Public Health Authority

Case Updates


November 6, 2026


Litigation Updates

 

This week’s newsletter discusses lawsuits related to tobacco control, assistance to individuals that are unhoused, and Medicaid work requirements. You can find our archive newsletters here.


Complaint Against Marketing of New Tobacco Products


Campaign for Tobacco Free Kids vs. FDA (U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland, Docket No. 8:26-cv-02767) was filed on July 14, 2026, by a coalition of public health groups, pediatricians, and parents challenging a Food and Drug Administration (FDA) policy that allows for the marketing of e-cigarettes and nicotine pouches without the scientific review and marketing authorization required by federal law. The complaint makes three primary allegations regarding the new policy. First, Plaintiffs allege the new policy violates the Tobacco Control Act by allowing new tobacco products to be marketed without prior authorization. Second, they argue that the new guidance violates the Administrative Procedure Act because it was issued without a notice and comment period. Finally, they argue that this new policy is arbitrary and capricious because it provides no meaningful justification for creating an enforcement safe harbor or for changing the agency’s longstanding approach to flavored tobacco products.


On October 9, the Plaintiffs filed a motion for summary judgment, requesting that the court vacate the FDA’s guidance and declare it contrary to law. Mitchell Hamline School of Law’s Public Health Law Center filed an amicus brief in support. 


Homeless Aid Groups Challenge Phoenix Ordinance


In Circle the City et al. v. City of Phoenix (U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona, Docket No. 2:26-cv-04222-PHX-DJH), Circle the City and Valle del Sol, organizations that provide services to unhoused people, challenged a Phoenix ordinance restricting medical treatment and food distribution in city parks. They argued that providing food and essential medical care is expressive activity protected by the First Amendment, while the City maintained that the ordinance only governs where such actions may take place, emphasizing concerns about medical waste, used needles, and overall use of park space. This case reflects a tension between groups providing services to unhoused communities and increasing local efforts aimed at criminalization as well as cuts to federal homelessness resources. 


The initial complaint was filed on June 15, 2026, with Plaintiffs seeking a preliminary injunction to block the ordinance. In July 2026, the City opposed that request, and the parties agreed to combine the injunction hearing with a trial on the merits. The court ruled against the Plaintiffs on August 11, 2026, disagreeing that “Plaintiffs’ provision of medical care or food to the unhoused is inherently expressive conduct under the First Amendment.” Plaintiffs filed an appeal to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals on October 16, 2026.


Medicaid Work Requirements and the “Medically Frail” Exemption


In Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz (U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, Docket No. 1:26-cv-12962-RGS), 25 states and the District of Columbia challenged federal restrictions on an exemption from Medicaid’s new work requirements. Filed on June 29, 2026, the lawsuit alleges that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) unlawfully narrowed protections for people with serious health conditions, violating the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) and the Constitution’s Spending Clause.


Congress established the requirements in the 2025 One Big Beautiful Bill Act. Beginning January 1, 2027, adults ages 19 to 64 covered through Medicaid expansion generally must complete at least 80 hours of work or community service each month, or enroll at least half-time in an educational program, to obtain or maintain Medicaid coverage. Congress exempted people who are “medically frail” or otherwise have special medical needs, including people with certain disabilities, substance use disorders, disabling mental disorders, and serious or complex medical conditions. CMS’s June 2026 interim final rule added a requirement that these conditions significantly impair a person’s ability to satisfy the work requirements. The Rule also limited States to claims and encounter data from the 12 months before an application is filed when verifying medical frailty (the “lookback period”) and limited individuals to one self-attestation of medical frailty per continuous period of Medicaid enrollment (the “self-attestation limit”).


The Plaintiffs argue that Congress had already identified the groups entitled to protection and had not authorized this additional test. They are also challenging limits on the Rule’s lookback period and self-attestation limit. The states warned that these administrative barriers would cause eligible residents to lose coverage and require costly changes to state eligibility systems.


On October 29, Judge Richard G. Stearns ruled partly in favor of the states, finding that CMS lacked authority to impose the additional impairment test. The court explained that Congress’s five listed categories established a minimum scope of protection that the agency could not narrow. However, the court upheld the 12-month lookback period and self-attestation limit, finding that CMS had adequately explained those policies under the APA’s arbitrary-and-capricious standard. The court did not reach the states’ alternative Spending Clause claim.


The court vacated the additional impairment requirement nationwide. Individuals who meet Congress’s medically frail criteria therefore need not separately establish that their conditions significantly impairs their ability to satisfy the work requirements. States, like before, still determine who qualifies for the exemption, but without applying the vacated impairment requirement, and the lookback period and self-attestation limits the court upheld still apply. The court also barred CMS from penalizing the Plaintiff States and the District of Columbia for implementation errors or delays for six months, giving them time to revise their eligibility systems. This temporary protection applies only to the Plaintiffs States and DC and does not change the January 1, 2027 implementation deadline for other states.


In Taylor v. Kennedy (U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland, Docket No. 1:26-cv-03705-GLR), five Medicaid beneficiaries, six medical organizations, and the City of Columbus filed a separate challenge to the new CMS rule on September 18, 2026. The lawsuit brings overlapping concerns from the perspectives of patients, providers, and a local government, alleging that CMS’s restrictions exceed its statutory authority and lack adequate justification under the APA.

Beyond the impairment test and verification limits challenged in Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz, Taylor contests a provision of the rule that prevents people with substance use disorders who have been in recovery for at least five years from qualifying. The Plaintiffs argue that Congress did not authorize this distinction and that CMS itself recognizes substance use disorders as chronic conditions that can persist during recovery.


The Plaintiffs and amici supporting them both emphasize how the verification rules could prevent eligible people from securing an exemption. The Plaintiffs point to the rules bar on using claims data older than 12 months, despite known delays in claims processing. Amici, including public health organizations and scholars, argue that added paperwork could burden people with serious health conditions and deny eligible individuals their coverage. For example, Plaintiffs October 20 motion for summary judgment describes the consequences for the individual Plaintiffs, including Sonya Taylor, who relies on Medicaid to manage diabetes and chronic kidney disease. The medical organizations argue that documenting eligibility would divert clinicians’ time from patient care and increase uncompensated work. Columbus similarly anticipates higher costs for providing health and emergency services to residents who lose coverage.


The Taylor case is still pending. Under the court’s scheduling order, the Defendants’ response and cross-motion for summary judgment were due November 3. The court declined to commit to a ruling before the work requirements begin on January 1, 2027.


Partner With Us! Please take this survey to let us know about local and state cases impacting public health or health equity, and to help us build our network of outside counsel. (password: amicus)

 

This newsletter is distributed by Public Health Law Watch.