Volume 18, Issue 2

April 2025

Adding verses Combining Disability:

Additional Discovery Needed 


By Darren Van Doren, Esq.


Recently, a few cases have been remanded back to the trial level for development of the record on questions related to rebuttal of the Combined Values Chart (CVC) in the context of Kite and/or Vigil. It should be noted that Vigil was decided on June 10, 2024.


December 6, 2024

In Avakian v. City of Baldwin Park, 2024 Cal. Wrk. Comp. P.D. LEXIS 452, there were multiple medical-legal specialists. Some of the physicians opined it was more accurate to add impairments based on synergism. One physician expressed opinions regarding synergism, but did not expressly endorse the additive method. Based on the overall record, the trial judge found applicant was permanently and totally disabled. There was also vocational rehabilitation expert opinion that applicant was not feasible for a return to the open labor market. Defendant filed for reconsideration and the case was remanded back to the trial level for further development of the record. Further inquiries on remand included, but were not limited to, the existence/non-existence of overlap. The en banc Vigil decision had been decided after the court granted reconsideration, and the court observed that the physicians had focused on overlapping body parts rather than activities of daily living (ADLs).  This case was “analytically incomplete” and further discovery was necessary.



Continue Reading...

Labor Code §4850 Benefits:

Is Applicant Entitled to Separate Benefits Despite the Existence of Overlapping Periods of Temporary Disability?


By Lisa Madden, Esq.


Pursuant to Labor Code §4850, first responders and public safety officers in California are entitled to up to 1 year (52 weeks) of their full salary when injured on the job and placed on temporary disability. If he/she is still disabled when the year is up, he/she can continue to receive up to an additional 1 year (52 weeks of temporary disability benefits.  

The Agaiby v. City of Culver City, 2024 Cal. Wrk. Comp. P.D. LEXIS 382 (Appeals Board noteworthy panel decision), the issue of whether applicant, who sustained two separate and distinct injuries, was entitled to separate full-year benefits pursuant to Labor Code §4850 for each injury, despite overlapping periods of temporary disability.  


Officer Agaiby sustained a specific injury on August 5, 2020, during an exercise workout in the course of his employment. Injury was alleged to the neck, back, bilateral shoulders and bilateral knees. He was temporarily disabled for a couple of weeks and then returned to modified duties performing desk work. He was taken off work on February 9, 2021; applicant did not return to work. He underwent surgery on his left shoulder on November 11, 2021. The PQME deemed him maximally medically improved for this injury on February 7, 2023.  


Officer Agaiby filed a second claim for a cumulative trauma for the period May 1, 1994, to February 8, 2021, for bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome. The AME concluded that the bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome was not due to the specific injury on August 5, 2020, but the result of the cumulative trauma through February 8, 2021, and applicant was temporarily totally disabled beginning February 9, 2021. Applicant was deemed maximally medically improved on February 16, 2023.  




Continue Reading...

Issues with Limited PQME Specialties


By Karanveer Bains, Esq.


It is no secret that a Worker’s Compensation Judge has the discretion to appoint a physician as the medical evaluator in a case. In a recent board panel majority decision, the majority recently upheld a trial judge’s use of discretion under LC 5701, to appoint a “regular physician” as the new medical evaluator should the parties fail to agree to an AME. 


In the recent panel decision of Hadley v. East Bay Municipal Util. Dist., ADJ10222062;ADJ8022488 (OAK), Jan. 27, 2025, Decision After Reconsideration, the majority upheld the ruling from the trial judge that Dr. Scott T Andersen was to replace their QME at the time Dr. Michael Bronshvag, lest they reach an AME agreement. 


For context, the parties had previously used an internal QME who passed away leading them request a new panel and getting Dr. Bronshvag as the internal evaluator. Over the course of 9 reports and a deposition in 3 years Dr. Bronshvag ultimately came to the conclusion that an additional QME was needed to provide an opinion on applicant’s bladder issues and recommended using a genitourinary specialist. 


Once the medical unit failed to produce a panel, Applicant’s Attorney then proceeded to petition to replace Dr. Bronshvag with a new evaluator. Defendant’s, obviously, argued that after almost 10 years of litigation of the claim, already being on their second internal QME, and now needing a specialist opinion, a new internal QME to replace Dr. Bronshvag would only cause undue delay in resolving this case. Defendant proposed that an additional be produced in toxicology or occupational medicine per Dr. Bronshvag’s recommendation. 



Continue Reading....

Fresno

7112 N Fresno St Ste 300

Fresno CA 93720

Ph: (559) 449-2558

Fax: (559) 449-2564


Bakersfield

1800 30th Street, Suite 320

Bakersfield CA 93301

Ph: (661) 328-2200

Fax : (661) 328-0022

Facebook  Instagram  Web