|
Quotes of the Day:
A quote from a Judge and Veteran who tells his jurors that jury service is as important as military service to the support and defense of our federal and state Constitutions:
“I would like to add one final thought. When you go home and turn on the news tonight, I don't care what channel you watch, someone is going to want to influence you in a certain way. You may be left thinking that your fellow citizens, or half of them, are not equal to you because they don't believe in things that you do. I say that that is hogwash, and those commentators are laughing all the way to the bank. No one here, from what I can tell, knows who is liberal or who is conservative, who is a republican or who is a democrat. But we all agreed, as far as I can tell, that we would show up and perform our constitutional duty with our fellow citizens and do the right thing. And I want you to think about that when you leave. Don't let people tell you that we're a divided nation. Decide that we are not, as you did today, and just do your duty. Thank you very much.”
– Tom Murphy
“Don’t worry about siding for or against the majority. Worry about taking up any of their irrational beliefs. “
– Marcus Aurelius
“The truth is like a lion; you don’t have to defend it. Let it loose; it will defend itself.”
– Augustine
Happy Birthday, Devil Dogs.
10 November 2024
A MESSAGE FROM THE COMMANDANT OF THE MARINE CORPS
https://www.cmc.marines.mil/Birthday/
1. Why North Korean Soldiers Are Prepared to Die in Russia
2. North Korean elite Storm Corps reduced to cannon fodder at Russian ‘meat grinder’ front line: sources
3. South Korea weighs arming Ukraine after North Korean deployment
4. South Korea’s Position On North Korea’s Troop Deployment To Russia: A Global Security Response
5. Yoon orders launch of economic consultative bodies to prepare for 2nd Trump administration
6. N. Korea blamed for 331 GPS disruptions this month: science ministry
7. US Senate Armed Services Committee Ranking Member Urges 'Immediate Response' to First Battle between North Korea and Ukraine
8. Expect the Worst From Russia and North Korea
9. South Korean arms to Ukraine as a three-course meal
10. Let 'America First' benefit Seoul
11. President-elect Trump: “I look forward to continuing the good cooperative relationship between Korea and the US”
12. 50,000 Russian and North Korean Troops Mass Ahead of Attack, U.S. Says
1. Why North Korean Soldiers Are Prepared to Die in Russia
Comments from number of us to include from the north Korean diaspora and my fellow Special Forces soldier, good friend ,and colleague, Hyun Seung Lee (though he is from the north Korean Special Forces)
Why North Korean Soldiers Are Prepared to Die in Russia
Nearly all would raise their hands to go, ex-military defectors explain, owing to regime loyalty, promise of higher status and a glimpse of the outside world
https://www.wsj.com/world/asia/north-korea-troops-russia-ukraine-war-7496e24b?mod=hp_lead_pos9
By Dasl YoonFollow
| Photographs by Tim Franco for WSJ
Updated Nov. 10, 2024 12:02 am ET
SEOUL—Ryu Seong-hyeon doesn’t need to imagine what the thousands of North Korean soldiers deployed to the Russian front lines might now be thinking. Not long ago, he was one of them.
Ryu darted across the Korean Demilitarized Zone to freedom in 2019—a rare soldier defection. He had a profile that mirrors many of the freshly dispatched troops today: young, underfed and blind to the outside world. Before he chose to flee, Ryu remembers moving bricks at construction sites and shivering outside as he stood guard. He ate mushy rice mixed with corn. Meat was a holiday treat.
Back then, if ordered to fight with the Russians, the now 28-year-old Ryu would have given a resolute answer: “Thank you.” His rationale: “Wouldn’t the meals be better at least?”
The North Korean fighters in Russia have been dismissed as mercenaries, cannon fodder and second-rate. But what gets overlooked, former North Korean soldiers and other military experts argue, is how ready to die many of these troops are—and how eager they might be to escape grim conditions back home.
It is unlikely the roughly 10,000 North Korean troops in the Kursk region, where Russia is trying to repel a Ukrainian incursion, will turn the tide of the bruising 2½-year war. But they provide Russian President Vladimir Putin with much-needed manpower and pose new threats on the deadlocked front lines. One of the biggest mysteries is the level of resolve these North Korean troops will bring to a battle far from home and for an unfamiliar cause.
Ukrainian incursion into Russia
Ukrainian advances in Russia
Russian forces
Front-line areas
Kyiv
Area of
detail
Rylsk
RUSSIA
Sudzha
KURSK REGION
Sumy
UKRAINE
20 miles
20 km
Note: As of Nov. 6
Source: Institute for the Study of War and AEI’s Critical Threats Project
Andrew Barnett/WSJ
Ukrainian officials said on Tuesday some North Korean soldiers had already engaged in combat on a small scale near the front lines. A day later, South Korea assessed the fresh arrivals had not yet engaged in full-fledged combat. The U.S. has said it expects North Koreans to begin fighting within days.
Nearly all of the troops sent to Russia—who include special-forces fighters—would have a similar set of motivations, the North Korean ex-soldiers say. They have been indoctrinated from a young age to sacrifice everything for the supreme leader. Children get urged in their school textbooks to prove their regime loyalty by volunteering to be the targets of hypothetical artillery strikes.
The troops’ deployment would be seen as the opportunity of a lifetime to bring back cash and glory to the Kim Jong Un regime. Those who die get valorized; those who survive come back heroes.
“North Korean soldiers are convinced that they should do anything for Kim,” Ryu said.
Ukraine’s military, like the Russian forces it is fighting in regions such as Donetsk, is also in need of ways to bolster its ranks. Photo: Serhii Korovayny for WSJ
‘Without an inch of hesitation’
Even North Korea’s top troops lack modern equipment and resources, putting them at a disadvantage relative to special forces trained in the U.S., Europe or South Korea, said David Maxwell, a retired U.S. Army Special Forces colonel with extensive experience in Asia. Many of North Korea’s soldiers, even special forces, spend the bulk of their time on agricultural or construction work, he added.
“North Korean special-operation forces training produces highly disciplined soldiers with intense loyalty, often willing to undertake extreme risks with limited equipment,” Maxwell said.
The Russians and Ukrainians have armed forces in the hundreds of thousands, with both sides facing attrition and struggles replenishing their ranks. Russia can recruit more than 30,000 fresh troops a month, though it often loses as many killed or wounded in Ukraine, according to Western estimates. Ukraine is suffering lower rates of casualties, though precise figures aren’t clear.
What makes North Korea’s initial deployment a concern is its ability to send more. North Korea has one of the world’s largest standing armies, at roughly 1.2 million, with several million more in reserves, according to South Korean estimates. The Kim regime fields the world’s largest special-forces unit at around 200,000, military experts say.
Soldiers sent to Russia are expected to be paid a monthly wage of around $2,000, much of which will go to the regime, South Korean officials say. Still, that is a staggering sum where most of the country lives on monthly earnings of a few dollars.
Kim Jong Un visits a North Korean special-forces training base in a photo released by state media. Photo: KCNA/Reuters
For decades, North Korea has struggled to supply enough food for its people due to international isolation and economic mismanagement, exacerbated by natural disasters. Around 45% of North Korea’s population of 26 million is undernourished, according to a World Food Program report. Even the military, which typically receives special privileges, experiences chronic food shortages.
The special forces hold a distinct spot atop the North Korean military pecking order. They’re better fed than other units, with more intense training in infiltration, infrastructure destruction and assassination. State television has aired footage that highlights the vaudevillian aspects of their training: Troops break lightbulbs with their bare hands and shirtless fighters get clubbed with wooden sticks. Others bend metal rods.
In September, Kim oversaw special-forces scouting and raid drills featuring the country’s “invincible revolutionary armed forces,” as state media called them. Each North Korean combatant, the report claimed, was the equivalent of 100 enemy soldiers. Kim’s approval filled the troops, whose cheers roared like thunder, with “boundless emotion, joy, great pride and self-esteem.”
Defector Lee Hyun-seung once belonged to North Korea’s special forces. Photo: Lee Hyun-seung
Lee Hyun-seung once served in North Korea’s elite “Storm Corps” special-forces unit before he fled roughly a decade ago. On top of the military drills, Lee, who is now 39, recalled attending daily ideological training sessions memorizing Kim’s commands and repeating their willingness to die for the supreme leader—a practice that no doubt continues for those dispatched to Russia.
“They may be sacrificed without making much impact in the war,” Lee said. “But they wouldn’t dare cast doubt on the leader’s orders to go to Russia.”
A worthwhile risk
North Korea often rolls out flashy military hardware at garish parades, from new tanks to artillery rockets and drones. But that advanced gear is likely not integrated at the troop level. The country lacks the funds to properly supply its military with such high-price equipment.
The recent North Korean arrivals were taught around 100 basic military terms in Russian—including “fire” and “in position”—though they appeared to have struggled with communication, South Korea’s spy agency told lawmakers late last month.
Given the focus on boosting Pyongyang’s nuclear arsenal, the training or food situation for soldiers hasn’t dramatically changed since Kim took power in December 2011, said Bang Jong-kwan, a former South Korean army major general. That limits their potential role in Russia to being foot soldiers, due to the language barrier and unfamiliarity with the terrain, he said.
Ukraine’s Sumy region shares a border with Kursk, where Russian forces are trying to beat back a Ukrainian invasion. Photo: Svet Jacqueline for WSJ
“They will experience high casualties because it’s highly unlikely that Russia provides advanced equipment or intel,” Bang said.
Nonetheless, many North Korean soldiers would see the risks as worthwhile. Those who have heard of the North Korean pilots who flew in combat against U.S. aircraft during the Vietnam War know that an overseas deployment will elevate a soldier’s status, said Sim Ju-il, who was a North Korean military officer for 30 years before escaping to South Korea in 1998.
The pilots who returned from Vietnam were greeted as heroes and promoted to senior officer ranks, the 74-year-old Sim recalled. Even the wives of the pilots who died on the battlefield were given elevated Workers’ Party status that grants them access to prestigious jobs.
It is that blind devotion to the Kim regime that Sim hopes to break—by going to the Ukrainian front lines. He said there are roughly 300 or so other former North Korean military members also willing to go. If deployed to the front lines, they hope to create “psychological disturbance” by sending antiregime leaflets and creating broadcasts to persuade the North Korean soldiers to surrender or defect, he said.
“I want them to know they have been lied to,” Sim said. “There is no need to die because of their loyalty.”
Former North Korean officer Sim Ju-il, 74, wants to get through to soldiers from the country he fled decades ago.
Write to Dasl Yoon at dasl.yoon@wsj.com
2. North Korean elite Storm Corps reduced to cannon fodder at Russian ‘meat grinder’ front line: sources
Here are comments from a number of the Korea watchers from military experts to human rights leaders.
Note that Dr. Bruce Bechtol outlines some of the places around the world where north Korean special forces have been employed (which never makes the news but Dr. Bechtol has documented the evidencel in his books and research).
Photos at the link: https://nypost.com/2024/11/09/us-news/north-korean-elite-storm-corps-reduced-to-cannon-fodder-sources/?utm
North Korean elite Storm Corps reduced to cannon fodder at Russian ‘meat grinder’ front line: sources
By Dana Kennedy
Published Nov. 9, 2024, 7:00 a.m. ET
108 Comments
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un, after sending estimated 8 million artillery shells and dozens of modern short-range ballistic missiles to Russia for Putin's war effort, has now sent 12,000 of his most elite soldiers to help Putin fight against Ukraine.
AP
North Korean Supreme Leader Kim Jong Un’s decision to send thousands of troops to fight alongside Russia will net him up to $25 million a month – but some sources say the soldiers may be quickly getting wiped out.
Kim deployed roughly 12,000 elite North Korean soldiers to the Russia-Ukraine battlefield – known as the meat grinder for its huge number of casualties, particularly on the Russian side – last month, and sources say he’s been paid $2,000 a month per soldier.
That’s a huge amount for the hermit nation where food is scarce and many of its 26 million people are starving to death, according to a 2023 BBC report.
However, Russian generals aren’t maximizing the use of the crack so-called “Storm Corps,” North Korean experts told The Post.
13
North Korea’s so-called Supreme Leader Kim Jong Un and Russian President Vladimir Putin have a long friendly relationship. During the past year, North Korea sent an estimated 8 million artillery shells and dozens of modern short-range ballistic missiles to Russia for Putin’s war effort.
POOL/AFP via Getty Images
13
North Korean soldiers preparing to take part in the Russian war effort against Ukraine.
@wartranslated / X
Language barriers, culture clashes and decisions like apparently disguising North Korean soldiers to look like Russian fighters from Siberia may have contributed to what at least one US official said were a “significant” number of North Korean casualties so far.
Explore More
Rather than deploying the North Koreans in their own contained units, the Russian commanders are reportedly mixing them in with Russian squads – with disastrous results. In one case that has lead a confused Russian unit to abandon North Koreans posted with them on the battlefield when they didn’t realize who they were.
13
North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un proudly reviewing some of his elite troops in North Korea.
Photo: @sbsnews8
13
A photo of North Korean soldiers shown on a TV program in South Korea last month.
AP
“They’re being wasted,” Asian expert Gordon Chang, author of “Plan Red: China’s Project to Destroy America,” told The Post.
“This is crazy stuff. They’re too good to be used as cannon fodder but that’s what’s happening. It’s perplexing how they are being utilized. If they were kept in their own self-contained units they could be absolutely lethal fighting the Ukrainians. But that’s not happening.”
The “Storm Corps” – or special forces – are said to be the “best-trained” and, importantly in a starving nation, the “best fed” of all the North Korean military.
However, the quality of that food remains questionable. The German tabloid Bild reported that as part of the North Korean troop deployment, Russian soldiers can be seen in various Telegram videos – which haven’t been verified – handling canned goods with the words – “Nureongi dog meat” written on them in Korean letters.
“Nureongi” are medium-sized dogs with brownish, short fur. This Spitz breed is a popular food dog in Korea. On the back it says: “Product exclusively for the army of the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea.”
13
Putin and Kim Jong Un at a state reception in Pyongyang, the capital of North Korea, in June 2024.
via REUTERS
13
Russians apparently posing with military officers from North Korea in the center of Moscow.
@wartranslated / X
It’s puzzling why Kim, 40, would want to sacrifice some of elite troops. The official name for the Storm Corps in North Korea is the 11th Corps of the Korean People’s Army.
“But remember, Kim doesn’t care about his people,” Sean King, an Asia specialist with Park Strategies told The Post. As a dictator, “he doesn’t have to worry about re-election. Hundreds of thousands have suffered in North Korean labor camps.”
Ukrainian soldiers battled North Korean troops along the Russian border Nov. 4, the first skirmish since the foreign fighters were deployed to help Moscow’s forces in Kursk in western Russia in their ongoing war, which has raged since February 2022.
The region had previously been under Russian control until Ukrainian forces, led by President Volodymyr Zelensky re-captured it earlier this year.
During the past year, North Korea sent an estimated 8 million artillery shells and dozens of modern short-range ballistic missiles to Russia for Putin’s war effort.
“It’s still unclear how the troops will be used, but they will probably be used for combat more than anything else,” according to Bruce Klingner, a former CIA and Defense Intelligence Agency veteran now with the Heritage Foundation.
13
North Korean military officers in Moscow with Russian officers.
@wartranslated / X
13
Photos like this one published on the Telegram app show the North Koreans and Russians seeming to play tourists near Red Square.
@wartranslated / X
13
Bild published photos purportedly of North Korean dog meat being served to an unsuspecting Russian army.
@wartranslated/ X
“Given that Russia is using a World War I ‘meat grinder’ approach to trench warfare and there is not much of an integrated command structure it’s not going to be easy for them,” added Klinger, who has studied North and South Korea for 31 years.
“There have already been messages intercepted by Ukrainian intelligence about the Russians not knowing what to do with them. There’s also some question about how good their training is. They may be special forces but it’s a mistake to think of them in the same league as the Navy Seals, for example.”
The North Korean soldiers, who are mainly in their late teens and early 20s, have never been out of the uber-controlled Hermit Kingdom, where most citizens are not allowed Internet access and are deprived of many basic freedoms taken for granted elsewhere.
But few North Korea scholars believe a recent post by Financial Times’ Gideon Rachman who wrote on X: “A usually reliable source tells me that the North Korean soldiers who have deployed to Russia have never had unfettered access to the internet before. As a result, they are gorging on pornography.”
Bruce E. Bechtol Jr., a professor of political science at Angelo State University in Texas who’s written numerous books on North Korea, said he doubts the troops would even have smartphones or computers in their possession.
13
North Korean soldiers preparing to take part in the invasion of Ukraine.
@wartranslated / X
“In North Korea you need a signed letter from Kim Jong Un to use the Internet and even then it’s tightly controlled,” Bechtol told The Post. “And remember that out of those 12,000 troops sent to Russia, 500 military officers and three generals went with them. They have a lot of supervision.
“It’s not like they’re a bunch of Marines deploying to the Philippines and going out to clubs to meet girls every night.”
Greg Scarlatoiu, president and CEO of the Committee for Human Rights in North Korea, said he thinks the porn story is a “psyops run by the Ukrainian side.”
But if they are checking out porn – even if it’s an old-school dirty magazine being tossed around – or considering defecting, the North Korean soldiers are playing a very risky game, experts said.
North Korea’s notorious “three generations of punishment” rule calls for an entire three generations of a person’s family to be punished for their sins by sending them to a gulag prison camp is still very much in play in North Korea.
Additionally, Kim Jong Un has reportedly “isolated” the soldiers’ families in case there are heavy casualties and the families blab to their villages.
13
North Korean soldiers getting supplies as they prepare to start fighting for Russia.
@wartranslated / X
Most concerning, said Chang, is that by Russia bringing North Korea into the volatile Russia-Ukraine war, they are escalating the conflict beyond Ukraine and Russian territory.
“It’s not inconceivable that Ukraine could hit North Korea in retaliation,” Chang said.
Bechtol said that contrary to popular belief, North Korea has involved its military on a number of occasions over the years in Africa, the Middle East and Vietnam – but have never deployed ground troops on this scale before.
North Korea’s military advisors helped train a wing of Zimbabwe dictator Robert Mugabe’s fearsome Fifth Brigade in the early 1980. That led to the Fifth Brigade massacring 20,000 people in Matebeland in 1983.
13
Kim Jong Un waving to some of his Korean People’s Army.
AFP via Getty Images
13
Kim Jong Un inspecting his troops in Pyongyang in 2018.
Gamma-Rapho via Getty Images
North Korean pilots flew in combat with North Vietnam against the US in the 1960s and have lent military support to Egypt and Syria against Israel.
North Korean leaders in capital Pyongyang also sent specialists and possibly a few ground troops to Syria to fight on behalf of Bashar Al-Assad’s government in 2016-2017 during their civil war and helped train Ethiopian fighters in their ongoing wars with Eritrea in the 1980s.
Western nations have criticized the North Korean deployment as a sinister escalation of the conflict.
“The first battles with North Korean soldiers mark a new chapter of global instability,” Zelensky said. “Together with the world, we must do everything to ensure that this Russian step toward expanding the war — this true escalation — becomes a loss.”
108
What do you think? Post a comment.
Scarlatoiu said he thinks the war will get so bloody for the North Koreans that they won’t even want to defect to the ‘evil’ and unknown West and they will just want to get home.
Even though they’ve been described as callow and inexperienced, the North Korean soldiers are well-trained and disciplined, he said. “They are going to experience so much blood sweat and tears I think they’ll be longing for their hometowns in North Korea, however tough those towns may be.”
3. South Korea weighs arming Ukraine after North Korean deployment
Do the right thing because it is the right thing to do.
Excerpts:
South Korea’s decades-long preparations for a possible renewal of hostilities with its northern enemy, coupled with its defence industry’s formidable manufacturing capacity, have created a large stockpile of weaponry including artillery shells, tanks, howitzers and surface-to-surface missiles.
A US ally, South Korea is a regular attendee at Nato summits and supplies several of its members. Analysts said its arms would largely be compatible with those already in operation among Ukraine’s forces.
“South Korean support for Ukraine could turn the tide on the entire conflict,” said Henry Haggard, a senior adviser at consultancy WestExec Advisors who served as minister-counsellor for political affairs at the US embassy in Seoul between 2021 and 2023.
“Korean firms not only make world-class armaments tailor-made to help Ukraine, they also have the production capacity to deliver essential weapons at a speed that could make a difference when needed most,” he added.
South Korea has provided support indirectly to Ukraine by replenishing US stocks of 155mm artillery shells delivered to Kyiv. “European governments are aware that South Korea has provided more artillery shells to Ukraine than all European countries combined, even if via third countries,” said Ramon Pacheco Pardo, a Korea expert at King’s College London.
South Korea weighs arming Ukraine after North Korean deployment
Financial Times · by Christian Davies · November 1, 2024
South Korea’s conservative President Yoon Suk Yeol is weighing directly providing arms to Ukraine, a potentially consequential shift in the conflict, in response to North Korea’s deployment of troops to the Russian front line.
Seoul has previously resisted entreaties from western allies to draw on its vast stockpiles of military armaments, preferring to contribute to Kyiv’s war effort through non-lethal aid. But North Korea’s deployment in Russia’s western Kursk region, which US officials said on Thursday could be as large as 8,000 troops, is shifting that calculation, according to analysts and diplomats.
Yoon and other senior officials in Seoul have described Pyongyang’s direct participation in the conflict as a threat to South Korea’s security, offering North Korean troops valuable battlefield experience. They also fear Moscow may share sophisticated military technologies in exchange for Pyongyang’s support.
Yoon has vowed not to “sit idle” in response to the North Korean deployment. His office confirmed this week that Seoul intended to send a delegation to Ukraine to monitor the North Korean forces, following a call on Tuesday between Yoon and his Ukrainian counterpart Volodymyr Zelenskyy.
But the prospect of directly supplying arms to Ukraine has been fiercely opposed by South Korea’s leftwing opposition, which holds a majority in parliament and blames the Yoon administration’s hardline stance towards North Korea for pushing Pyongyang into Moscow’s embrace.
“[Arming Ukraine] is an incredibly dangerous idea that treats people’s lives like pawns in a game of chess,” Park Chan-dae, floor leader of the Democratic party, told a party rally last week, arguing South Korea had no direct interest in the outcome of the war.
Yoon “shouldn’t engage South Korea in a proxy war with North Korea . . . in a faraway land”, said Park, adding that deepening Seoul’s involvement would “risk starting a military conflict on the Korean peninsula”.
“The South Korean government is caught between foreign partners asking for it to do more and an opposition demanding it does less,” said Jeongmin Kim, lead analyst at Seoul-based information service Korea Pro.
South Korea’s President Yoon Suk Yeol, left, with Volodymyr Zelenskyy in Kyiv in 2023. Zelenskyy said on Thursday that he was sending a representative to Seoul to make ‘detailed’ requests for weapons © Sergei Supinsky/AFP/Getty Images
South Korea’s decades-long preparations for a possible renewal of hostilities with its northern enemy, coupled with its defence industry’s formidable manufacturing capacity, have created a large stockpile of weaponry including artillery shells, tanks, howitzers and surface-to-surface missiles.
A US ally, South Korea is a regular attendee at Nato summits and supplies several of its members. Analysts said its arms would largely be compatible with those already in operation among Ukraine’s forces.
“South Korean support for Ukraine could turn the tide on the entire conflict,” said Henry Haggard, a senior adviser at consultancy WestExec Advisors who served as minister-counsellor for political affairs at the US embassy in Seoul between 2021 and 2023.
“Korean firms not only make world-class armaments tailor-made to help Ukraine, they also have the production capacity to deliver essential weapons at a speed that could make a difference when needed most,” he added.
South Korea has provided support indirectly to Ukraine by replenishing US stocks of 155mm artillery shells delivered to Kyiv. “European governments are aware that South Korea has provided more artillery shells to Ukraine than all European countries combined, even if via third countries,” said Ramon Pacheco Pardo, a Korea expert at King’s College London.
Zelenskyy said on Thursday that he was sending a representative to Seoul to make “detailed” requests for artillery and air defence systems in light of the North Korean deployment to Russia.
About 3,000 North Korean troops are believed to have been deployed to Russia’s western Kursk region © Eyepress/Reuters
But Seoul has until now declined to initiate direct lethal aid, citing the country’s Foreign Trade Act, which restricts arms exports “except for peaceful purposes”.
Pacheco Pardo said there had been “an understanding between Seoul and Moscow that South Korea wouldn’t provide direct lethal aid to Ukraine, while Russia limited its support for North Korea”.
Russia’s ambassador to Seoul declared this year that South Korea was “one of the friendliest among the unfriendly countries”.
But Pacheco Pardo said the understanding was “now over”.
“I think the Yoon government will provide lethal aid to Ukraine if it has proof that Russia has increased its support to North Korea, particularly the transfer of technologies that can help Pyongyang develop its missile, satellite, space and other high-tech programmes,” he said.
Russia declined to comment on Thursday on whether it had assisted North Korea’s missile programme, hours after Pyongyang tested its latest intercontinental ballistic missile, the Hwasong-19.
But a day earlier, during a meeting with US defence secretary Lloyd Austin in Washington, South Korea’s defence minister Kim Yong-hyun said there was a “high chance” that North Korea was seeking Russian defence technologies in exchange for its troop deployment.
A Seoul-based European diplomat said the South Korean government’s position on arms supplies “has moved” since the North Korean deployment, “but very, very cautiously”, noting that Seoul was likely to wait for the outcome of the US presidential election before deciding on its next step.
Jeongmin Kim said the Yoon administration appeared to be preparing to argue that providing lethal aid did not require parliament’s support and would not violate the Foreign Trade Act, on the grounds that arming Ukraine would contribute to international peace by helping bring the war to an end.
Such a move is likely to meet public opposition. According to a Gallup Korea poll conducted soon after the revelations of North Korean troops in Russia, only 13 per cent of South Koreans surveyed backed military support for Ukraine, while 66 per cent said support should be limited to non-military and humanitarian aid.
But Yang Uk, a defence expert at the Asan Institute for Policy Studies, argued that direct military support would help Seoul repay its historic debt to countries that sent troops to defend South Korea during the Korean war in the 1950s.
“We had the same experience when North Korea invaded us that Ukraine is having now,” said Yang. “The world came to help us then, so now the least we can do is contribute to the global order in return.”
Additional reporting by Christopher Miller in Kyiv
Financial Times · by Christian Davies · November 1, 2024
4. South Korea’s Position On North Korea’s Troop Deployment To Russia: A Global Security Response
Excerpts:
The deployment of North Korean troops to Russia is particularly disquieting for South Korea. The potential transfer of advanced Russian military technology to North Korea as part of this cooperation may substantially augment Pyongyang’s nuclear missile capabilities. Furthermore, the enhancement of North Korea’s conventional military forces could pose a direct threat to South Korea. Intelligence assessments shared among South Korea, the United States, and allied nations reveal that the deployment is still in its early stages, with North Korean troops already entering Russia. These developments signify a deepening military alliance between North Korea and Russia, which South Korea perceives as a serious and immediate security hazard.
In response to the mounting crisis, South Korea has issued resolute condemnations of North Korea’s actions, characterising the troop deployment as a breach of international law and a direct menace to regional and global security. South Korean officials have exercised caution in delineating their forthcoming actions, yet the government has hinted at a potential shift in its military stance.
...
In conclusion, the deployment of North Korean troops to Russia and the subsequent military collaboration with Moscow poses a significant challenge to global security. The response from South Korea, contemplating the possibility of supplying offensive armaments to Ukraine, underscores the gravity of the menace. The widespread condemnation on an international scale, notably from ASEAN, underscores the general apprehension regarding the implications of this alliance. Looking ahead, a synergistic strategy encompassing diplomatic, economic, and military measures will be imperative to counter the threat emanating from the North Korea-Russia partnership. As events unfold, the international community must stay vigilant in its endeavours to uphold peace and stability.
South Korea’s Position On North Korea’s Troop Deployment To Russia: A Global Security Response – Analysis
eurasiareview.com · October 29, 2024
The decision taken by North Korea to dispatch troops to Russia in support of the invasion of Ukraine represents a significant escalation in worldwide tensions. This action has elicited widespread condemnation from South Korea and the international community, posing a threat not only to the security of the Korean Peninsula but also to global stability.
In response, South Korea is considering potential adjustments to its military strategy, including the possibility of providing offensive weaponry to Ukraine, underscoring the seriousness of the situation. This article evaluates South Korea’s diplomatic, military, and economic reactions to the North Korean troop deployment while examining broader international responses, particularly from the United Nations and the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). Finally, the article offers recommendations for concerted action to address this evolving crisis.
North Korea’s Involvement: A Global Security Concern
North Korea’s participation in Russia’s conflict with Ukraine introduces a hazardous dimension to an already precarious situation. Through the deployment of troops and supply of armaments to Russia, North Korea not only bolsters its military collaboration with Moscow but also blatantly violates various United Nations Security Council (UNSC) resolutions that prohibit any form of military cooperation intended to restrict North Korea’s capacity to enhance its nuclear and conventional military capabilities. This development raises substantial security apprehensions as North Korea’s engagement could potentially prolong the conflict in Ukraine, destabilise the Korean Peninsula, and impede international endeavours to denuclearise North Korea.
The deployment of North Korean troops to Russia is particularly disquieting for South Korea. The potential transfer of advanced Russian military technology to North Korea as part of this cooperation may substantially augment Pyongyang’s nuclear missile capabilities. Furthermore, the enhancement of North Korea’s conventional military forces could pose a direct threat to South Korea. Intelligence assessments shared among South Korea, the United States, and allied nations reveal that the deployment is still in its early stages, with North Korean troops already entering Russia. These developments signify a deepening military alliance between North Korea and Russia, which South Korea perceives as a serious and immediate security hazard.
In response to the mounting crisis, South Korea has issued resolute condemnations of North Korea’s actions, characterising the troop deployment as a breach of international law and a direct menace to regional and global security. South Korean officials have exercised caution in delineating their forthcoming actions, yet the government has hinted at a potential shift in its military stance.
Traditionally, South Korea has furnished Ukraine with non-lethal assistance, abstaining from active participation in the conflict through offensive means. Nevertheless, with the deepening military collaboration between North Korea and Russia, Seoul is contemplating the allocation of offensive armaments to Ukraine. This departure from South Korea’s previous position would signify the gravity of the threat posed by North Korean engagement.
Principal Deputy National Security Adviser Kim Tae-hyo has elucidated the circumstances under which South Korea would contemplate furnishing offensive armaments to Ukraine. These conditions encompass scenarios where North Korea acquires advanced military technology from Russia or heightens its surveillance capabilities over South Korea. Should such scenarios materialise, South Korea might find itself compelled to escalate its involvement in the conflict in Ukraine by delivering more direct military backing to the nation.
This resolution would represent a pivotal juncture in South Korea’s foreign policy, as it would necessitate assuming an active role in counteracting Russian aggression. Concurrently exploring military strategies, South Korea is actively collaborating with its allies to address the threat posed by North Korea’s collaboration with Russia. Seoul has already initiated intelligence-sharing efforts with the United States and plans to dispatch a delegation to NATO headquarters in Brussels for further deliberations. This cooperative endeavour underscores South Korea’s dedication to collaborating with the international community in confronting this escalating challenge. South Korea’s engagement with NATO further signifies a comprehensive strategic alignment with Western powers in response to the burgeoning North Korea-Russia nexus.
International Reaction
The global community has collectively denounced the military collaboration between North Korea and Russia. In the 9th South Korea-U.K. Strategic Dialogue, both nations released robust statements criticising North Korea’s illicit transfer of arms and personnel to Russia. The U.K., in alignment with other NATO members, perceives this cooperation as a breach of international law and a menace to worldwide security.
These concerted endeavours to exert pressure on North Korea and Russia underscore the increasing consensus among Western nations regarding the necessity of more stringent measures to counteract these activities. The United Nations has also expressed apprehension regarding North Korea’s participation in undermining UNSC oversight sanctions against Pyongyang. Should further infractions arise, the UNSC might contemplate additional sanctions or diplomatic measures. Nonetheless, the efficacy of these actions remains uncertain due to North Korea’s extensive history of circumventing sanctions and its close ties with China and Russia, both permanent members of the Security Council.
ASEAN, notwithstanding its traditional non-aligned stance, has articulated concerns about North Korea’s involvement in the Russia-Ukraine conflict. ASEAN members, especially those in Southeast Asia, are cautious of the potential destabilisation of the broader Asia-Pacific region. North Korea’s military collaboration with Russia indirectly jeopardises ASEAN’s strategic interests by potentially instigating further militarisation in the region and exacerbating tensions with China. ASEAN advocates adherence to U.N. Security Council resolutions and underscores the significance of peaceful dialogue and diplomacy. ASEAN’s prudent yet resolute standpoint mirrors the delicate equilibrium it endeavours to uphold in regional security matters.
Recommendations and Conclusion
Given the seriousness of the situation, coordinated international action is imperative to prevent the escalation of the North Korea-Russia military pact. Primarily, diplomatic initiatives should concentrate on pressuring Russia and North Korea to cease their military cooperation by intensifying sanctions and fostering isolation in international arenas. Nations like South Korea, Japan, and ASEAN members should persist in cooperating with the U.S. and NATO to forge a united front. Secondly, economic sanctions against both North Korea and Russia should be heightened, targeting pivotal sectors that underpin military collaboration, such as arms production and logistics. Lastly, South Korea’s military readiness should be fortified through enhanced collaboration with NATO and regional allies to deter potential threats.
In conclusion, the deployment of North Korean troops to Russia and the subsequent military collaboration with Moscow poses a significant challenge to global security. The response from South Korea, contemplating the possibility of supplying offensive armaments to Ukraine, underscores the gravity of the menace. The widespread condemnation on an international scale, notably from ASEAN, underscores the general apprehension regarding the implications of this alliance. Looking ahead, a synergistic strategy encompassing diplomatic, economic, and military measures will be imperative to counter the threat emanating from the North Korea-Russia partnership. As events unfold, the international community must stay vigilant in its endeavours to uphold peace and stability.
The opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own.
References
- Cha, Victor D. The Impossible State: North Korea, Past and Future. HarperCollins, 2012.
- Snyder, Scott A. South Korea at the Crossroads: Autonomy and Alliance in an Era of Rival Powers. Columbia University Press, 2018.
- Kotkin, Stephen Armageddon Averted: The Soviet Collapse, 1970-2000. Oxford University Press, 2008.
eurasiareview.com · October 29, 2024
5. Yoon orders launch of economic consultative bodies to prepare for 2nd Trump administration
Excerpts:
He emphasized the new U.S. administration's shift in policies could bring significant changes to the global economy and security landscape.
"Consequently, this will directly affect our economy and security, so thorough preparations are essential," he added.
...
Yoon anticipated positive momentum for the shipbuilding and petrochemical sectors under Trump's energy policies and highlighted the importance of strengthening cooperation in advanced industries, including artificial intelligence, biotechnology and quantum technology.
During a phone conversation with Yoon on Thursday, Trump expressed the U.S.' interest in working with South Korea in the shipbuilding industry, particularly in naval shipbuilding, exports and maintenance.
"In defense, based on our robust South Korea-U.S. alliance, we must maintain a strong deterrence against North Korea and be prepared to lead in promoting genuine peace and prosperity in the Asia-Pacific region," Yoon said, noting significant structural changes in security could arise.
(2nd LD) Yoon orders launch of economic consultative bodies to prepare for 2nd Trump administration | Yonhap News Agency
en.yna.co.kr · by Kim Soo-yeon · November 10, 2024
(ATTN: ADDS more details in last 2 paras)
By Kim Eun-jung
SEOUL, Nov. 10 (Yonhap) -- President Yoon Suk Yeol on Sunday called for the launch of finance, trade and industry consultative bodies to brace for the potential impacts of former U.S. President Donald Trump's return to the presidency.
Yoon made the call during an economic and security meeting with ministers and senior aides to discuss preparations before Trump assumes office in late January.
"International markets have already begun responding based on anticipated policy directions even before the new U.S. administration takes office, so the government should monitor the markets closely and ensure thorough preparations," Yoon said.
He emphasized the new U.S. administration's shift in policies could bring significant changes to the global economy and security landscape.
"Consequently, this will directly affect our economy and security, so thorough preparations are essential," he added.
President Yoon Suk Yeol convenes a meeting with senior government officials and presidential aides at the presidential office in Seoul on Nov. 10, 2024, to discuss economic and security implications of a second Trump administration. (Yonhap)
Yoon anticipated positive momentum for the shipbuilding and petrochemical sectors under Trump's energy policies and highlighted the importance of strengthening cooperation in advanced industries, including artificial intelligence, biotechnology and quantum technology.
During a phone conversation with Yoon on Thursday, Trump expressed the U.S.' interest in working with South Korea in the shipbuilding industry, particularly in naval shipbuilding, exports and maintenance.
"In defense, based on our robust South Korea-U.S. alliance, we must maintain a strong deterrence against North Korea and be prepared to lead in promoting genuine peace and prosperity in the Asia-Pacific region," Yoon said, noting significant structural changes in security could arise.
A second Donald Trump administration is expected to bring shifts and unpredictability to the U.S.-South Korea alliance, potentially increasing pressure on Seoul to take on a larger share of the burden as a U.S. ally.
Another key focus will be how Trump might address North Korea's denuclearization, especially amid growing skepticism about Washington's commitment to this goal, as well as his approach to Russia's war in Ukraine at a time when North Korean troops have been sent to Russia to support the war.
Yoon said he and Trump agreed to meet at an early date during the phone call to engage in further discussions.
Principal Deputy National Security Adviser Kim Tae-hyo explains about an economic and security meeting convened by President Yoon Suk Yeol during a press conference held at the presidential office in Seoul on Nov. 10, 2024. (Yonhap)
During the meeting, Yoon instructed the government to closely engage with Korean companies to reflect their needs into policies in a manner that best serves the national interest, Sung Tae-yoon, the chief of staff for policy, said in a briefing.
Attendees to the meeting analyzed Trump's proposed tariffs on imported goods and energy policies, aiming to identify new business opportunities and minimize potential negative impacts on Korean businesses, according to Sung.
On security matters, the officials discussed defense cost sharing for U.S. Forces Korea, North Korea's troop deployment to Russia and other bilateral alliance issues.
The discussions focused on strengthening collaboration with the U.S. to enhance deterrence against North Korea, improve security and defense industry cooperation, and create synergies through advanced industries and technological cooperation, Principal Deputy National Security Adviser Kim Tae-hyo told reporters.
Observers predict Trump, known for his transactional view of alliances, may seek to renegotiate the defense cost-sharing agreement with South Korea, potentially jacking up Seoul's share of the costs for stationing the 28,500 U.S. troops here.
Meanwhile, Yoon is believed to have started practicing golf for the first time in eight years, ahead of a potential meeting with Trump, known as a golf lover.
He appears to be taking into account the case of then Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, who built personal ties with Trump through golf during Trump's first term.
ejkim@yna.co.kr
(END)
en.yna.co.kr · by Kim Soo-yeon · November 10, 2024
6. N. Korea blamed for 331 GPS disruptions this month: science ministry
Electronic warfare takes place across the spectrum of conflict and will have great impact on operations than at any time in history.
N. Korea blamed for 331 GPS disruptions this month: science ministry | Yonhap News Agency
en.yna.co.kr · by Woo Jae-yeon · November 10, 2024
SEOUL, Nov. 10 (Yonhap) -- North Korea was identified as the source of 331 cases of GPS disruptions reported this month, the science ministry said Sunday, noting that no major issues or damage occurred.
The Ministry of Science and ICT said it had "consistently detected radio interference originating from the Kaepung and Haeju areas of North Korea." Radio interference involves transmitting jamming signals within the GPS frequency band, disrupting the use of GPS signals.
During the first 10 days of November, 331 interference cases were recorded, with 279 targeting airplanes and 52 affecting ships. No damage was reported as a result of the disruptions.
The ministry said it has been operating a continuous monitoring system in coordination with the land and maritime ministries to ensure the safety of air and sea travel and will continue working together to maintain a high level of readiness.
jaeyeon.woo@yna.co.kr
(END)
en.yna.co.kr · by Woo Jae-yeon · November 10, 2024
7. US Senate Armed Services Committee Ranking Member Urges 'Immediate Response' to First Battle between North Korea and Ukraine
Are these Republicans in sync with the incoming administration? What is meant by direct US military action?
Excerpts:
“ This news should be a wake-up call to the free world ,” Rep. Wicker said . “ Our adversaries are working together to expand and deepen cooperation . ”
He continued, “ The axis of aggression is operating on the battlefield, and North Korea’s aggression threatens the security of Europe and the Indo-Pacific region ,” and urged , “ We must address this issue immediately . ”
Rep. Wicker also said , “ The Biden - Harris administration must begin dramatically increasing the costs of imposing sanctions on Russia and China, the two pillars of the axis of aggression that are fueling North Korea’s aggression . We have no time to waste , and the world is watching . ”
Senate Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Ben Cardin ( D-Md .) criticized North Korea’s decision to send troops on March 25 , saying , “ This decision dangerously escalates Vladimir Putin’s unjust war against Ukraine . ”
House Homeland Security Committee Chairman Mark Green ( R-Tenn .) also posted on his Social Media account the same day, saying , “ North Korea’s decision to send 3,000 troops to Russia is absolutely unacceptable ,” and “ The United States must make it clear that it will not tolerate this . ”
Rep. Mike Turner ( R-Ohio ) , chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, also released a statement on the 23rd of last month , arguing that “ if North Korea invades Ukrainian territory, the United States should consider direct military action . ”
Meanwhile, the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe (CSEC), chaired by Rep. Joe Wilson ( Democrat, South Carolina ) , is scheduled to hold a public hearing in the U.S. Congress on the 14th to discuss measures to deal with security threats such as North Korea-Russia military cooperation .
This is a Google translation of an RFA report.
US Senate Armed Services Committee Ranking Member Urges 'Immediate Response' to First Battle between North Korea and Ukraine
https://www.rfa.org/korean/in_focus/nk_nuclear_talks/north-ukraine-russia-senator-roger-wicker-condemn-11072024144212.html
WASHINGTON-Cho Jin-woo choj@rfa.org
2024.11.07
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky speaks at the U.S. Congress during his visit to the United States in December 2022. Behind him, Vice President Kamala Harris (left) and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi hold the Ukrainian flag presented by President Zelensky.
/ Yonhap News
00:00 /02:30
Anchor : A U.S. House of Representatives member expressed deep concern over the news that North Korean troops deployed to Russia recently engaged in their first skirmish with Ukrainian forces, and urged the U.S. administration to respond immediately . Reporter Cho Jin-woo reports .
Senator Roger Wicker ( R-Mississippi ) , the top Republican on the Senate Armed Services Committee, issued a statement on the 6th expressing deep concern over the news of North Korea's first engagement .
“ This news should be a wake-up call to the free world ,” Rep. Wicker said . “ Our adversaries are working together to expand and deepen cooperation . ”
He continued, “ The axis of aggression is operating on the battlefield, and North Korea’s aggression threatens the security of Europe and the Indo-Pacific region ,” and urged , “ We must address this issue immediately . ”
Rep. Wicker also said , “ The Biden - Harris administration must begin dramatically increasing the costs of imposing sanctions on Russia and China, the two pillars of the axis of aggression that are fueling North Korea’s aggression . We have no time to waste , and the world is watching . ”
Ukrainian President Vladimir Zelensky confirmed earlier on the 5th that Ukrainian troops had engaged in their first battle with North Korean troops attached to Russian forces .
[ Ukrainian President Zelensky ] The first battle with the North Korean army is opening a new page in the instability of the whole world . We must do everything we can to ensure that this move by Russia to escalate the war ends in defeat .
US Senate Foreign Relations Committee Chairman : Troop Deployment to North Russia ‘ Worrisome and Dangerous ’
North Korean Defector Groups : “ Hope Russian Troops Will Contribute to Psychological Warfare Against North Korean Forces ”
Senator Roger Wicker (R-MS), the ranking Republican on the Senate Armed Services Committee, expressed deep concern over the news of North Korea’s first engagement in a statement on the 6th. / Office of Senator Wicker
U.S. lawmakers have been raising their voices in criticism since news of North Korea's deployment of troops to Russia broke last month .
Senate Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Ben Cardin ( D-Md .) criticized North Korea’s decision to send troops on March 25 , saying , “ This decision dangerously escalates Vladimir Putin’s unjust war against Ukraine . ”
House Homeland Security Committee Chairman Mark Green ( R-Tenn .) also posted on his Social Media account the same day, saying , “ North Korea’s decision to send 3,000 troops to Russia is absolutely unacceptable ,” and “ The United States must make it clear that it will not tolerate this . ”
Rep. Mike Turner ( R-Ohio ) , chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, also released a statement on the 23rd of last month , arguing that “ if North Korea invades Ukrainian territory, the United States should consider direct military action . ”
Meanwhile, the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe (CSEC), chaired by Rep. Joe Wilson ( Democrat, South Carolina ) , is scheduled to hold a public hearing in the U.S. Congress on the 14th to discuss measures to deal with security threats such as North Korea-Russia military cooperation .
Editor Kim So-young , Web Editor Lee Kyung-ha
8. Expect the Worst From Russia and North Korea
Excerpts:
This interlocking of the fates of each autocratic regime over the last year has created a perverse incentive structure of ever deepening commitments and greater escalation to secure victory and avoid defeat. It is a dynamic that makes the continued Western strategy of escalation management a losing one. Instead, the United States and its allies should assume that North Korea’s presence in the war will grow unless deterred by overwhelming force.
Ideally, that means allowing Ukraine to interdict North Korean troops in their staging areas before they reach the battlefield. Failing that, U.S. leaders can at least provide Ukraine with a mass infusion of the hundreds of thousands of cluster munitions left in stock to blunt North Korean advances. Cluster munitions were initially designed to counter mass human wave attacks on the Eurasian steppe. The controversy surrounding their use and residual threat to civilians is overblown in this case, considering the frontlines of the war are already an uninhabitable moonscape pummeled by millions of explosives and seeded with more mines than anywhere else on earth. The United States should specifically supply its entire inventory of M26 cluster munition rockets, which is set to be destroyed anyway, a policy already advocated by an array of prominent military analysts.
Finally, Ukraine and NATO should work with South Korea to develop a potent information campaign against North Korea. The overwhelming transparency of the battlefield provided by commercial drones, smartphones, and satellite internet will provide unprecedented opportunities to capture and disseminate setbacks and humiliations faced by North Korean forces. Ukraine exploited similar disasters faced by Russian forces early in the war to rally international support and undermine the Kremlin’s effort to mobilize the population. North Korea’s famously closed society may be even more sensitive to the shock of scenes of gruesome casualties suffered in another country’s war. This sensitivity may be exploited to keep deployments and subsequent bad news resulting from them limited.
Expect the Worst From Russia and North Korea
thediplomat.com
Over the last year, the autocratic regimes in Moscow and Pyongyang have increasingly intertwined their fates via ever deepening commitments and greater escalation.
By Dan White
November 09, 2024
Subscribe for ads-free reading
No country makes hyperbolic statements quite like North Korea. So it is easy to dismiss the November 1 pledge by North Korea’s top diplomat Choe Son Hui while visiting Moscow that the country will “always stand firm by our Russian comrades until victory” as just the latest in a long line of exaggerated declarations.
This would be a mistake.
For over a year now Kim Jong Un has demonstrated with both substantive material assistance and the signing of a formal mutual defense pact that he is deeply invested in Vladimir Putin’s success. Now North Korean troops are primed to enter combat in support of the Russian military. The United States and its allies should recognize signs that deescalating North Korea’s involvement in the war is not going to succeed, and shift to a strategy of aggressively deterring Pyongyang from investing more troops in the war.
For weeks Western observers and officials have had to repeatedly revise cautious estimates of the size and purpose of North Korean troops deployed to Russia. Conservative assessments are perfectly reasonable, but there appears to be an irresponsible amount of wishful thinking driving analysis. The thousands of North Korean troops now in Russia have been variously assessed by Western analysts to be anything from technicians and operations support to internal security. None of these explanations satisfies any pressing needs for Russia’s war effort. Russia’s months of grinding offensives have, however, created an inexhaustible demand for replacement combat troops. As raw materials for the Russian military to expend to continue pressure on Ukrainian defenses, North Korean soldiers are an adequate substitute for Russians who would otherwise have to be drawn from a potentially destabilizing mobilization.
Under ordinary circumstances it would make little sense for Kim to casually throw away the lives of thousands of politically reliable troops in a war far from its borders that is already consuming over a thousand Russian soldiers per day. But there are rational forces propelling North Korea into the war as a combatant and putting it on track for significant escalation.
Both Putin and Kim have arrived at an opportunity to resolve existential threats to their regimes. Putin’s grip on power hinges on the perception of a Russian victory in the war in Ukraine. Kim has staked the future of his regime on a robust North Korean nuclear deterrent. The common thread uniting both parties is a perception that the threat to their survival in both instances originates from a fundamentally zero-sum competition with the West. Both stand to either gain or lose together, and therefore have good reason to make unprecedented commitments to one another during this war.
South Korean Defense Minister Kim Yong-hyun has suggested that North Korea’s willingness to provide troops on top of millions of artillery shells and dozens of ballistic missiles will come in exchange for Russian technical assistance to upgrade its nuclear weapons forces. Kim Jong Un may believe his claim to this assistance will grow stronger with the number of troops he sacrifices and is willing to further sacrifice to help Russia win. In a sense the thousands of North Korean troops sent to Russia may be more valuable to the Kim regime dead on the battlefield in Ukraine, as a down payment for advanced strategic weapons systems, the ultimate security guarantee against the superior conventional militaries of the United States and South Korea.
Russia previously worked to contain North Korea’s nuclear ambitions as a matter of national interest, but hindsight suggests that Russia had long reconciled itself to accommodate a nuclear North Korea. This is a shift that has been accelerated with a wholesale reevaluation of Russia’s national interests leading up to the war. The new guiding principle for Russia appears to be revising the international order to give it enduring status as a great power, and not as a sphere of influence in a superpower competition between the United States and China.
Russia has repurposed this self-interested geopolitical strategy into a broader critique of the “rules-based” international order and a desire for a multipolar world. It’s a critique validated by stalwart support from another nuclear pariah state. It demonstrates that when pressed far enough, the rules-based international order shows itself to be an illusory form of social control used by the West to hold back legitimate the dissenting interests of a select few “worthy” great powers.
Alignment with another robust nuclear power unconstrained by international norms is also a hedging strategy for Russia that allows it to remain independent of overbearing influence by either the United States or China over the long term. This hedging strategy provides Putin with the incentive to strengthen his ties with North Korea and to strengthen Pyongyang’s capability to disrupt global politics with a more robust nuclear arsenal.
This interlocking of the fates of each autocratic regime over the last year has created a perverse incentive structure of ever deepening commitments and greater escalation to secure victory and avoid defeat. It is a dynamic that makes the continued Western strategy of escalation management a losing one. Instead, the United States and its allies should assume that North Korea’s presence in the war will grow unless deterred by overwhelming force.
Ideally, that means allowing Ukraine to interdict North Korean troops in their staging areas before they reach the battlefield. Failing that, U.S. leaders can at least provide Ukraine with a mass infusion of the hundreds of thousands of cluster munitions left in stock to blunt North Korean advances. Cluster munitions were initially designed to counter mass human wave attacks on the Eurasian steppe. The controversy surrounding their use and residual threat to civilians is overblown in this case, considering the frontlines of the war are already an uninhabitable moonscape pummeled by millions of explosives and seeded with more mines than anywhere else on earth. The United States should specifically supply its entire inventory of M26 cluster munition rockets, which is set to be destroyed anyway, a policy already advocated by an array of prominent military analysts.
Finally, Ukraine and NATO should work with South Korea to develop a potent information campaign against North Korea. The overwhelming transparency of the battlefield provided by commercial drones, smartphones, and satellite internet will provide unprecedented opportunities to capture and disseminate setbacks and humiliations faced by North Korean forces. Ukraine exploited similar disasters faced by Russian forces early in the war to rally international support and undermine the Kremlin’s effort to mobilize the population. North Korea’s famously closed society may be even more sensitive to the shock of scenes of gruesome casualties suffered in another country’s war. This sensitivity may be exploited to keep deployments and subsequent bad news resulting from them limited.
Authors
Guest Author
Dan White
Dan White is a program associate at the Woodrow Wilson Center's Kennan Institute. Dan is responsible for managing Kennan Institute programs and policy outreach. Dan's research focus includes grand strategy and geopolitics in Eastern Europe and Eurasia.
Dan holds Masters Degrees from the Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS), the Naval Postgraduate School, and the University of Washington, and a Bachelors Degree from the University of Central Florida. Dan is a former officer in the U.S. Army and a veteran of the War in Afghanistan.
Subscribe for ads-free reading
thediplomat.com
9. South Korean arms to Ukraine as a three-course meal
Excerpts:
In closing, despite the saying, “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing,” which was incorrectly attributed to Irish statesman Edmund Burke, that saying retains strong relevance in Ukraine’s ongoing defense against Russia’s illegal invasion, a blatant subversion of the overarching principle of state sovereignty in international law.
With its unique and unrivaled defense production capabilities, the ROK is well-positioned to act as a force for good in global affairs and take action by supplying a three-course meal military aid package to Kyiv, with significant reputational and economic gains extractable from such a move amidst President Yoon’s commitment to transform the ROK into one of the world’s top four arms suppliers by 2027.
South Korean arms to Ukraine as a three-course meal - Asia Times
A menu of South Korean arms that could be served up to Ukraine in response to Russia’s wining and dining of North Korea
asiatimes.com · by Nah Liang Tuang and Thomas Lim · November 7, 2024
After Moscow and Pyongyang inked a de facto Mutual Defence Treaty in June 2024, Seoul remarked that it would reconsider the issue of supplying military aid to Kyiv. This is significant because South Korea has held a long-standing policy prohibiting the supply and export of arms to active conflict zones.
The rethinking process of this policy could be accelerated due to evidence of North Korean armaments being used against both civilian and military Ukrainian targets, as well as the deployment of Korean People’s Army (KPA) soldiers on the frontlines in the ongoing 2022 Russo-Ukrainian War. Understandably, Moscow is prepared to prioritize its relations with Pyongyang over Seoul, with such favoritism likely to endure in the future.
From the Republic of Korea’s (ROK) perspective, defense and military cooperation between a Russia desperate to win this war and a Kim Jong Un regime cognizant that it can press for a favorable deal exchanging the North’s arms and men for military technologies ranging from missiles to submarines and even nuclear weapons, greatly heighten the potential for destabilization of an already-fragile intra-Korean relationship and brinksmanship in the Korean peninsula.
Accordingly, a previous article made the case for the ROK to supply military aid to Kyiv, citing reasons such as i) upholding the United Nations (UN) norm of Ukraine’s right to legitimate self-defense, ii) communicating strong opposition to Moscow regarding any current or future military technology aid to the DPRK, iii) showcasing the efficacy of South Korean “K-arms” amidst a rapidly expanding market share, and iv) establishing the groundwork for the ROK to potentially take up the role of Ukraine’s future economic and military-industrial partner.
When Moscow finally crosses Seoul’s red line by providing missile and/or nuclear technology to Pyongyang, there should exist political will and security imperatives for the incumbent Yoon Suk Yeol administration to authorize arms shipments for Kyiv. This article offers a three-course culinary comparison to illustrate South Korea’s potential arms shipments for Ukraine in the ongoing war.
Appetizer armaments
An appetizer is a small dish served before the main course to whet the appetite. Similarly, “appetizer” armaments could undertake the form of limited quantities of selected weapons intended to assess suitability and demonstrate effectiveness, thereby whetting the interest of the Ukrainians for its inclusion as part of a future “main course” shipment, or to act as impetus and motivation for other countries to consider for future acquisitions.
Two such South Korean military “appetizers” are the AT-1K Raybolt anti-tank guided missile (ATGM) and the KP-SAM Chiron surface-to-air missile (SAM).
The Raybolt ATGM can either be operated by small teams of soldiers or mounted on light strike or armored vehicles, giving such units the ability to match and out-pace the striking range of tank-mounted armaments. Its infrared-imaging targeting system also increases strike accuracy and lethality, while being suitable for both day and night operations.
Lastly, its warhead is designed for maximum penetration and effectiveness against modern tanks and armored vehicles equipped with explosive reactive armor, which allows the asset to be utilized by Ukrainian soldiers in pushing back against the Russian ground offensive by destroying Russian tanks and armored personnel carriers.
A small initial consignment of Raybolt ATGMs would help supplement depleting Ukrainian stocks of West-supplied Javelin missiles, thereby helping to relieve any anti-tank missile scarcity in the ongoing struggle on land.
From the perspective of LIG Nex1 and Hanwha Vision, the manufacturers of AT-1K missiles and launchers respectively, the ability to benchmark the Raybolt’s performance against the Javelin (the premier asset of its weapon class) in an active warzone would be critical in data collection for future arms development projects, while also being a superb advertisement of sales if the asset generates significant wartime results for Ukraine’s territorial defense.
A Chiron man-portable SAM system positioned on top of a high-rise building. Image: Korea Defense Blog
For the Chiron SAM, it, too, is infrared homing, deployable with smaller troop sections, systems-integrable onto various military vehicles, and suitable in different operating environments. It can shoot down low-flying aircraft and helicopters while maintaining relatively productive strike capabilities against aerial drones, which is critical for the ongoing land war.
Even if in limited quantities, KP-SAM’s allure for a Ukraine desperately in need of missile stocks to reinforce its short-ranged air defense is evident, and it could either be deployed to strengthen air defense protection for frontline troops to maintain their defensive formations, or be used for the holistic reinforcement of Ukraine’s Integrated Air Defence System (IADS), providing a missile umbrella to guard more Ukrainian cities and critical infrastructure against Moscow’s suicide drones and cruise missiles.
Finally, considering that countries such as Romania have already chosen to purchase the Chiron, the KP-SAM’s high combat performance in warfighting scenarios could open the floodgates for potential buyers seeking a more cost-effective and deployable option than the Javelins. This would open the door for more defense exports into the European region and military aid for Ukraine in its defense against Russia.
Main course munitions
In Western cuisine, the main course is the most substantial and indispensable part of any meal. Correspondingly, metaphorically describing any armament type as a “main course” implies that such weapons are critical for the war’s conduct.
Ironically, the scale-tipping “asset” that anyone could provide for Ukraine at the current juncture would be ammunition (and not a specific arm), as it seeks to overcome issues of ammunition shortages that have led it to concede ground on multiple fronts in the primarily land-based war thus far.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s September 2024 visit to a munitions production factory in the US state of Pennsylvania is evidence of the prioritization placed on replenishing its ammunition stockpiles. Such “main courses” could include ammunition for rifles and machine guns, grenades, mortar bombs and artillery shells for howitzers, amongst others.
With global ammunition supply chains under significant strain owing to the Covid-19 pandemic and the eruption of multiple conflict flashpoints, Ukraine’s survival and territorial defense is, perhaps, contingent upon the expeditious and sustained provision of ammunition.
With South Korea’s developed military-industrial complex capable of quick shipment rollouts and remarkable speed in weapon supplies, akin to the carbohydrates of a main meal, ammunition for Ukrainian ground forces could be supplied in significant quantities as a ‘main course’, given the small, yet linear shift towards favorable political winds in the ROK’s parliament regarding the arming of Ukraine.
The ROK has already displayed its capacity to produce and supply munitions, with its supply of 550,000 155mm artillery shells to the US over the past year, which allowed Washington to free up corresponding munitions for Kyiv. Additionally, South Korea could also supply 105mm shells compatible with North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) STANAG-compliant military assets, many of which are currently used by Ukraine.
Since the ROK has a stockpile of about 3.4 million 105mm shells and is relegating its 105mm artillery to reserve service as it transitions to 155mm artillery assets, it is well-placed to provide ammunition to assist in Ukraine’s defense of Russia.
Missiles for dessert
At this juncture, it is worth mentioning that both ammunition and SAM missiles can be classified as defense-oriented weapons with limited offensive range, making export political authorization more palatable for the ROK. However, if the current war is to be concluded on Kyiv’s terms, more politically contentious “dessert” weapons might be required to be presented onto the meal table.
While Ukraine could continue to resist Russia into 2025 and even 2026 using the above-mentioned “main course” and “appetizer” arms, the cumulative suffering inflicted upon the former is unconscionable. Hence, it would be morally preferable to expedite the end of this war in Ukraine’s favor. One of the means to this end is the supply of “dessert” weapons like the Hyunmoo series of ballistic missiles, specifically the Hyunmoo-1A and Hyunmoo-2A.
Both Hyunmoo versions are guided land-attack missiles with ranges of 180km and 300km, while carrying powerful 500kg and 1000kg warheads respectively. Furthermore, both are older variants of the series with the 1A already retired and the 2A having a 20-year service record.
A still from a video showing a test launch of the Hyunmoo-4 SRBM, currently the largest South Korean ballistic missile. Photo: YTN NEWS CAPTURE
Sign up for one of our free newsletters
Hence, South Korea’s military readiness should not be impacted if 1A stocks were exported to Ukraine. The development of the Hyunmoo-4 and 5 variants can accelerate the timeline for the stand-down of the 2A versions, opening up potential room for export to Ukraine.
Considering the unfortunate reality that Ukraine only possesses long-range attack drones with small warheads and insufficient stocks of Neptune cruise missiles, being gifted the Hyunmoo 1A and 2A would help decisively shift the momentum of this war in Kyiv’s favor.
Old though the 1A and 2A versions might be, their extensive ranges and heavy warheads would enable devastating strikes on Russian munition/fuel depots, troop/vehicle garrisons, command and control facilities, and other infrastructure critical to the Russian invasion, previously considered relatively safe by Moscow due to the lack of Ukrainian long-range strike capabilities.
As for any protests from Moscow should Seoul supply these pivotal “desserts” to Kyiv, such complaints ring hollow since it is public knowledge that Pyongyang and Tehran are already providing ballistic missiles for Russia’s unjust war. The export of such assets could prove to be a game-changer for Ukraine in its campaign thus far, bringing the three-course meal to a satisfying end.
In closing, despite the saying, “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing,” which was incorrectly attributed to Irish statesman Edmund Burke, that saying retains strong relevance in Ukraine’s ongoing defense against Russia’s illegal invasion, a blatant subversion of the overarching principle of state sovereignty in international law.
With its unique and unrivaled defense production capabilities, the ROK is well-positioned to act as a force for good in global affairs and take action by supplying a three-course meal military aid package to Kyiv, with significant reputational and economic gains extractable from such a move amidst President Yoon’s commitment to transform the ROK into one of the world’s top four arms suppliers by 2027.
Nah Liang Tuang (PhD) is a research fellow at the Institute of Defense and Strategic Studies (IDSS), a constituent unit of the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies (RSIS), Nanyang Technological University in Singapore.
Thomas Lim is a senior analyst with the Military Studies Program under RSIS. The viewpoints and arguments presented in this article are the authors’ own and do not represent any stand of IDSS or RSIS.
Thank you for registering!
An account was already registered with this email. Please check your inbox for an authentication link.
asiatimes.com · by Nah Liang Tuang and Thomas Lim · November 7, 2024
10. Let 'America First' benefit Seoul
Excerpts:
Putting America first at the expense of allies’ sacrifice is neither sustainable nor workable. The South Korea-U.S. alliance will remain strong only when the two sides seek joint gains.
Fortunately, Seoul and Washington need each other more than ever. The two sides need to fulfill their commitments to the alliance to bring the desired results.
The U.S. president-elect will certainly add pressure on Seoul to pay more for the U.S. troops stationed in the country. The survival of the South Korea-U.S. defense-cost sharing deal, concluded in October to increase South Korea’s contribution by 8.3 percent to $1.47 billion in the first year, remains uncertain. During the campaign rally, Trump called for a hike nearly nine times higher, suggesting $10 billion as an appropriate amount to keep U.S. forces in South Korea.
...
The alliance works when all involved sides understand they need each other. But it will fail when either side tries to take advantage of the others for its own sake.
Trump 2.0 should be an era where Seoul and Washington rediscover their counterparts and strive to seek mutual gains. Trump’s “America First” should be implemented in a manner that can also benefit South Korea.
Let 'America First' benefit Seoul
The Korea Times · November 10, 2024
Former U.S. President Donald Trump praises his senior campaign adviser Susie Wiles during an election night event at the Palm Beach Convention Center in West Palm Beach, Florida, Nov. 6. gettyimagesbank-Yonhap
Mutual efforts needed to keep Korea-US alliance strong
Former U.S. President Donald Trump’s victory in the Nov. 5 presidential election has stoked fears about the future of the South Korea-U.S. alliance, rather than raising hopes for it.
Such a troubled reaction to the U.S. election outcome is not a South Korea-specific phenomenon. Other U.S. allies in Asia and Europe are also wary of the U.S. election’s possible fallout on their economies and foreign policies.
Trump’s policy slogan, “America First,” is a source of their concern. When he takes office in January, he is highly likely to push around his country's allies — not to mention China, which the Trump campaign identified as the greatest threat to the U.S. — to contribute more, if not sacrifice themselves, to help the U.S. maximize its interests.
Putting America first at the expense of allies’ sacrifice is neither sustainable nor workable. The South Korea-U.S. alliance will remain strong only when the two sides seek joint gains.
Fortunately, Seoul and Washington need each other more than ever. The two sides need to fulfill their commitments to the alliance to bring the desired results.
The U.S. president-elect will certainly add pressure on Seoul to pay more for the U.S. troops stationed in the country. The survival of the South Korea-U.S. defense-cost sharing deal, concluded in October to increase South Korea’s contribution by 8.3 percent to $1.47 billion in the first year, remains uncertain. During the campaign rally, Trump called for a hike nearly nine times higher, suggesting $10 billion as an appropriate amount to keep U.S. forces in South Korea.
To realize "America First," Trump will also add pressure on South Korea to carry more of the burden to keep the Indo-Pacific region safe, given that burden-sharing is a central part of his defense strategy. A nightmare situation will unfold if the U.S. refuses to defend Taiwan were its sovereignty to be challenged by China. If this happens, Seoul will be asked to choose between Washington and Beijing. Even during peacetime, Seoul could face pressure to clarify its stance on Taiwan as Trump hinted at cutting U.S. defense costs for Taiwan.
According to Project 2025, a controversial plan drafted by the Heritage Foundation to overhaul the U.S. government to promote a conservative agenda, the U.S. will make China's subordination of Taiwan or other U.S. allies in Asia more difficult, but should do this “at a level of cost and risk that Americans are willing to bear.” Trump distanced himself from Project 2025, but his campaign pledges that were summarized in Agenda 47 share a lot with the plan.
The Yoon Suk Yeol government should chart a post-U.S. election strategy based on flexible thinking and wisdom.
Yoon needs to sit down with his aides in the presidential office as well as Cabinet ministers to navigate all possible options that can help Seoul adjust to the forthcoming Trump administration smoothly.
Among others, the Yoon government must explore in which areas the two sides can cooperate to produce mutually beneficial outcomes. Certainly, there are areas with much room for bilateral cooperation with the U.S. to create a win-win situation. Shipbuilding and maritime defense for instance show strong potential. The fall of the shipbuilding industry has emerged as a grave security threat to the U.S. as China steps up its maritime ambitions. China his risen to the world’s top shipbuilding and shipping nation, having 230 times more shipbuilding capacity than the U.S. The U.S. is looking to South Korea as a partner to help rebuild its shipbuilding industry. U.S. Navy Secretary Carlos Del Toro’s trips to South Korea and Japan in February and March came against this backdrop.
The alliance works when all involved sides understand they need each other. But it will fail when either side tries to take advantage of the others for its own sake.
Trump 2.0 should be an era where Seoul and Washington rediscover their counterparts and strive to seek mutual gains. Trump’s “America First” should be implemented in a manner that can also benefit South Korea.
The Korea Times · November 10, 2024
11. President-elect Trump: “I look forward to continuing the good cooperative relationship between Korea and the US”
The message to Pyongyang through this Google translation of an RFA report is that the alliance will remain strong in the face of the north's political warfare strategy which seeks to drive a wedge in the alliance.
Keep in mind the primary target audience for RFA and VOAA reports is in north Korea.
President-elect Trump: “I look forward to continuing the good cooperative relationship between Korea and the US”
https://www.rfa.org/korean/in_focus/north-trump-yoon-president-phone-call-11072024040656.html
Seoul-Lee Jeong-eun leeje@rfa.org
2024.11.07
President Yoon Seok-yeol is talking on the phone with U.S. President-elect Donald Trump at the presidential residence in Hannam-dong, Seoul on the 7th.
federation
00:00 /04:14
Anchor : U.S. President-elect Donald Trump spoke on the phone with South Korean President Yoon Seok-yeol and discussed the situation regarding North Korea . Lee Jeong-eun reports from Seoul .
South Korean President Yoon Seok-yeol congratulated U.S. President-elect Donald Trump on his election victory in a phone call on the morning of the 7th .
Kim Tae-hyo, First Vice Director of the National Security Office of South Korea, said this during a press briefing at the Blue House on the same day, adding that the two sides agreed to meet at an early date .
President Yoon and President-elect Trump discussed the situation in North Korea in detail during their phone call .
In particular, they shared their assessments of military trends, including North Korea's dispatch of troops to the Ukraine war, and shared concerns about the urgency of the situation in Ukraine .
They also shared situations and expressed concerns about North Korea's growing nuclear capabilities , ballistic missile provocations , dropping of sewage balloons on South Korea , and GPS jamming in the West Sea .
Regarding Korea-US-Japan cooperation, President Yoon evaluated that the strengthening of the cooperative relationship among the three countries and the establishment of the Camp David trilateral cooperation system were also due to the contribution of President-elect Trump, who solidified cooperation among Korea-US-Japan during his first term .
Regarding the ROK-US alliance, he said that they should continue a close partnership covering all areas, including security and economy, and President-elect Trump also said that he hopes that the good cooperative relationship between ROK and the US will continue .
In addition, South Korea and the United States agreed to build joint leadership in the Indo-Pacific region , on the Korean Peninsula, and at the global level .
- President Yoon sends congratulatory message to Trump: “ROK-US alliance will shine brighter”
- North Korean defectors in the U.S. expect “strong North Korea policy” after Trump’s election
As President-elect Trump is likely to enter into negotiations with North Korea after taking office with the goal of nuclear disarmament rather than denuclearization, some are also calling for South Korea to consider arming itself with nuclear weapons .
In this regard, South Korean Foreign Minister Cho Tae-yeol emphasized at a plenary session of the Foreign Affairs and Unification Committee held at the National Assembly on the same day that strengthening the US' extended deterrence against South Korea is the most appropriate measure at present .
[ South Korean Foreign Minister Cho Tae- yeol ] I still believe that strengthening the US' extended deterrence (against South Korea ) and enhancing its enforcement capabilities is the most appropriate measure at present .
Lee Jae-woong, South Korea's Foreign Ministry spokesperson, also emphasized at a press briefing that day that the South Korean government's position on North Korea's denuclearization is firm and that the United States understands the importance of bipartisan cooperation between South Korea and the United States, adding that South Korea and the United States will continue to work closely together to this end .
[ Lee Jae-woong, Spokesperson for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Korea ] Our government’s position on the denuclearization of North Korea is firm, and to this end, we are cooperating closely with the United States and will continue to do so in the future . As I said before, the United States understands the importance of bipartisan cooperation between South Korea and the United States, and we plan to continue to cooperate closely in that direction in the future .
Han Dong-hoon, leader of the People Power Party, South Korea's ruling party, congratulated Trump's election victory at the party's supreme council meeting that day, but emphasized that Trump's reelection would be both a crisis and an opportunity for South Korea's security and economy, and that this should be used as an opportunity .
He also said that the strong ROK-US alliance will serve as a solid foundation for the development of both countries, and he evaluated that the foundation has been greatly strengthened recently .
He added that he was confident that the new Trump administration and the South Korean government would be able to build a productive relationship based on this, and emphasized that the South Korea-U.S. alliance would be further strengthened in the future .
South Korea's main opposition Democratic Party of Korea congratulated Trump's election victory through a commentary by Chief Spokesperson Cho Seung-rae on the 6th , and said that President-elect Trump made a mark in the history of peace on the Korean Peninsula by leading the first-ever North Korea-US summit .
He also expressed hope that President-elect Trump's new term could open a new chapter in the history of peace on the Korean Peninsula .
This is Lee Jeong-eun of RFA's Radio Free Asia in Seoul .
Editor Yang Seong-won
12. 50,000 Russian and North Korean Troops Mass Ahead of Attack, U.S. Says
Here it comes. Will this be a pig push, a major attack?
Excerpts:
The North Koreans will be fighting as light infantry, without the benefit of armored vehicles. And current Ukrainian tactics of artillery fire and drone attacks have proved devastating to unprotected Russian troops.
That said, if Russia gains momentum, it may not stop at its border but might try to drive Ukrainian forces back farther. It is not clear if the North Korean government will authorize its forces to conduct sustained operations in Ukraine or if they are intended only for the Kursk counteroffensive, according to U.S. defense officials. Some American officials believe that North Korea could order its troops to stop at the border while the Russian forces press deeper into Ukraine.
U.S. officials said they did not know how effective the North Koreans would be, considering their lack of ground combat experience.
George Barros, an analyst at the Institute for the Study of War, said that in spite of that inexperience, the North Korean forces are well organized. “The one thing that they might actually be better at than the Russians is cohesion and discipline,” he said.
Rob Lee, a Russian military specialist at the Foreign Policy Research Institute in Philadelphia who recently returned from a visit to Ukraine, added, “Thousands of additional infantry can make a difference in Kursk. These soldiers are younger and in better physical shape than many Russian contract soldiers.”
50,000 Russian and North Korean Troops Mass Ahead of Attack, U.S. Says
Ukrainian officials expect a counteroffensive in western Russia to begin in the coming days as North Korea’s troops train with Russian forces.
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/10/us/politics/russia-north-korea-troops-ukraine.html
Listen to this article · 7:13 min Learn more
A Ukrainian army vehicle passing through the destroyed Russian border post at the Sudzha crossing and into Russia in August.Credit...David Guttenfelder for The New York Times
By Julian E. BarnesEric Schmitt and Michael Schwirtz
The reporters have been covering Russia’s war in Ukraine.
Nov. 10, 2024, 5:04 a.m. ET
Want to stay updated on what’s happening in North Korea and Russia? Sign up for Your Places: Global Update, and we’ll send our latest coverage to your inbox.
The Russian military has assembled a force of 50,000 soldiers, including North Korean troops, as it prepares to begin an assault aimed at reclaiming territory seized by Ukraine in the Kursk region of Russia, according to U.S. and Ukrainian officials.
A new U.S. assessment concludes that Russia has massed the force without having to pull soldiers out of Ukraine’s east — its main battlefield priority — allowing Moscow to press on multiple fronts simultaneously.
Russian troops have been clawing back some of the territory that Ukraine captured in Kursk this year. They have been attacking Ukrainian positions with missile strikes and artillery fire, but they have not yet begun a major assault there, U.S. officials said.
Ukrainian officials say they expect such an attack involving the North Korean troops in the coming days.
For now, the North Koreans are training with Russian forces in the far western part of Kursk.
The Russian-North Korean offensive looms as President-elect Donald J. Trump prepares to re-enter office with a stated goal of ending the war quickly. Mr. Trump has said little about how he would settle the conflict, but Vice President-elect JD Vance has outlined a plan that would allow Russia to keep the territory it has seized in Ukraine.
Some U.S. military and intelligence officials have grown more pessimistic about Ukraine’s overall prospects, noting that Russia has steadily gained ground, both in Kursk and in eastern Ukraine. Officials say the setbacks are partly a result of Ukraine’s failure to solve critical shortfalls in troop strength.
President Biden has been deeply supportive of Ukraine, pushing Congress to approve billions of dollars in aid and having the U.S. military and spy agencies provide critical intelligence to help Kyiv fight the war.
One Western official said Ukraine’s surprise incursion into Kursk in August thinned out its forces across the battlefield in eastern Ukraine, leaving them vulnerable to Russian advances. But that official, and U.S. officials, said Ukraine still had a strong defense in Kursk and might be able to hold, at least for a time.
The officials interviewed for this article spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss sensitive intelligence assessments and offer a candid appraisal of Ukraine’s battlefield prospects.
Western and Ukrainian officials say the arrival of North Korean forces is a major escalation after more than two years of war.
North Korea has sent more than 10,000 troops to fight with Russia in Kursk, American officials say. The troops are wearing Russian uniforms and have been equipped by Moscow, but they will probably fight in their own discrete units, U.S. defense officials said.
Ukrainian officials said Moscow had supplied the North Korean forces with machine guns, sniper rifles, antitank missiles and rocket-propelled grenades.
Russia has been training the North Koreans in artillery fire, basic infantry tactics and, critically, trench clearing, American officials said. That training suggests that at least some of the North Korean forces will be involved in frontal assaults on Ukraine’s dug-in defensive positions.
“We fully expect that D.P.R.K. soldiers could be engaged in combat,” Sabrina Singh, the deputy Pentagon press secretary, said on Thursday, using the initials of North Korea’s formal name, the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea.
U.S. officials are not sure what constraints the government of President Kim Jong-un has put on the use of its forces. However, American officials expect them to be directly involved in the fighting.
A Ukrainian official said the North Korean forces had been divided into two groups, an assault unit and a support unit, which will help provide security inside the territory recaptured from Ukrainian forces.
North Korea has a large army but, unlike Russia, has not been involved in ground combat for decades. The troops North Korea is deploying, however, are considered its best, drawn from the 11th Corps, home to the country’s special operations soldiers.
The Ukrainians captured hundreds of square miles of territory with little opposition, but Russia has slowly chipped away at those gains — reclaiming roughly half the seized territory — and now appears ready to conduct a much larger-scale operation.
American officials believe that the Ukrainian troops will prove difficult to dislodge, and that the Russian and North Korean forces will probably take heavy losses, similar to what Russia has suffered in eastern Ukraine. U.S. and British military analysts put the current number of Russian troop deaths and injuries at an average of more than 1,200 a day.
Image
North Korean soldiers parading in Pyongyang, North Korea, in 2012. Soldiers from an elite unit of the North Korean army are believed to be joining Russian soldiers to try to recapture territory in the Kursk region of Russia.Credit...David Guttenfelder/Associated Press
The North Koreans will be fighting as light infantry, without the benefit of armored vehicles. And current Ukrainian tactics of artillery fire and drone attacks have proved devastating to unprotected Russian troops.
That said, if Russia gains momentum, it may not stop at its border but might try to drive Ukrainian forces back farther. It is not clear if the North Korean government will authorize its forces to conduct sustained operations in Ukraine or if they are intended only for the Kursk counteroffensive, according to U.S. defense officials. Some American officials believe that North Korea could order its troops to stop at the border while the Russian forces press deeper into Ukraine.
U.S. officials said they did not know how effective the North Koreans would be, considering their lack of ground combat experience.
George Barros, an analyst at the Institute for the Study of War, said that in spite of that inexperience, the North Korean forces are well organized. “The one thing that they might actually be better at than the Russians is cohesion and discipline,” he said.
Rob Lee, a Russian military specialist at the Foreign Policy Research Institute in Philadelphia who recently returned from a visit to Ukraine, added, “Thousands of additional infantry can make a difference in Kursk. These soldiers are younger and in better physical shape than many Russian contract soldiers.”
In exchange for supplying troops, U.S. officials believe North Korea expects to receive rocket and missile technology from Russia as well as diplomatic support. But Ukrainian officials said North Korea may also be hoping to battle-harden its troops and learn from the tactics being developed in the war.
U.S. defense officials said they did not know if North Korea would send additional reinforcements. A senior Ukrainian official said Ukrainian intelligence officials had predicted that North Korea could send as many as 100,000 troops.
Russia is struggling to meet its monthly recruiting goal of roughly 25,000 troops as its casualties mount, meaning the North Korean soldiers are critical.
Mr. Barros called the North Korean deployment an “alternative pipeline.”
“It is likely not going to be a one-time shipment of 10,000 soldiers,” he said. “It is more likely going to be a way to regularly pull in thousands, perhaps up to 15,000 men a month.”
Andrew E. Kramer contributed reporting from Kyiv.
Julian E. Barnes covers the U.S. intelligence agencies and international security matters for The Times. He has written about security issues for more than two decades. More about Julian E. Barnes
Eric Schmitt is a national security correspondent for The Times, focusing on U.S. military affairs and counterterrorism issues overseas, topics he has reported on for more than three decades. More about Eric Schmitt
Michael Schwirtz is an investigative reporter with the International desk. With The Times since 2006, he previously covered the countries of the former Soviet Union from Moscow and was a lead reporter on a team that won the 2020 Pulitzer Prize for articles about Russian intelligence operations. More about Michael Schwirtz
See more on: Russia-Ukraine War, President Joe Biden, Kim Jong-un , Donald Trump
De Oppresso Liber,
David Maxwell
Vice President, Center for Asia Pacific Strategy
Senior Fellow, Global Peace Foundation
Editor, Small Wars Journal
Twitter: @davidmaxwell161
Phone: 202-573-8647
email: david.maxwell161@gmail.com
|