|
It is said that “a rising tide lifts all boats.” Our State Chamber policy positions, while never perfect, are based upon fairness, facts, and a belief that policy should benefit the greatest number of people and do the greatest good. With that in mind, we oppose House Bill 417, not because we have an issue with a very small subset of restaurants, but because that bill benefits some restaurants at the expense of other restaurants and thousands of other local small businesses across Delaware. We have developed a comprehensive Gross Receipts Tax reform proposal. However, we have kept it “on the shelf,” which is consistent with House leadership's remarks at our End-of-Session Policy Conference that tax reform is best addressed through a comprehensive review of the tax code rather than through piecemeal changes.
There are over 60,000 registered small businesses operating in Delaware, and according to the State of Delaware, 2,286 of those are licensed restaurants. Of those licensed restaurants, 695 paid their Gross Receipts Tax last year. If enacted into law, HB 417 would completely exempt approximately half of those restaurants from their Gross Receipts Tax obligations, and we think that’s patently unfair. It’s unfair to competitor restaurants that still must pay taxes, and to small business retailers that oftentimes share locations next to restaurants, or manufacturers, or contractors; the list goes on and on.
What we support is comprehensive Gross Receipts Tax reform because all small businesses are struggling with wage and product input inflation, insurance expenses, rent, and more.
Fairness matters. Equity matters. Why would the General Assembly single out 350 restaurants for a tax giveaway without considering the impacts that would have on other competitor restaurants or other small businesses? If enacted, is it possible that the 350 restaurants that no longer pay Gross Receipts Taxes will become financially healthier and stronger, while competitor restaurants struggle or fail because they must still pay thousands of dollars in taxes?
|