|
“As discussed, ‘recruit’ plainly means to induce, enlist or persuade, someone to join a group or to participate in some undertaking. In the abortion context, recruiting means ‘providing information,’ ‘especially information trying to persuade a girl to have an abortion or regarding the provider, time, place or cost of an available abortion’; ‘subsidizing or fully funding an abortion – whether through donations or discounted services – by making the abortion more attractive (persuading) or more feasible (inducing)’; financial support and logistical assistance’; legal advice that ‘persuades a minor to obtain a legal abortion’; and expressions of persuasive encouragement’ all ‘might be prosecuted’ under this statute…And each of these applications involves protected speech.’
Judge Julia Gibbons (from the decision)
Late last week, U.S. Circuit Judge Julia S. Gibbons ruled to permanently enjoin Tennessee’s Underage Abortion Trafficking Law. Judge Gibbons was appointed to federal court by President Reagan and named to the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals by President George W. Bush.
The law which was passed in 2024 made it a crime to recruit, harbor or transport a minor girl or obtain abortion drugs for her without her parent’s consent. Throughout the legislative process, it was stated several times that this was a parental rights bill. Parents have the right to know what is happening with their children and no adult should be able to keep them in the dark about dangerous drugs or invasive surgeries.
It makes perfect sense.
Soon after the legislation was signed into law, Democratic State Representative Aftyn Behn and Nashville Attorney Rachel Welty, both radical abortion activists, brought suit against the enforcement of the law. Within months, enforcement was temporarily blocked and on Friday of last week, Judge Gibbons made that injunction permanent.
The challenge was based on freedom of speech concerns dealing with the term “recruit”. Behn and Welty both admitted that they actively advocate for abortion and that they don’t check the age of those inquiring about how to abort children but that they regularly give information about out-of-state abortions. They claimed that once the decision is made to abort, they help pregnant girls with details about the abortion, whether it be traveling to another state or ordering drugs over the internet. They brought the suit because they were scared that their actions would be considered “recruiting”, and they could face up to 11 months and 29 days in prison.
The attorney for the two told the court that the term “recruit” was too vague and that it chilled the free speech of his clients. The judge ruled that the definition of the term was not the problem with the law; it was clear enough. The problem was with the law itself; it was “unconstitutionally overbroad.”
What is striking is that in the entire 32-page ruling, the judge hardly ever refers to the intent of the bill, which was to ensure that parents are involved in the care of their children, and that those who recruit, harbor or transport them without their consent should be held accountable.
The law was passed to protect underage girls and their parents. The judge claims to protect free speech. She has decided that it is well within the rights of abortion activists, perpetrators, and other adults to recruit underage girls even if it leaves them at risk of those who could harm them and leaves their parents completely in the dark.
How can this make sense? We need to pray.
This week, please pray and fast for those who will be defending this legislation as it works its way through the appeals process. Also, let’s pray for supernatural protection for Tennessee’s pregnant minors who have been left unprotected by the law. May the Holy Spirit surround them with Heavenly advocates.
Thank you for praying and fasting for an end to abortion.
For Life,
Stacy Dunn, President
TN Right to Life
|