|
A great editorial by Mary Outley, Pat Shipe, and Barbara Sykes
The October 29 editorial in the Akron Beacon Journal provides a thoughtful discussion of the role of public education and how the EdChoice voucher program is incompatible with public education.
Barbara Sykes, president of the Akron Public Schools Board of Education, Pat Shipe, president of the Akron Education Association and co-chair of the Ohio 8 Coalition, and Mary Outley, superintendent of Akron Public Schools authored the editorial. Each of them is in a strategic position to provide a thoughtful review of the negative impact of the state’s EdChoice voucher private school system—an uncommon school system.
GUEST
Ohio public schools' fight against vouchers still isn't over | Opinion
Mary Outley, Pat Shipe, Barbara Sykes
Guest opinion
Oct. 29, 2026, 6:02 a.m. ET
A recent Ohio appellate court declared the state's EdChoice voucher program unconstitutional.
More than 300 Ohio school districts, including Akron, participated in the legal challenge.
Ohio should be equally committed to ensuring that every neighborhood public school provides opportunities worthy of every child.
Public education represents one of the most important promises we make as a community: that every child, regardless of income, neighborhood, background or ability, deserves a quality education and the opportunity for a successful future. In Akron, that promise is deeply rooted in our history.
Today, Ohio faces consequential decisions about public education funding, accountability and its constitutional responsibility to provide a thorough and efficient system of public schools. The recent Ohio appellate court ruling declaring the state's EdChoice voucher program unconstitutional has brought these questions into sharper focus.
More than 300 Ohio school districts, including Akron, participated in the legal challenge. The ruling, which remains subject to further proceedings, raises a fundamental question: How does Ohio ensure that educational choice does not undermine its responsibility to maintain strong public schools accessible to every child?
As leaders representing Akron Public Schools, we bring different perspectives and responsibilities to our work. We do not always agree, but we stand united in one belief: Strong public schools are essential to strong communities, and every Akron child deserves the opportunity to succeed.
We respect a parents' right to make educational decisions they believe are best for their children. In fact, close to 90% of Ohio's K-12 students attend public schools. However, educational choice and public accountability should never be mutually exclusive.
Public schools and their school boards operate under extensive requirements involving financial transparency, academic accountability, public oversight, nondiscrimination and services for students with disabilities. With over a billion Ohio taxpayer dollars annually supporting non-public educational institutions, the public deserves assurances that those funds are spent responsibly and accompanied by appropriate accountability.
The discussion must also recognize a defining responsibility of public education: Our public schools educate students with diverse academic abilities, economic circumstances, disabilities and personal challenges. Unlike private schools, our responsibility is not limited to students who are easiest or least expensive to educate. That is not a weakness of public education. It is one of its greatest strengths.
Voucher supporters frequently frame their arguments around educational equity, social justice and equal opportunity. These are values we share. But genuine equity requires more than providing opportunities for wealthy families to attend private schools, particularly now that Ohio’s voucher program is available to families regardless of income. It requires ensuring that neighborhood public schools provide qualified educators, strong academic programs, safe learning environments, modern resources and specialized services.
Educational opportunity should not depend upon a family's finances, transportation options or ability to navigate competing educational systems. Rather than focusing exclusively on helping some students find opportunities elsewhere, Ohio should be equally committed to ensuring that every neighborhood public school provides opportunities worthy of every child. And that is the equity we should focus on. Achieving that goal requires the active involvement of our entire community.
Local and state decisions influence school funding, educational programs, accountability standards and resources available to students. Their consequences reach far beyond classrooms. They impact our neighborhoods. That is why civic engagement matters.
Community members should understand the issues, examine the records and priorities of those seeking public office, participate in public discussions and exercise their right to vote. Those entrusted with decisions about public education carry extraordinary responsibility. Their understanding of public schools, commitment to educational opportunity and approach to accountability deserve careful consideration.
Public education should transcend political parties and competing ideologies. Its future is shaped not only by elected officials, but also by citizens who participate in determining their communities' direction.
Supporting public education also means acknowledging our responsibilities. Akron Public Schools faces real challenges requiring transparency, responsible leadership, meaningful collaboration, and a willingness to listen to educators, families, and students. Our roles may lead us to different conclusions about addressing those challenges, but our commitment to students must remain stronger than our disagreements.
Ultimately, Ohio's educational system should not be measured by how many families can leave their public schools, but by the opportunities available to every child who depends upon them.
Akron's future and the future of its public schools are inseparable. We believe in our students, educators, families, and this community's extraordinary potential. Fulfilling that promise requires engaged citizens, accountable leadership, elected representatives who understand public education's essential role, and an unwavering commitment to every child's success.
As the November midterm elections approach, we encourage every eligible community member to become informed, understand where candidates stand on public education, and exercise their right to vote. Our schools are a shared responsibility, and the decisions we make today will help define the Akron we leave for generations to come. Our children deserve nothing less. And Akron's future depends upon it.
Barbara Sykes is president of the Akron Public Schools Board of Education. Pat Shipe is president of the Akron Education Association and co-chair of the Ohio 8 Coalition. Mary Outley is the superintendent of Akron Public Schools.
READ DOWNLOAD SHARE
The Coalition's latest book, Right Down the Drain: The Cost of Siphoning Billions in Ohio Public Funding into Private School Vouchers, is available to read, download and share for FREE at both of the website links below
Right Down the Drain - Vouchers Hurt Ohio
Right Down the Drain
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/OhioEandA
VOUCHERS HURT OHIO
vouchershurtohio.com
Like Vouchers Hurt Ohio on Facebook: Vouchers Hurt Ohio
|