Dear friends, 

Early in my surgical career, I was asked to give a second opinion about the treatment of a 40-year-old woman with advanced rectal cancer. She was an elementary school teacher and the mother of two young teenage daughters.


She had already been assessed by a highly respected surgeon in another Canadian city, who believed the cancer was too large to remove and recommended palliative radiation and chemotherapy. My assessment was much the same. The chances of removing the tumour completely were close to zero. The risk of her dying during such a complicated operation was high, as was the likelihood of extensive rehabilitation.


Then she told me what she hoped for. She wanted to live to see her daughters get married.

Throughout my career, I encountered decisions for which every option carried risk. My responsibility was to weigh those risks carefully, explain them honestly and understand what mattered most to the person whose life was in my hands. Sometimes, that meant having the courage to attempt something with an uncertain outcome.


My work at Federation has brought that lesson into a different part of my life.


The generosity of Ottawa’s Jewish community is exceptional. Our volunteers and staff are equally committed to explaining the needs, reaching out to donors and thanking them for making our work possible. Among our greatest challenges is deciding how best to respond when those needs exceed the resources available.


We raise approximately $5 million each year, while we continue to see the needs grow. Those needs span a lifetime, from Jewish education for our children to care and connection for our seniors, and everything in between.


Each of us brings experiences that create a particular passion for one cause or another. Those commitments have helped build the institutions on which our community depends. Today, rising antisemitism and growing demands on our services ask us to look beyond our individual priorities and consider what will best strengthen the whole community.


That may require us to rethink familiar ways of working.

For example, several of our agencies need social workers and psychological support for the people they serve. Could we plan for those needs together? Could shared expertise help more people receive care? Could a coordinated approach to government grants bring additional professionals into our community?


These are questions worth exploring with our partners. Doing so takes trust, a willingness to reconsider established arrangements and the courage to try something new. Federation has begun these conversations because the risks of change must be weighed alongside the risks of leaving growing needs unmet.


As we confront antisemitism, we also need the courage to reach beyond familiar circles. It can feel uncomfortable to approach someone whose experience differs from our own, ask for their support or begin a conversation without knowing how they will respond. Those conversations can also be the beginning of meaningful relationships.


Early in 2027, Federation will host a town hall centred on The Power of One, a campaign to combat antisemitism, bringing together community members, partner organizations, non-Jewish allies and civic leaders. We will share our work and explore how each of us can help build a stronger, more connected response to antisemitism.


I hope you will join us and invite two non-Jewish friends. Each invitation is an opportunity to deepen understanding and ask someone to stand with us.


We cannot know where every conversation will lead. We can choose to begin one, to reconsider an old approach or to place our trust in a new partnership.


Let us have the courage to take those steps together, for the good of our community and the city we share.


I think again of my young patient.


We agreed to proceed with surgery. After a lengthy and difficult operation, I had removed most of the tumour but could not remove all of it. Telling her and her family that the remaining cancer would likely take her life was one of the most difficult conversations of my career.

Yet her story did not end as we expected.


She sent me a Christmas card every year for more than 25 years.


I have never forgotten her. She taught me something about hope, about listening, and about the possibilities that can emerge when people make a difficult decision together.

Shabbat Shalom, 

Hartley Stern signature 2017

Hartley