{View as Webpage}

White Banner with black and bright green text "TA Spotlight: Highlights from the ICADV TA Team." Series of colorful icon squares on the left side featuring various symbols, including the Illinois Coalition Against Domestic Violence logo.

This is a continuation of ICADV’s technical assistance communications spotlighting information that helps to inform domestic violence services providers how they can maximize the resources available to them.


TOPIC: Civil v. Criminal Orders of Protection

TIMELINE: 1 Week

White banner with a black information icon and text 'HERE'S THE SCOOP' on a bright green background.

Civil v. Criminal

Orders of Protection

 
 

What is a(n) (Civil) Order of Protection (OP)?

 
 
A camera scans over documents on a clipboard that read "Order of Protection", a law book, and a gavel that then pounds to signal adjournment.

A civil order of protection is a document that a survivor can file on their own behalf that sets limits on the behavior of the person causing harm and provides consequences if the OP is violated. No criminal charge is necessary to file an OP in civil court. An OP can be filed in the petitioner’s county of residence, the respondent’s county of residence, the county where the abuse took place, or the county where the petitioner is temporarily located if they left their home to avoid further abuse.

A note on language: a petitioner is the person who is filing for the OP; the respondent is the person who the OP is against.

 

What are the three types of (Civil) OPs that apply to domestic violence?

 
 

Emergency Order of Protection (EOP)

➤ Three potential outcomes:

  • Judge dismisses the petition.
  • EOP is NOT granted but the judge issues a summons to talk to both parties and determine if they'll set a hearing date or not.
  • Judge grants the EOP.

➤ Lasts for 14 to 21 days and provides a temporary OP until a hearing occurs.

 

Interim Order of Protection

➤ This occurs if the respondent hasn't been served with the OP.

➤ Lasts for up to 30 days and is an extension of the EOP.

 

Plenary Order of Protection

➤ Once the respondent is served with the OP, a hearing occurs.

  • After being served, if the respondent does not come to court, the petitioner can be granted the OP by default.
  • If the respondent is present, then a hearing occur where both parties provide testimony and present evidence.
  • The burden of proof is on the petitioner.

➤ Lasts up to two years but can be renewed indefinitely.

 

What is a Criminal Order of Protection?

 
 

A criminal order of protection is slightly different from a civil order of protection, but the two can co-exist and how that happens depends on the jurisdiction. 

It can be filed by a few different people:

Icon of a person with the scales of justice
 

The prosecution/State's Attorney's Office

Icon of a person and a cause/support ribbon
 

The survivor

Icon of two people and the scales of justice
 

The survivor and their private attorney

Icon of two people reaching out a hand to one another and a cause/support ribbon

The survivor and an advocate (systems advocate or community advocate)

This OP is filed with criminal charges though every jurisdiction is different in how they approach that process. Because the OP is attached to the criminal case, it typically only lasts the duration of the case; however, it does make it easier to serve the OP to the person causing harm. If there is already an OP in civil court, the OPs must be similar enough for them to co-exist, i.e. the inciting incident and the date of that incident should align between the civil and criminal OPs. If necessary, the survivor can dismiss the civil OP or petition to amend it. A benefit of a criminal OP that is introduced by the State’s Attorney’s Office is that the survivor may not have to testify like they would for a civil OP.

 

What are remedies?

 
 

Remedies are specific requests that petitioners can include in the OP that will dictate the respondent’s behavior. There are police enforced remedies and court enforced remedies:

Police enforced remedies include but are not limited to:

 
Stack of documents icon with a circle overlapping in the bottom right corner. In the circle is a police badge.

Police enforced remedies include but are not limited to:


#1 No abuse which means the respondent cannot harass, intimidate, abuse, neglect, or exploit the petitioner in any way.


#2 Possession of the residence


#3 Stay away from certain places


#5 Care and possession of children


#8 Concealment of children


#14 No entry into the residence while under the influence


#14.5 Firearms

 
 
 
Stack of documents icon with a circle overlapping in the bottom right corner. In the circle is a gavel.

Court enforced remedies include but are not limited to:


#4 Counseling (for the respondent)


#5 Care and possession of children


#6 Temporary decision-making


#7 Respondent's parenting time


#9 Order to appear


#10 Possession of personal property


#11.5 Possession of animals

 
 
White paper with black handwritten words that appear one letter at a time, reading "Note to Advocates." Paper is paperclipped on top of a light grey piece of paper, with a bright green tab with a heart in the top right corner.

Court/legal advocacy is a foundational service in the domestic violence world, and we have pushed and fought to see progress in our courts when survivors need help from the legal system. OPs are a vital tool for holding people who cause harm accountable and keeping survivors and their children safe. While OPs are typically granted in civil court, there will be times that an OP is possible in criminal court which can be a very different experience. That being said, you are still an advocate, so you still have a role with that survivor. Wendy Vaughn, Clinical Professor & Director of Clinics at Northern Illinois University College of Law and Zeke Giorgi Legal Clinic, said it perfectly when she and I spoke recently: 

“Advocates are support people so go back to the basics: sit in the courtroom with the survivor, remind them what to bring to court, act as a liaison with the State’s Attorney’s Office to determine meeting dates, etc.”.

Not all of these actions may be possible in your jurisdiction, but do what you always do: work with the survivor to find out what they need and continue to push the legal system to become more trauma-informed and respond effectively to the needs of survivors in your community. 

-- Samantha Dickens (she/her), Director of Technical Assistance

 
Light grey rectangle with bold black text that reads "Tech Safety." A black icon of a gear with a padlock in the center is to the left of the text.
A laptop showing a courthouse, a gavel, and the scales of justice

Remote proceedings/virtual court are available in some counties and may prove helpful in some key ways:


➤ Creates access for petitioners who cannot get to a physical court location easily.


➤ Increases safety since petitioner and respondent won’t be in the same physical location.


➤ Reduces risk of triggers since petitioner and respondent won’t have direct physical contact.

Some of the cons of remote proceedings may be:


➤ Difficulties with or lack of necessary technology.


➤ Lack of an advocate presence or challenges for an advocate to provide emotional support.


➤ Confidentiality and privacy concerns.


Advocates have become skilled in remote proceedings due to the COVID-19 pandemic. If you’re interested in crowdsourcing more information about remote proceedings from other advocates, post your questions in the ICADV Court Advocate Listserv.


In Illinois, all court documents are supposed to be electronically filed (e-filed); however, there is an exemption form. Because domestic violence situations are both urgent and time sensitive, they often qualify for this exemption so that paperwork can be submitted in the most accessible way for petitioner.

➤ What is an Order of Protection? – Brochure


➤ Advocacy 101 Training Series – Introduction to Legal Advocacy for Non-Legal Advocates

White banner with three black gear icons and text 'RESOURCES' on a bright green background.
Link to information "What are criminal protective orders?" on the Illinois Legal Aid Online website
Link to page "3 types of Orders of Protection" on the Illinois Legal Aid Online website
Link to information "Filing Protection Orders" on the Illinois Attorney General website
Link to page "Approved Statewide Forms - Order of Protection" on the Illinois Courts website
Link to document "A Guide to Illinois Protective Orders" on the Illinois Coalition Against Sexual Assault website
Link to information "Illinois Restraining Orders" on womenslaw.org
Link to information "Exemption from E-Filing" on the Illinois Courts website
Link to page "Remote Proceedings Directory & Resources" on the Illinois Courts website

Services Guidelines Manual, Section 2, Chapter 7, Adult Services, Counseling and Advocacy, pages 83

White banner with a black calendar icon and text 'UPCOMING SPOTLIGHTS' on a bright green background.

➤ AI Series: The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly


➤ Immigration Resources Update


➤ Housing After Shelter

White banner with a black checkmark icon and text 'WRAP UP' on a bright green background.

☑ Orders of Protection are a critical tool in creating safety for survivors, but they can be complex with many moving parts.


☑ Keep in mind:

  • Civil OPs can be filed by the survivor without criminal charges.
  • Criminal OPs are attached to criminal charges and can be brought by the State’s Attorney’s Office.
  • Remedies are specific options that can be requested during an OP.
  • Remote proceedings come with benefits and deficits to help petitioners consider carefully and prepare for thoughtfully.
  • Petitioners can file an exemption to e-filing if that works better for them!

Did you enjoy this Spotlight? Have any questions or concerns? Have topics you'd like to see in future Spotlights? We would love to hear from you! Please take this brief survey to tell us about your experience: 

Complete the Survey HERE

This project was supported in part or in whole by a grant provided by the Illinois Department of Human Services (IDHS). Points of view or opinions contained within this document are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the official position or policies of IDHS.

 
 
Facebook  Instagram  LinkedIn  X  Web

Wait! Don't unsubscribe yet!

ICADV values timely and consistent communication with members. We ask that you carefully consider before unsubscribing to ICADV emails. Unsubscribing from a certain campaign might result in you not receiving important information and notifications that are sent using that same group in the future. If you have questions or wish to unsubscribe from a particular type of email campaign, please contact Christina.