Seeing Red?
You open an account statement, and it shows numbers in red. Before you’ve read a single line, your stomach tightens and your anxiety rises. That reaction isn’t a coincidence. Research shows that we react reflexively to the color red.
There’s a reason red evokes a strong response. We learn at an early age that red means stop or danger. It’s the color of stop signs, fire engines, and flashing police lights. Teachers use red pens to mark errors. Red is associated with danger, fear, and anger.
In stock markets around the world, red is used to indicate the direction of the market. In the United States, red means share prices are falling. In China, it’s the opposite. Red means stocks are rising. The color that means “down” in New York means “up” in Shanghai. That’s important because it shows that our response to red is learned. A color actually tells you nothing about your investments, but our brains react to it anyway.
In 2020, a group of researchers investigated how colors affect money decisions. They conducted eight experiments with more than 1,400 participants and found that showing information in red changed people’s reactions and expectations.
-
Participants took less risk. Participants were asked to choose between high- and low-risk financial options. When potential financial losses were shown in red, they were about 20 percent less likely to pick the riskier option than when the possible losses were shown in black.
-
Participants were less optimistic. Participants were shown stocks that had lost value over a 12-month period and asked what might happen next. When the losses were shown in red, they tended to expect prices to keep falling. When losses were shown in black or blue, many expected prices to recover. The data was the same, but the color changed the forecast.
We often take color for granted when reviewing financial information, and we shouldn’t. Our subconscious response to color has the potential to affect our decision-making. One strategy is to ignore color and review the numbers, along with the time frame. A brief negative return in a 10-year upward trend is still a 10-year upward trend. It works the other way, too.
Any time you have questions or concerns, please get in touch. We’re happy to review the numbers – no matter what color they are – and offer some perspective
|