FINAL RULE - Modernizing H-1B Requirements, Providing Flexibility in the F-1 Program, and Program Improvements Affecting Other Nonimmigrant Workers


 
 

Dear Valued Client:


Our office is honored to have you as a client and would like to make sure that we are able to meet and exceed your expectations with your H-1B petition filings. We are issuing this letter to help our clients better understand the new final rule that incorporates key changes to H-1B regulations.


The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has published the final rule for the H-1B visa program, which will have some drastic changes for compliance and how “specialty occupation” is characterized and evaluated. I have prepared the key points for these changes and how the new rule will be applied in the future.


Clarifying Requirements and Improving Program Efficiencies


DHS is addressing how “specialty occupation” is defined and applied to current and future H-1B petitions. This interpretation allows USCIS to evaluate what degree fields the petitioner can accept and determine if it is related directly to the job duties to qualify as a specialty occupation.


The application of this rule allows USCIS to review whether the employee has the requisite underlying degree that supports the job offered. An example would be that if an employer has an opening for a Java Programmer and would accept a degree in computer science, engineering, business or related degree. The employee has an MBA with 10 years of programming experience, but now USCIS can review to see if that degree relates to the position and if an MBA relates to this position. 


USCIS would then review what is required by the employer, the employee’s degree and what the typical degree requirements are for the specified SOC code. Here the Occupational Outlook Handbook (OOH) states that computer programmers “typically need a bachelor’s degree in computer science or a related subject”, which would then disqualify this candidate from this position and SOC code.


USCIS can now also determine if the SOC code is correct by examining the job duties in the petition and supporting documents. Another key change is that the officers can now evaluate information contained in the FDNS reports, including job duties obtained by the end client from a site visit. This new approach will allow the adjudicating officer to review the job duties listed (or what was stated in a site visit) to determine if the SOC code correctly corresponds to the position. If the officer determines that the job duties do not properly correspond to the SOC code, they will have the ability to issue either a notice of intent to deny or a notice of intent to revoke if the petition was approved previously.


A sample from a recent NOID is listed below:


“Consequently, the duties that the beneficiary will perform do not correspond to the LCA occupation. The INA and USCIS regulations require that you provide a certified LCA for the occupation in which the beneficiary will be employed. Here, the LCA you provided is not for the occupation in which the beneficiary will be employed as required under the INA and USCIS regulations. Hence, the LCA cannot be used to support the instant Form 1-129.”


The rule will also codify the requirement for filing an amendment when there is a material change in the terms and conditions of employment. This is like the current policy for material change; however, this could be used against current H-1B approved cases when a project ends. USCIS could challenge that there is a material change of employment if a project is completed, and an amendment is not immediately filed reflecting the change in employment conditions. This could be a detrimental change that would impact current H-1B employees who are between projects.


Another sample regarding maintaining status for the beneficiary:


“You were previously approved to employ the beneficiary and you are filing this petition to extend that employment. To be eligible for this request, you must show that the beneficiary maintained their H-1B nonimmigrant status and was working under the terms and conditions of their previously approved petition. However, the evidence you submitted is insufficient to show that the beneficiary maintained their status throughout the previous H-1B approval period.”


The new rule also has a provision requiring beneficiaries to prove maintenance of status with all petitions, and now that participation in site visits is required, even proving maintenance of status to the FDNS officer.


Strengthening Program Integrity


Another major change will be the evaluation of the position and determining if the petition includes a bona fide position in a specialty occupation AVAILABLE for the beneficiary at the start date.  Speculative employment will be a major focus with this new policy and will require documentation of work to be available as of the requested start date.


Currently as a part of the ITServe lawsuit settlement, USCIS is not permitted to require contracts or client letters to determine whether there is specialty occupation work available. The new rule will do away with this settlement and allow USCIS to request contracts or similar evidence (client letters) to determine if there is a bona fide position.


Again, as mentioned prior, USCIS now can determine if the LCA filed supports the petition. This can be based on information filed with the H-1B petition, employee comments, or FDNS site visit reports.


The definition of what is a “United States employer” has been updated and expanded from the current definition. All petitioners now must have a legal presence and amenable to service of process in the United States. Foreign owned and operated consulting companies will need to assure a local agent that is present in the United States. This requirement will also allow FDNS to inquire as to the complete ownership of each consulting company and verify that the ownership is present in the United States.


A "FDNS site visit" refers to an on-site inspection conducted by USCIS Fraud Detection and National Security (FDNS) unit, and these compliance reviews ensure that petitioners and beneficiaries follow the terms and conditions of their petitions. This process includes reviewing the petition and supporting documents, researching information in public records and government systems, and, where possible, interviewing the petitioner and beneficiary through unannounced site visits.


FDNS site visits are now mandatory.  All petitioners and H-1B workers are required to participate and any refusal can lead to the case being denied. Non participation in the site visit or if the officer arrives and the office is not open, can now lead to serious implications from the FDNS officer report. These reports can be used to establish that the petitioner does not have any specialty occupation work available.


“Accordingly, USCIS conducted a site visit at the location on July 8, 2024. It has been determined that the petitioner has filed petitions where there is no specialty application work available. It has also, been determined that fraud has been committed as the company is not supplying specialty occupation work.”


Additionally, if the employee works at a third-party end client, USCIS will review the information provided by the end client to determine if the position qualifies as a specialty occupation. We are requesting all clients to have an open line of communication between all employees and all vendors and clients to avoid any miscommunications or not replying to the officer’s request in a timely manner. 


We are asking our clients to be informed of these new changes and to remember that it is crucial to consult with an immigration attorney to understand the latest requirements and best practices for preparing for a FDNS site visits and filing practices for H-1B petitions.


Please email or message me or our staff in whatsapp for any additional questions about these changes.


Thank you for choosing our office to work with you for your immigration needs and please feel free to share our contact information with any of your contacts.


Contact us for any additional information.
 
 
Sincerely,

Lucas Garritson, Esq.
Attorney
t: (214) 774-4713
Burgos & Garritson Law
  
Burgos & Garritson Law | Website
Facebook  Linkedin  Youtube  Twitter