Public Health Authority
Case Updates

September 22, 2023

This newsletter is distributed by Public Health Law Watch as part of Act for Public Health, a working group of the Public Health Law Partnership that is convening to provide law and policy research, analysis, and expertise in support of public health authority.

This week's case updates:


Wednesday, September 13th: In National Association for Gun Rights v. Grisham, a gun rights activist group filed suit in the District Court of New Mexico against the state government for declaring gun violence a public health emergency and suspending open and concealed carry laws in parts of the state. The suit, arguing that the orders violate the Second Amendment, names the New Mexico Department of Health Secretary as well as Governor Lujan Grisham as defendants. The court granted the requested temporary restraining order, and a motion for a preliminary injunction is currently pending.


Thursday, September 14th: In Meta Platforms v. District of Columbia, the DC Court of Appeals upheld a subpoena against Facebook’s parent company, Meta, seeking data on their internal COVID-19 misinformation policies. The District of Columbia initially filed suit against Meta alleging they misled the public on their commitment to addressing misinformation on their platforms during the pandemic. The lower court held, and the Court of Appeals agreed, that the information the subpoena seeks is not governed under the Stored Communications Act, so a warrant is not required to compel Meta to produce it.


Thursday, September 14th: The Northern District of Texas dismissed the majority of claims in Schelske v. Austin for mootness, except for the claims of an Army service member discharged for not receiving the COVID-19 vaccine. The plaintiffs sued claiming that the Army violated the Religious Freedom Restoration Act in mandating the COVID-19 vaccine for all service members. All but one of the plaintiffs in the case remained in the Army throughout the litigation, and given the vaccine mandate’s recission, the court held their claims were now moot. The claims brought by the one plaintiff who had been discharged, however, can still proceed to seek reinstatement, or to change his discharge record to honorable.

 

Spotlight: Federal District Court in Mississippi requires religious exemptions to childhood vaccine mandate

On Tuesday, August 29th, 2023, final judgment was entered in Bosarge v. Edney, which held that Mississippi’s childhood vaccine mandate was unconstitutional and had to permit religious exemptions moving forward. The mandate was challenged under the Free Exercise clause of the First Amendment.


Background

Prior to the ruling, Mississippi was one of six states that did not permit religious exemptions to childhood vaccine mandates. Mississippi also currently has the highest childhood vaccination rate in the United States, and while 43 out of 50 states have seen measles cases in the past 10 years, Mississippi has not seen a case since 1992.


Mississippi has not always disallowed religious exemptions. Prior to 1979, religious exemptions were allowed, but only for those practicing a “recognized” religion that was known to require prayer or spiritual healing. In Brown v. Stone, a practitioner of an unrecognized religion sued on behalf of his child after his religious exemption was denied. The Mississippi Supreme Court held that only providing religious exemptions to some religions did, in fact, violate the Free Exercise clause, but did not order the remedy hoped for by the plaintiff. Instead, the court held that the state held an overriding interest in mandating childhood vaccinations to protect school children. Though the mandates might burden religious beliefs, “the exception, which would provide for the exemption of children of parents whose religious beliefs conflict with the immunization requirements, would discriminate against the great majority of children whose parents have no such religious convictions.” The court therefore ruled that the violation of the Free Exercise clause would be remedied by eliminating all religious exemptions, making Mississippi the second state at the time to do so.


The Present Case

The plaintiffs, Amanda Bosarge and other parents, sued Edney in his capacity as State Health Officer, the State Attorney General, as well as various local school principals, on behalf of their children. These children remained unvaccinated due to their parents’ religious beliefs, and under the Mississippi childhood vaccine law, they were therefore not allowed to attend public or private school. Backed by the Informed Consent Action Network, an anti-vaccine advocacy group, the plaintiffs filed suit in federal district court in September 2022, alleging that Mississippi’s policy denying religious exemptions violated their rights under the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment.


Judge Sul Ozerden, a George W. Bush appointee, issued a preliminary injunction on April 18th, 2023, holding that the plaintiffs had demonstrated they were likely to succeed on their claim and be found to be irreparably harmed if a process to receive religious exemptions was not immediately put in place.


Importantly, the Attorney General did not contest the plaintiffs’ claim that religious exemptions should be allowed, instead arguing that Mississippi law already permitted them. The court found uncompelling the Attorney General’s argument that the Mississippi Religious Freedom Restoration Act (MRFRA) indirectly allowed for religious exemptions, though neither the more specific vaccination statutes, nor the State Health Department’s policy allowed for them. The court did find compelling the Attorney General’s statement that barring the MRFRA, the mandate scheme would “substantially burden” some parents’ religious beliefs, and based on the prevalence of religious or philosophical exemptions in other states, a total ban on religious exemptions would not be “the least restrictive means” of protecting children’s health.


The preliminary injunction went into effect on July 15th, 2023, requiring the Mississippi Department of Health to develop a process to grant religious exemptions, or not enforce the vaccine mandate at all. Judge Ozerden held that even though preliminary injunctions ordinarily only apply to the parties involved, the admissions of the Attorney General supported making the ordered religious exemption process open to any who applied.


The court’s final order largely followed the same logic as the preliminary injunction. Drawing principally on the Supreme Court’s decision in Fulton v. Philadelphia, the Bosarge court’s opinion granting the preliminary injunction ultimately rested on the belief that medical exemptions and religious exemptions are the same, and to offer the former and not the latter violates the Free Exercise clause. The process to apply for a religious exemption created by the Health Department per the preliminary injunction was deemed acceptable by the court. The Health Department and state Attorney General advised the court that they would not oppose the motion for summary judgment or the permanent injunction.


What this means for public health

This case is representative of a larger trend attacking vaccine mandates, in particular childhood vaccines. Last week we covered Fox v. Makin, a Maine case similarly challenging a lack of religious exemptions that was allowed to proceed to trial. However, not all attacks have succeeded, with the Second Circuit recently upholding Connecticut’s 2021 repeal of religious exemptions in We the Patriots USA Inc. v. Connecticut Office of Early Childhood Development. More challenges to the remaining states without religious exemptions (California, Connecticut, Maine, New York, and West Virginia) on Free Exercise grounds are likely, though chances of success are less clear.

 
The Public Health Law Partnership includes organizations with decades of experience in public health law, authority, and governance, including ChangeLab Solutions, the Network for Public Health Law, the Center for Public Health Law Research at Temple University, the Public Health Law Center at Mitchell Hamline School of Law, and Public Health Law Watch, a George Consortium initiative housed at the Center for Health Policy and Law at Northeastern University.
 
 
 
Twitter