Dear All Souls Community,



Thank you to everyone who shared your time, candor, and hopes through our recent congregational survey—and to everyone who attended our first listening session on Sunday, October 4. Your voices are helping shape All Souls’ next chapter. Because the survey and first session represent only part of our community, we warmly invite everyone—whether or not you have participated so far—to join an upcoming listening session or speak with us during coffee hour.


We are deeply grateful to the 271 members and friends who completed the survey. At the same time, 271 responses represent only a portion of our congregation—the survey went out to approximately 800 individuals. We need broader participation to ensure that the ministerial search reflects the full range of experiences, priorities, and hopes across All Souls.


As we prepare for our ministerial search, the brief synopsis below highlights the clearest themes from the survey: what we treasure, where we want to grow, and what our next minister should understand about this remarkable community. These themes reflect the 271 people who responded, not the entire congregation, which is why continued participation matters. The full survey results can be found at [this link].

Survey Synopsis: What We Heard from 271 Respondents


1. What We Treasure Most About All Souls


  • Trusted Leadership and Deep Commitment: Across generations, respondents expressed strong confidence in our ministers and lay leaders. More than 64% have called All Souls home for over a decade—and more than 43% for over 20 years—reflecting extraordinary dedication, institutional memory, resilience, and generosity.
  • Inspiring Worship, Music, and Intellectual Vitality: More than 85% identified inspiring services, musical excellence, and substantive sermons as central to congregational life. Respondents want to preserve our exceptional music and choir, familiar Sunday service format, and distinctive blend of intellectual rigor, spiritual reflection, theological pluralism, and beauty.
  • Our Unitarian Universalist Identity: Respondents deeply value our Seven Principles and our enduring commitments to diversity, openness, inclusivity, and social justice.

2. Where We Are Ready to Grow


Our strong foundation gives us every reason to be ambitious. Your responses highlighted four opportunities to bring fresh energy to congregational life:

  • Make It Easier for Great Ideas to Take Flight: Many respondents want clearer, faster, and more flexible pathways for launching new initiatives.
  • Welcome Younger Generations and Families: Two-thirds of respondents are over 60, while fewer than 10% are under 40. Building meaningful connections with younger adults and families with children emerged as a shared priority.
  • Meet Difference with Openness and Grace: Respondents called for candid, constructive dialogue; broader participation in decisions; and a culture where difficult conversations and diverse perspectives are welcomed.
  • Build a Truly Hybrid Community: Members who participate partly or entirely online want fuller access to small groups, committee work, and social justice initiatives.

3. What Our Next Minister Should Know About All Souls



Your vision for our next minister came through with inspiring clarity:

  • An Inspiring Preacher, Community Builder, and Pastor: Above all, respondents seek a minister who delivers meaningful worship, nurtures warm connections, and offers genuine pastoral care. Spiritual presence and relational warmth matter more than administrative management.
  • Compassion, Intellect, Courage, Openness, and Warmth: These were the qualities named most often—a leader who honors our history while inviting us boldly into the future.
  • A Community Worth Joining: In one word, respondents described All Souls as Passionate, Engaged, Unique, Caring, and Full of Potential.
  • A Future Filled with Possibility: The words that rose most often were Hopeful, Optimistic, and Excited—a powerful expression of confidence in what comes next.

Next Steps: Keep the Conversation Going


This survey is more than data—it is a compass. Your insights will guide the Search Committee, Board, and leadership team as we tell the story of All Souls and introduce our congregation to prospective ministerial candidates.

Thank you to the nearly 40 people who attended our first listening session on Sunday, October 4. It was a thoughtful and spirited conversation—but nearly 40 attendees are only a small share of our community. We need many more voices in the room. Please bring your perspective, questions, and hopes to at least one of the next two sessions:

  • Sunday, October 18, 1:00 p.m., after the church service
  • Tuesday, October 20, 7:00 p.m. on Zoom; invitation to follow.


To the 271 people who completed the survey, and to the nearly 40 people who attended our first listening session on Sunday, October 4: Thank you so much! Your honesty, care, and commitment have given us valuable clarity and momentum. Now we ask the wider All Souls community to take part so that our next steps—and our ministerial search—are informed by many more voices.



With profound gratitude, courage and hope for what comes next,

  • Julie Brannan, Committee Co-Chair
  • David Rockefeller, Committee Co-Chair
  • Shu-Wie Chen
  • Nancy Northup
  • Jennifer Vermont-Davis
  • Bryce Stack
  • Karen Steele
  • Victor Fidel