The two monuments among Bach’s compositions that are universally acknowledged as the most impressive are the compilation of movements known as the Mass in B Minor and the
Saint Matthew Passion
. Although the surviving manuscript version of the Mass in B Minor reveals details of its derivation from nearly 35 years of Bach’s music, the only autograph manuscript of the
Saint Matthew Passion
dates from what was probably its third performance, given nearly a decade after the first.
While a great many historical disciplines have benefited from centuries of exploration, certainly it is the field of Bach studies that has garnered the most attention from musicologists. Literally hundreds of music historians have focused their efforts on accurately identifying timelines, manuscripts, contexts, and background circumstances of Bach’s music, and among them are a dozen or so giants in the field. Yet, despite their best efforts and with all best intentions and tireless dedication to the processes of discovery, many points—some fine and some quite general—are still left in question.
The genre of the Passion settings that Bach would produce in Leipzig was relatively new to their audiences. In fact, musicologist John Butt points out that we, now in the twenty-first century, are more familiar with the format than Bach’s congregations were. Such is one of the advantages of looking backwards and carefully studying, through typically annual performances of the works, those great and towering examples of rhetoric that have tremendous power and effectiveness.