How Do School Committee Candidates View Education Issues?

Medfield Insider reached out to the three School Committee candidates on the ballot to ask 7 education-specific questions. These questions came from a variety of resources, including National School Board Association, the non-profit GreatSchools, and the candidate’s own information sessions.

Using alphabetical order by last name for each person, below are candidate answers to the questions. Each candidate viewed this article in advance and has attested in writing that it matches what was provided to Medfield Insider (with exceptions made for a small number of capitalization, punctuation and formatting changes).

Note: Even though Robert Worth's name appears on the ballot, he publicly announced in the Patch and Hometown Weekly that he was withdrawing from the race. Also, any write-in candidates who surfaced less than a week before the election did not allow for enough time to coordinate their participation in this Q&A.

According to Massachusetts law, school committee powers are essentially limited to selecting, evaluating and terminating the superintendent; reviewing and approving school district budgets; and establishing educational goals and policies for the district. Some exceptions for other areas apply. Details are available here.

1. What three actions would you take to improve student outcomes (as defined by you)?

FLAVIA BENSON:

  • Giving students the opportunity to get extra help, support, and tutoring in needed subjects,
  • Support for executive functioning needs, and
  • Providing teachers with professional development opportunities that specifically address the needs of the student body.

TIM KNIGHT:

  • Increased academic/emotional support systems & resources to address behavioral and emotional issues so students/staff are better equipped to manage stressors/distractors, and have the best possible environment for academic achievement.  

  • Ongoing work to strengthen community & engagement at the school, grade, and class level focused on increased interaction & meaningful student-centered discussions between parent, teacher/school administration, and students.

  • Examination of culture that is driving us to sign our kids up for so many events/clubs/teams and driving performance-related anxiety for our kids.

LAUREN LILJEGREN:

  • Create a publicly available district-wide scorecard. We can’t improve what we don’t measure.

  • Update our superintendent's goals to reflect the same objective data points we use to measure district success. Superintendent performance rating and contract should be based on success in improving these metrics.

  • Measure the success of initiatives against stated goals. Where initiatives are not successful, funding should be reallocated.

2. What data should you and other SC members use/rely on to measure district performance?

FLAVIA BENSON: MCAS, school attendance, student retention, advanced class placements, and college acceptance, to name a few.

TIM KNIGHT: We currently measure performance through executive summaries and research of various data sources. These include assessment data, (DIBELS/BAS/Renaissance), Metro-West Adolescent Health Survey results, MCAS results, benchmarks, community/parent/student/teacher survey results, enrollment data, financials, publicly available IEP/504 compliance-related information, RISE cases/referrals/hospitalization/trends, etc. Having the key metrics consolidated and made more accessible over time is an excellent opportunity for efficiencies and betterment.

LAUREN LILJEGREN: We should use objective, measurable indicators to determine performance such as graduation rate, MCAS scores, and district and school rate of attrition. In addition, a simple and consistent parent satisfaction survey should be added. Disciplined year-over-year tracking should be implemented.

3. Would you support a MCAS moratorium if School Committee was asked, and why/why not?

FLAVIA BENSON: No, I would not. In the first years of implementing the MCAS in our state, SAT scores rose, MA students became competitive with their international peers, where previously American students lagged, and, most importantly, studies demonstrated a correlation between equity and academic proficiency.

TIM KNIGHT: I would support a moratorium if we had an alternative system in place to monitor academic performance, measure progress, and determine areas of need. There are pros/cons to these systems that would have to be thought through before justifying any decision.

LAUREN LILJEGREN: Under normal circumstances, I do not support moratoriums on testing. MCAS are a consistent measure of school performance across our state, and annual data is needed to ensure districts are held accountable.

4. How would you improve the district's Special Education services?

FLAVIA BENSON: We need to give teachers the tools to be able to follow what is needed for IEP programs. We need additional staffing for teachers, qualified paraprofessionals, proper technology for kids that may not be currently utilized, and we need to evaluate the cost effectiveness of having specialists in our district versus outplacing students. Most importantly, special ed teachers need to have appropriate professional development opportunities to learn new things and share experiences so that they can address specific needs of specific kids in our specific district.

TIM KNIGHT:

• Drive increased accountability by identifying a member of the School Committee to interface with our Director of Special Services, Superintendent, and community to better understand needs, priorities, and progress. This would also include dedicated time to communicate progress as part of our agendas and gather inputs.

• Increase teacher capacity through ongoing professional development that is more programmatically focused on strategic needs.

• Continue to coordinate across all buildings/schools so that there is increased consistency in our support systems to ease the transition for all families.

LAUREN LILJEGREN:

The committee should vote to create a Special Education Subcommittee to provide recommendations to improve parent satisfaction and MCAS scores, and reduce out-of-district placements and attrition for children with disabilities.

5. Do you support bus fees, and why/why not?

FLAVIA BENSON: This really depends on several factors regarding the district, its needs, and whether it’s facing a budget deficit. I would prefer to see the district address fiscal responsibility and reigning in spending without cutting needed programs before approaching the topic of imposing a bus fee. Understanding that transportation also has an environmental impact, investments in walking and biking infrastructures should also be considered as part of that larger conversation for “alternative”, healthier, and environmentally friendlier ways to get to school.

TIM KNIGHT: Bussing fees are worth exploring due to the high cost of the annual bussing contract and desire to reduce emissions. Care must be taken to ensure that we do not negatively impact emissions by increasing the number of cars that are dropping off students, or introduce an accessibility issue that makes it difficult for families with financial constraints to absorb the cost.

LAUREN LILJEGREN: Yes. Bus fees, with generous need-based exceptions, are consistent with neighboring communities and will free-up funding for other initiatives.

6. What concrete steps would you take to increase community engagement in Medfield Public Schools?

FLAVIA BENSON: One of the reasons I decided to run for School Committee was because I felt I wasn’t heard, in fact, I felt shut out. I don’t want our community to feel that they don’t have a voice. Engagement requires that we be open, transparent, and emotionally engaged with the audience, particularly in meetings. We need to also have open conversations regarding community needs, and not just assume we know what the community is thinking. Surveys, questionnaires, public dialogue are all way to gain better perspective and engaging the community at large.

TIM KNIGHT:

  • Identify an individual responsible for all communications across the schools, with community engagement being an area of priority. Initially, this would be an added responsibility for an existing employee, however, I would like to explore how this can be self-funded in order to support a full-time resource.

  • Define a strategy for “community engagement” including goals of the program and assessment of channels currently in place (PTO, Site Council, Principal Coffee, PIN, Social, Email, Web Sites, etc.). Once we clarify the strategy, we can then measure, prioritize, and improve in the areas that have the greatest impact.

  • Near-term focus on local schools as there is less complexity and typically a stronger engagement model in place. By building at the local level, we can better understand how to extend to the entire district and community. 

LAUREN LILJEGREN: Community engagement in Medfield is high, though the interests and recommendations of our community are often ignored when decisions are made. For example, the DEI Task Force should be an official subcommittee, and we need increased school committee oversight of site councils.

7. What specific professional development topic(s) do you believe could help you maximize your contributions as a school committee member?

FLAVIA BENSON: I believe some key workshops offered by MASC on district governance would help maximize my contributions as a member and in aligning with the district. For example:

1. "Installing the Infrastructure" - which covers aligning SMART (Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant, Time-bound) goals in the superintendent evaluation to district goals and demonstrates the use of data to monitor progress;

2. "Setting the Walls" - making sure time is spent effectively and focuses on student achievement and the district’s goals, and learning about specific tools that can be adopted to ensure smooth and effective meetings focused on student progress, and

3. "Laying the Roof" - which provides committees with the tools to sustain effective governance practices into the future, through changes on the governance team, and to ensure continued focus on improvement in student achievement.

Lastly, I would like to establish a special education subcommittee to determine the needs in our district and take advantage of the MASC Special Education Committee in addressing those issues.

TIM KNIGHT:

  • Role of School Committee with focus on typical challenges, operating model, and lessons learned. MASC has an introductory course that we all take, however, I think if I were to join as a new member, I would like to see this as Basic, Intermediate, and Advanced over my 3-year term, with a focus on operating efficiently, adapting to the “next generation of parents, and delivering results. 

  • Best practices for community engagement & communication across the town.

  • Ongoing education focused on compliance, governance, special education, emerging trends, and resources available for us.  

LAUREN LILJEGREN:

Professional Development around goal setting (SMART goals), performance evaluations, moderation of community forums, and budgeting, would benefit current and future members of our School Committee.