Warranty and Customer Pay Revenue News from Armatus...SEPTEMBER 2026 ISSUE

 

Your Warranty Rate Was Approved…Don’t Wait 12 Months to Address Your Effective Labor Rate


by Jordan Jankowski, Armatus COO

Getting a warranty labor rate increase approved feels like a win. The manufacturer signed off, the new rate is loaded into the DMS, and the service department is now billing warranty repair orders at a higher number than it was a month ago. For most dealers, that’s where the project ends – filed away until the next eligibility window opens – twelve months out, the next calendar year, or whatever cadence the applicable state statute sets. Some may even stop at service and never look into parts.


That’s also where the money starts leaking back out.


You’ve Been Approved, So, What’s Next?

The approved warranty rate is what the manufacturer agreed to pay per hour for warranty work, based on either a factory submission or a statutory filing under state law. The effective labor rate (ELR) is what the dealership actually collects, calculated by dividing total labor sales by total hours sold across a given category of work.


The bigger opportunity is what happens next. Approval doesn’t just reset the rate – it resets the clock. The next eligibility window, whether that’s twelve months out, the next calendar year, or a shorter interval set by the applicable state statute, is now on the calendar, and the best use of the time between now and then is improving ELR, not just generically raising the customer-pay rate and assuming the warranty rate will follow. A statutory submission is built from the actual repair order data in specific categories of work, not from your door rate, so a generic customer pay increase is not, on its own, a strategy for an approval next time. What moves the number that matters is the ELR on the repair categories the submission actually draws from, which is exactly where leakage does its damage. Manufacturers...



Read the complete story on the Armatus website

 

The New Service Retention Paradox: Record Revenue, Shrinking Market Share


by Sean Reyes, Armatus Chief Marketing Officer

Dealership fixed operations has never been more profitable on paper. Customer-pay labor rates continue to climb, vehicle technology has increased repair complexity, and the average repair order has reached historic highs on inflationary pricing and longer repair times. Industry reports continue to show record service and parts revenue across franchised dealerships, creating the impression that fixed operations has never been healthier.


Yet beneath these impressive financial results lies a troubling contradiction. While revenue is increasing, dealerships continue losing service customers to independent repair facilities at an alarming rate. Every year, millions of vehicle owners who purchased their vehicles from franchised dealers gradually migrate to aftermarket providers for maintenance and repair. The result is a growing disconnect between profitability and market share. Welcome to the new service retention paradox.


For dealership executives, this paradox represents one of the greatest strategic challenges facing fixed operations today – whether dealerships can retain enough customers to sustain long-term growth in an increasingly competitive service marketplace.

The growing gap between higher revenue and declining customer retention has significant implications beyond the service department. Customers who regularly service their vehicles at the selling dealership are substantially more likely to purchase their next vehicle from that same dealer. Every service customer lost today represents risk to immediate service revenue and future vehicle sales...



Read the complete story on the Armatus website

 

Who doesn't like a discount? In the current consumer climate, price is a significant consideration for vehicle owners requiring service or maintenance. However, in the attempt to overcome a service decline, the overuse of discounting has significantly damaged what the store hopes to realize in a retail warranty reimbursement.



Every discounted repair order can become evidence that your advertised retail rate isn't the rate you actually charge.



If a dealership routinely advertises a $200 labor rate but frequently reduces that rate through coupons, goodwill adjustments, manager discounts or other pricing concessions, the OEM can question whether $200 truly represents the dealer's customary retail pricing.


The repair orders being used to establish the dealer's retail rate become financial evidence. The cleaner and more consistent those transactions are, the easier it is to demonstrate that the requested warranty rate accurately reflects the dealership's normal retail pricing.


And there's an important distinction: the approved warranty reimbursement rate is not necessarily the dealer's door rate. It is a rate established through the applicable state/OEM process using qualifying retail transactions and statutory rules. The objective is to establish a defensible, documented retail rate - not simply to hand the OEM the dealership's posted labor rate.


This is an important distinction for staff that the fixed operations leader needs to clearly communicate, then manage. Yes - customers are important. Yes - price matters. But there are other ways to support the customer base beyond discounting. And, when discounting cannot be avoided, it should be authorized only by a service department manager.


Easily view all RO activity where discounting was applied with the Fixed Ops Performance Center (FOPC), a data insights and coaching platform. Learn more about FOPC here.

 
 
 

Travel and Events


9/20 - 23/2026: CNCDA (CA) Annual Convention at the Fairmont Kea Lani Hotel in Maui HI - Sponsor

9/21-22/2026: NMADA (NM) Annual Convention at the Sandia Resort & Casino in Albuquerque, NM - Sponsor and Presenter


9/23-26/2026: Western ATAE Annual Conference at the Fairmont Kea Lani Hotel in Maui - Sponsor


9/24/26: NNCTDA Fall Blast at the Oak Creek Sporting Club in Brainard, NE - Goody Cart Sponsor


9/28-10/1/2026: Southern ATAE Annual Conference at the Nemacolin Resort in Farmington, PA - Sponsor and Presenter

 
 

Armatus Dealer Uplift

50 Schilling Road, Suite 200

Hunt Valley, MD 21031


www.dealeruplift.com

Not a Subscriber to this Newsletter? Add yourself to the list.


Give Us a Follow on Social!

LinkedIn