LAWYERS' PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY RESULTS
|
|
Jack Slimm (Mount Laurel, NJ) obtained, on pretrial motions, an order of dismissal of a legal malpractice action involving $12 million in liquidated damages. This case arose out of two underlying Law Division actions, two bankruptcy matters, a Federal District Court action, an appeal to the Third Circuit, an underlying foreclosure and note action, and an appeal to the Appellate Division. Jack represented a well-known bankruptcy practitioner in connection with claims made by the plaintiff-borrower against the lending bank, the bank officers and counsel.
Josh Byrne (Philadelphia, PA) received the following results:
-
February 14, 2023 – The Superior Court affirmed an order of the trial court sustaining preliminary objections handled by Josh, who successfully argued that the wrongful use of civil proceedings [Dragonetti] claim, which arose out of an underlying wrongful use of civil proceedings claim, was barred as a matter of law by the applicable statute of limitations.
-
February 7, 2023 – Josh had preliminary objections sustained in a legal malpractice case on the basis that the plaintiff’s breach of contract claim was barred by the gist of the action doctrine and the statute of limitations had expired on any potential negligence claim.
-
January 30, 2023 –Josh achieved dismissal of a disciplinary complaint. In this matter, our client was the victim of a sophisticated scam which caused the client to send IOLTA funds belonging to another client out of the country.
-
January 25, 2023 – Josh achieved dismissal of a 99-paragraph disciplinary complaint which alleged lack of communications with clients over the course of a 12-year-long underlying matter. The response to the disciplinary complaint was over 100 single-spaced pages setting forth the details of the underlying matter and included more than 150 exhibits.
Aaron Moore (Philadelphia, PA) obtained a nonsuit at the beginning of trial in a legal malpractice case. In the underlying matter, our client represented a subcontractor in connection with its efforts to collect payments on a project. The contractor who hired the subcontractor was terminated from the project. The project owner orally promised payment to the subcontractor if it completed the work. The work was completed, and the subcontractor did not get paid. Thereafter, the subcontractor retained our client to prosecute a civil action. Our client sued the owner by its trade name, and the subcontractor was awarded all amounts owed at the underlying trial. The subcontractor stopped paying our client’s legal fees; thus, execution on the judgment was not completed. The subcontractor then sued our client, claiming that its judgment was uncollectible because it was against a trade name. Before the jury came into the courtroom, the court granted Aaron’s motion for nonsuit based on the court’s orders granting our motions in limine seeking to preclude certain evidence and arguments.
Jack Slimm and Jeremy Zacharias (Mount Laurel, NJ) were successful on February 28, 2023, before the New Jersey Appellate Division, which affirmed a decision dismissing a complex legal malpractice action arising out of an underlying first-party coverage action in the U.S. District Court involving hundreds of thousands of dollars in building damage caused by Super Storm Sandy. The plaintiffs filed a complaint against alleging claims for legal malpractice. At the close of discovery, a motion for summary judgment was filed on behalf of the defendants, asserting that an order for dismissal was entered. Upon affirming the trial court’s decision, the Appellate Division, reviewing de novo the grant of summary judgment, held that the plaintiffs had not established proximate cause as a matter of law and that expert testimony was necessary to prove proximate causation and damages. The causal relationship between the defendants’ alleged malpractice and plaintiffs’ asserted loss was not obvious and, therefore, the trier of fact could not resolve the issue as a matter of common knowledge without the assistance of expert testimony. The court held that the expert’s opinion was an impermissible net opinion with no evidential weight since the expert failed to explain the why and wherefore behind the opinion.
*Prior Results Do Not Guarantee a Similar Outcome
|
|
Kohut v. Vlahos, 289 A.3d 96 (Pa. Super. 2022), purported named beneficiaries to a will cannot state a legal malpractice claim based upon an unsigned will. “Until Decedent signed a revised will, his purported intent to continue to leave his entire estate to Heirs remains unknown.”
Cohen v. Horn, No. 22-2148, 2022 WL 17546950, at *2 (3d Cir. Dec. 9, 2022), summary judgement appropriately granted by district court applying New Jersey law because “Cohen failed to obtain an expert to explain the defendants’ duty of care and how it was breached.”
Odyssey Contracting Corp. v. Georgoulis, No. CV 22-338, 2022 WL 6755465, at *2 (W.D. Pa. Oct. 11, 2022), judgment on the pleadings granted on statute of limitations basis in legal malpractice action. The court reaffirmed that Pennsylvania does not apply a continuous representation rule and breach of contract claims in legal malpractice actions must “emanate from a ‘specific executory promise.’”
|
|
SEISMIC CHANGES MAY SOON BE COMING TO FLORIDA STATUTES FOR COMPARATIVE NEGLIGENCE, LODESTAR FEE, STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS AND ONE-WAY ATTORNEY’S FEES AGAINST INSURERS
|
|
With the support of Governor Ron DeSantis, Florida House Bill 837 was filed on February 15, 2023, which would bring comprehensive reforms to civil litigation in Florida. In an attempt to try to stomp out Florida’s notoriety as being one of the nation’s leaders in frivolous lawsuits, this legislation would dramatically change the state’s framework for comparative negligence, lodestar fees, statute of limitations and one-way attorney’s fees against insurers. “For decades, Florida has been considered a judicial hellhole due to excessive litigation and a legal system that benefitted the lawyers more than people who are injured,” said Governor DeSantis. “We are now working on legal reform that is more in line with the rest of the country and that will bring more businesses and jobs to Florida.” The bill also has the support of Florida Senate President Kathleen Passidomo and House Speaker Paul Renner.
Florida Statute 768.81, which addresses comparative fault, would be amended to read that for negligence actions, “any party found to be greater than 50 percent at fault for his or her own harm may not recover any damages.” Under current law, a plaintiff could still obtain a recovery even if a jury found him or her to be primarily at fault. For example, a plaintiff who is found to be 80% responsible by a jury can be awarded 20% of the damages based on an allocation of fault. With the new law, that same plaintiff would be barred from recovery, as would any plaintiff found to be at least 51% liable for their damages.
To calculate an attorney’s fee award, Florida courts follow the lodestar method established by the federal courts. Fees are calculated using the number of attorney hours reasonably expended multiplied by the reasonable hourly rate. However, courts may decide that the lodestar figure is insufficient and award a multiplier of between 1.5 to 3.0 in light of the contingency risk. The proposed revised Fla. Stat. 57.104, titled “Computation of Attorney Fees,” would create a “strong presumption that a lodestar fee is sufficient and reasonable” in any action in which attorney’s fees are awarded by the court. This presumption may only be overcome “in a rare and exceptional circumstance with evidence that competent counsel could not otherwise be retained.” If passed, plaintiffs’ attorneys will no longer regularly see fee awards that are doubled or tripled.
House Bill 837 would reduce the statute of limitations for negligence actions from four years to two years in Fla. Stat. 95.11. This would result in all negligence actions having the same time limitations as the current more restrictive two-year period to bring a professional malpractice action (other than medical).
Additionally, the bill would eliminate one-way attorney’s fees in lawsuits against insurers, which provide for a fee award to a plaintiff who obtains a judgment against an insurer, no matter how small. One-way attorney’s fees were eliminated last year by the Florida Legislature for lawsuits against property insurers, and the new law would expand that prohibition to all lines of insurance.
The House Civil Justice Subcommittee voted to approve the bill, and it moved forward in the legislative session started on March 7, 2023.
|
|
Kim Berman (Fort Lauderdale, FL) co-presented “Insurer Malpractice Claims Against Defense Counsel: Recognizing, Defending, and Preventing Potential Claims” on January 24, 2023, on behalf of Strafford. This webinar guided insurance defense counsel through the increasingly important topic of insurer claims against defense counsel for legal malpractice committed while defending the insured. The program reviewed common errors, whether a cause of action exists and who may assert it, how liability is established, whether and how work restrictions and counsel guidelines imposed on defense counsel affect liability, how damages are proved, and whether and how the attorney-client privilege or work product protection of the insured affects the case.
Alesia Sulock and Josh Byrne (Philadelphia, PA), authored the article “When Disciplinary Counsel Knocks on Your Door, How Do You Respond?” in the Legal Intelligencer
Josh Byrne (Philadelphia, PA) participated in the presentation “Ethics and Malpractice Avoidance” at the Pennsylvania Bar Association’s Mid-Year Meeting along with Justice Sallie Updyke Mundy and Michael Furlong of CNA.
Josh Byrne (Philadelphia, PA) presented at the Philadelphia Bar Association’s Bench-Bar meeting on “Practicing with Integrity” with Chief Disciplinary Counsel Thomas Farrell, Judge Tiffany Palmer, and Judicial Candidate Kay Yu.
Jeremy Zacharias (Mount Laurel, NJ) and Danielle Robinson (Fort Lauderdale, FL) presented a webinar on negotiation skills to a client’s national team of claims professionals.
Jack Slimm (Mount Laurel, NJ) provided a case law update on recent civil cases that impact the Bench and Bar at the Camden County Bar Association Civil Practice Update.
Jeremy Zacharias (Mount Laurel, NJ) moderated this panel discussion, which included practitioners and judges.
|
|
The material in this law alert has been prepared for our readers by Marshall Dennehey. It is solely intended to provide information on recent legal developments, and is not intended to provide legal advice for a specific situation or to create an attorney-client relationship. We welcome the opportunity to provide such legal assistance as you require on this and other subjects. If you receive the alerts in error, please send a note tamontemuro@mdwcg.com. ATTORNEY ADVERTISING pursuant to New York RPC 7.1. © 2023 Marshall Dennehey. All Rights Reserved.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|