|
As reported in prior Buzz articles, the Fair Housing Act was recently amended (“the Amended FHA”) to establish a procedure for municipalities to file a “Fourth Round” action with the Affordable Housing Dispute Resolution Program (“the Program”), seeking a Compliance Certification and/or Judgment of Compliance and Repose approving its Housing Element and Fair Share Plan. The Borough filed such an action earlier this year and, subsequently, the Honorable Gregg A. Padovano, J.S.C., issued an Order setting the Borough’s Fourth Round Obligations to include a “Present Need” obligation of 65 and a “Prospective Need” obligation of 480. The Borough Planning Board then adopted a Housing Element and Fair Share Plan (the “Borough HEFSP”). The Mayor and Council endorsed the Borough HEFSP by resolution, and the Borough submitted the Borough HEFSP to the Program.
Trelia Franklin Lakes 1, L.L.C. (“Trelia”), the contract purchaser of 370-378 Pulis Avenue in Franklin Lakes, filed an objection to the Borough HEFSP on August 29. An additional objection was filed by the Fair Share Housing Center. The Fourth Round statutorily prescribed process is now in the mediation stage, with the Program tasked to mediate a resolution of the issues between the Borough and its two objectors by a December 31 deadline.
While the Borough was actively working on a resolution with the objectors, on December 8, the Borough, with no notice, received a letter from The Hekemian Group (“THG”) indicating that THG had reached a preliminary agreement which contemplates that a THG entity would acquire approximately 60 acres of the Becton Dickinson (“BD”) property. As explained in the letter, the “contemplated transaction does not include the vast majority of the BD campus on the southwest side of the BD Property…. It is anticipated that the Subdivided Portion would include a substantial contribution towards the Borough’s affordable housing obligations.” The letter does not provide any further information as to the proposed development of the property, though THG representatives have indicated that THG will be providing a concept plan in the near future. THG is requesting that the 60 +/- parcel be included in the Borough HESP which is currently the subject of review by the Program.
The Mayor and Council are working with their Affordable Housing Attorney and Borough Planner to develop a plan for addressing this request which best protects the interests of Borough residents.
The Borough, like most municipalities, is seeking approval of its Fourth Round affordable housing plan by the Program in accordance with the Amended FHA. Had the Borough decided not to follow this statutorily prescribed process, it would have been exposed to the potential for “builders’ remedy” lawsuits, which are lawsuits brought by property owners or developers seeking to have the Borough meet all or a portion of the Borough’s obligation on property owned by the property owner or developer. Builders’ remedy lawsuits can result in high density development on sites chosen by individual property owners. By following the statutory process, the Borough is retaining its authority to meet its obligation through an appropriate planning process. Should the Borough be able to secure approval from the Program, it will have repose from builder’s remedy lawsuits. Should the mediation process before the Program fail, the Borough could face arguments regarding loss of immunity.
Mayor Charlie Kahwaty explains, “Franklin Lakes is committed to voluntary compliance with its Mount Laurel obligations. That said, the Borough intends to comply in a manner that is consistent with the Borough’s long-term planning vision, which does not include overdevelopment or overburdening infrastructure and services beyond municipal capacity. To that end, Franklin Lakes has joined in lawsuits that challenge the constitutionality and fundamental premises of more recent Mt. Laurel statutory and caselaw. While the outcome of these and other lawsuits cannot be predicted, we believe that it is our obligation to the community to pursue any remedy that protects the prerogatives of local government, to the extent it is consistent with the law.”
The Borough will keep the public informed as the status of this ongoing process with regular e-blast updates.
|