theocratic encroachments. I’ll get to (just a few of) those.


[…]


We may never know how many legal victories The Orders Project or Trans Representation Project notch up, but the MRFF is considerably less shy.


The military has always had a problem in the ranks with radical Christian theocrats, white supremacists, and the Venn diagram where both of them serve. The MRFF, for instance, has been peeling back the ties of U.S. Army Lt. General Brian Eifler to election deniers, Jan. 6 backers, and the anti-democratic New Apostolic Reformation movement.


Responding to the MRFF’s reporting about Eifler abusing his position to waterboard Jesus down the throats of his troops, the Army’s inspector general launched an investigation. But now EIfler has his dream boss and his dream commander in chief.


Weinstein saw all of this coming decades ago, and has been ringing the alarm bells, as evidenced by his 2008 interview with New Humanist magazine. Weinstein hears directly from the canaries in the coal mines, the military and intelligence men and women who tell him about radical Christian encroachments, usually from the top down, usually targeting Christians for being wrongly or insufficiently Christian.


[…]


Even before Trump won the election, congressional Republicans mounted an assault on every single person in the U.S. military and intelligence communities. They tried to rewrite U.S. law to make it illegal for any of them to contact the MRFF. That would include not only complaints to MRFF but responses to MRFF from the chain of command, the legions of base commanders and other supervisors who do the right thing when Weinstein educates them that, no, soldiers can’t be made to listen to sermons and that, no, veterans hospital can’t have a Bible display in the lobby, and on and on and on.


The Republican-controlled House of Representatives actually approved this bill to curtail the speech rights and religious freedom of members of the U.S. military. Weinstein turned the tables and the legislative language was changed to codify Pentagon responses to Weinstein’s complaints.


Which means now Weinstein and the MRFF are positioned and established to defend infringements on the rights of those who serve in the military and intelligence communities.


Already in January, the MRFF wrote at the time, it had gotten “hundreds of calls from clients” — how the MRFF refers to the service members it helps — “anxiously asking the same question: ‘What do I do if I’m given an illegal order by Trump and his minions?’”


The answer, as Weinstein publicly declared, was “come to us.” The MRFF, in other words, announced it was looking for a fight. Lots of fights. Fights on behalf of service members under siege from military theocrats seeking to co-opt the United States armed forces and twist its legacy and the resources provided by a diverse populace to their own, personal, unconstitutional ends.


And while it’s easy to imagine that Hegseth and Trump are steamrolling all opposition, the MRFF has been racking up some victories.


  • The MRFF pushed back after the Naval Academy removed displays celebrating Jewish women alumni prior to a visit by Hegseth. The displays were restored.
  • The MRFF prevented a Christian commander from forcing soldiers to attend a mandatory Easter service.
  • Hilariously, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy took time off — from the awesome job he’s doing ensuring that our airports definitely aren’t fucked — to rescue a Jesus painting the MRFF got removed from display at the Merchant Marine Academy by putting it in his office — which, it’s worth noting, is not putting it on public display. Duffy, of course, portrayed this as a win.

Christian nationalist and long-time MRFF enemy

Sen. Ted Cruz wants a piece of Sean Duffy’s

giant Jesus media attention



THE DAILY WIRE

COVERS MRFF


Ted Cruz Backs Trump Official’s Attempt To ‘Bring Jesus Up From The Basement’ — Literally


By: Leif Le Mahieu


Monday, May 12, 2025


The Daily Wire quotes Ted Cruz’s shmoozingly congratulatory letter to Duffy, writing:


“Your statement—’Can we bring Jesus up from the basement?’—was more than rhetorical. I trust it will be seen as an imperative,” Cruz wrote. “Thank you for your principled leadership, for defending our nation’s religious heritage, and for working to ensure that this government-commissioned memorial is returned to its rightful place.”


Cruz said the removal of the painting had no legal basis and was an example of the academy being “hostile to religion.”


“Its sudden concealment in 2023—done hastily in response to a single baseless complaint—did a great disservice to the Academy’s heritage and to the memory of those the painting was meant to honor. To this day, no legal rationale has been provided, and the painting is reportedly out of public view in a flood-prone basement,” Cruz said. 

Sean Duffy’s official DOT press release, complete with yet another video, announcing that he’s moving giant Jesus back to its constitutionally repugnant location

in the Academy’s Elliot M. See conference room


Thursday, May 15, 2025

 


U.S. Department of Transportation Secretary

Sean P. Duffy Announces USMMA’s Christ on

the Water Painting is Moving out of the Basement


Thursday, May 15, 2025


WASHINGTON, D.C. – U.S. Secretary of Transportation Sean P. Duffy announced that the historic Christ on the Water painting will be moved out of the basement and returned to its original location in the Elliot M. See Room at the United States Merchant Marine Academy’s (USMMA) Wiley Hall. The painting, which depicts Jesus Christ guiding sailors through stormy seas, is a significant symbol of the Academy’s religious and maritime heritage. The painting, which had hung in the Elliot M. See Room for nearly 80 years, was moved to the flood-prone basement of the chapel under the Biden Administration.  

 
 

More recent coverage of

Sean Duffy’s giant Jesus crusade

Christian Broadcasting Network:

Sean Duffy Hangs Portrait of Jesus in Office, Calls for Original to Be Rehung After Being Sidelined


Catholic Vote:

Transportation secretary to restore historic painting of Jesus to place of prominence at Merchant Marine Academy


The Washington Stand:

Jesus Returns, Voters Get Chance to Protect Babies, and More: 3 Stories You Missed


The Daily Wire:

The Biden Admin Banished This Historic Jesus Painting. Sean Duffy’s Moving It Back To Spotlight.


The Christian Post:

Son of merchant mariner who painted USMMA Jesus painting 'honored' by Duffy's support


UPI:

'Christ on Water' painting to be displayed again at U.S. Merchant Marine Academy


Metro Voice:

Jesus Painting Restored at Merchant Marine Academy


Breaking Stories:

Ted Cruz Applauds Push To Restore ‘Christ on the Water’: A Stand for Faith, History, and American Values


Life Site News:

Transportation Secretary Duffy puts painting of Jesus back to prominent location at naval academy


Slay News:

Sean Duffy Announces Restoration of ‘Christ on the Water’ Painting to Merchant Marine Academy After Biden Removed It

 

Previous MRFF coverage of MAGA Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy’s USMMA Jesus cheerleader performance

 

The conservative Christian and MAGA/Christian nationalist media are giddy over Sean Duffy’s

USMMA Rah-Rah-Jesus performance

The Western Journal:

“Watch: Military Academy Goes Wild When Trump Official Reveals Plans for Jesus Painting That Biden Admin Hid”


The Christian Post:

“Midshipmen erupt when Duffy demands Jesus painting be restored at Merchant Marine Academy: 'Let's bring Him up!’”


Focus on the Family’s

The Daily Citizen

“Secretary Sean Duffy: Let’s Bring Jesus Up from the Basement”


Catholic News Agency:

“Bring Jesus up!’: Sean Duffy rallies merchant marines over controversial painting move”


Charisma News:

“Midshipmen Rejoice: Jesus Returning to the

Merchant Marine Academy”

Background on MRFF’s 2023 victory in getting the Merchant Marine Academy to move enormous

Jesus painting to Academy’s chapel

MRFF's Inbox


“Merchant Marine Midshipmen Should Contact the Law Firms ‘Contracted’ by Trump to Fight Anti-Semitism”


From: (name withheld)

Date: May 15, 2025 at 7:07:20 PM MDT

To: Mikey Weinstein MRFF <mikey@militaryreligiousfreedom.org>

Subject: Merchant Marine Midshipmen Should Contact the Law Firms “Contracted” by Trump to Fight Anti-Semitism


Dear Military Religious Freedom Foundation,


In recent weeks several law firms “contracted” with President Trump to do nearly one billion dollars of pro bono work fighting, among other things, anti-semitism. This is to preclude President Trump’s imposition of 1950s-era, Joe McCarthy like consequences on these law firms.


Okay. A deal’s a deal.


Won’t you please direct Midshipmen at the United States Merchant Marine Academy to ask these law firms to seek injunctive relief to stop the return of the “Christ on the Water” painting to the Eliot M. See Room at the Academy’s main administration building (Wiley Hall)? See https://www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/us-department-transportation-secretary-sean-p-duffy-announces-usmmas-christ-water


Imposing an enormous Jesus figure on Midshipmen as they sit for honor boards and use the room for other proceedings violates the First Amendment of the Constitution and sends a message to those who are Jewish (among other religious cultures) that they are not welcome at the Academy.


How can the Trump administration insist that Harvard practices anti-semitism while at the same time, force Jesus on Jewish Midshipmen at the United States Merchant Marine Academy?


I want Harvard to use this act by Transportation Secretary Duffy in Harvard’s own legal battle against the Trump administration. With this move at the Merchant Marine Academy, it seems clear the Trump administration is in fact more interested in promoting anti-semitism than it is in eliminating it.


I resent how much this will cost in taxpayer money. I resent having to use a portion of these law firms’ allocated pro bono time for this.


1980s Graduate of the U. S. Merchant Marine Academy

“Trump’s Transportation Secretary Vows to

Undo MRFF’s 2023 Victory Getting USMMA

to Move Giant Jesus Painting to Chapel”


From: (name withheld)

Sent: Sunday, April 13, 2025 8:44 AM PM

To: Mikey Weinstein <mikey@militaryreligiousfreedom.org>

Subject: Trump’s Transportation Secretary Vows to Undo MRFF’s 2023 Victory Getting USMMA to Move Giant Jesus Painting to Chapel


Hi Mikey 


I am as pissed as you are at the fact that Duffy played this issue and at the reaction of some of the midshipmen.


From what I have been able to glean there is NO intent to put the painting back in the See conference room and the Academy has made this clear to Secretary Duffy. Rather, I am hearing the thought is to put it in the museum.


The placement of the picture in the chapel was to an appropriate place, (it was in the lower-level basement of the chapel by the entrance to the chapel used for daily Catholic Mass 


and indeed the only spot in the chapel where there was room).  But it was not a great location, and many viewed it as an insult. I though it was Ok but not great and can understand how people felt.


So, a movement to get it out of the basement – which is what this was is not wrong.


As to your “blast”. I can appreciate your ire at the thought of the painting returning to the conference room. I also appreciate that him stoking the fire was not appropriate.


In many situations you have first quietly reached out to educate and generally it works. Perhaps Duffy needs such an eduction rather than backing him into a corner where he has no choice but to come out swinging.


BTW the Academy and its administration and the Chaplain are fully supportive of religious plurality. As for us Jews, this academic year we had a superb Friday evening service that was attended by the Superintendent

and her Husband and the Deputy Supe and at which we dedicated two new Torah mantels, one of which was paid for by the Academy and we welcomed a Holocaust Torah.


We observed International Holocaust Remembrance Day and we will be observing Yom HaShoa.  


Last year 6 midshipmen made the trip to Aushwitz, and I hear that this summer it will be 15.


And of course, in 2023 the Museum produced the I am a Jew exhibit.


So while one should be ticked at Duffy, it is not appropriate to state or even suggest that the Academy is anti-semitic because it is not or to call it the Merchant of Venice Academy.


(name withheld)


To see response from

MRFF Founder and President Mikey Weinstein:

incoming hate


“Wtf”


From: (name withheld)

Date: May 15, 2025 at 10:45:32 AM MDT

To: info@militaryreligiousfreedom.org

Subject: Wtf


This is one of those times where the “plucky” underdog, the one man “army” doesn’t and shouldn’t win. You would go the world a favor by shuttering your doors and vanishing into the ether.


To see responses from

MRFF Founder and President Mikey Weinstein

and MRFF Board Member John Compere:

 

SUPPORT MRFF’s SOCIAL MEDIA


Please Help Increase

MRFF’s Social Media Engagement

youtube.com/@MikeyMRFF

PLEASE MAKE A

100% TAX-DEDUCTIBLE DONATION


MRFF is a 501C3 Nonprofit

If you prefer to mail a check, please use this link to download a printable donation form

Please Share on Social Media

X Share This Email
LinkedIn Share This Email
MRFF Information/Contact:
(505) 250-7727
 
Facebook  X