|
A Consistent Life Ethic Values the Dignity and Value of All Human Life
Caroline Bennett, FCLNY Policy Analyst
"There is a philosophy that holds human life to be inherently valuable. Not conditional on age, nationality or what a court has decided – but simply because a human being exists.
It is called the consistent life ethic, and it demands that human life has inherent value at every stage, in every nation, under any circumstance, regardless of whether defending it is politically convenient. It is the most honest position available in our current moral landscape and the most demanding because it challenges everyone and flatters no one.
Consider what consistency would actually require. It would demand opposition to the bombing of civilian populations in Gaza and Iran − conflicts in which children account for a devastating share of the dead. It would demand opposition to capital punishment, which has claimed innocent lives and is applied with documented racial and economic disparities and geographic arbitrariness. It would demand serious scrutiny of euthanasia's expansion, with the quiet pressure it places on our elderly, disabled and poor to view their lives as burdens.
And it would demand that abortion be part of the conversation as well. The unborn are yet another marginalized group that society has dehumanized, because subsidizing abortion is politically expedient. Meanwhile, the real issues plaguing women facing unintended pregnancy
− affordable childcare and housing, paid parental leave, robust non-discrimination laws against pregnant women and mothers in the workforce − are swept under the rug.
The right says it's pro-life, then cuts social safety net programs that support vulnerable mothers and children. The left claims to empower marginalized communities, yet blocks even modest restrictions on abortion past 20 weeks, even with exceptions for rape, incest, and the mother’s health, failing to keep pace with medical advancements in fetal viability.
The consistent life ethic does not ask you to abandon your values. It calls you to notice that the logic you use to defend one vulnerable life applies to others too.
This is not a moderate position. It is a radical one − in the oldest sense of the word. It goes to the root. And the root is simple: every human life has worth. Every single one. Without exception."
|