Public Health Authority
Case Updates

September 15, 2023

Case updates this week:


Wednesday August 16th: In Fox v. Makin, a Maine district court allowed a case to proceed challenging Maine’s mandatory childhood vaccine policy. Specifically, the plaintiffs argue that the lack of a religious exemption violates the free exercise and equal protection clauses. The court held that the plaintiffs’ case was plausible, given a recent 1st Circuit case that held a similar mandate for Maine healthcare workers also potentially violated the free exercise clause.


Friday September 1st: in Apter v. Health & Human Svc., the Fifth Circuit held that three doctors can use the Administrative Procedure Act to overcome sovereign immunity in their suit against the FDA regarding messaging on ivermectin to treat COVID-19. The doctors allege that the FDA’s campaign to discourage individuals from taking the drug interfered with their practices and harmed their reputations.


Tuesday September 5th: In Howell v. Cooper, a North Carolina appeals court held that bar owners negatively impacted by COVID-19 shutdowns could proceed with their claims against the Governor. Though the state argued that sovereign immunity should apply, the court held that the bar owners had overcome this by sufficiently alleging plausible constitutional violations. The lone dissenter argued that the COVID emergency laws are presumed constitutional, and therefore the court would need to hold Cooper’s actions arbitrary or irrational in another case before stripping his immunity.


Thursday September 7th: In DiCapua v. City of New York, 10 teachers who lost their jobs for not complying with New York City’s COVID vaccine mandate were ordered rehired and given back pay by a New York state trial court. The judge held that the denial of religious exemptions and subsequent firing of the plaintiffs had been unlawful, arbitrary, and capricious, in part because most of the student population was also unvaccinated. However, the plaintiffs’ request to certify a class was denied for being overbroad.


Thursday September 7th: Former BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee employees filed a class action lawsuit in a federal district court alleging they were fired for not receiving the COVID-19 vaccine after their religious exemptions and reasonable accommodation requests were unfairly denied.


Friday September 8th: In Missouri v. Biden, the Fifth Circuit narrowed the injunction limiting the ability of federal agencies to ask social media platforms to take down certain posts. The lower court held that the agencies had violated the First Amendment by pressuring platforms to remove posts related to topics such as COVID-19 origin theories, vaccine side-effects, and election fraud. The amended order only applies to the White House, the Surgeon General, the CDC, and the FBI, cutting three additional agencies. The language of the injunction also softened, with the agencies not being allowed to “coerce” companies to delete posts. However, the injunction was administratively stayed by Justice Alito on Thursday, September 14th, and will not go into effect until Saturday, September 23rd at the earliest.

 
 
This newsletter is distributed by Public Health Law Watch as part of Act for Public Health, a working group of the Public Health Law Partnership that is convening to provide law and policy research, analysis, and expertise in support of public health authority.
The Public Health Law Partnership includes organizations with decades of experience in public health law, authority, and governance, including ChangeLab Solutions, the Network for Public Health Law, the Center for Public Health Law Research at Temple University, the Public Health Law Center at Mitchell Hamline School of Law, and Public Health Law Watch, a George Consortium initiative housed at the Center for Health Policy and Law at Northeastern University.
 
 
 
Twitter